10 ms·
Let’s Put an End to Prosecutorial Immunity (2018)
- m0zg 5y agoA modest proposal: if you're going to do it, and have the political wherewithal to push it through, do it in _your own_ county/city, then wait for 5 years or so to see the effects. I.e. if Hollywood wants to "defund the police", defund Beverly Hills PD first, see how well that works. Sick and tired of people proposing harebrained policies that affect everyone else but them.
- WalterBright 5y agoNot to split hares, but this is the first time I've ever seen harebrained spelled correctly in the wild.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 1123581321 5y agoAccording to Algolia it’s spelled right on HN about two thirds of the time (370 vs 170 results.) Not bad for that word!
- m0zg 5y agoThat's the difference between people who read, and those who don't. On the flip side, I don't know how to pronounce some of the words that I know how to spell, so when I read I sub-vocalize them incorrectly. There's no need to separately learn pronunciation in my native Russian - it's phonetic, with very few, minor deviations. Nor is there a need to learn spelling - it is governed by very few simple rules.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- upbeat_general 5y ago1. Hollywood != Beverly Hills 2. IANAL but I believe this would have to be done on a state or federal level not a local level. 3. Why do you think the change is "harebrained"?
- pseudalopex 5y agoI think they mean people who run the entertainment industry live in Beverly Hills. Unclear what it has to do with activists all over though.
- ncmncm 5y agoStart by disarming the police.
- m0zg 5y ago> Start by disarming the police. Do it in _your own_ neighborhood though, not somewhere else. Something is telling me that this is not what you had in mind when writing that comment.
- SauciestGNU 5y agoWhy do you think that's not what we're trying to do? I am politically active against my local police because their violent policies affect /me/ and people I care about.
- ncmncm 5y agoDo you often hear voices telling you falsehoods? Best get that checked out.
- jawns 5y agoWhile we're at it, let's have the Supreme Court clarify that aside from identifying yourself, you have the right to remain silent during a Terry stop. It seems pretty obvious that if you have the right to not answer officer's questions in consensual encounters (where you're not suspected of a crime) and arrests (where you're charged with a crime), you should also have the right to remain silent during an investigative detention. But just because it's obvious doesn't mean it's legally protected. It turns out that the Supreme Court has declined opportunities to clearly establish the right to remain silent during a Terry stop. Which means that in some cases, a person can be charged with obstruction if they refuse to answer an officer's questions during a Terry stop. Worse yet, if a court later finds that the officer has violated a person's constitutional rights by arresting them for refusing to answer questions, qualified immunity prevents the victim from being compensated for the injustice, because the right to remain silent during a Terry stop is not considered "clearly established." Here's a link to a piece titled "Obvious But Not Clear: The Right to Refuse to Cooperate with the Police During a Terry Stop." It was published in the American University Law Review in 2020. Written by a University of Denver law professor and an attorney who graduated from that university, it reviews all of the relevant case law and urges the Supreme Court, other courts, and state legislatures to "clearly define" the right, which would remove qualified-immunity protections for officers who violate that right. https://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2117&context=aulr https://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?...
- hellbannedguy 5y agoWhen I was younger (Actually I was pulled over about a year ago for no reason.). I was pulled over for basically an old car, and hair below my ears. I didn't want to say anything, but knew if didn't kiss their badge, I might get pricy ticket. The one time I didn't answer their rediculious questions, like, "Where you are going. What are you buying at Safeway. It seems strange you are buying dinner at 10 pm". These were the actual questions. She walked around my car looking for something to ticket, and then said I was speeding. A $350 ticket. Yea, I tried to fight it, but she actually showed up in court, and the judge sided with the Police Officer. (In California their was a bill that would essentially legalize jaywalking. It was drafted because cops were using jaywalking violations to harass, and intimidate citizens. Basically, I have nothing on you, but I could site you for jaywalking. Governor Neusome vetoed the bill. I get where he was comming from, but still disappointed. I don't know the solution other than every cop, including undercover cops, should have a camera on every minute of their shift. Only using a bathroom could the cop flip the cover on the camera. Those tapes should be allowed to be retrieved in an easy fashion by anyone. If cops resist, their are many people in line for that job.)
- largbae 5y agoIt's an interesting proposal, but we have to find some way of fitting intent into the picture, or good prosecutors will be paralyzed. Since this is clearly US-focused, how do other countries do it?
