15 ms·
Message from cycling heaven: it’s not that fantastic here
- pmdulaney 5y agoThere is an advantage to enjoying unpopular things. When I seek out used books on matters of interest to me, the prices are low. When I go riding on bike paths in Los Angeles, there aren't gobs of other cyclists that I have to deal with. Yes, you can have too much of a good thing.
- joeberon 5y agoI find it quite distasteful and lacking perspective when hearing Dutch people say "cycling really isn't that great!" (although I know that's not really the point of this article). But still, don't ignore the horrific reality of really a lot of the world at this point: suburban america is just one isolated example. I know there's always some level of "the grass is always greener" but the Dutch emphasis on making cycling out to be not so really a big deal actually is a bit ridiculous frankly.
- cheschire 5y agoI got none of that from this article. I felt the author was trying to express the need for balanced considered approach to change rather than just a blind push to implement what the Dutch have. There's weakness inherent in the Dutch model, and while it might be the perceived pinnacle we've achieved as humanity, perhaps there's a better model if we consider it further. That's what I got here.
- dochtman 5y agoYup. Given, too, that it was presented at the Dutch Cycling Embassy, I (as a Dutchman) read this as the author trying to raise the bar/challenging the Dutch discussion on transit (or Movement, as her book is called) not to get complacent.
- crispyambulance 5y ago> author was trying to express the need for balanced considered approach to change rather than just a blind push to implement what the Dutch have. I think that's a thoughtful concern, but really, the least of our problems in the USA is traffic planners blindly copying Amsterdam and going overboard with bike infrastructure. That just isn't going to happen. Ever. On the plus side, there are US-based traffic planning innovations that have demonstrated some success in certain metro areas such as "Complete Streets". There's more of these now than ever before.
- joeberon 5y agoMy point exactly. It's still a relatively utopian situation compared to most places in the US
- viburnum 5y agoAmsterdam does not equal the Netherlands.
- sufehmi 5y agoAnother thing I only noticed when I visited Amsterdam - it's scary for pedestrians. I love cycling, been cycling for 25+ years, including commuting to my office via (beautiful) cycling path at Birmingham canals. But when I visited Amsterdam, of course I don't have my bike there, so I went anywhere using Uber, and walking around - and that's when I noticed that: It's really scary to be a pedestrian in Amsterdam. In a lot of places, the cyclist path is on the same surface with the pedestrian path. Of course it's separated with lanes (read: paint job on the surface) - but we are on the same surface, next to another. Several times I was almost hit by the cyclists, I'm pretty sure I was on my / pedestrian's path, but I almost got hit anyway. A lot of the cyclists are cycling in a very high speed. That was a new feeling & experience for me, and I didn't like it. I hope the situation will become better for the pedestrians.
- alistairSH 5y agoThat wasn’t at all my experience when I visited. Yes, some paths in the tourist area were crowded, but at no time did I feel unsafe. Add in the street car/trolley and easy ability to cycle out of the tourist district and it was pretty awesome, IMO.
- airza 5y agoWalking in Amsterdam isn't my favorite; as you have alluded to the cyclists there have long since grown tired of stoned tourists wandering into the bike lane and don't yield in the same way as in other cities. But compared to the US, where every street crossing requires dashing across 4-8 lanes of traffic in the 20 seconds allotted to me by the Car Gods... there is no comparison in terms of subjective or objective danger.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- easytiger 5y ago100%. As a pedestrian Amsterdam is genuinely awful. I've been many times and nearly been taken out by cyclists and trams. Ebikes are causing a big rise in incidents too. There is no sane or remotely cohesive design to layouts and few curbs and so on
- navait 5y agoAs with all things, there are trade-offs, nothing will ever be perfect and we should solutions if it improves tings. How many people die per 1000 km traveled? Accidents? Injuries?
- an9n 5y agoI live in NL a few years back, and when I asked a colleage about buying a bike he said: 'just go to central Amsterdam and wait for one of the [slang word for tracksuited petty thief I can't remember] to speak to you. They'll ask you what you want, even what colour, and bring something back within 15 minutes for €50 (or whatever)'. A downside of everyone cycling there is that bike theft is absolutely rife.
- azeirah 5y agoYeah it's very common to hear "wanna buy this bike? It's yours for 10 our".. at a night out, in basically every city. Heck, I know a homeless guy I talked to a couple of times and helped out with food and stuff, I know him by name. A couple months later I met him drugged of his ass on the Main Street, offering me a bike I'm like "nahh dude come on" My pretty expensive bike got stolen at some point too :(
- xqyf 5y agoCar theft is more common where cars are more common
- Hamuko 5y agoI've never lived somewhere where cars weren't the most common method of transportation and I've only heard about bikes being stolen. Probably because it's just so much harder to steal a car whereas you can feasibly just carry a bicycle on your back.
