9 ms·
Hacker steals government ID database for Argentina's entire population
- goldcd 5y ago"Ministry of Interior said its security team discovered that a VPN account assigned to the Ministry of Health was used to query the RENAPER database for 19 photos “in the exact moment in which they were published on the social network Twitter.”" My guess is that this was slightly afterwards - I know if I had access to the db and saw some information being posted on twitter, I might want to cross-check (well that make more sense, than the poster looking up these people and doxing them instantaneously)
- sudoaza 5y agoNah looks like a legit way to get it, probably unintended, for sure Ministry of Health is way less secure than RENAPER. Somebody was looking around, found that and win.
- bobsmooth 5y ago"According to a sample provided by the hacker online, the information they have access to right now includes full names, home addresses, birth dates, gender info, ID card issuance and expiration dates, labor identification codes, Trámite numbers, citizen numbers, and government photo IDs." And entire country just got doxxed. That's insane.
- maze-le 5y agoAll this information in one database... Thats the real insanity here. Why would anyone think that this is a good idea? Leave aside security and safeguards for a moment, just compiling this database is neglectful at the very least...
- sofixa 5y agoWhat? How do you imagine that could work? Only paper records, and any interaction with any public administration thing takes a few months? It's generally a good idea to have the tax office, the healthcare ministry/insurance people, police, etc. know who the people of the country are and how to identify them. It's the norm in the EU, and works fine as long as security is taken seriously (which obviously wasn't in Argentina).
- Pxtl 5y agoYes, I think it's a good idea for government to have that info. Government needs to provide services and manage resources, which means knowing who and where people live, and have a proper ID number to manage that data. The alternative is for government to have 90% subsets of the same data in a a thousand different databases, one per-department, per-jurisdiction.
- Arrath 5y agoAnd then Dept A thinks you live here, Dept B thinks you live there, Dept C thinks you have a warrant out for your arrest, and little municipal dept Y.43 thinks you're dead. Yeah, I can see a few problems with that.
- marcosdumay 5y agoThat's a basic citizen database. The only non-obvious information is the labor identification code. Except for that, it's just "who exists and how do we call them?"
- heavenlyblue 5y agoI don't understand how you can seriously think that having two databases instead of one would make it any easier. OK, if we had two databases the overlap would be, let's say, 50% and there would be another 20% in the database A that doesn't exist in database B. Still 70% of information stolen. That on top of the fact that having two separate databases means twice the probability of different bugs in two different systems. We must all move away from using PI as passwords, that's all we need to do. Then this problem will go away.
- dewey 5y ago> We must all move away from using PI as passwords, that's all we need to do. Then this problem will go away. You make it sound like it's an easily solved problem, which it apparently isn't.
- adolph 5y agoI just use password reset every time I have to log in and do enough login fails afterward to lockout my account.
- vadfa 5y agoIsn't it like this in practically every European country? We have ID cards with every one of those fields printed on them, including thumbprints. All of that information is probably in one big table somewhere.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoMost EU cards also integrate fiscal id numbers and national healthcare id numbers in the chip but arguably do exclude registered address, so only a city/province of residence is available.
- vadfa 5y agoNot sure about the rest but Spanish ID card includes full address.
- N19PEDL2 5y agoItalian ID cards too, as well as the owner's signature, the fiscal code (an unique identification code similar to the SSN in the USA) and the fingerprints (though these latter are stored in the chip only, not printed on the card). It's very likely that this data is also stored in some government database, which I hope will never get breached.
- CaciaraAsAServi 5y agoNitpick (as you well know) - codice fiscale in Italy differs from USA SSN in that, for once, it has never had AFAIK any semblance of secrecy at all, as you can easily construct it starting from name, surname, place and date of birth [1] Funnily enough, this sometimes results in two individuals computing to the same code [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_fiscal_code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_fiscal_code [2] https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omocodia https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omocodia
- soco 5y agoSwiss cards not but well Switzerland is not EU...
- gomox 5y agoThis is a country where when they installed license plate scanners on highways they accompanied them with large screens that show the plate that was just scanned. So as to... I don't know, brag that you're collecting all this information, that is to be inevitably leaked in a while? To make people feel safe, while clearly indicating the highway exits to avoid if you actually steal a car?
