21 ms·
Paintmakers are running out of the color blue
- burnafter182 5y agoThe Greeks didn't have a word for the color blue.
- rhn_mk1 5y agoThe Russians have two.
- missedthecue 5y agoLike "Blue" and "Navy"? Or just two blues? If the latter, what's the reason?
- tetromino_ 5y agoWhat's the reason why English and most other languages of Europe treat blue and green like distinct basic colors, while many languages of Asia have one word encompassing both? What's the reason why Hungarian has two basic words for different kinds of red? It's just a historical artifact of language evolution. Russian happened to the evolve two different distinct basic color words for blue; to an English speaker, both are different shades of blue, but in Russian, neither is a shade of the other; and Russian has no single color word encompassing the English concept of "blue".
- tigen 5y agoEven in English, in certain contexts, blue-green middling shades are treated individually (turquoise, cyan). Of course there are many color names in paint/art, but even in everyday situations there is a pretty clear concept of turquoise being its own distinct color.
- ceejayoz 5y agoAzure, cobalt, sapphire, cerulean, indigo, aquamarine... Most languages probably have quite a few.
- tetromino_ 5y agoTwo basic color words for different types of blue. You might think of azure, cobalt, and sapphire as shades of blue. To a Russian speaker, синий and голубой are not shades of each other, they are different basic colors, like blue and green in English. And there is no one color word in Russian encompassing all blues.
- jazzyjackson 5y agojust as there is no word in English encompassing all blue-greens
- defanor 5y ago> To a Russian speaker, синий and голубой are not shades of each other, they are different basic colors, like blue and green in English. As a native Russian speaker, I always understood "голубой" as a light shade of "синий" (blue), and that's how it's defined in dictionaries [1,2]. [1] https://academic.ru/searchall.php?SWord=%D0%B3%D0%BE%D0%BB%D1%83%D0%B1%D0%BE%D0%B9&from=xx&to=ru&did=&stype= https://academic.ru/searchall.php?SWord=%D0%B3%D0%BE%D0%BB%D... [2] https://ru.wiktionary.org/wiki/%D0%B3%D0%BE%D0%BB%D1%83%D0%B1%D0%BE%D0%B9 https://ru.wiktionary.org/wiki/%D0%B3%D0%BE%D0%BB%D1%83%D0%B...
- ceejayoz 5y agoNah. https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/26918/could-people-perceive-the-color-blue-in-ancient-times https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/26918/could-peo... (Be sure to read the #2 answer, which I find more compelling than the first.)
- tombert 5y agoThis is completely tangential but does anyone who has any real experience with painting done anything with the VR painting apps? I have one called PaintingVR, and I think it's cool, but I have no real experience with physical paints (always opting to use a digital drawing tablet since I was a kid). If anyone has any experience, how do you feel it compares to the real deal?
- genghisjahn 5y agoKing Spray on the Oculus Quest is pretty good (cue the multi threaded chain about Oculus requiring a FB login).
- highland586 5y agoI'm really enjoying Kingspray as well. It's really close to spraycan painting, they even got the dripping effect just right.
- ozten 5y agoVermillionVR[1] is incredibly realistic! I really felt like I was in that brick studio with a nicer set of equipment than I'd ever used. I guess I used easels sort of like that in college, but in the real world I didn't use such a formal setup. The realism and sense of presence made me notice the missing haptic feedback and the lack of smell feedback (linseed oil, turpentine, etc), but the audio feedback and the physics are really great. My experience was with Vive Pro 2 and Valve knuckles. [1] https://vermillion-vr.com/ https://vermillion-vr.com/
- azinman2 5y agoMy hope is that supply chain issues will make clear the downsides to execs (not just the workers) and governments of externalizing all manufacturing abroad and out of reach. Look at the chaos caused by a pandemic, now imagine war or purposefully using supply chain as leverage.
- coliveira 5y agoThis is all momentary situation caused by the pandemic. In one year, people will not even remember this. Companies will not spend billions of dollars unless they have no other option.
- mywittyname 5y agoI disagree. People will remember this and make irrational decisions based on these memories for years. For comparison, the Great Financial Crisis still looms over us so much that people still anticipate another huge housing burst. And when companies like Ford announce that they aren't using FICO scores to determine if a person qualifies for a loan, people on websites start fearmongering about another sub prime lending crisis.
