27 ms·
Obsidian – A knowledge base from a local folder of plain text Markdown files
- hn8788 5y agoMy biggest protip for Obsidian would be to never look at the connections graph. If you've got any kind of "completionist" mindset, it's easy to waste a bunch of time trying to perfectly format your notes so every node has a bunch of connections to other nodes. Once I got out of the habit trying to maximize the amount of backlinks in each note, it became a useful tool instead of a chore.
- crucialfelix 5y agoFor me the act of making connections is part of the review process. The connections are really in my head. The documents are just part of the memorization and structuring. I don't spend much time on it though. Just when a subject is unclear in my mind. The Jiggl extension gives a local network view that is actually useful and not overwhelming. You can custom style nodes by folder or tags. This makes it intuitive and worth keeping open in a frame.
- CraigJPerry 5y agoIronically i found the same behaviour in me and immediately thought it would be a great idea to further gamify colleagues writing docs. There is something rewarding about keeping the graph optimal. It becomes almost pretty to look at.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoJust add some achievements, XP, levels, silver/golden/diamond/epic statuses to notes with pretty colors and shiny graphics, and a lootbox mechanism with slot machine sound effects.
- nmaleki 5y agoCheck out my Obsidian instance for my YouTube channel: https://notes.recursion.is https://notes.recursion.is
- sachin-12 5y agoLooks great! How did you host it in your own domain?
- stoicjumbotron 5y agoIs that a single vault? Looks amazing!
- vira28 5y agoOnly thing that's holding me from using Obsidian is native Apple pencil support.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoObsidian really needs to start issuing NFT contributor badges, to those who volunteer to pay for the software.
- chaoskanzlerin 5y agoHere's an older HN thread with the author in it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23324598 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23324598
- bachmeier 5y agoAside from the technical characteristics of Obsidian, they have created a great community, particularly on Discord. They sell things (I'm a happy customer) but you can use it completely free. No nagging to buy or hitting you with ads or anything.
- tomcooks 5y agoBut how can I trust something I don't have the source code of as my second brain? My files are what is most dear to me, literally a backup of my brain.
- Havoc 5y agoSource code here matters less than the format of the data being accessible IMO
- PovilasID 5y agoWhat about non markdown alternatives. I colab with people who will not use markdown. Notion is ok... But I would like tools with some real knowledge management not just the basics
- conradludgate 5y agoI really do need to get started on a personal wiki. I might give this a try. It would be nice if I can get the files into git that I can save to a private github repo (I'm fine paying the one time payment to support them but $8/month seems too much for a simple sync feature)
- jammaloo 5y agoI've been playing with this app for a few minutes, and it does appear to save everything in plain text files, so adding it to git would be straightforward. I'm currently saving into a dropbox folder, which gives me automatic syncing.
- Version467 5y agoSince it's just markdown files, using a fit repo to sync it is trivial. There's even an obsidian plugin to automatically commit/push in regular intervals (i.e. every 30 minutes).
- gala8y 5y agohttps://github.com/denolehov/obsidian-git https://github.com/denolehov/obsidian-git
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Tomte 5y agoDokuwiki is easy to use, mature, stores its data in plain text files (no database needed, or supported). It also shows backlinks out of the box.
- bachmeier 5y ago> It would be nice if I can get the files into git that I can save to a private github repo It's just a directory of markdown files. Nothing preventing that directory from being a Git repo. Lots of people use it that way (or with Syncthing, Dropbox, or whatever).
- ncallaway 5y ago
- u-rate 5y agoGreat software, 100% recommend.
- throwaway81523 5y agoSpoiler: "Obsidian is a powerful knowledge base on top of a local folder of plain text Markdown files. " Thanks but org mode seems to handle that kind of thing just fine.
- rvieira 5y agoObsidian is great. I'm a paying supporter (catalyst and sync). Weirdly I started playing with Emacs + org-mode recently (never been an Emacs user before!) and I'm seriously considering making it my exclusive "second brain". Something about org-mode, org-babel, org-jupyter, org-agenda and org-roam that just clicks with me.
- jstx1 5y agoEmacs is so customisable that as soon as I want to customise anything, I get lost searching for solutions online and inevitably give up on using Emacs altogether.
- rvieira 5y agoThat is true. I use emacs-mac with spacemacs which works pretty well out of the box. What I try to do, to not go into the "hacking Emacs" rabbit hole, is to really avoid tweaking it unless something is really interfering with my workflow.
- marco_craveiro 5y agoI think the biggest problem with Emacs is that you cannot really make sense of a lot of stuff until you start programming elisp in anger. I tried for many years to copy and paste snippets etc, but now I realised you just need to bite the bullet and learn it like any other programming language and be prepared to do "real development" in Emacs. Its very difficult to be a "tourist" in Emacs, IMHO, a lot of things just don't make sense until you became more of a elisp programmer.
- laserlight 5y agoCouldn’t agree more. I used to get annoyed that I had to copy and paste code snippets that I found over the Web just to configure basic stuff. It got out of control pretty quickly. Now I understood that Emacs is supposed to be used by programming it. Turns out it was meant to be a feature, not a bug.
- 5y ago
- delaaxe 5y agoPlease tell me this is compatible with Johnny decimals https://johnnydecimal.com/ https://johnnydecimal.com/
- EleanorKonik 5y agoI use Johnny Decimal style files & folders with Obsidian and it's great. I wrote about how (and why) I implemented my Johnny Decimal system into Obsidian here, if it helps: https://eleanorkonik.com/yet-another-hot-take-on-folders-versus-tags/ https://eleanorkonik.com/yet-another-hot-take-on-folders-ver...