- xqyf 5y agoThat's why it's bad to rely on anecdotes. Car theft is up in 2019 and 2020 in the US https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-auto-theft https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-auto-the...
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoThere used to be a lot of casual car theft in the UK. Teenagers would steal the car and go off joyriding. That has largely stopped as the cars have become more secure.
- Vinnl 5y agoThat title doesn't match the content at all. Yes, it's cycling heaven here, and yes, it's fantastic and I wouldn't trade it for any other infrastructure in the world — but of course there are some trade-offs, and this article lists a number of minor downsides.
- Ensorceled 5y agoI was thinking the same as I read the article ... "This actually sounds pretty fucking fantastic"
- nend 5y agoIt's a bit of a weird title because it implies the article is going to be a rebuttal against how great the cycling is, but at the same time the phrase "it's not that fantastic" implies the cycling is still a little fantastic as well.
- gigglesupstairs 5y agoNot sure but it looks like a case of bad translation. The whole thing - title and content.
- 9387367 5y agoReads as clickbait blogspam for an author promoting their forthcoming book.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoQuestion: at what age does a normal Netherlands person stop biking? I love biking now - but I'm just wondering at what age a normal biker gets too old to bike everywhere daily.
- superice 5y agoThey don’t. You see elderly people on bikes all the time here. They just happen to have fewer places to go after retirement.
- mahkeiro 5y agoI would love to have the feedback of a few Chinese people that were living in China before the car transition on that subject. I remember Beijing in the 90s with thousands of bicycles and it was a big jungle! After that experience, I started to think that only mass transit is going to be a real solution for dense cities.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoEnormous bicycle traffic was a reality in Shanghai in the 2010s. (I'm not Chinese, but I lived there.) Has the car transition happened yet? Will it ever? It's extremely difficult -- and expensive -- to get a city license plate.
- refurb 5y agoGo to Singapore. Car ownership is at 11%. Very good mass transit. Plenty of fatalities since: 1) people still use taxis to get around, 2) you still need to transport cargo. Or go to a SE Asia country with few car. Motorbikes dominate and they try and avoid you but it’s nerve wracking. Plenty of bikers get crushed by trucks.
- analog31 5y agoI went to grad school in the early 90s. One of my friends from China told me a story, that he had gotten permission to buy a gas scooter. He said that he kept it for a few weeks, then got rid of it: The scooter could go no faster than a bike due to all of the bike traffic.
- rocgf 5y agoIt is amazing just how many people draw conclusions from having visited Amsterdam for coffeeshops and the Red Light District, without having cycled or gone outside of Amsterdam's city center. The city center in Amsterdam is not the Netherlands, and it's not even the rest of Amsterdam. When you talk about how difficult it is for pedestrians in Amsterdam, that's a clear sign you're not a local and that you don't know what you're talking about. Amsterdam's city center is historic, largely unchanged from almost half a millennium ago in terms of structure, with millions of tourists coming every year to visit. Take a 20 minute walk outside the touristic spots and you might be extremely surprised.
- sktrdie 5y agoYup. Also would still take Amsterdam city centre walking (full of bikes & with little pedestrian lanes), instead of most other city centers that have sidewalks but are entirely polluted with noisy and smoggy cars.
- alistairSH 5y agoWho said it was bad for pedestrians? I’ve visited as a tourist and didn’t find downtown to be problematic as a pedestrian. The street cars are handy. And renting a bike and leaving downtown was easy and enjoyable. All around excellent approach to transit, from what I saw. Edit - I see the other comment now. Lol. Not my experience at all.
