11 ms·
Bitcoin: Who owns it, who mines it, who’s breaking the law
- Traster 5y agoIt is so hard to know whether these reports are really done with the vigour that justifies trusting the conclusions but I guess I'll spend some time finding out.
- Traster 5y agoFirst observation: their research points out 80% of transactions are via exchanges and it seems their research basically does nothing to analyse that 80%, it's all on-chain analysis (ie, completely worthless and extremely ironic since they literally describe the block chain being a move away from a "few centralized record keepers" - bitcoin is far better, only accounting for 80%) >"Without proper regulation, this is going to be a very dangerous place for many retail investors.” I don't like Bitcoin. I hold no bitcoin. Even for me, this reeks of institutionalism. Is it better that you pay repetitive over-draft charges at your bank or exorbitant fees to your local investment advisor, or watch your savings disappear into nothing through inflation? I don't know how, but MIT is radicalising me. To be honest the over-arching theme of this article is just "let's apply all the legacy regulations to bitcoin". Which is probably right in general, but this article does a poor job of selling it.
- ur-whale 5y agoI think your sentence makes more sense of s/vigour/rigor/g
- Traster 5y agoI think both work.
- ur-whale 5y agoPrevious discussion of actual paper: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28874803 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28874803
- yboris 5y agoNever forget the enormous pollution that Bitcoin generates! https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ Currently comparable to the entire energy consumption of Poland!
- rglover 5y agoObligatory: now do the petrol dollar.
- yboris 5y agohttps://www.statista.com/statistics/881541/bitcoin-energy-consumption-transaction-comparison-visa/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/881541/bitcoin-energy-co... 1 bitcoin transaction ~ 1,800 kWh 100,000 visa transactions ~ 150 kWh
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoYes but: 1 Bitcoin ~ validated by millions of nodes 100,000 visa transaction ~ validated by one entity
- yboris 5y agoHas there been, in the last few decades, any concerns about the validity of the Visa transactions?
- linschn 5y agoOf course, have you never heard of credit card fraud?
- colinmhayes 5y agoCredit card fraud is effectively the same as someone stealing your bitcoin wallet password. Bitcoin does nothing to stop that. In fact, credit cards are much better at stopping fraud since they'll just undo any transactions you dispute.
- programmarchy 5y ago> Illegal activity is a small fraction (3%) of what actually goes on in the Bitcoin blockchain. The other 97% should be considered illegal activity, too, since it's all one big Ponzi scheme.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mam3 5y agoYou must be fun at parties
- programmarchy 5y agoJust testing out Poe's law again.
- archontes 5y agoPonzi schemes aren't often as forthright that they're promising vapor.
- solitus 5y agoIs 3% really "small"?
- f38zf5vdt 5y agoThe underground economy in developed countries is estimated at around 10% of the GDP, so comparatively yes. [1] [1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets-economy/062216/how-underground-economy-affects-gdp.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets-economy/062216...
- marcosdumay 5y agoUnderground economy is a term for any transaction that isn't reported to the government and don't pay taxes. It's not a name for illegal activity only. Most of it is perfectly legal or is illegal only because it's evading taxes.
- solitus 5y agoGood to know, thanks for the link!
- stathibus 5y agoI have a hard time understanding how anyone can claim they know the true percentage of crypto transactions that are used for illegal activity. At best they can report the subset that they were able to track down, and it seems reasonable to believe that most large value illegal transactions are carried out by people who know how to hide it.
- h00dui 5y agoThere have been tracing applications around for years now in this space. They've identified wallets & send micro transactions around to many to distinguish who is who in terms of dark markets, services, bad actors etc. Given the many hacks with wallets and also services selling that data believe me they know more than you are giving them credit. In terms of the bad actions.. Those who are trying to hide money have known this for years so they are in different currencies that provide better privacy.
- stathibus 5y agoI didn't make any claims about how much they know.
- hellodanylo 5y agoThey use various clustering algorithms and heuristics, but it's true that it only gives a lower bound at best. For example: https://youtu.be/D_Eqz8_Jm2E https://youtu.be/D_Eqz8_Jm2E
- wait_a_minute 5y agoThey don't know the true percentage, and what we do know per the findings shared by Coinbase [0] is that the amount of fraud is not meaningful. It's the same situation with other forms of currency. I really think the claims about fraud are intentionally overblown because bad actors just want to subsume crypto's momentum. [0] - https://blog.coinbase.com/fact-check-crypto-is-increasingly-being-used-for-criminal-activity-and-is-a-haven-for-illicit-856a71dfb399 https://blog.coinbase.com/fact-check-crypto-is-increasingly-...
- pjmorris 5y agoFTA: "The authors found that participation in Bitcoin is skewed toward the elite. Their research showed that at the end of 2020, there were 1,000 “clusters” controlling 2 million bitcoins." (and 4 million among the top 10,000 accounts) This claim doesn't distinguish between wealthy people who acquired bitcoin and people who are now wealthy because they acquired bitcoin.
- gruez 5y ago>and 4 million among the top 10,000 accounts How are they defining "accounts"? Bitcoin addresses? It's hard to take them seriously if that's the case, because many people can be sharing one bitcoin address (custodial wallets, exchanges) and a single person can have many bitcoin addresses (most wallet software generate fresh addresses for each transaction). Drawing any conclusion from such flawed methods seems highly irresponsible.
- varajelle 5y agoFrom the article: > The authors clustered addresses so that all addresses that sent bitcoins in any single transaction were deemed to belong to the same entity.
- varajelle 5y agoAnd those who could have been wealthy if they did not loose their private keys
- stevev 5y agoThe so called whales in the article are crypto exchanges holding btc, and not actual individual holders. The only person to hold more than a mill is Satoshi.
- betwixthewires 5y agoSo much wrong with this article. Funds don't originate with criminal activity, they originate with coinbase transactions. A dollar used on illegal activity doesn't make that dollar less useful, that's part of the whole idea behind money in the first place. You don't measure how much money was used at some point doing illegal activity, if you go back far enough, every dollar was used on something illegal at some point. The only honest measure is how much is currently being used for illegal activity. "The elite" implies people that own mansions on long island. But the elite in this case includes regular people that made the smart financial decision to go in on this thing early. When being elite is superfluous it becomes a meaningless distinction. Addresses do not equate to individuals. The article is interesting though, it is still a decent article and somewhat informative.
- iszomer 5y agoWeird tangent with how cocaine has "contaminated" the US paper currency. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8835657/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8835657/