- helmholtz 5y agoBloody brilliant! Assigning states is exactly how I use tags too. With tags, I always find that I'm just adding more avenues to be unhappy with imperfection. "Oh, is that the perfect tag? Is that tag too obvious? How will I remember this tag later on?" I would hate to have to develop an entire philosophy of tagging, because I have too many others anyway. So I prefer to deal with the one-stop uneasiness of "is this the right folder for it?". Still not perfect, but just the one. Thanks for writing that post! I look forward to reading more on your website.
- chrisco255 5y agoSure you can easily implement that in Obsidian. It's simply a traditional file directory structure of markdown files.
- MrDresden 5y agoUser of Obsidian here. I don't see why that would be problematic. You can name each folder/note what ever you want. I guess you could also write a plugin for Obsidian that would do this for you. I don't really see the need for numbering though. Obsidian has a very robust system for tagging and linking together notes. Coupled with proper search, I can always find what I need. I do store my notes in a hierarchical context centric way (Finances > Loans > Calculations) which also helps.
- 5y ago
- Joeboy 5y agoWhat I'd like is an easy way to keep my notes synced on my laptop and my android phone. I suppose I could install git on my phone and do it that way, but maybe there's a less faffy way I'm missing?
- boomskats 5y agoObsidian Sync does exactly this. Works very well in my experience.
- Joeboy 5y agoIt's paid which is a bit off-putting, but maybe I shouldn't be so cheap. Edit: It looks like it's backed by git so maybe it could be used for free, with a bit of faffing. Unfortunately I'm cheap and lazy.
- gala8y 5y agoTry Syncthing (Synctrayzor is a nice wrapper on Win, Syncthing-Fork on Android is better than original Syncthing), if you don't want to pay for their Obsidian Sync.
- input_sh 5y agoAs long as you can sync a folder on your phone (whether with Git or any cloud service), mobile app can open it. Of course, you may experience some conflicts, but that's why you can pay them not to worry about that. Totally worth the price for me, though I do have a permanent discount ($5/month, as does everyone that signed up before Sep 30th).
- ricardolopes 5y agoI keep my notes synced on a Dropbox folder. On my Android I use Dropsync to keep all synced changes in the local file system (the official Dropbox app supports that but only for paying users). Overall this setup Just Works for me.
- nabusman 5y agoI use simplenote for this. It is basic text-based note keeping and free (by the Wordpress folks).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bunsenhoneydew 5y agoI really love obsidian. Sure it has a couple of wrinkles, the mobile app is new still and has a couple more wrinkles, but it scratches so many itches I have around note taking. Currently using it alongside https://get.mem.ai/ https://get.mem.ai/ and love the pairing for knowledge base and real time notes. I’m working on combining the two to come up with my ideal set up.
- dfee 5y agoJust tried out mem.ai. Unfortunately, very buggy through account creation (registering my phone number failed) and the layout doesn’t work on mobile. As something that’s built and branded for quick release of information, I think there’s some more work to be done. Worth following, but isn’t immediately useful for me.
- kzrdude 5y agoI think I've seen this as a vscode extension, right? (For now I personally use vimwiki, instead. I just can't quite leave the vim keybindings for typing.)
- slightwinder 5y agoNo, they have no specific vscode-extension. That would kinda defeat the whole purpose of it. But there are a bunch of markdown-extension doing more or less similar things. But IMHO a dedicated app serves the purpose better so far. VS Code is good, as an editor. But it's not (yet) an app-platform.
- bachmeier 5y agoYou are probably thinking of either Dendron or Foam.
- kzrdude 5y agoYou're right - dendron. Thanks
- theprotocol 5y agoThanks for mentioning these! They look pretty interesting.
- jiggunjer 5y agoCan someone explain what's the benefit of having markdown files instead of e.g. a mysql database like a conventional wiki?
- patatino 5y agoWay easier to backup for most people
- jiggunjer 5y agoI just run the wiki in docker and take regular snapshots? I also find the requirement "have internet" is a good trade-off against the requirement "install client on every device".
- slightwinder 5y agoHow is docker easier for most people? How does docker even work with multiple devices? Mobiles? and how much storage does a docker-snapshot wastes?
- jiggunjer 5y agosnapshots aren't that big. A wiki server just runs on a single server? I thought it was pretty common among the HN population to have a cloud note solution. Syncing files seems more hassle than a one-time docker setup.
- Barrin92 5y agointeroperability for one. Makes it fairly trivial to move notes between apps. I tried out Obsidian because I could just copy my logseq markdown files over.
- dunefox 5y agoA database isn't a markdown file.
- input_sh 5y agoI'd like to mention some community plugins that extend it even further: - Query your notes into tables/lists: https://github.com/blacksmithgu/obsidian-dataview https://github.com/blacksmithgu/obsidian-dataview - Templates with variables: https://github.com/SilentVoid13/Templater https://github.com/SilentVoid13/Templater - QuickAdd: https://github.com/chhoumann/quickadd https://github.com/chhoumann/quickadd Markdown compatibility is cool, but what's even cooler is stringing these together to be able to create a new note in a specific folder with a template that contains some variables, and having all of that automatically added in an index note. If emacs scares you and other options are too limiting, this is where you'll find that sweet spot between user friendliness and extensibility.
- jaxomago 5y agoI never thought of creating an index via a template, that's really cool. Do you have a link to an example template?
- opan 5y agoThe comments here made it sound exciting, but it seems like it's proprietary, which is a no-go for me. I'll stick to plain text file notes and the occasional org-mode for now.
- nonamechicken 5y agoWhile Obsidian may be proprietary, as long as the files follow standard markdown syntax, it can be opened in any markdown editor. I am currently using both Obsidian & Typora on the same workspace folder(I like Typora better for editing since its WYSIWIG). Not being locked down to any specific software was the primary reason I moved away from OneNote.