- stef25 5y ago> This is a country where when they installed license plate scanners on highways they accompanied them with large screens that show the plate that was just scanned. This is done in France when it catches you driving too fast. "ABC 123" you're going too fast! It's a bit jarring your plate up on a screen so it works kind of well against speeding. They don't need to store your plate to use this feature. Of course plates are being scanned (and probably stored) all over the place now (toll booths, big roads in & out of the cities), not denying that.
- gomox 5y agoIn our case its not shaming you for speeding or anything specific, it just displays every plate that it scans to advertise the scanner. Also in a not very surprising turn of events, a lot of the screens just show a fixed plate these days which makes you wonder which component broke (is it the screen, or the scanner?)
- Spooky23 5y agoThe horse left the barn before you were born. All of this information is in multiple single databases maintained by insurance companies in the US. And that data is in turn linked to all sorts of behavioral and affinity data. GEICO knows more about you than DMV.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- richlandlord 5y agoTo be fair this information is already public in argentina. There is no secrecy to almost any of this, as ID numbers are public, sequential and queryable for tax status, debt status, etc.
- taurath 5y agoWhat are the fallback plans here in case of a hack like this? Assign new numbers, somehow? Require all financial activities be done in person? The implications all seem awful
- gjvnq 5y agoThe "right" solution is to not use person info as "passwords". Instead, give everyone a digital certificate with the private key stored in smartcards that don't allow anyone to copy the key, only to use it.
- jeroenhd 5y agoThose are problematic as well, because they're very costly. One country that implemented authentication and signing this way (I think it was Estonia?) had to recall and replace every single smart card after someone discovered a way to clone the RSA chip on them. With some bad luck, you're replacing these multiple times per year because smart card vendors often overstate the security of their products. You could, of course, use real passwords, like every single service out there on the internet. Force some level of 2FA for security as well and you should be fine security wise. Incremental plaintext numbers are not passwords, though. European countries have solved this problem in a variety of ways (that have been made cross-compatible and federated, even) and none of them use numbers on identification as a security number.
- inter_netuser 5y agoThe only real fix is not to have central databases at all (Germany does that to a large extent), and keep only necessary things on electronic media (Lawyers and psychiatrists still do that today). It can be done. Not everything must be electronic, and not everything must be centralized.
- stef25 5y agoHere in Belgium we have smart card IDs. You assign a 4 digit pin as password and then use a smart card reader to access various govt websites. Only problem is you have to install a browser plugin that has to be compatible with your browser version and some non-technical people get confused. Apart from that it's actually a pretty good system. It's now being replaced with a smartphone app, one that uses servers in the USA which poses all kinds of GDPR / privacy issues.
- gomox 5y agoThe "tramite number" mentioned in the article is quite funny. "Tramite number" translates loosely to "filing number". When national IDs were issued each one got a "tramite number" that I'm guessing was sequentially assigned when the physical ID cards where issued. Because this number is vaguely random and is printed on the actual physical ID card, it was used as a password on government apps (for example, for getting authorization to move around during covid). To log into the app, you enter your national ID number and then the "tramite number" that is printed on your physical ID card. Of course, the number can't be changed, and is stored in plaintext in a large database somewhere. It therefore makes for a horrible password. The database in question just got stolen, and the aforementioned apps now include all sorts of sensitive PII.
- rtkwe 5y agoSame problem happened with SSN in the US. It was too convenient of a unique, quasi-secret identifier so it became a password too.
- riffraff 5y agoI never understood the SSN-as-quasi-secret bit: isn't it widely dispersed anytime you need some medical stuff?
- vmception 5y agoYeah, and people within earshot are not the issue, it’s the place that has thousands of SSNs getting hacked that the issue, so there is no reason to be secret about it.
- puglr 5y agoTo add to this, prior to the internet it really wasn't that bad of a "password". Once upon a time vacuuming up batches of SSNs for nefarious purposes wasn't a realistic attack scenario, let alone a "just assume every criminal has your SSN" one.
