4 ms·
Define "against the rest of us". The whole point of earning "extra" money is to be able to lay claim to scarce resources. Inevitably, outbidding someone for s
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
Define "against the rest of us". The whole point of earning "extra" money is to be able to lay claim to scarce resources. Inevitably, outbidding someone for something will be felt as using the extra earned money against them. If you cannot outbid someone, then the extra money is worth nothing, and hence there is no reason to work more than average.
- amelius 5y agoIf you take my comment as a basic premise of a fair economy, then "outbidding" does not make any sense. In fact, it makes more sense to share scarce resources. There are still many non-scarce things you can spend your extra money on. An example of what you can do: buying expensive cars. An example of what you can't do: buying up land so that everybody else has to pay higher prices for housing.
- gruez 5y ago>There are still many non-scarce things you can spend your extra money on. >An example of what you can do: buying expensive cars. Why are expensive cars not scarce? They're ultimately built using scarce resources (eg. steel, rubber, plastic, labor).
- agent327 5y agoExpensive cars are just as much a scarce resource as everything else is.
- chii 5y ago> non-scarce things you can spend your extra money on if they are non-scarce, then you already have obtained your required amount, and thus no longer demand more. > buying up land so that everybody else has to pay higher prices for housing. buying up assets, since assets would be scarce, allows you to demand payment for their use, and thus, ensure your future financial situation is secure. It sucks for those who don't own assets, but this system resolves the conflict of how to assign assets amongst people. And it gives those who don't own assets the motivation to work harder. The resulting society will then have more aggregate wealth than before.
- Jensson 5y agoNo, the scarcest resource is human time. If person A works for 1 hour then he added 1 hour of human work time to the pool of resources. Therefore it makes sense that he can now extract 1 extra hour of human work time from the pool of resources. Him doing that trade doesn't reduce the number of human work hours available to others, instead he increased the value of the pool since now there is more diversity of jobs the pool is capable of performing. Your assumption here is that you can trade human work hours for finite natural resources on some market, and that everyone has to pay for those resources on the market. There is nor reason why you should be able to do that, rather the natural system is to allocate all finite resources equally to each person and then you an pay for those with your work, but you working harder to pay a person to share his resources with you wouldn't affect anyone else in the economy unless they too wants to have extra of that resource.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> If person A works for 1 hour then he added 1 hour of human work time to the pool of resources. Therefore it makes sense that he can now extract 1 extra hour of human work time from the pool of resources. What if no one wants that 1 hour of labor? What if more people want 1 hour of a certain type of labor that exceeds the supply of that certain type of labor?
- Jensson 5y ago> What if no one wants that 1 hour of labor? Doesn't have to be hours, the hour was just to represent that it is a human working and not a finite resource. Different human work can be valued differently.
- sokoloff 5y agoThat wasn't at all clear (and you seemed to me to be suggesting exactly the opposite) in your comment upthread.
- amelius 5y ago
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> An example of what you can do: buying expensive cars. The fact that it is expensive is what defines it as scare (i.e. lots of demand relative to little supply). How about using a less fuel efficient vehicle? Is that “against others” as it uses up the non polluted portion of the environment? > An example of what you can't do: buying up land so that everybody else has to pay higher prices for housing. Land is not the same everywhere. Low humidity, Mediterranean climate, coast California views are extremely scarce and in high demand. How are you going to fit 8B people onto the world’s desirable land?
- Jensson 5y ago> Land is not the same everywhere. Low humidity, Mediterranean climate, coast California views are extremely scarce and in high demand. How are you going to fit 8B people onto the worlds desirable land? If you want better than median living conditions then you work for it. There is no reason why it should be free to live in the best parts of the world if not everyone can, otherwise the privilege of living there would be a source of injustice.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWho decides what is median living conditions and how is that decided?
- Jensson 5y agoThe conditions that are left when those above median have chosen theirs. If you want better you work for it. If you don't want better then you share the work those who worked for theirs produced. So you work just as much as you want, and others working more means those who don't have more. It is true that if you want a luxury resource, like a very attractive location to live in, then others working more for that position means you also would have to work harder if you want to have it. But I don't consider people competing for luxury resources a problem, no that is a feature and is what makes the economy tick. If you don't want that rat race you have to live in median conditions.