- nerdponx 5y agoMarkdown, or CommonMark?
- capableweb 5y agoObsidian has it's own flavor of Markdown there is bunch of stuff other Markdowns (including CommonMark) doesn't support. > We strive for maximum capability without breaking any existing formats, therefore we use a slightly unorthodox combination of flavors of markdown. It is broadly CommonMark, with the addition of some functionality from GitHub Flavored Markdown (GFM), some latex support, and our chosen embed syntax https://help.obsidian.md/How+to/Format+your+notes https://help.obsidian.md/How+to/Format+your+notes
- avgcorrection 5y agoThey should call it Markdown* then.
- capableweb 5y agoWhy? "Markdown" is not a standard, it's a loose collection of formats. CommonMark is a standard, and they are not calling it that. Anything that is Markdown-like can be called Markdown. It's the same deal with lisps. Lots of languages are "lisps", even the ones that are slightly different than the ones you're used to. Then there is a Common Lisp that is a language that is also a lisp.
- archibaldJ 5y agoI'm the type most comfortable with taking notes on a physical piece of paper (cuz then I can draw stuff and make mind maps). After many months I'm still learning to use Notion more extensively for different things e.g. automating stuff via the API This is my first time coming acrossing Obsidian, just wondering if anyone's been using both Notion and Obsidian. How would doing things in one and not the other differ from a use-case perspective, etc? (I never quite understand this graph thing from a cognitive-offloading perspective, and how it should be utilized for domain-specific things, etc) I feel like it's often the act of taking notes that is benefitial (eg helping us to clear up the conceptual space). But maybe that's cuz I'm not in a name-intensive field like biology?
- taurusnoises 5y agoI use both Notion and Obsidian. The main difference is that Notion is an entire database processing platform, especially once you get into mirroring databases, and getting savvy with filters and check boxes. Not to mention the fact that everything in Notion is its own page. This makes it wildly customizable, and again, programmable. Obsidian is a lot more static. It's basic strengthis having offline capabilities, simplicity, and markdown. I use it exclusively for my Zettelkasten, which I also have on Notion (I started my ZK and migrated it over to Obsidian). Obsidian is great for ZK in part due to its simultaneous multiple panel openings. So, you can see multiple notes at once. Notion can do this too, and I've use its Gallery fxn for exactly that, but there's something less claggy about Obsidian in this regard. Notion is great for GTD and project management (again, when used dynamically with filters etc). Obsidian is great for note storage and retrieval, as well as processing ideas and arguments for use later in writing articles, scripts, etc.
- archibaldJ 5y agoI see! Thanks for the detailed breakdown and comparisons! I'm now somewhat convinced that I should definitely get familiar with Obsidian and exploring different aspects of it Zettelkasten has been something that I wanna try out for a while!
- 5y ago
- Datagenerator 5y agoThe Open Source solution which serves me well for years has been TiddyWiki (1). Supports Tags and various modes of output. Each page one file or all in one, very open so recursive changes can be applied on the shell in plain files. (1) https://tiddlywiki.com/ https://tiddlywiki.com/
- 1f60c 5y ago> TiddyWiki That's an interesting name for an open source project. :P
- rg111 5y agoThat's a typo. See URL.
- hairofadog 5y agoI think they understood that. I read that comment as a friendly, good-natured way to point out the typo.
- kepano 5y agoTiddlyWiki in many ways is the best predecessor to Obsidian, in that it follows many of the same priorities and tradeoffs. I was a big user of TiddlyWiki but Obsidian has so many UI quality of life improvements, and the plugin ecosystem is evolving at such a rapid pace that I decided to jump ship. I wrote a guide on my migration process: https://forum.obsidian.md/t/import-from-tiddlywiki-5-to-obsidian/731 https://forum.obsidian.md/t/import-from-tiddlywiki-5-to-obsi...
- tomcooks 5y agoI had a lot of problems with tiddlywiki, I never managed to get the self hosted html file version nor the php solutions to work.
- hda111 5y agoYou probably mean the NodeJS version. I agree. It’s not just starting a Docker container. There are more steps involved. And there is no authentication.
- d4rkp4ttern 5y agoLast I checked there was no good way to do quick capture of articles from mobile iOS to obsidian. Scenario — I come across an article on my iPhone, and I just want to dump title + URL (maybe even the text content) into obsidian. This is a must have for any note taking tool. Anyone have a good workflow for this, please share. Ideally an iOS shortcut.
- taurusnoises 5y agoMy main gripe with Obsidian. That, and the fact that it costs almost $100 to have the mobile app sync with the desktop. That's insane to me, and feels vindictive. I'm all for paying for the platform. Seriously. These ventures need bottom - up support. But, syncing is a basic feature that any mobile app should have baked in. Charge for 24-hour support, something that actually requires the time of the team.
- digitalengineer 5y agoJust download the app make a vault. Same it in iCloud or google drive. Now use your desktop pc and copy the files over. Done and a accessible vault in your smartphone.
- LVB 5y agoNote that iCloud Drive on the Mac is a bit random about when it decides it wants to sync files. I ended up abandoning that setup after too many times of being somewhere and finding my laptop never pushed up the latest version of a file.
- digitalengineer 5y agoThank you for the insights. I have not experienced it yet, but am moving to another cloud solution for my peace of mind ;-)
- taurusnoises 5y agoYou can't just save the vault in Good Drive on your phone, because the vault is looking for a folder on your phone to sync to. The Drive option simply isn't there. From what I've seen you have to download another, third party sync app, to do that, and that just sounds clunky af. Obsidian charging $90 a year(!) for sync is just super lame. I can wait til they realize that.