- Stevvo 5y agoIn other countries it's simple; Prosecutors are treated exactly the same as any other citizen. Breaking the law is illegal for them and their institutions. If 'good prosecutors' will be paralyzed by no longer being permitted to plant evidence, fake testimonies and commit other deplorable acts, them maybe they are not good prosecutors?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 5y agoSources / references would be handy here.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bradleyjg 5y agoThis is a very American system solution and it won’t work. People go on and on about getting rid qualified immunity but it’s only a partial immunity and cases are still fairly frequently lost. Look at what happens in those cases—-the city pays a lot of money. The cops suffer no consequences at all. They pay nothing. They even often get overtime for participating in the trial. Lawsuits are a failed means of regulation when it comes to state actors (they are a failure in regulating other things as well but that’s a different conversation). It’s time we admit that instead of insisting we just need this one more tweak. Let’s put in place real political accountability and then empower politicians to make genuine reforms—-even over the objections of civil service unions.
- yeetaccount 5y agoIf the police unions don’t like your laws they don’t enforce them. If they really don’t like you, they don’t show up at your house when there’s an intruder. If they really really don’t like you, they are the intruder.
- erdos4d 5y agoQuiet man, these fucking bootlickers will start understanding its all just a big protection racket if you keep making sense like this!
- Spivak 5y agoDoesn’t the first one make sense though? Isn’t the refusal to enforce laws the check the executive branch, at all levels of government, has on the legislature?
- giantg2 5y agoI don't think so. They are supposed to set standards or make tweaks for how the law should be enforced. They aren't supposed to outright ignore it. Just like judges are not supposed to legislate from the bench. I think the misapplication and unequal enforcement of the law undermines the entire system. Nobody will think it's fair that they get prosecuted and some other person doesn't. Justice for all, my ass.
- rayiner 5y agoI’m a pretty pro-criminal justice reform guy, but most folks in that camp really don’t understand how very guilty most people in prison are. From first hand experience, the system is already inundated with meritless litigation, appeals, etc. People in person don’t exactly have a lot of better things to do. Innocence Project and similar organizations have to screen hundreds of cases to find the one or two meritorious ones. Ending prosecutorial immunity would mean 99 completely frivolous lawsuits for every one worth considering.
- brazzy 5y agoWhat alternative solution do you propose? Because leaving things as they are is clearly worse than the scenario you describe, especially since those hypotheyical 99 frivolous lawsuits could be dismissed with very little effort. Police do not have this immunity and yet somehow they can do their job without being paralyzed by frivolous lawsuits.
- rainworld 5y agohave to screen hundreds of cases to find the one or two meritorious ones And even then, legal merit, long after conviction, brought forward by a team of highly motivated activists, against an indifferent (or often enough even sympathetic) legal system does not equate innocence. Peculiarities of the American legal system and political pressures exacerbate this.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoIt's also a matter of what you can prove. If you find DNA evidence or a video recording to exonerate you, that's great. But if you're in prison because a cop planted drugs on you, there is no DNA evidence. There may not be a video recording of the events. How can you prove your innocence? Sometimes you can't, even when you are.
- aaomidi 5y agoPeople who are pro criminal justice reform understand people are guilty. But they're trying to solve the actual systemic issues that lead to crime, not just say crime doesn't happen. Excessive policing, not spending money on social services, etc etc are all making it worse. https://ips-dc.org/three-felonies-day/ https://ips-dc.org/three-felonies-day/ So yeah, we've over criminalized shit and we're spending money on mercs instead of investing in society.
- 1cvmask 5y agoKamala Harris withheld exculpatory evidence from an innocent person. The judge reprimanded her. Now she's promoted and voted into the second highest office in the country. Government is around so that we can fail upwards. Thank god she gets to live the American dream. In other countries such prosecutorial abuse would land you in jail. https://nypost.com/2020/09/03/kamala-harris-rampant-prosecutorial-abuses/ https://nypost.com/2020/09/03/kamala-harris-rampant-prosecut... https://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/capitol-alert/article233375207.html https://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/capitol-aler... There is a whole list of abusive prosecutors who got political success ranging from Eliot Spitzer, Rudolph Giuliani and now Kamala Harris.
- ncmncm 5y agoKamala Harris got her political cachet by fixing California's voting system. It is, today, quite difficult for a crooked elections official to produce a fraudulent election result in California. That was not the case before Harris, when California was all-in on wholly electronic voting, with deeply unreliable voting machines. Unfortunately, Alabama and Louisiana bought the surplus machines. We may hope they have since been retired.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- civilized 5y agoTerrifying human being. Why do such awful people rise to the top?
- 1cvmask 5y agoThe voters voted for her. We should ask the majority of the voters I suppose. These were known about her even when she got voted in as California senator. Clearly majority of Californians agree with innocents (mainly Blacks) being jailed. Or NYers with Eliot Spitzer or Rudolph Giuliani.
- throwawayboise 5y ago
- spaetzleesser 5y agoIn my view if a prosecutor, judge or cop breaks intentionally or knowingly break the rules, it should be treated as a very serious crime and they should be punished harshly. These people are trusted by society with enormous power over people's lives and their behavior should have the highest integrity. Once people have doubts about the legal system, a civilized society can't really work properly. A vast majority of the workers in the legal system are doing their job with honesty. It should also be in their interest to get rid of corrupt people.
