20 ms·
Hardened wood as a renewable alternative to steel and plastic
- jaclaz 5y agoOf course I cannot access the full text article, but the claim that this HW can be sharpened and become "3 times sharper" than "most commercial table knives" sounds not very scientific.
- moron4hire 5y agoSharpness can be quantified, and most table cutlery is probably made from 420 stainless steel. Not a particularly great steel, but very common.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoSince "table knife" means the typical dull cutlery knives (as opposed to e.g. steak or kitchen knives), I have no doubt that wood (hardened or not) can be sharpened like that.
- ummonk 5y agoYeah I suspect they're comparing to cutlery knives out of the box - without any extra sharpening.
- jaclaz 5y agoNot only, a "good" knife can be measured by its sharpness (and still the 3x sounds very little scientific) but also by the durability of its sharpness, there is a a youtube channel[0] by a guy that makes blades out of "everything" and they are actually sharp, but how much do they last (and last sharp enough) is unsaid, and in the end of the citation it seems like they propose these HW knife as a replacement for plastic cutlery. [0] as an example only a knife made out of plastic bottle material (should be PE): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZnT31JeBTg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZnT31JeBTg
- ummonk 5y agoYeah, and with a Brinell hardness of just 31 I doubt knives made out of this material would hold an edge that well.
- symby 5y agoI'm sold. Where can I get some of this hardened wood? I would like to experiment with it and maybe incorporate it into products.
- rtkaratekid 5y agoI’m also interested in this
- opwieurposiu 5y agoMost of the sources for this stuff I have found sell it as deck boards. https://store.us.kebony.com/pages/samples https://store.us.kebony.com/pages/samples
- tromp 5y agoI'd love some hardwood cutlery. Assuming it's soak-proof, as I often leave dirty kitchenware to soak before washing it.
- anon_cow1111 5y agoI'll give you a more specific reply along with the parent poster while I'm at it... You definitely can cut meat etc, with densified wood, just don't expect it to hold an edge like your steel cutlery, especially if you're using with something besides a soft cutting board. The article mentions oil-treatment so it probably won't absorb water in normal kitchen use. In terms of edge-retention there just isn't a good alternative to steel atm. This wood will likely preform around the same as unhardened steel or aluminum, So it'll cut but you'll need to sharpen it frequently. If you're looking more for fancy-pants artistic appeal and don't mind high price, there's always obsidian blades out there from small-time makers. They'll be about as good as ceramic sharpness-wise, but look a lot nicer IMO.
- fredley 5y agoIt's tough to get, it doesn't just grow on trees.
- anon_cow1111 5y agoI have a tiny bit of advice I might be able to lend here, for experimentation purposes mainly. Regular hardwood can be heat-treated to increase its density and compression strength considerably, in the most basic form this can be done at home by heating it... slowly... up to ~400F (typically just holding it over a hot-plate until it's light-medium brown. You'll want a temperature-stable oven for wood more than a cm or so thick) This won't provide the same density this study has achieved, but it'll give you a quick proof-of concept for next to no cost. In the article I believe they also chemically alter the wood by removing lignin with a boiling sodium hydroxide solution. Basically dissolving out the 'dead weight' and leaving more cellulose, which is what's giving wood most of its strength. They do also use physical compression under heat, which wouldn't be too hard to achieve with mere run to home-depot, but I'm not sure how much effort you want to put into this as of now.
- nico_h 5y agoCan't read the article. How energy efficient and environmentally friendly is the hardening process compared to making steel? And is it a "in 20 years" thing again, like all new battery tech?
- martythemaniak 5y agoA general note: in a world of super cheap solar or wind, energy efficiency doesn't matter as much. It's cheap because In many instances, the end product is the "battery". A desalination plant can be run when the sun is out and the end product (clean water) can be stored and used. In this instance, the hardening step stores energy in the final product. Just run that step at the right time.