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoThis looks great. Downloaded. Jotted down some Sunday morning idiocy. Paid for Catalyst. Question: who decided Moldova [1] was a good idea? Was Obsidian.kp taken? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.md https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.md
- delta1 5y agomd = markdown
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> md = markdown Makes sense. Is (EDIT: the use of the TLD) .md a convention in the markdown community?
- stphnclysmth 5y agoYes. I have seen the .mdown extension also, but .md is the default in every editor I've used, and it's a default for readme files on Gitlab and GitHub.
- hannasanarion 5y agoWe're talking about the website here, not the file format. .md is the top-level-domain for Moldova, Obsidian.md exists at that address by the good graces of the Moldovan government.
- Socketier 5y ago.md is the markdown file extension, so having a .md TLD is a clever and amusing idea imo as Obsidian is, after all, a markdown editor.
- capableweb 5y agoIt's clever until you hit issues with uptime, or breaking the specific rules of the TLD. I'm also a supporter of Obsidian, but it scares me that the domain is under the whim of the Moldovian government and could get shut down/redirected if someone who uses Obsidian Publish decides to write "bad" stuff about government officials since the TLD doesn't allow that. > Registration restrictions: Prohibited domain names with bad taste, foul language, injurious to public order or to public sensibilities, with offending character, or with obscene or pornographic words From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.md https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.md
- rg111 5y agoI have switched to Obsidian and I use multiple vaults for multiple purposes. One is for work, one is for personal projects and notes. One for Books and Movies I watched or want to watch. And one for Zettelkasten[0]. Obsidian is extremely customizable and user-friendly. And to make things even better, which is a must for many people including me, it saves the files as .md in the local storage. You can even sync it among n devices for free using Box, Sync, Mega, OneDrive, Dropbox or whatever floats your boat. Just as a quick exercise, I spun up a fully functional Obsidian clone that runs in the browser that works locally, in four hours using React- just in case the company goes under in future. It works great. [0]: https://zettelkasten.de https://zettelkasten.de
- Macha 5y agoThe one thing I found weird when I looked into Zettelkasten is the focus on having relatively hard to read IDs as the primary part of the title. It could certainly help in the original use case of having to categorise and store physical paper notes, but it just feels obsolete in a world where you have digital notes, hyperlinking, and search.
- the_fury 5y agoI've found that to be exactly the case. Once you are able to freely hypelink your notes, the ID isn't really helpful. It's the first thing I dropped from mine.
- hannasanarion 5y agoThe funny ID thing was necessary when zettelkastens were physical cards in a box that you need to keep in order so that you can look them up. Digital zettelkasten apps have largely dropped the ID systems, you link cards just by their name, and you can use folders or internal headers for ordered structure when you want it.
- lethologica 5y agoYou don’t need crazy IDs any more. In Obsidian I just make sure each of my notes has a descriptive title and that’s enough to ensure it’s unique. Some of my notes are literally just a bunch of links to other notes because the title of the notes is descriptive enough that stringing a bunch together I can form entirely new sentences.
- bambax 5y agoI built a simple journal solution for myself two years ago. It sends an email every day and I can reply to it, and the response is stored in an SQLite database, in plain text. The db is on a remote server but copied to Dropbox every day (and in any case all the emails also exist in my sent folder). It is surprisingly effective at storing not just what I did with my day, but random thoughts and ideas, solutions to bugs, etc. All I have to do is type something every day. In 2 years I have typed around 150k words. For reading he whole thing is just one plain html page, searchable in the browser. I'm currently experimenting with documenting my reading, while the book is being read (instead of a summary at the end). We typically forget what we expect while we read, and only remember the final impression. Taking notes at the end of each reading session, not just about what I just read, but also about what I think will happen next, and revisiting that later, is surprisingly interesting.
- exhaze 5y ago> but copied to Dropbox every day This seems unnecessarily complex - have you considered replacing this with rsync + cron job?
- bambax 5y ago"Copied to Dropbox" is a copy cron to a folder that is shared on Dropbox. No API was harmed -- or used -- for any of this[0]. It's also in effect a poor man's backup, because the db is renamed with today's date so each copy doesn't overwrite any other. [0] Edit: not in fact true. The email part uses Mailgun's API (from when you could use routes with a basic account).
- phreeza 5y agoI think (though you can never be quite sure on HN) that this was a joke referring to initial reactions techies had to Dropbox.
- galfarragem 5y agoI'm somehow on the same boat as you. I've tried dozens of "fancy" tools but they never stuck. A plain text file, kind of a "flat wiki", that you can search with your text editor may be the grail of note taking. What I consider critical is to "tree-shake" it often to remove the cruft. Hints: - Tree-shake your notes each time you iterate them. You'll leverage your excitement and it won't be a chore. - Maintain part of your notes public, it will be a catalyst to polish them. A git repository is perfect for that. Serendipitously, I started a related thread a couple hours ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28895647 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28895647
- kazinator 5y ago> With Obsidian, your data sits in a local folder. Never leave your life's work held hostage in the cloud again. ... says a brochure page for proprietary software.
- sofixa 5y agoSoftware can be proprietary and local-only.
- capableweb 5y agoDid you completely misunderstand the text segment you quoted? It doesn't say that the software itself is open-source/free software, it's just talking about the data it produces/maintains/uses, so your comment seems to be way offside.
- kazinator 5y ago"Did you misunderstand the text segment you quoted? Nowhere does it say, 'I am ironic'; therefore, you have no right to find irony in it. You, you, too-freely-associating nitwit, you."