- giantg2 5y ago"A vast majority of the workers in the legal system are doing their job with honesty. It should also be in their interest to get rid of corrupt people." On thing this misses is that many people violating rights might just be incompetent. Then the corrupt ones use incompetence as a defense.
- throwawayboise 5y agoBe careful what you ask for though. Cops are given a lot of discretion about whether to make an arrest, issue a citation, or a warning, or none of the above. If you start demanding that they never "break the rules" it could have outcomes you didn't want.
- pauldenton 5y agoWe've already got selective enforcement. Compare how the protestors who stormed the capital during the Kavanaugh hearings got treated compared to those on January 6. look how anti lockdown protestors were treated compared to BLM protestors. If you want a world with selective enforcement you're living in it.
- Buttons840 5y agoWhat kind of comment is this? You seem to argue that it's OK to "break the rules" sometimes, and your reasoning for this is something vague about unwanted outcomes? I don't see any substance to this comment. If you have an argument you need to make it more explicit.
- AlbertCory 5y agoProsecutorial immunity out, but not prosecutorial discretion? Why should a prosecutor be able to effectively rule some behaviors "not crimes" by declining to prosecute them, when the legislature has decided they are crimes?
- RHSeeger 5y agoUnfortunately, we have decades of laws written overly broad that make huge swaths of behavior into crimes, with the people passing them saying "yeah, but we won't use them that way". At least to me, this is abhorrent and such laws should never be passed, but here we are. If all laws were enforced every time they applied, the vast majority of the population would be in jail.
- smnrchrds 5y agoThere is a book called Three Felonies A Day with the same premise. I have not personally read it so I cannot vouch for its accuracy. That being said, this is what the description for the book says: > The average professional in this country wakes up in the morning, goes to work, comes home, eats dinner, and then goes to sleep, unaware that he or she has likely committed several federal crimes that day. Why? The answer lies in the very nature of modern federal criminal laws, which have exploded in number but also become impossibly broad and vague. In Three Felonies a Day, Harvey A. Silverglate reveals how federal criminal laws have become dangerously disconnected from the English common law tradition and how prosecutors can pin arguable federal crimes on any one of us, for even the most seemingly innocuous behavior. The volume of federal crimes in recent decades has increased well beyond the statute books and into the morass of the Code of Federal Regulations, handing federal prosecutors an additional trove of vague and exceedingly complex and technical prohibitions to stick on their hapless targets. The dangers spelled out in Three Felonies a Day do not apply solely to “white collar criminals,” state and local politicians, and professionals. No social class or profession is safe from this troubling form of social control by the executive branch, and nothing less than the integrity of our constitutional democracy hangs in the balance. https://www.amazon.ca/Three-Felonies-Day-Target-Innocent/dp/1594035229 https://www.amazon.ca/Three-Felonies-Day-Target-Innocent/dp/...
- 5y ago
- _8j50 5y agoAlso, end or restrict plea bargaining.
- giantg2 5y agoI have witnessed prosecutorial misconduct. According to the state Bar, even though the acts alleged would violate the professional code of ethics, they will only investigate if the court has formally declared that prosecutorial misconduct occurred. The fact is, the people in power will continue to say that those involved in running the system should have immunity. Why? Because according to them (multiple court rulings) the system itself is more important than the people who it governs. Complaints against the judiciary are so secret, that even if the file contain exculpatory evidence, they will refuse to turn it over on the basis that the secrecy is necessary to protect the integrity of the system and uphold the public trust. Let that sink in... The only reason things would need to be secret is if the system was covering up misdeeds and not punishing its members appropriately. More people would trust the system if there was transparency and appropriate discipline/oversight. It's really no wonder that 2-10% of the incarcerated population is innocent.
- 3finmunchousen 5y agoIf you haven't already seen this it is deplorable. https://www.propublica.org/article/black-children-were-jailed-for-a-crime-that-doesnt-exist/amp https://www.propublica.org/article/black-children-were-jaile...
- spaetzleesser 5y ago"Because according to them (multiple court rulings) the system itself is more important than the people who it governs" I remember reading about a guy who got convicted although he was innocent. In one appeal the appeals court basically said "We know you are innocent but the process was followed correctly so we won't open the case again". "It's really no wonder that 2-10% of the incarcerated population is innocent." As far a I know most of these people got bullied by prosecutors into a plea bargain: "We all know you didn't do it but you have the choice to accept 3 years prison or go to court and risk getting 30 years." Tough choice especially if you can't afford lawyers.
- giantg2 5y agoTrue, over 75% of cases never go to trial so I would assume they comprise a large number of them.