- zdragnar 5y agoThis kind of thinking is why cryptocurrency miners are setting up shop at substations. They get severely discounted electricity from the utilities, in exchange for ramping up and down their servers to keep the grid load balanced. Except, of course, cryptocurrency isn't nearly as useful as, say, desalinated water.
- orasis 5y ago“Except, of course, cryptocurrency isn't nearly as useful as, say, desalinated water.” Heresy!!
- vkou 5y ago> Except, of course, cryptocurrency isn't nearly as useful as, say, desalinated water. I'd like to expand on this a bit. The major problem with cryptocurrency is that the value of a typical coin seems to be ~ the cost of electricity needed to mine one. This means that a crypto miner turns $1 of energy into ~$1 of wealth. As far as business plans go, this is an absolutely horrific use of energy. Nearly no other business produces so little wealth, for such a high energy input. The economy in general, by the way, turns $1 of energy into ~$17 of wealth. [1] [1] https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=36754#:~:text=Expressed%20as%20a%20percent%20of,lowest%20since%20at%20least%201970 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=36754#:~:tex....
- tomtomftomtom 5y agoFauci funded COVID-19: https://www.zerohedge.com/covid-19/nih-admits-funding-gain-function-covid-experiments-gives-ecohealth-five-days-report https://www.zerohedge.com/covid-19/nih-admits-funding-gain-f...
- erpellan 5y agoThere's also Accoya acetylated wood, which is already commercialized: https://www.accoya.com https://www.accoya.com
- kfprt 5y agoUsually 'hardened wood' is just wood where the air has been replaced with epoxy. The problem is epoxy is expensive and not different enough from a pure plastic.
- dymk 5y agoI think what you're describing is more often referred to as "stabilized wood", and doesn't involve the "densification" process as described by the infographic. I'm not willing to pay for the article to read it, but it seems like this is pretty different from epoxy stabilized wood (which isn't particularly hard).
- fhood 5y agoStabilized wood is essentially as hard as whatever it's stabilized with. But yeah, the interesting concept is the densification. I dunno about replacing steel, but if soft fast growing woods can be converted into something closer to a hardwood, and the volume lost and extra time still puts it out ahead, that is pretty exciting.
- raman162 5y agoI wonder how fire resistant hardened wood is. I can imagine cities like Chicago having a hard time to use wood in commercial buildings with history launch as "The Great Chicago Fire"[0] [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Chicago_Fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Chicago_Fire
- account_b 5y agoI think wood can be quite fire resistant even with traditional modifications like charring. And it may retain structural integrity better/longer than steel. I think steel can become an enemy in a fire quite abruptly.
- OldHand2018 5y agoChicago allows mass timber buildings up to 6 stories, although a developer has proposed an 80-story mass timber building. So that guy may do all the work to open the door.
- jccalhoun 5y agoFrom what I've read, they are pretty fire resistant because they are dense and so will char and burn slowly. There have been a couple articles on here in the last couple years about "wooden skyscrapers" and they have made that argument.
- sfink 5y agoI've been intrigued for a while about various modified wood technologies (eg hardened wood, transparent wood), but I'm always disappointed because it usually ends up just being a minor support structure for a very non-wood material (generally epoxy). This one shows a compression step, so maybe it's different, but I'd really like more info on whether this is actually renewable or sustainable in any interesting sense. Very reminiscent of the supposedly renewable & sustainable bamboo products that are anything but. I love bamboo, but flooring should make you think "plywood" not "waving groves of fast-growing giant grasses". It's another glue and epoxy thing. Update: https://phys.org/news/2021-10-hardened-wooden-knives-slice-steak.html https://phys.org/news/2021-10-hardened-wooden-knives-slice-s... is a much better source.
- jonpurdy 5y agoCurious about your opinion on bamboo products. I assume you're referring to modern bamboo desks, shelves, and other items that are made from Chinese bamboo and made in China. They typically slice the bamboo grass pieces into ~8 sections, then use planing machines to create planks※. These are then pressed and glued together to make products. These products are then shipped overseas using the same methods as other products. If the glue used is either sustainable or they don't use very much of it, and the bamboo is grown locally, what makes it less sustainable than using wood? And certainly more less energy-intensive than steel. ※ I am not a woodworker, don't know terminology.
