4 ms·
> they are not a union, they are a racket. The core leverage of a union is a mafia-style "wouldn't it be a shame if your business burned down?". How are you dr
by roenxi 5y ago
> they are not a union, they are a racket.
The core leverage of a union is a mafia-style "wouldn't it be a shame if your business burned down?". How are you drawing the line between union and racket? Is there something more nuanced than what you find socially acceptable?
- diordiderot 5y agoIn civilized societies, like the ones across the Atlantic, labor representatives work cooperatively with management in non adversarial manner because children aren't indoctrinated into thinking they're the star of there own Hollywood film
- batch12 5y agoWhat? This point made sense until the tangental snark after 'because'. Should've stopped there.
- adventured 5y ago> In civilized societies, like the ones across the Atlantic, labor representatives work cooperatively with management in non adversarial manner because children aren't indoctrinated into thinking they're the star of there own Hollywood film Yeah right. The unions in Europe have always been more violent and dangerous than the ones in the US. The French labor unions would like a word with you about being civilized (they're anything but). And which societies would those be? The forever dictatorships in Eastern Europe? The regressive monarchies all over Western Europe? Look up how many constitutions the French have had, because they can't get anything right. Most of Europe was a backwards, primitive disaster until the last 40-50 years. Mass genocide, tens of millions butchered in wars, millions cast into slavery in North and South America, monarchy, dictatorship, totalitarianism, Communism, Socialism, Colonialism. Oh yes, those glorious enlightened Europeans, we have so much to learn from their ... wisdom. Europe largely are constitutional and democratic infants compared to the US, crawling from behind by more than a century. It'll take a miracle for Europe to not be back to killing itself before another few decades is up. The sole reason they didn't spend the post WW2 era slaughtering each other is thanks to the US occupation of Europe, which prevented war with Russia and largely kept the major powers from being allowed to attack other weaker nations.
- Glawen 5y agoWow, so many childish arguments. This is the type of simple reasoning that led to Irak war. Of course you replied by taking the French Union example, and not the much better German Union model. I do not bother to reply the second paragraph as it is just a child rant.
- iammisc 5y agoThank you for pointing out European backwardness. America is extremely stable compared to Europe. The time between the founding of the eu and now is the longest Europe has ever been without two major powers at war. Europe was basically the middle east version 0.5.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'm assuming you caught the bit about "millions cast into slavery in North and South America". A legacy which still lives on. Much of the stability of North America is built on that slavery (and the 100-million or so lives it cost), genocide of the original inhabitants (another mass killing of as many as 100 million), and of course, the protective moat of thousands of miles of ocean east and west. Europe's own most stable polities are also shielded by water (Britain) and/or terrain (Scandinavia).
- iammisc 5y agoOh right, I forgot Europeans never had any slavery... You have to be joking. The entire feudal system was built on the backs of serfs, who were slaves for all intents and purposes.
- disgruntledphd2 5y ago> The sole reason they didn't spend the post WW2 era slaughtering each other is thanks to the US occupation of Europe, which prevented war with Russia and largely kept the major powers from being allowed to attack other weaker nations. That's a pretty strong take, do you have any evidence for said take?
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y ago
- l33t2328 5y agoUh...labor representatives are inherently in an adversarial relationship with management. Further, I’m not sure this xenophobia toward US labor relations has any basis in reality.
- pas 5y agoYes, but they are in a forced cooperation. Especially in the short term. Labor laws have extra protection for union leaders, and unions obviously can't strike forever, and the employer can't let go of too many people to decrease labor expenses (otherwise they can't operate the firm). Both parties have tools to try to assert their interests, but those are all blunt instruments that only have a certain useful range.