14 ms·
I've got some visibility to the logistics industry. My experience doesn't quite fit some of the posts in here / that story. Drivers have been making LESS over
by duxup 5y ago
I've got some visibility to the logistics industry. My experience doesn't quite fit some of the posts in here / that story.
Drivers have been making LESS over the years for a few decades now.
Nobody wants to hire 18 year olds generally, insurance wouldn't allow it any way...
Logistics companies who hire drivers have been complaining about driver shortages but not increasing wages for years as well... and they actually seem to meet demand just fine. Issues at choke points like ports don't seem to be a pure driver supply issue from what I've seen.
The logistics industry is super price sensitive, people will complain... but they'll also wait to ship a thing to save a couple bucks (I'm not kidding when I say a couple bucks) all while complaining.
The drivers you hear who make a good living have specialized skills / work for specialized companies and do not reflect the industry as a whole.
- avgDev 5y agoI used to be friends with a few truck drivers, and all of them were making money because all of them were cheatings the books non-stop. It was basically a job requirement. Drive 48 hours? No problem. This has been made a lot more difficult with the electronic log books. Edit: Just want to add some additional information. Trucking companies at least were my friends worked, were extremely toxic. They made close to $100k. However, their personal life suffered greatly. Dispatchers would call them non-stop, even when they had doctor visits/family gatherings scheduled. The dispatchers would give them loads, that were basically humanely impossible to be delivered on-time by the book. Some of them would be awake all day, and leave in the evening then drive 24 hours+. Dispatchers would often scream at them, when they would call because they were falling asleep and were not going to make the delivery on-time because they needed a nap. Some of them actually crashed, because they saw a "deer" lol.....they fell asleep. These friends were uneducated, and made terrible financial decisions, such a purchasing expensive cars and modifying them. Little to no savings. This put them in an awful position in which they had to keep driving no matter how toxic the environment was. Unfortunately, I don't really know how they are doing today, as we grew apart.
- imtringued 5y ago>These friends were uneducated, and made terrible financial decisions, such a purchasing expensive cars and modifying them. Little to no savings. From a macroeconomic perspective these guys are heroes.
- duxup 5y agoYup, there was a big hit to guys driving extra hours when it became easier to spot them. It was easy to make extra money, but it was at the cost of all of their time. It kinda inflated how good a living you could make...at least looking at the end results. But it also wasn't very realistic.
- watwut 5y agoDriving too much is not just at the cost of time. It is at the cost of life, drivers and whoever he crashes into.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>Driving too much is not just at the cost of time. It is at the cost of life, drivers and whoever he crashes into. Do you really think a middle aged truck driver is (was) holding the steering wheel for 16hr straight as a matter of routine business? Of course not. Tropes like that make for easy online virtue points but that wasn't the reality for the overwhelming majority of people who were cooking the books. These guys were putting in 60-80hr 6/7 day weeks. It's no different than the plant maintenance tech or the IT guy doing the same thing. What they sacrificed was their outside of work life. Nobody is working those kinds of hours and having a life outside work. You would have physical complications from that in very short order. And occasionally someone would go overboard, drive 36hr straight and cause a crash. And because that's an easy thing for people who have zero knowledge of industry incentives and feedback loops to get their panties in a knot over they made it "extra illegal" because you can't make being an idiot illegal. And so now the industry cuts far less tasteful corners and pays everyone crap and you have drivers who have barely memorized the pre-trip, have barely and hours behind the wheel, can't read english, and who choose a different career in short order and are likewise treated as disposable. So the net effect is more or less a wash but a handful of people get to get big raises and some politicians can pat themselves on the back for "solving" logbook fraud.
- mistrial9 5y agoI watched a grown man, a skilled and conscientious man, learn to drive an 18-wheeler in California and try to make a living. It is dangerous, it will test the nerves of the driver. You will be bullied, it is the culture. The price pressure on wages, for a fully qualified and competent driver, were relentlessly downward in the USA. The ports here are full of refugees sleeping in the cabs of their leased trucks. The callousness and stupid-on-stupid business practices are a cacophony. Civilized people need not apply to either end of it.
- president 5y agoThat's life. Not everyone can afford a cushy 6-figure desk and chair job.
- avs733 5y agoThe problem is society can’t afford the outcome of paying truck drivers less. Lower paid, younger, less experienced, more exhausted, and passed off truck drivers are an increased danger to other drivers. That is an externality, to say it’s just life is pretty much saying it’s acceptable to underpay people as longing as the only risk is to others…
- thrashh 5y agoYeah I think it’s ridiculous that people forget that we only got to this point because previous generations built a framework which we currently live in and where many of us can prosper. If we want to abandon that and go back to the centuries of fiefdom where we barely made progress, by all means do it somewhere else.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- avs733 5y agoCorporations willing to hollow out the foundation of society is their fault, not people who get told to “find a better laying job” If your job is essential to the functio of society you should 1) have a living wage 2) have a group advocating and bargaining in Your interests 3) have a say in the corporate management Essential employees are essential to society, not to corporations. Society (I.e., government) should assure they are treated in a functional way
- typon 5y agoIt's an extremely difficult and dangerous job. The drivers deserve to be paid more than the current wages. Driving ruined my dad's health permanently - the long term costs aren't even factored in usually.