- svachalek 5y agoThe usual complaint I see against bamboo products is that they use hard bamboo that grows like trees, but promote a sustainable image based on the idea of soft bamboo that grows like grass. I haven't heard it's less sustainable than wood, just not any more sustainable.
- wrycoder 5y agoKg of wood per hectare-yr would be a good measure of how much useful wood is created, and also how much carbon is locked up in it.
- westurner 5y agoFrom "Hemp Wood: A Comprehensive Guide" https://www.buildwithrise.com/stories/hempwood-the-sustainable-new-building-material https://www.buildwithrise.com/stories/hempwood-the-sustainab... : > HempWood is priced competitively to similar cuts of black walnut. You can purchase 72" HempWood boards for between $13 and $40 as of the date of publishing. HempWood also sells carving blocks, cabinets, and kits to make your own table. Prices for table kits range from $175 to $300. Jul 5, 2021 […] > Is Hemp Wood Healthy? Due to its organic roots and soy-based adhesive, hemp wood is naturally non-toxic and doesn't contain VOCs, making it a healthier choice for interior building. > Hemp wood has also been tested to have a decreased likelihood of warping and twisting. Its design is free of any of the knots common in other hardwoods to reduce wood waste. https://hempwood.com/ https://hempwood.com/ FWIU, hempcrete - hemp hurds and sustainable limestone - must be framed; possibly with Hemp Wood, which is stronger than spec lumber of the same dimensions. FWIU, Hemp batting insulation is soaked in sodium to meet code. Hopefully the production and distribution processes for these carbon sinks keeps net negative carbon in the black.
- killfauci 5y agoFauci needs to be arrested today. NIH Admits they funded GoF Research at Wuhan. https://www.nationalreview.com/news/nih-admits-to-funding-gain-of-function-research-in-wuhan-says-ecohealth-violated-reporting-requirements/ https://www.nationalreview.com/news/nih-admits-to-funding-ga...
- dd36 5y agoI’ve seen this before. It starts getting curious at the “chemical treatment” step.
- Animats 5y agoThey're taking the lignite out of the cellulose, and then compressing the resulting soft mesh into a harder material. A few years ago, "transparent wood" was a thing. That was taking out the lignite, and putting some transparent plastic in. Not clear what's special about their compression step.
- dan353hehe 5y agoThe heated compression step allows the cellulose to form hydrogen bonds with other cellulose fibers, which strengthens the wood and makes the epoxy redundant.
- Animats 5y agoThat's all? No additives during the compression? And nobody figured this out before?
- dan353hehe 5y agoIt’s often the obvious and simple things that are overlooked, because they obviously won’t work :)
- Animats 5y agoI'm surprised that this wasn't invented back when Henry Ford was trying to use agricultural products in autos. (The "hemp car" urban legend comes from that project.) Plastics were expensive, so there were attempts to use agricultural products as filler. The trouble was that cellular materials swell when wet. Plastic+ag waste didn't hold shape if used for exterior auto body parts. Same problem as Masonite, particle board, etc. With enough heat and pressure, does this new material avoid that problem? Or is it a "do not get wet" product.
- mjh2539 5y agoWe have, for all intents and purposes, an unlimited supply of carbon and iron. Assuming we one day get over our FUD of nuclear energy (which with the use of breeder reactors is considered a renewable form of energy), it follows that steel itself can be considered renewable.
- korantu 5y agoAnd even co2-negative, if made with captured co2
- hammock 5y ago>Widely used hard materials, e.g., alloys and ceramics, are often nonrenewable and expensive Alloys and ceramics are non-renewable? Aren't they pure mineral?
