6 ms·
Replacing Ballmer with Nadella was possibly the best move a company's board of directors & shareholders have made in the history of corporate governance
by paxys 5y ago
Replacing Ballmer with Nadella was possibly the best move a company's board of directors & shareholders have made in the history of corporate governance
- short12 5y agoBalmer doesn't get enough credit but he was exactly what was needed during that pretty long timeframe. But nadella taking it from there was an equally good decision I think balmer got to be the fall guy for a lot of things and that was why he was put in as CEO
- reducesuffering 5y agoHow do you explain Balmer deriding the iPhone and completely failing to pivot into mobile?
- missedthecue 5y agoYou win some you lose some. It's perfectly possible that any Microsoft phone product would have been doomed, whether it was executed under Nadella, Gates, or anyone else. Ballmer did start Azure though, which is basically carrying Microsoft today. Their Surface product was also released under Ballmer's direction.
- devnull3 5y ago> Ballmer did start Azure though This is analogous to Xerox experimenting with GUI and not really believing in it. No real drive, no zeal. Satya doubled down on it. Made it priority 1 and most importantly executed it well. Ballmer's world view was completely different which was more rooted in 90s and early 2000s. He was more of Windows guy and not really seeing the changing trends. That is why MSFT's foray into mobile looked like an after thought.
- short12 5y agoOf course he is going to belittle another company's achievement but Microsoft had zero chance in the mobile game in the first place and they knew it Saying the windows phone was half assed is being generous
- to11mtm 5y ago> Saying the windows phone was half assed is being generous IDK if I'd go that far. I used my Windows phone right up to the bitter end of it's ability to function. The app ecosystem itself sucked, but the platform was IMO better from a sandboxing standpoint, and frankly every Windows Phone 8/10 device I had was better experience from a 'phone' standpoint. Things other than phone/email/music/navigation got bad quick. But I loved them as phones.
- solarkraft 5y agoI passionately hate Windows on desktop along with most other pre-Nadella Microsoft products. I enjoyed using Windows phone. The UI isn’t even particularly pretty, but in most senses it’s pretty reasonably designed and, very importantly, extremely responsive.
- ghaff 5y ago>Microsoft had zero chance in the mobile game I'm not sure I agree. They needed to get past a Windows-centric mindset just like Intel would have needed to get past an x86-centric one. But it's not clear to me why Microsoft couldn't have built off of a very large developer and user community--and enterprise buyers--to have at least played on a somewhat equal footing to Google and Apple.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoThey bought Nokia, they had the best mobile operative system ever created. Meego, Linux, Qt. Insanely good developing experience, a decade ahead what iOS or Android had. It could have been the efficient, user friendly open source rival to the Objective C and Java. They literally missed the opportunity to make a decent and open phone and it was all by design. They killed Nokia on purpose, right when the N9 was released.
- PedroBatista 5y agoHow do you explain Bill Gates completely missing the Web in the late 90's? How do you explain Intel completely missing mobile? Without 80's and 90s Ballmer, Microsoft would be a totally different thing and it's very possible there would not be a Microsoft today. And I don't care for any of these assholes, but he was very important for Microsoft and shaped the industry, like it or not.
- 1123581321 5y agoHiring Eric Schmidt and buying NeXT are up there.
- downWidOutaFite 5y agoGoogle would be smart to replace Sundar Pichai, that company has been ruderless.
- anxrn 5y agoSince Sundar became CEO: - GOOG has grown nearly 300% (last 5 years). It is by far the strongest performing large tech stock this year (>+50%). - They just announced one of their best quarterly earnings in their history (highest quarterly revenue increase in 14 years). By these metrics, Sundar seems to have been a great pick. If not for the above metrics, how would you evaluate the CEO?
- downWidOutaFite 5y agoI don't think it takes great leadership to maintain hold of their search and youtube monopolies. In cloud, GCP is getting beat by AWS and Azure. But Google's main failure is their complete inability to innovate new products over the last decade.
- vecter 5y agoEither that or bringing Steve Jobs back to Apple via NeXT. I haven't been following MSFT closely for a while. What are some of the major decisions that Nadella has made to help create this great success over the past 6-7 years?