- yokoprime 5y agoWhat is your point? I've moved my obsidian notes to vscode and back without any issues. Is closed source software somehow incapable of having true statements?
- kazinator 5y agoApproximately: "It's funny to be criticizing user freedom and lock-in issues with other programs, above a link to buy your stuff from an app store."
- groby_b 5y agoCloser: "I am incapable of reasoning, except in broad generalities". Having an open and simple file format that is easily imported/exported is all many of us want from software. We are actually perfectly OK with paying people for work. Separating data freedom from access to source code is a perfectly meaningful thing to do, even if you personally don't like it.
- avinassh 5y agoI am looking to move from Notion, looking for an alternative. Here are few things I am looking for: 1. It is easy to back up or export my data 2. Great UI! May be its just me, I care about the UI a lot and if it is nice, I seem to be writing more 3. Support for templates, so that I can write daily journal/entries with predefined fields 4. Support for keyboard shortcuts (or mouse-less operations) so that I can link or embed documents quickly
- capableweb 5y agoSeems you left the comment at the right submission then as Obsidian supports all of those things.
- RichardChu 5y agoMight be worth checking out Notabase [0]. The UI is designed to be really clean and easy-to-use. [0]: https://notabase.io https://notabase.io
- SN76477 5y agoI do like Notion. I have been a paying customer for the last year. But I find that it has too many limitations for how I work. Why can I not customize colors? Why is there no plain text block? Why is there not a simple table? So many basic things seem missing.
- hannasanarion 5y agoIf what you have in your notion is mostly ideas, concepts, and thoughts, then Obsidian is a great choice. It is not as great for storing facts, because of the lack of something resembling Notion's robust database system. So I use both: Obsidian for ideas, beliefs, concepts, explanations, class notes, etc. Notion for Goals, freelance client project info, job hunt tracking, to watch/read lists, images and links for internet arguments, plans for video games, travel plans, technical solutions, exercise and practice routines.
- krzyk 5y agoI just downloaded deb and was a bit worried that it has 60MB, quick check on forums and it us unfortunately Electron :( Oh well, back to vim and cd.
- dm319 5y agoI feel like I'm the only one mentioning vim-wiki here. But, vim-wiki?
- sundarurfriend 5y agoOr its lighter-weight alternative, wiki.vim
- capableweb 5y agoAlways fun to see these original comments in a HN thread. If you write this on Twitter you can get hundreds of retweets, hurry before someone else writes the tweet! Jokes aside, Obsidian being a Electron application is not a issue. The app starts in under 3 seconds for me, barely uses any RAM and CPU usage remains stable and low. If you want to actually contribute anything to this thread, feel free to give feedback on specific issues you find, that it's using too much CPU or whatever. But as it stands, you're not really adding much here.
- dotancohen 5y ago> The app starts in under 3 seconds for me For me that would be a showstopper. 3 seconds to open my notes app? I would have already lost my train of thought. :wq
- MrBoomixer 5y agoYou may also use any other note taking app as your default brain dump and use Obsidian as your editor tool to work your notes afterwords. Just for note taking anything would work its markdown/text. Where obsidian wins is backlinking information and all the wonderful community plugins that's been appearing.
- jeffreygoesto 5y agoThis link gives me a 404. https://help.obsidian.md/Plugins/List+of+plugins https://help.obsidian.md/Plugins/List+of+plugins
- EleanorKonik 5y agoTry this one: https://publish.obsidian.md/hub/02+-+Community+plugins/02.01+-+Plugins/02.01+-+Plugins https://publish.obsidian.md/hub/02+-+Community+plugins/02.01...
- inferense 5y agoObsidian is great, but in a way it's quite limited as it only replaces the note-taking app / text editor I used before. We're building something similar but more capable https://acreom.com https://acreom.com.
- kjksf 5y agoConstructive criticism: change the name before it's too late. The immovable rule for good names is: they should be easy to pronounce and easy to type if you hear it from someone else. Obsidian is a good name. Workflowy is a good name. Acreom - I wouldn't know how to pronounce it. If someone told me "use acreom" I wouldn't know what to typo into google to find it. Also, a non-dark theme is a must.
- wolverine876 5y ago> a non-dark theme is a must Why?
- Svenstaro 5y agoI read the site and frankly I can't really figure out what this does for me especially over obsidian.
- throwaway984393 5y ago
- steve_adams_86 5y agoI’m slightly relieved reading this. I see markdown everywhere, I can’t stand it, and I wonder why people are so crazy about it. It’s nice to know I’m not alone. Unfortunately I don’t think markdown is going anywhere. I think I see it far more than ever and there’s no sign of it slowing down.
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoTextile and LaTeX are better, anyway. At least it's not HTML or BBCode.
- ncallaway 5y agoI have been sent word documents that I’ve been totally unable to read. I’ve never been sent a markdown file that I haven’t been able to read. I’ve been sent a PDF that looks correct, but I’m not able to easily edit. I’ve never been sent a markdown file that I’ve been unable to edit. For a document format to be able to be widespread it needs to be interoperable and work on all systems. Markdown is popular because plain text works everywhere. I’m not convinced that markdown is the ultimate format, but it has more good properties than most other available formats.
- cratermoon 5y ago> I’ve been sent a PDF that looks correct But "looks correct" for PDF presumes a certain form factor of the device used, because of the fixed page size. PDFs are a pain on many e-readers because they are laid out for US letter or A4 at a certain resolution. On a smaller device I often find I have a choice of either a. seeing an entire page at one time, as intended, but needing a magnifier to read anything, or b. zooming in to be able to read the text comfortably but then having to scroll left/right/up/down to read. There's no option in PDF to reflow the text to fit the resolution and size of the device. I'm not much of a fan of epub but at least the text reflow allows for normal reading. Also, exporting text from a PDF to import to anything else is trying at best.