- hammock 5y agoHere is a non-paywalled description of the process. https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/environment/a16758876/chemical-treated-super-wood-steel/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/environment/a167588... >Lignin is what makes wood rigid and brown. Somewhat counterintuitively, Hu and his team removed the wood's lignin polymers in order to make their wood even stronger. >The lingin removal allowed the team to compress the wood under a mild heat of around 150 degrees Fahrenheit. Without the lignin binding together the wood's cells, the scientists were able to make its cellulose fibers very tightly packed. >When the fibers are jammed together...the wood's fibers begin to form hydrogen bonds. So essentially they found a different (more natural-sounding for sure) way to polymerize cellulose. Right now bamboo or sugar cane are broken down and polymerized all the time via a different process to make plant-based plastics, rayon, etc.
- panzagl 5y agoAre the long term effects any less detrimental than other polymerized materials, or is this basically another way to make plastic?
- account_b 5y agoAs far as I know, the Earth's surface cannot meet humanity's current need for hydrocarbons, polymers or building materials. Biomass production is limited by sun energy and most importantly phosphorus and nitrogen cycles. Even hundred of years ago, people were already exhausting regenerative capacities and back then there were only around half a billion humans living on all this planet. Petrol chemistry and mineral exploitation saved Earth's ecosphere short term. But obviously that can't last forever. It's nice to have functional carbon sinks and all, but we will never replace even the majority of petrol, metallic and mineral based production of today with biomass derived alternatives. The surface and geological cycles cannot support that. And food is priority. If phosphorus rock is gone, we're fucked for good. We need to cut down.
- vimy 5y agoWe need to mine in space.
- bhhaskin 5y agoThis. If we want to continue human progress then space is really the only option.
- account_b 5y agoNo, that's still ignorant of ecological processes, I think. We need to adapt culturally/economically. What do you think happens, if we continue as we do, but assume "infinte" ressourses? You would still exhaust regenerative/reparative capacities, accumulate chemical byproducts and waste - shift balances. See nitrification of water bodies. The core problem is our lazyness to recapture uncompressed former dense resources; to operate closed cycle. And well, I have my doubts we can establish the extend of space exploitation to meet our current e.g. global phosphorus needs within the next 30 years. Is phosphate rock even plenty around in asteroids?
- mikeg8 5y agoReally, the only option? You must be joking.
- fluxflexer 5y agoThe most interesting thing is the Force/Displacement curve. It shows some plastic deformation even after the breaking point, which is unusual for „hard“ Materials. May this just be some gloryfied Epoxy with wood as filler?
- nick238 5y agoThat stress/strain curve in the Cell Matter "Graphical Abstract" is garbage past the point of peak stress. If it's tested in their double shear jig as shown, once it displaces significantly (> radius of the nail) the force is more the pull-out force, basically just the friction between the hole and the nail surface. Or, the nail might just be digging an oblong hole in the shear jig. It's maybe interesting, but a regular stress/strain setup is better to lead with. The Nature article has some normal stress/strain curves which show brittle failure https://www.nature.com/articles/nature25476/figures/6 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature25476/figures/6
- mensetmanusman 5y agoIt appears they are relying on the hydrogen bonding in the cellulose after lignin removal, so it should be >50% wood, i.e. not an epoxy with wood filler.
- oliwarner 5y agoThe graph in that composite diagram is really bothering me. Their "hardened wood" product is 23 times harder than "natural" basswood. When dried, basswood (aka lime) is an extremely soft hardwood. It's very popular with novice turners and hand carvers. When green (natural?) you can carve it with a stone. Species matters. Lignum vitae is 20 times harder than basswood.
- beambot 5y agoSpecies matters, but so does availability. Lignum vitae is an endangered species, so it's not really a renewable alternative at the scale humanity requires.
- icedistilled 5y agofun fact, you can grow Lignum Vitae in SoCal in certain areas, not just in Florida. San Diego would probably grow lignum vitae well because it seems to like the random humid weeks in Los Angeles and just exists for the rest of the year
- carapace 5y agoDo you know anyone who has Lignum Vitae seeds or seedlings for sale or trade?
