4 ms·
> we can physically create ample prosperity for every human on Earth today or you imagine it is possible, because you have it. It is not likely that every hum
by chii 5y ago
> we can physically create ample prosperity for every human on Earth today
or you imagine it is possible, because you have it.
It is not likely that every human can live the wealthy life style of americans. Current day technology can barely withstand the lack of gas and fossil fuel for a few weeks.
Until the day star trek replicators exist, it won't be possible.
- benreesman 5y agoPhotovoltaics alone are efficient at levels that would have sounded preposterous when I was a kid. This is over and above the fact that we’ve known how to build safe, reliable fission reactors for decades now. I want to believe that there’s a reason we don’t better than “nuclear reactor” shares a word with “nuclear weapon”, but when the planet you live on is substantially built out of raw fuel that doesn’t poison the skies, and you keep burning the kind that does? I don’t know what your background is, it sort of sounds like you can tell I’m a US passport holder and are coming from a different POV. A little inside baseball: during the entire 20th century and bleeding into the 21st, Americans did in fact enjoy a quality of life that most of the world did not. In some limited ways that’s even true today. But in the ways that matter, it’s getting really rough for the average family here these days. Something like 70% of American households could be forced into the red over a broken car needed for work, and basically everyone here is either paying (one way or another) much/most of what they earn on artificially expensive healthcare that the rest of the civilized world takes for granted. People use the term “opioid crisis” because even that is easier to say than: “people are killing themselves at a rate we refuse to even print”. There was an implied contract: on the one hand the US citizen got to burn a bunch more carbon and have a bigger TV, on the other hand that person was paying for the invention of everything from the transistor to the Internet, paying for the R&D on most important pharmaceuticals, policing the seas via the US Navy so all those container ships make it to their destination, keeping India and Pakistan’s nuclear aspirations in their lane, containing the only super states more authoritarian than the USA (e.g. you can buy a 5nm phone from foundries that you couldn’t absent wars my family members have fought and died in). Ceteris paribus it’s still more advantageous to be born in Santa Barbara than Kinsasha. But this “clueless, spoiled American” trope is wearing thin. It was the British Empire that did most of the ugly colonial stuff that we somehow got blamed for, and when the median person in a country is choosing between healthcare and heating oil: words like “wealthy” might not be the best to generalize with.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>In some limited ways that’s even true today. GDP per capita in America is about $64K, world GDP per capita is about $11K ($17K PPP). If you think Americans aren't that well off then you are mistaken.
- benreesman 5y agoIIUC GDP per capita is roughly the arithmetic mean? The United States is winding down it’s run as the most productive, innovative, dynamic economic superpower in the recorded history of humanity. That was inevitably going to create the odd Ken Griffin, or Jim Simons, or Jeff Bezos or whatever. But to the median person, it’s cold fucking comfort that Bezos is dragging the average up via his useful deployment of capital while they are literally cold.
- imtringued 5y ago>world GDP per capita is about $11K ($17K PPP) That number is being dragged down by a huge number of people in global poverty. There is enough potential here to get to $30k PPP and I'd say that would be enough "wealth" for the vast majority of people.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>It is not likely that every human can live the wealthy life style of americans. That's not the same thing as ample prosperity. It's clear that America and other rich parts of the world have been overindulging for some time.
- benreesman 5y agoEh, it’s a tricky question when indulgence becomes over-indelgence. The USA inherited a world where colonial exploitation, brutality, and genocide were the accepted norm. In fact, like all adolescents raised by abusive parents, the USA took it out on someone even less able to defend themselves. With that said, the type checker is going to say that we’re going to compare like with like, and as utterly dominant hegemonic global superpowers go, the USA isn’t really pushing the scoreboard on innocent lives taken or ruined. The Empire or the USSR or the Mongols would be embarrassed if they had a weekend when they failed to genocide more people than the USA ever has. It’s a sad defense to be less evil, but if there’s ever been a world-spanning empire that didn’t slaughter innocents in job lots, I’ve never heard of it. Heavy lies the head that wears the crown, as the CCP is about to re-learn. When it’s your job to carry global stability on your back, you might unwind with an over-indulgence in some OPEC output. For better or worse, this is pretty much the PRC’s problem now, and I for one am looking forward to a world where being American doesn’t make one a priori complicit in the fucking Raj.