- duped 5y agoBold to predict that the supply shortages will be over in one year
- joe_the_user 5y agoCompanies will not spend billions of dollars unless they have no other option. I don't think you're necessarily right this is temporary. But companies always have the option of just not producing. If no one has blue paint, for most uses, the consumer just buys another color and grumbles. And the things that are most likely to have a shortage would be those things that are cheapest produce a large scale in just one part of the world, so they're things that would be hardest to replace.
- gremloni 5y agoI wish it gets to that point. A country that doesn’t manufacture is a huge loser in the long run. I hope it comes back to America in a heavily automated, sustainable fashion.
- lonk 5y agoMining yellow from green can help.
- Kluny 5y agoJazz musicians have started singing the yellows.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- smegcicle 5y agoYInMn Blue is nothing but trouble
- bitwize 5y agoIt's all right. According to Hackernews, we need only change our languages to exclude a word for blue, then blue won't exist and we wonpt need blue paint.
- aazaa 5y agoThat website is a catastrophe. The banner on the left prevents the intro text from being read. There's also a banner on the right which is similar in behavior. Neither can be dismissed. Text can't be copied without dragging along useless marketing material. There is no Reader view to nuke the bad design decisions. Strangely, the original story ran on Bloomberg itself, which isn't mentioned in the article. Fortunately, the archive.md trick works. https://archive.md https://archive.md
- junon 5y agoThese sorts of comments are against HN guidelines. It's not conducive to complain about the site's poor UX, as aggravating as it is.
- aazaa 5y agoYou're right. Deleting... Oops, can't do that, it appears.
- CamperBob2 5y agoDisagree. Atrocities like this website exist precisely because the sort of people who hang around here didn't say 'No' when ordered to create them.
- junon 5y agoTake it up with dang, then. I don't make the rules.
- kowlo 5y agoAn amazing display of the modern web: https://imgur.com/a/6a15t0U https://imgur.com/a/6a15t0U
- oasisbob 5y ago> "There is one basic color tint that is extremely difficult to get" Any idea of the possible tint which is being referred to? Wondering if it's a mineral source requiring mining, heavy-metal processing, or what?
- archildress 5y agoCould be Titanium Dioxide that is involved in whitening. Have seen enough from my view that this would be my guess. And what could be more basic than that. :)
- stan_rogers 5y agoLikely cobalt. Most of the other blues are either made of relatively abundant elements or have very good synthetic equivalents.
- skhr0680 5y agohttps://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2018/05/14/new-blue-pigment-color-chemistry https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2018/05/14/new-blue-pigment-...
- shakna 5y ago> Rising energy costs - coal and crude - have pushed up prices of raw materials such as phthalic anhydride, cuprous chloride and urea. These are used to manufacture CPC Blue (Copper phthalocyanine blue) crude, a key ingredient of pigment blue, which in turn goes into the making of various shades of blue paints. [0] [0] https://m.timesofindia.com/city/ahmedabad/gujarats-bolt-from-blue-leaves-global-paint-makers-in-red/articleshow/87196319.cms https://m.timesofindia.com/city/ahmedabad/gujarats-bolt-from...
- archildress 5y agoThank you Toyota and practitioners of "lean" / "Six Sigma" that told us all about the wonders of just-in-time, to only carry exactly as much inventory was needed for demand. After all, we'd rather have that cash in a bank account than tied up in inventory. While well intentioned, the problem is that it all relies on assumptions, largely tied to demand. And when demand goes through a wild whipsaw, and everyone takes diverging viewpoints of the shape of that whipsaw curve, the highly interdependent chain snaps. Labor is an issue for sure. But make no mistake, the "restart from COVID" supply chain conundrum owes a lot of its pain to optimizing everything to the hilt, then reacting slowly as the world around us changed.
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoToyota actually isn't as JIT as you make it out to be, but that notwithstanding, what's the alternative? Stockpile 30 years' worth of Christmas ornaments in warehouses in Oklahoma, right next to the oil storage?