- javipas 5y agoIt seems the hack has been denied by Argentina's government officials https://www-lanacion-com-ar.translate.goog/sociedad/tras-un-confuso-episodio-desmienten-que-se-haya-hackeado-la-web-con-los-datos-de-todos-los-dni-del-nid13102021/?_x_tr_sl=es&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=es&_x_tr_pto=nui https://www-lanacion-com-ar.translate.goog/sociedad/tras-un-... (via Google Translate)
- lukas238 5y agoFrom Argentina here. Government launched a web site were one can change his own "trámite number" (aka application number). Thad said, this is garbage. Government security is a joke here. Few years back, another security break happened because a police data base was publicly accesible. The fix was to "block" international access by editing national DNS.... I want to cry.
- the_svd_doctor 5y agoHow do you authenticate to change your tramite number? With the previous number?
- madmulita 5y agoWelcome to Peronistan.
- HeckFeck 5y agoThere are many reasons to oppose government ID schemes on principle. Consequences like these just demonstrate the case.
- standardUser 5y ago"Government ID" sounds redundant. What other form of ID would make sense? Either we live in a world without IDs (and other information inevitably fills that void and becomes a de facto ID), or we allow for-profit enterprise to manage personal identification.
- supertrope 5y agoFacebook login /s
- supertrope 5y agoIAM is a tough problem. We need solid technical underpinnings, scalable and consistent new ID issuance procedures, revocation and reiussance workflows, accommodation for those on the wrong side of the digital divide, fraud resistance, and of course this has to be at very low cost for equity reasons and good stewardship of tax money.
- otrahuevada 5y agoHacker has been discovered to be a random disgruntled employee looking for a quick buck. Hope he serves as a lesson of how to not behave as a public servant.
- ByThyGrace 5y agoSource?
- otrahuevada 5y agoNobleza obliga, latest news indicate the guy extricated a whole lot of records and it would appear authorities are nowhere near as close to unequivocally identifying him as was originally said.
- otrahuevada 5y agohttps://www.lanacion.com.ar/sociedad/tras-un-confuso-episodio-desmienten-que-se-haya-hackeado-la-web-con-los-datos-de-todos-los-dni-del-nid13102021/ https://www.lanacion.com.ar/sociedad/tras-un-confuso-episodi... IT talked to Twitter and found a very narrow amount of people with the ability to do this.
- ByThyGrace 5y agoBut that was before what the OP article is claiming. > However, The Record contacted the individual who was renting access to the RENAPER database on hacking forums. > In a conversation earlier today, the hacker said they have a copy of the RENAPER data, contradicting the government’s official statement. > The individual proved their statement by providing the personal details, including the highly sensitive Trámite number, of an Argentinian citizen of our choosing.
- otrahuevada 5y ago"Breach" in this case would imply this was an external attacker and not an inside job; from all the info that is available at the moment, what appears to have happened is some guy with continous access to an entirely legitimate system but malicious intent basically managed to craft his own dump of all the records. Based solely on the exposed field names those are not typical for government databases either, so this might have been reconstructed from a report or something. It also looks like the underlying permissions scheme is garbage, as there is literally no reason for this volume of data to be exportable by a random -even authorized!- user at the reported location.
- aemreunal 5y agoSame thing happened some number of years ago with Turkey and its ID database. The Turkish IDs have a "national ID number" (assigned to each citizen, is for life and is unchangeable) and a serial number for the ID itself. You need the national ID number to do certain things, similar to SSNs in the US. Similar to SSNs in the US, it's an absolutely horrible form of identity verification/authorization.
- adolph 5y agoSimilar thing happened in the US with a government database of PII and background check investigations. For a high value target its just a matter of when, not if. OPM subsequently confirmed that investigators had "a high degree of confidence that OPM systems containing information related to the background investigations of current, former, and prospective federal government employees, to include U.S. military personnel, and those for whom a federal background investigation was conducted, may have been exfiltrated." The Central Intelligence Agency, however, does not use the OPM system; therefore, it may not have been affected. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Personnel_Management_data_breach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Personnel_Management...
- forinti 5y agoIt's not hard at all to get your hands on a Brazilian CPF (Fiscal ID) database. You can buy it on DVD.
- mparnisari 5y agoI wish the article explained what the hacker can do with this data. The most I can think of is that it allows people to take loans on behalf of others.
- cptaj 5y agoProbably not. In latin america, government ID is pretty public and you share it for a lot of trivial stuff. It isnt considered a secret
- bearnax 5y agoThis is why, in Futurama, the government still uses paper docs.