- eganist 5y agocomplete strategy shift to service subscriptions. It's honestly that simple.
- ghaff 5y agoAlong with playing nicer with open source. The thing I probably find most impressive is that they have been able to do so well as a business while basically losing mobile--which I'm not sure I would have thought was possible.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- HatchedLake721 5y agoCloud/Azure
- eganist 5y agoyup, and it pervades everything Microsoft does now. Windows, Office, Azure, etc. they've all been packaged as services funded either by consumers or ads.
- jonny_eh 5y ago> Either that or bringing Steve Jobs back to Apple via NeXT. That one move by a board directly caused the biggest positive shift in a corporation's fortunes I can think of.
- reilly3000 5y agoBig focus on internal culture shift, allowing Linux adoption and OSS to flow freely, heavy focus on cloud, building a decent hardware business, and very strategic enterprise partnerships ie Salesforce. Let’s not discount tech stock valuation inflation is nearly unprecedented at this point, some credit is due there. Still, Balmer was driving the company off a cliff with his brutish orthodoxy. Nadella transformed the company based on new assumptions about positioning in the modern digital economy, not the desktop days.
- Thaxll 5y agoAll the tech compagnies have increased in value over the last 10 years, not sure the board of director have anything to do, or their CEO. Is there a single major tech compagny that has lost valuation?
- paxys 5y agoHow much has IBM increased in value over the last 10 years? HP? Intel? Cisco? Oracle? There are tons of large tech companies which have severely underperformed the S&P 500, and Microsoft was in the same category for the previous 10 years while Ballmer was at the helm.
- rc00 5y agoIBM has lost about a third. The rest have underperformed. (IBM is the runaway loser here.) https://ibb.co/RbKvHk3 https://ibb.co/RbKvHk3
- sailingparrot 5y agoHave they? IBM stock was at it's peak 10 years ago. Sure, now it might seem a bit ludicrous to put MSFT in the same category as IBM, but 10 years ago Microsoft was far from sexy and not part of what people would imagine would be the future of tech (There is a reason there was no M in FAANG when that term appeared). IBM and MSFT where in the same category back then. Now, since Nadella took over 5 years ago, Microsoft image has completly changed. And over the past 5 years, while all the "FAANG" have increased in value indeed, they have not increased equally. Microsoft has increased the most, even more than Apple. Who would have bet on that? It has grown about 50% faster than Google and 2x faster than Facebook. And when you say that they all have increased in value, their is a strong survivorship bias in there, you are only thinking about those companies that are still performing well today. We forget about Nokia, HP, Blackberry etc. That where big back then, but couldn't transform themselves. Just has everyone predicted Microsoft would not be able to.
- rc00 5y agoIBM has entered the chat...
- mandeepj 5y ago> Replacing Ballmer with Nadella was possibly the best move a company's board of directors & shareholders have made in the history of corporate governance Worth posting - Microsoft almost passed[1] on Nadella, first during his recruiting interview and later during his CEO interview[2]. [1,2] - in rush now, but will post links later, if someone asks about them. Sorry
- renerthr 5y agoInterested in those 1,2 references. Thanks.
- mandeepj 5y ago[1] - https://www.inc.com/justin-bariso/microsofts-ceo-says-this-single-interview-question-changed-his-life-and-taught-him-a-major-lesson-in-empathy.html https://www.inc.com/justin-bariso/microsofts-ceo-says-this-s... [2] - https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/magazines/panache/dreaming-to-be-a-ceo-you-have-to-really-want-it-says-satya-nadella/articleshow/67535001.cms?from=mdr https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/magazines/panache/dream...
- throwawaysea 5y agoBing, Azure, and Office 365 all started under Ballmer. Microsoft’s stock was not priced rationally during his time but the company’s financials were also record setting for much of his tenure. About the only thing missed was smartphones. It was a big miss but obviously it hasn’t mattered since Microsoft’s present success has been built entirely on what Ballmer started. I am not sure why he is so vilified. All leaders will make mistakes. But in his case people are willing to ignore the successes. Nadella gets some credit as well, but it would be a falsehood to attribute Microsoft’s move into online services to him.