- archildress 5y agoIt’s almost as if there are happy mediums in between the two scenarios. :)
- LurkingPenguin 5y ago2 years' worth of Christmas ornaments? 10 years' worth? The amount of crap that we consume is astounding. And in many cases, each specific type of crap requires a bunch of smaller crap (components). There is literally no way for a consumption-driven society as broad and deep as ours to stockpile years' worth of everything.
- archildress 5y agoAll planning really is based on assumptions, like safety stock levels. In organizations you typically have someone who decides "hey, this is the right level of inventory to keep, based on our demand right now." That's not a bad approach, but the problem is a lot of supply chain planning is top-down and dictates "we only want to keep $x tied up in inventory" and as you can imagine that number is driven by management as low as possible. When COVID happened last year, levels were slashed so low and now the supply chains can't recover. Basically my view is that it's this over reactiveness and obsession with free cash flow has swung so far so as to create a too-painful jam. I would agree that over consumption is a problem, albeit a separate one to the conversation at hand. Cheers.
- xyzelement 5y agoI think the color purple is considered regal because whatever the dye used to be made from (crushed marine life or something like that) was very expensive. So if you had purple, it meant you were rich. It would be kinda funny if blue things became a sign of wealth because of this.
- routerl 5y agoIt wasn't just any purple, but the particular purple that came from a species of sea snail. For example, purple dyes were common in China many centuries before the Roman Tyrian Purple we're talking about, but never gained this luxury status. So it's worth pointing out that Tyrian Purple was an exceptionally long lasting dye; it did not fade when left in the sun, or after washing. Compared to other purple fabrics, Tyrian Purple fabrics always looked brand new, and I suspect that this is the real origin of their high-status associations.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoSo it was expensive to make and worth the expense involved because of it's unusual durability. It wasn't some artificial scarcity, like modern day diamonds, nor "valuable" merely because it was scarce. Thank you for that. That's a wonderful bit of trivia.
- toxik 5y agoWell, “worth it” is a stretch - I think they almost put the snail to extinction from needing so much of it.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI meant financially. People have been doing terrible environmental damage to indulge themselves for eons. We aren't exactly the brightest bulb in the box about some things.
- routerl 5y agoIsn't it just? I like that it wasn't enough for it to be rare (which it was) and laborious to produce (which it was), but also that it had unusual and very practical properties. It seems as if today, mainly due to marketing, luxury goods get away with just being rare (even if artificially), or just being laborious to produce (e.g. the old (false) notion that "a Rolls Royce is completely hand-made").
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoSo much for future printings of House of Leaves.
- TomAbel 5y agoAfter the 2011 Japan earthquake automakers ran into a the same problem, they ran out of a pigment called Xirallic made by Merck >After the earthquake, automakers worldwide were forced to stop making cars of certain colors because they couldn't get the aluminum-flaked Xirallic pigment that makes the paint sparkle. Merck was making the pigment at only one plant worldwide -- its Onahama plant in the quake zone -- and kept significant stocks of the product only at the same factory. It took months to restart the plant and resume deliveries.[1] The Verge did a really good profile of the perils of just-in-time manufacturing in respect to Apple that highlights how highly efficient JIT in reducing costs but that it ultimately leads to more fragile supply chains.[2] >Just-in-time manufacturing is highly efficient, but it’s not resilient.This style of manufacturing cuts costs — but it also means that if the supply chain is disrupted, there will be shortages.[2] I really like this insight >To make a more resilient system, a lot of companies may have to rethink just-in-time manufacturing. Resilience doesn’t show up as clearly on balance sheets as cost reduction, but it’s crucial for surviving disruptive events. Lowering costs by creating economies of scale and volume looks good most of the time, but once there’s a failure, companies don’t have many options.[2] [1]https://www.autonews.com/article/20130715/OEM10/307159926/pigment-maker-s-lesson-from-japan-quake https://www.autonews.com/article/20130715/OEM10/307159926/pi... (Paywalled) Archive: https://archive.md/Yoqe2 https://archive.md/Yoqe2 [2]https://www.theverge.com/2020/3/13/21177024/apple-just-in-time-manufacturing-china-coronavirus-supply-chain https://www.theverge.com/2020/3/13/21177024/apple-just-in-ti...