- dajohnson89 5y agoWhat are the health risks?
- neverartful 5y agoDriving accidents
- celim307 5y agoFrom acquaintances I know, the combination of long periods of sitting, stimulant abuse, lack of healthy food options, inconsistent sleep, air quality from being around other trucks, stress from the job, and mental isolation from being away from friends and family all are really hard, even for a year. Now imagine a 30+ Year career.
- nonameiguess 5y agoSitting for 8-12 hours a day in a cramped position is bad for your back, neck, shoulders, hips. Name a joint and it's gonna get messed up eventually. There's also a risk of blood clots and generally anything that can be caused by poor circulation, especially in your legs. Add to that poor sleep from sleeping in your cab or possibly a crappy motel if you're lucky, not getting enough sleep, rarely being able to exercise or eat well, and obesity and muscle degeneration start to become pretty serious risks, too.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- typon 5y agoThis is exactly what happened with my dad
- throwaway2037 5y agoThank you to share you first hand insights. What do you think about this YouTube video that has over 4m views? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GQXVgniI-hw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GQXVgniI-hw Basically, this guy says take it on the chin for a year or two and keep a clean record. Then you can easily change companies and earn a solid middle class salary. Do you believe it or think his wages are bit "bubbly"? Honestly, I'm not involved in the logistic industry, but his video looks "no-BS" and straight forward. If was looking for solid working class / middle class job, I would be watching this video for tips!
- duxup 5y agoIt's hard to speak to anyone's given experience. It's not impossible that anyone could drive well for a while and land in a good place, but that's not the industry I see. I don't see people suddenly getting paid well after 30 months. I don't have first hand experience with the Walmart example, but I've heard from others they get their pick of the most experienced drivers / don't pay poorly, but they're not the industry and the idea of just meeting their minimum to be considered and magically getting a job sounds a bit silly. To me that's a YouTube video that implies a lot, isn't impossible, but doesn't say much about the odds of any of it being true for a given person either ... The industry I know has demand for drivers, but the outcome of that isn't what you might think. There's "demand" where they demand folks who aren't paid well, and then there's real demand.
- neither_color 5y ago“The first thing I do when I wake up is reacclimate my self to the baffling reality of conscious experience” I felt that. This video makes it seem pretty cool actually, minus the packaged foods and microwaved meals.
- kingaillas 5y agoThat's a good video: humorous, informative, interesting. >If was looking for solid working class / middle class job, I would be watching this video for tips! You might want to watch more videos, move over to his youtube channel... because he quits trucking earlier this year: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gk8AnMzhZZE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gk8AnMzhZZE The downsides caught up to him after ~3 years. He also worked his salary out to roughly $8/hr (see video for details) considering time spent "on the job". So, perhaps this isn't the solid advertisement for the industry you were thinking it is.
- newacct583 5y ago> complaining about driver shortages but not increasing wages This is the core truth in virtually every "<worker> shortage" story. It's true for every profession, every occupation, every market. Pay a market wage and the problem goes away. What the headlines really should be is "Rapid change in wages causes headaches for employers". I mean, it's true that short term shocks to wage levels (and covid has been one hell of a shock) cause disruption to markets. That's worth covering. But the root cause is not and never has been a "lack of people", it's that the population of people willing to work at the now-sub-market wage is smaller than employers want.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> What the headlines really should be is "Rapid change in wages causes headaches for employers". It's more like employers are feigning a labor shortage because they want access to the cheap and abusable visa labor they exploited before the pandemic.
- giantg2 5y ago"Logistics companies who hire drivers have been complaining about driver shortages but not increasing wages for years as well..." Sounds like a lot of companies and industries these days, including mine for software devs.
- JPKab 5y agoYou forgot the part where people under 21 years of age aren't allowed to drive big rigs across state lines. Electronic logbooks are the main reason drivers lost wages recently. Turns out that the market had adjusted to an equilibrium that expected drivers to fudge their log books, and once the ability to fudge was removed, the absolute morons who fill the ranks of logistics companies wouldn't up their rates and the market equilibrium was broken. This caused drivers to leave the business. It can't be overstated how absolutely dumb the average desk jockey in the logistics space truly is. Having had to deal with a few different companies over the years (Hapag Lloyd, various CPG companies, Marten), there was no contest in offices with just straight up low-IQ but cocky jocks filling the desks. A brother-in-law is in the transportation industry, and he routinely uses fancy words he doesn't understand on calls (I hear them when I'm visiting) and nobody on the call is capable of calling him out. A recent example was when he was saying that "we need to work on improving the linear regressions on our deliveries"........ I tried to explain to him that the term wasn't what he thought it was, and he literally couldn't absorb what I said. He is in charge of hundreds of millions of throughput for a massive food corporation whose products are in every household in the country. Near as I can tell, the entire industry is a bunch of mediocrities with spreadsheets spending most of their days in meetings comparing their numbers and getting yelled at when they don't line up correctly.