- Robotbeat 5y agoI think ground level in city centers should be for pedestrians and less-than-15mph bikes (and other slow vehicles 120kg or less). Everything else is either elevated or subterranean, including bike lanes and most definitely cars and trucks. Conveyance is a utility like sewer or electricity, and like sewer and electricity, it shouldn’t be flowing at ground level. Minneapolis has some interesting solutions. The skyway (in both Minneapolis and St. Paul) connects all the buildings in the downtown via elevated (or subterranean) pedestrian pathways, important in the 0 degrees F (-18C) winter. But ideally, you’d flip the situation with the cars and trucks on the non-ground-level with the streets purely for people or low speed and low mass vehicles like bikes. Minneapolis also has the Greenway, superhighway for bikes that is grade-separated from much of the rest of the city (sitting below, in like a greenery-surrounded canyon, with bridges above), an old railroad route. Pretty fantastic.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoFair enough. But I live in "Cycling Hell"; Long Island, NY. It's hard to feel sorry for Amsterdam. We have twisty, windy roads, with few shoulders, and what shoulder there is, is filled with rubble, trash, and dead critters. Cyclists here need to basically stay in the road, or wipe out. Staying in the road has its own drawbacks. Namely, Long Island drivers. A few years ago, a local politician made a comment to the effect that "No one should ride a bicycle on Long Island." It drew fire from cyclists all over the country. Unfortunately, he actually had a point, because we have some of the least-suited cycling roads in the world. New York City is even crazier, but traffic can't go fast, there, so it's less likely that cyclists will be killed. There are frequent cycling accidents in the city. I moved up here from the DC suburbs, where they had cycling support similar to Amsterdam. Fortunately (or not), I am not a cyclist. I walk two miles, every morning, and I've learned to do that as early as possible. If I wait until after 6AM, I have to deal with the same knucklehead drivers as the cyclists. I've taken to wearing what I call my "clown suit"; a bright, dayglo shirt or jacket, with reflective stripes, and obnoxious sneakers. Even so, I still need to be very cautious. People drive like crap in the morning. Traffic lanes, crosswalks and stop signs are just "suggestions."
- GnarfGnarf 5y agoCycling works in the Netherlands because it's such a flat little country. A model that doesn't necessarily export everywhere.
- addicted 5y agoeBikes and pedal assist bikes change that equation though.
- randomsearch 5y agoMaybe. But they’ve also invested massively in infrastructure and transformed their roads. So it’s not clear to me which is the most important factor, but conversely American cities have terrible cycling infrastructure and car-serving cities everywhere and everyone drives, hilly or no.
- brodouevencode 5y agoUgly American here, bound to a vehicle because I live in the suburbs. > That there are complaints from car drivers about the number of people bringing their children to school by bicycle. Whether the cyclists are willing to adapt. I can sympathize with this, or at least what I understand of it given it seems to be translated from Dutch. In the neighboring big city there are bike lanes (though sharing the same surface as the autos) for most of the major thoroughfares. Bicycling has become more and more popular over the past couple of decades, and I’m totally fine with that. I gladly yield to those paths and the cyclists using the where I can, and generally follow all the rules of the road. I’ve not had a traffic citation since 2004. However I’ve noticed over the past decade or so that that cyclists are becoming increasingly aggressive - disregarding the rules they must follow: cutting through traffic, ignoring lights and not yielding to pedestrians at pedestrian crossings. It’s gotten so bad that some of the optimal paths I could take to the office I don’t. More than once has a cyclist confronted me, one even smacked my vehicle with his backpack, because I blew the horn when they jumped off the curb and directly into traffic. I want to support more bike friendly initiatives because I like the health and environmental benefits, I just don’t want to be associated with the assholes come with the territory.
- arp242 5y agoThe context here is that when I was at school, you were simple not allowed to bring your child to school in a car unless there was a specific reason. Actually, you weren't even allowed to cycle unless you lived more than ~1km away (due to lack of cycle racks). They were flexible about this of course (e.g. being picked up every once in a while was fine), but being dropped off/picked up every day was very rare. This was the case at both elementary schools I attended. In high school it was a non-issue since pretty much everyone cycled or walked anyway. With this context in mind, cars complaining about cycles is rather ... odd. > one even smacked my vehicle with his backpack, because I blew the horn when they jumped off the curb and directly into traffic. Cars horns are really loud, come across as very aggressive, and immediately send adrenaline levels up. It's a horrible communication method, especially to people who aren't in cars, that usually only provokes the wrong kind of responses in people.
- 5y ago
- legitster 5y agoI spent a week once in The Hague- it may have been my favorite place I have ever been. The real magic is not the bike lanes - it's that people don't need to lock up bikes! I can't say enough about how much of a game changer that is. In the US, the logistics of securing a bike makes the affair so much of a hassle. I basically gave up bike riding after the third time my bike was stolen.
- azeirah 5y agoHuh? You didn't need to lock up your bike in The Hague? In every city in the Netherlands I'm aware of, bikes get stolen aallll the time. Only in villages and other rural areas can you trust the environment to not steal your bikes. That's because everybody knows each other, there's no chance you're going to get away with stealing a bike, there's a lot of trust. But in a city? Was it in the outskirts?
- thaumasiotes 5y agoIt's a context-sensitive metric. I would estimate that in Shanghai it took one to two months for my unlocked bike to get stolen. (I lost three bikes this way.) That doesn't sound great, but in San Francisco it'd be a matter of days.
- legitster 5y agoWhen I was in The Hague there were always a dozen bikes parked outside of every restaurant, shop, etc. Maybe they got locked up for longer term parking, but here in the states I have had a bike stolen while I was still within 15 feet of it.