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoJust how much stock would companies need to avoid the problems we have now? This isn't just a supply side problem, demand for some goods has gone through the roof. How can a business compete on resilience when all their competitors are cheaper because they carry less stock. I'm not even sure I'd want that as a consumer. Mostly I'd rather wait than pay more (although obviously not for food).
- azinman2 5y agoExcept waiting ripples through the economy. You may not need a particular thing, but something that depends on it for their business 18 chain links away from things you need, does. And without it, certain businesses might not be able to sell anything, and thus go bankrupt, and thus put people out of work. It's all a very complicated interconnected web
- chiefalchemist 5y agoPaintmakers (plural)? Or paintmaker (singular)? Was this a proactively written article or a quick rehash of a press release? It mentions a single paint manufacturer. One. No doubt there are supply chain issues. Apparently there are journalism integrity issues as well. Yeah, it feels innoscent. But lazy and journalism are two words that do not belong together. Ever.
- vitus 5y agohttps://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/gujarats-bolt-from-blue-leaves-global-paint-makers-in-red/articleshow/87196319.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/gujarats-... seems like it fills in several missing details that other commenters have asked about (what is it about blue? is this more than just a single paintmaker in the Netherlands?). (I have my own gripes about that website, like how it tries to prevent copy-pasting via JS, or that it links to arbitrary phrases that aren't common topics or other news articles like you'd expect. But at least it has more context about this situation.) > To put things in perspective, an estimated 59% of the annual 1.1 lakh tonne of global supply of blue pigment comes from Gujarat (India's share is 82%). > However, pigment manufacturers - small and large - in the state have been forced to reduce production by 25-50% due to the surge in prices of raw materials, their unavailability and working capital issues. > Rising energy costs - coal and crude - have pushed up prices of raw materials such as phthalic anhydride, cuprous chloride and urea. These are used to manufacture CPC Blue (Copper phthalocyanine blue) crude, a key ingredient of pigment blue, which in turn goes into the making of various shades of blue paints.
- joecool1029 5y agoWonder if the new blue pigment, YInMn blue will start to replace some of the older pigments sorta like the NAND industry shift from planar NAND V-NAND, or if it's remaining stupidly expensive still. Discussion from 9 months ago on HN about the new blue (top comment was interesting on pigment pricing): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25807199 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25807199
- runnerup 5y agoNo. Raw materials of YInMn will never be cheap enough to compete with phthalo blue. Chemical formula for phthalo blue is C32 H16 Cu N8 Of these, everything is super cheap and only Cu (Copper) really has any substantial cost. 1 kg of Copper (15.7 moles) is $10. 1 kg of hydrocarbons (~9 moles, Octane) is...about $0.48 at a US gas pump. Chemical formula for YInMn blue is (loosely) Y In0.8 Mn0.2 O3 Of these, everything is super expensive and only the "O" (oxygen) is relatively cheap. 1 kg of Indium (8.7 moles) is over $600. Doing some dimensional analysis with additional hidden molecular weights, you can make 1 kg (1.75 moles) of phthalo blue with less than $1-2 of raw materials. Currently the price of raw phthalo blue pigment is about $6 in bulk, so we can assume that processing costs about $4-5 per kg (65-80%), and the $1-2 of raw materials makes up 20-35%. However, just the indium in 1kg (4.17 moles) of YInMn blue will cost you $275. Now, this is twice as many moles vs phthalo blue so assuming (bad assumption) that you need roughly the same number of pigment molecules for visual perception you could get the equivalent "deepness" as 1kg of phthalo blue with half the weight of pigment ($140). But even if your Yttrium and Manganese were completely free, and processing cost you $0.00 per kilogram....you'd still be 10 times what the price of phthalo blue is in the current shortage! Yttrium is $34/kg btw, so you'll need about $12 of this to make 1kg of YInMn. Manganese is $2/kg and you'll only need about $0.10 of manganese to make 1kg of YInMn.
- xenonite 5y agoI am not so surprised as the new iPhone is colored blue. /irony off
- h2odragon 5y ago..and the artists all cried out in woad
- kaminar 5y agoHe's a victim of the planned crisis...it will only end when compete control is established...or those squeezing us are removed.