- aazaa 5y agoOdd that there's no video introduction. The first hit I found on Google had two ads and was a guy basically wandering around the app as if he had never used it before. > Obsidian is a powerful knowledge base on top of a local folder of plain text Markdown files. This doesn't help me. I use a directory of Markdown files powered by VS Code to take notes already - ever since Evernote began getting bad, which was a long time ago. What does Obsidian offer beyond that? I can't tell from the page. I'm not asking for an answer here. Instead I'm noting that the page itself doesn't answer the questions that I have as a current Markdown-notetaking user.
- kepano 5y agoThis is an incredible time for knowledge management tools. Just a couple of years ago I was pulling my hair out trying to get a local wiki to feel like a native app, and now we have a dozen great options to choose from. I started using Obsidian when it came out last year, and it instantly clicked for me. I immediately migrated 20 years of notes to it. What differentiates Obsidian from all of the other tools in this area, is that they have made extensibility a top priority. The sheer breadth of plugins, themes, and other community-driven tools that have been generated in 18 months is spectacular. It makes it easy to recommend Obsidian because you can shape it into whatever you want. There are a handful of plugins like Dataview, QuickAdd, Kanban and Periodic Notes that make Obsidian an incredibly powerful environment for thought. I made a theme for Obsidian called Minimal that attempts to make the app feel more native, especially on Mac: https://github.com/kepano/obsidian-minimal https://github.com/kepano/obsidian-minimal ...and published a couple of my own plugins and a Web Clipper bookmarklet: https://gist.github.com/kepano/90c05f162c37cf730abb8ff027987ca3 https://gist.github.com/kepano/90c05f162c37cf730abb8ff027987... The Obsidian community is just so fun, friendly, and collaborative, that you can't help but get involved and work on making the ecosystem better.
- rektide 5y agothe perspective that software is good because it's soft- as in malleable- is nice to hear. i too feel like the more open-potential endlessly extensible form of computing is what's interesting & compelling. it's ehy computing appealed to me & still is. contrasting to computing as mechanization, big systems, & mass market software, where focus is on control & usually core, well planned user flows. this is boring rigidware. yet it's share of computing has radically risen. good to hear of syccessful flexible software in the world.
- smusamashah 5y agoI made a Windows 98/2000 theme for Obsidian which feels faster because animations are disabled and have more Thanks to Electron that I could do that. It was mentioned in the previous thread by its creator that because it's Electron you could make a css to make it look like anything you want.
- runjake 5y ago
- astro_robot 5y agoI’ve been interested in Zettelkasten for over a year and have tried all of the apps (Obsidian, Notion, pen and paper, etc.) but I still haven’t found a good system for using it. I always feel like it’s either too much information or too little. Any tips?
- brazed_blotch 5y agoSpent the last week's evenings researching this. Make a list of the features you need. For me, using markdown and YAML frontmatter was the best solution. As for traversing the notes, I picked VSCode (I would have picked Obsidian but it does funny things with front matter that I didn't like, and it lagged a lot on my computer). Primarily because it has extensions that update links automatically when the filepath to a note changes, and for graph view. You can use vim inside VSCode as a text editor. That's all I need really - VSCode to traverse, vim to edit. What's great about this system is it really does stick strictly to commonmark and YAML usage isn't restricted at all (you don't even have to use the frontmatter if you don't want to), so your notes are completely portable. Edit: typo
- kseistrup 5y agoThe CLI tool nb is excellent for taking notes in an editor of your own choice, and for making bookmarks (if readability CLI is installed it will make a local text copy of the page you're bookmarking): https://github.com/xwmx/nb https://github.com/xwmx/nb It's AGPL'ed.
- gala8y 5y agoWow, that is interesting. Thanks for sharing.
- noja 5y agoDoes Obsidian have a web interface so I can use it from other computers (not mine)? Edit: https://obsidian.md/publish https://obsidian.md/publish ($16/mo, appears to be read-only)
- EleanorKonik 5y agoSome folks use a remote desktop or put their files on a private github repo so they can edit them remotely, but it's not "the full experience."
- ulisesrmzroche 5y agoIf you're a Vim fan you're probably going to like Obsidian. Great app for Zettelkasten fans
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MikeCapone 5y agoThis 6-part video series by Nick Milo is a great way for newbies to get introduced to Obsidian and go up the learning curve rapidly: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgbLb6QCK88&list=PL3NaIVgSlAVLHty1-NuvPa9V0b0UwbzBd https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgbLb6QCK88&list=PL3NaIVgSlA...
- jstummbillig 5y agoCan anyone share their experience using Obsidian in a multi-user/team setup?
- stakkur 5y agoObligatory ‘This is a what I use Emacs for and no database needed’ comment.
- cratermoon 5y agoIt's worth pointing out that here, half a century later, we are finally getting something like the tools that Ted Nelson wrote about in his 1965 paper "Complex information processing: a file structure for the complex, the changing and the indeterminate" https://doi.org/10.1145/800197.806036 https://doi.org/10.1145/800197.806036 [PDF available https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Complex-information-processing%3A-a-file-structure-Nelson/ec17c284f1fb35ac2387630efa072b384cf03d84 https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Complex-information-pr...]
- mdu96 5y agoObsidian is awesome. No more words needed.
- stewbrew 5y agoI have just tried the Android version. I'm no Android dev but what is Obsidian written in?