- thraxil 5y agoI lived in Utrecht for a year and a half and I've been to The Hague a few times. I'm a little confused. I don't remember seeing things any different there than Utrecht and in Utrecht we definitely locked up our bikes. Or do you just not count the wheel locks that every typical Dutch bike has built in? Even those, you really just use if you're running in somewhere real quick. If you're going to leave your bike out somewhere for more than 15 minutes or so, you'd still chain it up. The big difference vs somewhere like NYC (where I lived previously), is that you don't necessarily need the biggest and toughest locks (unless you have a really nice bike, which will definitely still be at risk of being stolen) and that bike racks and secure places to lock your bike are much more frequent. Dutch bikes are also generally heavy and chunky and have all their components (lights, seat, etc) pretty securely attached. In NYC even if you locked your bike up, if you had a halfway decent seat, that would get stolen if you didn't take it with you.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoA thought experiment I often perform in Manhattan: Look at the road, and imagine that every car is two pedestrians. Consider how much empty space would be left on the road. Now, look at the amount of empty space on the sidewalk. Notice anything? In cities, cars take up an inordinate amount of physical space—far more than their fair share. And then drivers still complain they don't have enough room and are stuck in traffic, because of course they are, cars are huge! Screw cars in cities. In busy areas like lower Manhattan, you shouldn't be able to drive at all unless you have a documented need (commercial vehicle, physical disability, etc). Make sure the people who truly have to drive can actually get around without waiting in traffic, and then leave the rest of the space for pedestrians, cyclists, and others who can use the resource efficiently.
- DoneWithAllThat 5y agoWhat do you mean by “fair share” in this context?
- alistairSH 5y agoI wouldn’t use “fair share” myself. But personal cars are horribly space-inefficient. See linked image. Add in required parking and it’s even worse. https://www.detroittransit.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/space-needed-to-move-ppl-by-bus-bike-car-AV.jpg https://www.detroittransit.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/sp...
- avaldes 5y agoIf I understand correctly, what that image is saying it doesn't matter what type of car you use still they're all space inefficient?
- alistairSH 5y agoYes. Similar images have been published over the years, all attempting to show how space inefficient cars are compared to other transit options. This particular one takes it a step further by calling out EVs as no better than ICEVs with regard to space consumption.
- jFriedensreich 5y agoits super nice to finally see someone share my feelings. it is hard to express these views sometimes because they are often faced with hard backlash by a lot of bike activists who see biking as the only answer to climate change and strict bike lanes with super defensive construction against cars and all other modes of transportation as the only way to achieve this. there are much more flexible and nice ways than the dutch model.berlin is moving hard in the dutch direction and it feels like a short sighted and suffocating development. we need a public space that is open and adapts to small developments, we will have e scooters e motorbikes small electric cars self driving microcars, super fast electric wheelchairs with ai emergency prevention for elderly or disabled, relatively slow moving parcel and grocery delivery robots.and all of this has to take into account that walkability is still the number one factor for quality of life feeling in neighbourhoods.
- snapetom 5y agoBicycling has had this "we are beyond reproach" attitude for years due to its health and environmental benefits. At least in my city, it's led to a sense of entitlement and militantism. Red lights and stop signs are routinely ignored by bicyclists. I've witnessed plenty of near misses against pedestrians, and myself have been hit by a bicyclist while I was on the pedestrian side of the path. A lot of these comments misses the point of this article. This isn't a pro or anti cycling article. The point is that a lot of are not following laws and common courtesy. Being on a bicycle does not exempt you.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>Red lights and stop signs are routinely ignored by bicyclists. That old trope is continually brought up yet the research is clear that cyclists stop at read lights more often than car drivers.
- cataphract 5y agoTo the extent that this meandering article makes a point, it doesn't match my experience in the Netherlands at all. In residential streets there are usually no bikelanes and there is street parking, kids playing football and so on, that is, the street is by no means dedicated to cycling. Take for instance a street where I used to live: https://goo.gl/maps/1T8PzJfPjxpT1JdN9 https://goo.gl/maps/1T8PzJfPjxpT1JdN9 This is true even near a primary school where kids bike to: https://goo.gl/maps/e4thCUV1WV5p1JLE9 https://goo.gl/maps/e4thCUV1WV5p1JLE9 The segregated paths are usually alongside roads or wide streets.
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoReThinking cities is wildly expensive. And it will take a long time One thing that is / will speed it up is remote working. Once we divorce the location of the city from the location of the people, the cities stop competing in attracting the company and need to attract the employees. Which will me a better facilities for humans not companies. It's the one big benefit I see from remote working and amazingly I expect to see it within the same metro-area. Don't have mega-cities and mega-mayors. Have lots of small neighbourhoods that experiment with each other.