- icedistilled 5y agoAbout a decade ago I ordered some from a nursery in florida, in retrospect I'm not sure that's an ideal thing to do. But I think I did order directly form the nursery so hopefully they were following the regulations, whereas amazon will freely help third parties sell completely illicit plant materials that could bring pests.
- meepmorp 5y agoI think the point of using basswood as a reference is to demonstrate the effectiveness of the hardening process by using a very soft wood. Separately, basswood is fairly quick growing, making it a decent candidate for commercialization of the whole technology.
- billiam 5y agoI am totally encouraged by this report. The sentence that really gets me from a companion paper linked below: "Cellulose, the main component of wood, has a higher ratio of strength to density than most engineered materials, like ceramics, metals, and polymers, but our existing usage of wood barely touches its full potential." It's just a beginning, but a good one. Hard to see HW replacing the myriad things we use steel or ceramics for, but intriguing.
- canadian_tired 5y agoWood is renewable when you can grow it, cut it up into useful shapes, then at the end of its useful life, compost it. As soon as you add a shit load of processing and plastic and other stuff it's not "wood" anymore than gasoline is a dead dinosaur. As for things like plywood that use glue for the laminations...glue is the most expensive and important part of the product. Not the wood so much. Replacing steel? I don't think so. Yes, steel is a dirty thing ecologically... but steel things last a long time... and require, in general minimal processing...unlike this hardened wood proposal. If steel showed up today as a new material, it would be lauded for all its technical properties. But it is now old and not so sexy.
- EGreg 5y agoNot to mention all that carbon released when the wood decomposes - no ?
- mikeg8 5y agoNo expert here but I believe it depends on how it decomposes. If wood rots at the surface, my understanding is more carbon is released into the atmosphere but if it is buried or decomposed using fungi or soil microbes, more carbon is captured into the soil. Forests have a lot of decaying and decomposing deadfall wood but still seem to be a carbon sink so it may be a layering thing...
- spfzero 5y agoThat's the reason you use wood chips and bark for mulch in a garden; to add carbon to the soil.
- canadianfella 5y agoDo you have a source for that? That sounds wrong.
- psd1 5y agoIt isn't the usual primary reason. You use these things to provide a mulch layer over the top of tilth; it suppresses weed germination. If all you want is to add organics, you'd probably fork in manure.
- peatfreak 5y agoAm I the only person who is irritated by the misuse of the phrase "23-fold", which really means multiplied by 2^23, not multiplied by 23?
- telotortium 5y agoNo, 23-fold means "multiplied by 23" - https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fold#:~:text=multiplied%20by%20(a%20specified%20number)%20%3A%20times%20%E2%80%94in%20adjectives https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fold#:~:text=mult...
- anon_cow1111 5y agohttps://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-01600-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-01600-6 I think this is an article describing the same process, with more detail than the abstract above. A quick ctrl+f lists Teng Li's name in both so probably the same research group. (Originally found on /. several years back)
- catskul2 5y agoCan we all stop for a second and appreciate the "Graphical Abstract"? IMO it's great, and every paper that where such a thing is reasonable should have one!
- ostenning 5y agoWhenever I hear about renewable trees I cant help but think how policy failures often lead to more and more forests being destroyed. Perhaps it would be better if we stop over commodifying trees in general and try to reduce our reliance on them and hopefully partitioning them off from the economy could encourage regrowth
- hadlock 5y agoPlaces like Washington State have had replanting programs in place since well before I was born. In the US we have more trees now than we did 100 years ago, forestry and forest management as a problem was solved 50+ years ago. There's the issue of disappearing rainforest in the amazon, but that's largely due to the fact that growing food is a more valuable use of that land than forest, and has nothing to do with the economic value of the wood on the land.