- tomcooks 5y agoApparently Electron
- stevenpetryk 5y agoI like to use Obsidian on iOS and then Foam on my computer. They happen to have a lot of the same custom Markdown syntax, and I prefer using VS Code on my computer :) https://foambubble.github.io/foam/ https://foambubble.github.io/foam/
- abcd0880 5y agoWhat does Obsidian offer that Foam doesn’t or vice versa? I use VSCode for writing and programming so am trying to avoid yet another tool for note taking and knowledge management.
- stevenpetryk 5y agoFoam doesn't run on my phone. Because VS Code doesn't run on my phone. So I use Obsidian to edit a synced folder on my phone, just because it is functionally similar to Foam but runs on iOS.
- abcd0880 5y agoThanks.I don’t need access to my knowledge base from my phone so will start with Foam. Any Obsidian features that you particularly miss in Foam?
- afro88 5y agoDoes anyone know the name of the note taking tool where pretty much everything is a bullet point, and each bullet point can expand to show sub bullet points. The website is essentially the tool itself IIRC. I've been trying to remember it for ages. I saw it in the comments for a different note taking tool on HN...
- peakaboo 5y agoI think you mean workflowy.
- sleavey 5y agoEmacs with org-mode?
- emerged 5y agocheckvist?
- Hates_ 5y agoPerhaps https://workflowy.com https://workflowy.com or https://dynalist.io https://dynalist.io ?
- afro88 5y agoI think it was workflowy, thank you. Looks like they've added a ton of features since I first checked it out too, nice.
- dhruval 5y agoI think you are taking about moo.do?
- pchm 5y agoRoam Research, most likely
- rodneyzeng 5y agoTo me, the fatal weakness of obsidian, after trying it for 5 min to realize it, is sync functionality. It only supports icloud sync and its paid sync. This is turn down 100%.
- drodil 5y agoJust get the git plugin and create private repo somewhere. Problem solved
- rodneyzeng 5y agoyou can do this in obsidian mobile app?
- Havoc 5y agoThink parent is talking about desktop. On iOS working copy works to sync against git but it’s a little manual
- luxpir 5y agoOr syncthing. I already had it set up between phone, pi and PC, so threw the notes dir into there. Now free to switch between desktop and mobile with quasi instant updates.
- DavideNL 5y agoYou can sync the folder (=vault) with any tool you prefer… including git.
- rodneyzeng 5y agoyes but this is not feasible on obsidian mobile app, right?
- rovr138 5y agoCurious, what kind of sync are you wanting for the mobile app?
- chrisweekly 5y agoObsidian is so great. I switched from RoamResearch and have hardly looked back.
- submeta 5y agoWhat I am missing most in Obsidian is this: It does not show the date created of the document. I need to hover over a note to see that info. This is such a basic and super important info, I am wondering why it‘s neglected so much. Every note taking app always shows the creation and/or modification date: Evernote, Bear, Ulysses, and every other app I know. Also the aesthetics is not on par with Bear or Ulysses. Finally, I tried to import my Roam Research notes into it. Ended up with thousands of empty pages that were just tags in Roam. By the way: Obsidian users aggressively try to convince users of other tools how superior it is, on Reddit forums for various note taking apps and even on twitter. Haven’t seen this behaviour, even from vim or Emacs lovers.
- trutannus 5y ago> It does not show the date created of the document You could use/write an extension for that! Obsidian is very extensible. I think there's template extensions you can use to put the datetime in the title, or in the filename.
- lethologica 5y agoCouldn’t you just write the date on your note?
- Havoc 5y agoI just set this up today using self-hosted gitlab and working copy on iphone. Not friction free (since on phone you need to trigger git push/pull) but seems to be working well. Still need to get used to it, but the combination of git backed, self hosted and markdown seems pretty future proof
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zerker2000 5y agoI wish any of these projects(obsidian, logseq, Roam) supported WikiWord autolinks alongside [[Mediawiki]] ones. See also: https://apenwarr.ca/log/20100901 https://apenwarr.ca/log/20100901
- taigi100 5y agoI often see people in this community being fans of note taking apps. Yet, I never really found why it's useful, maybe someone can enlighten me on that :D 1. For tech articles / knowledge databases -> tech seems to change so fast that research done 3-4 months ago is mostly useless (except for a few more high level areas) 2. For recording / knowledge database purposes -> i never seem to go back to them tho, googling (or duckduckgoing?) seems faster to reach an answer. 3. For current note-taking / todo lists / etc they work well, but so does a simple notepad. A history of those doesn't seem to help me with anything specifically. 4. Same for book notes / reading notes, i never seem to go back to them, actually. So, in what domains or where do find those apps actually useful?
- jiggunjer 5y agoApart from the transfer aspect I identify two other reasons for taking notes: The act of note taking itself may help structure and focus thoughts, regardless of intent to review or transfer the note. It may also be cathartic. It gives peace of mind to know I own the detailed information on X, just in case. Or perhaps making a pretty list about something random lets me take my mind of work for a few minutes.
- WA 5y agoFor me it’s similar. I want to write it down to get it out of my head. But I think it’s important to understand one thing about notes and organization systems in general: do you optimize for speed of writing stuff down or do you optimize for retrieving the information? I know that I am in the former camp. That’s why my note taking system is as follows: I have a folder called Notes in Sublime. I create a new file, use a text snippet to insert the current ISO date (2021-10-18) give it a headline, write everything down in free-form without a structure, save it as a plain text file and be done with it. When I want to read a note (doesn’t happen that often), I mostly remember the headline I used: Cmd+O to open that file. If nothing comes up, Sublime has good regex search capabilities.
- jiggunjer 5y ago
- jollybean 5y ago"A second brain, for you, forever. Obsidian is a powerful knowledge base on top of a local folder of plain text Markdown files. " I have no idea what that means and a quick perusal of the site doesn't really tell me what this is, If you want more people to download this please do a better job of explaining what it is. Is this a tool for Markdown writers? A a journaling tool? Does it cache my browsing experiences? Why can't people write marketing copy in user-centric terms? I'm going to try in only because everyone here seems to love it, but wouldn't bother if that wasn't the case. Please step back and think about how to introduce new products to new visitors, thanks.
- watrami 5y agoI can totally recommend this tool. I use it daily and perform a sync between all devices with syncthing.
- JonathanBuchh 5y agoI’m really grateful to Obsidian for getting me into personal wikis. The devs work super quickly and it’s amazing to see what the two of them have been able to accomplish. I wish there were more Obsidian-like communities out there. Although I mostly use vimwiki these days, I still use Obsidian for viewing backlinks. Does anyone know how to do this in (n)vim?
- jrm4 5y agoJust to chime in here, long time "http://zim-wiki.org http://zim-wiki.org" guy here. I'm still basically sticking with Zim for most of what I do, but that's probably mostly the equivalent of "personal muscle memory," for structured things. But I am moving to Obsidian for anything "non-heirarchical" or "unstructured;" which for me is my "bookmarking" system as well as my personal Zettelkasten/brain exploring gardeny thing. The graph and extensibility is just fantastic, and I like knowing that I can export it wherever whenever.
- wbharding 5y agoWhile Roam has become something of a dumpster fire with its unprompted Reddit megaban, losing its whole dev team, etc, they do deserve partial credit for awakening the world to the possibility that there is much out there worth exploring beyond Evernote and Notion. There are now so many promising tools (most based on backlinking, as Roam popularized) that we have a site https://noteapps.info https://noteapps.info dedicated to chronicling the differences in some 30 viable note apps that now exist. At least half of these note apps were created in the past three years alone. That said, Obsidian is in rareified air among the third gen note apps. The pace of evolution is right up there alongside Craft and Amplenote, where almost every week there is some interesting new wrinkle being added. I can’t wait to see how productive we will become in the next 10 years as these tools let us leverage our brains far beyond what has been historically possible.
- bigdang 5y agoThey lost their whole dev team? Can you share a link?
- capableweb 5y agoYeah, also doubting this as after searching around on the interwebs I cannot find anything to support this statement. Edit: found some sort of source from deleted content from Redddit - https://www.reveddit.com/v/RoamResearch/comments/pvj0o2/off_is_roam_doing_okay_as_a_company/ https://www.reveddit.com/v/RoamResearch/comments/pvj0o2/off_... Seems to be a misreading of a support reply, where they replied "this is a known issue that our engineer is aware of." and then the pitchforks come out. The founder of the company replied in the same thread too: > We're doing quite well. > Besides myself and Josh (the engineers who built Roam) - we've got 5 other engineers working on the team to varying degrees -- including the author of Datascript, which Roam and the majority of the Roam clones are built off. > Right now we earn enough each year to keep the company going for 2-3 years, and as a result we're able to invest in major open source projects that we (and all the Roam clones built in Clojure) will be able to build from for many years to come.
- wetpaws 5y ago>megaban I went to subreddit to check this and apparently it's a dozen trolls who like writing that founder is nazi. Ughm, ok.
- might9900 5y agoWhich knowledge management apps with backlinks are not Electron? I'd prefer non-Electron. Electron: VS Code (Foam, Dendron), Logseq, Obsidian, Joplin Not Electron: Emacs (Org-roam), Athens (?)
- tlavoie 5y agoAdd Neuron and its upcoming replacement.
- student2k 5y agois the screenshot working flow better in obsidian now? I like how you can just bind a key to area screenshot in Evernote, then edit the note.
- jayant_kaushik 5y agoObsidian might be a great tool but I use Remnote and it has not given me any reason to switch to any other knowledge management tool. It’s a breeze to create organised notes with it and creating flashcards has never been easier. It also allows to download your entire knowledge base in markdown or JSON. With its latest UI overhaul things have got even better. Also I see Obsidian does not have a webapp or a windows app and that’s a deal breaker for me as I have to work with Apple and Windows devices. I have it tried Obsidian yet and it does not look like Remnote will give me a reason to do so anytime soon. Happy note taking! The golden age of note taking! :)
- _apaz 5y agoIf Obsidian weren't proprietary, I'd probably be excited for it. They do make it easy to jump ship, but I'm still both morally opposed and skeptical. If they really had your best interests at heart, they wouldn't keep any secrets. While the company appears not to be evil at the moment they could change their mind at any time, potentially without you knowing. Instead I've chosen to replicate Obsidian's functionality in VSCodium. The parts that are missing (Mostly advanced search/scraping functionality) writing scripts to do. This works well because I've already modified almost every aspect for writing code. Extending it to notes should be relatively simple.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nextaccountic 5y agoSo, I want to share an alternative: https://github.com/srid/neuron https://github.com/srid/neuron It's also just a bunch of markdown files And, uhhh.. I just found out this: > Neuron is being superceded by Emanote: https://github.com/srid/emanote https://github.com/srid/emanote Cool
- tlavoie 5y agoI've played with Neuron too, and liked it. I'm using org-roam at the moment, but will keep an eye on Emanote. One of the better advertisements for Neuron is the author's own notes being posted online as exported HTML.
- konart 5y agoMy main problem with those great apps is that I never write anything, and when I do - I never look back there. Sometimes I feel like other people consume 10x more information than I do. What do you put there?
- ChrisArchitect 5y agoHere's a bunch of discussion about this from only 3 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27807850 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27807850
- kushan2020 5y agoIf anyone is interested in checking out similar idea but for browser: https://bangle.io https://bangle.io