- ksec 5y agoFor people who are interested in Timber Building / Construction. The World's Tallest Timber Buildings [1], Why Finland is Building a Wood City [2]. Why There Are No Timber Skyscrapers [3], Why All Buildings Should Be Timber [4] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3JqSsc8ZKk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3JqSsc8ZKk [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4QYkEpw9pA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4QYkEpw9pA [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p_8LlcuV0gc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p_8LlcuV0gc [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ieBVNgMkcpw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ieBVNgMkcpw
- turtlebits 5y agoAll of these sound good, but the caveat is that they are wood + epoxy/resin/glue.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoWhy is that a caveat?
- sp332 5y agoThe knife in the article is just wood, with some food-grade oil on the surface.
- sixstringtheory 5y agoTo add more huge timber structures to the list, here’s a starting point to see/learn more about the historical Kennecott mine in Wrangell-St. Elias Nat’l park in Alaska [0]. I’ve had the good fortune to walk through it–it is simply incredible. [0]: https://www.nps.gov/wrst/learn/historyculture/kennecott-mines-national-historic-landmark.htm https://www.nps.gov/wrst/learn/historyculture/kennecott-mine...
- zz865 5y agoI live in a wood framed 5+1. Its great being in renewable wood building - but the downside is its a huge fire risk. Plus because of this the sprinkler system is vast - and keeps flooding apartments.
- jcrawfordor 5y agoPermali is a commercially available hardened wood with impressive properties, but it's based on impregnation with a resin which is not the most environmentally friendly process. A particularly interesting application of Permali is the nuts and bolts fastening the ATLAS-I Trestle (said to be the largest wooden structure in the world) together, since the nature of the facility required use of a dialectric material for the large fasteners. The resin process has definite downsides though... I'm curious about the chemical process involved in this proposal. Historically, chemical treatment of wood has been a significant source of environmental contamination. Although modern precautions reduce this problem, it'd be a big step forward if the chemicals involved here are pretty safe.
- ryanmarsh 5y ago"Hardened wood" = wood cellulose + glue
- colonwqbang 5y agoOne of the steps to produce it seems to be soaking it in mineral oil. Maybe I missed something, but it seems pretty strong to call it renewable if it's made from fossil petroleum.
- Gatsky 5y ago(Can't read the damn paper, even with University journal access. Why is academia so fundamentally stupid? Is it not obvious to a scientist that when your paper comes out it would be a good idea for a lot of people to be able to read it? Thanks to Cell Press for extracting profit to hold back scientific progress.) Anyway I presume this relates to the group's previous work, where they boil the wood in sodium hydroxide to leach the lignin and then compress it. The final product doesn't have any resin additives, so is not a composite.
- tjmc 5y agoMechanical engineer here. This article is very light on a lot of detail which would allow you to reasonably compare this material to steel, plastic or any other material. Just a few that come to mind: Hard materials are usually brittle materials that fail suddenly. How tough is it? ie. Can it accept some deformation without significant weakening and will it stretch or crack prior to failure? What is its compressive strength? What is it's tensile strength? Could it be used to reinforce concrete? Pipe liquids or gases? Does it's strength drop when it gets wet? How dense is it? How flammable is it? How easy is it to machine without damaging it? And of course the big one - how much does it cost?
- sixstringtheory 5y agoI’d been interested to know your thoughts on pykrete! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pykrete https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pykrete
- tjmc 5y ago"Plausible, but ludicrous"
- ummonk 5y agoArticle is paywalled (and sci-hub doesn't work), but the Brinell hardness of 31 while certainly higher than normal hardwoods, is extremely soft compared to metal - softer than even wrought iron without a heat treat. I'm sure it could be made "sharper" than cheap cutlery, but that doesn't mean it will hold an edge well. I'd also be curious how recyclable the material remains after the chemical treatment required to densify it - I would suspect it's like e.g. MDF / plywood which is very bad environmentally due to the glues.
- LinuxBender 5y agoDo knives made from this process set off metal detectors?
- _xerces_ 5y agoWhen ceramic knives are produced, they insert a metal rod into them to ensure that they do set of metal detectors. I imagine they could do something similar here.