6 ms·
Privacy fears as Moscow metro rolls out facial recognition pay system
- 1cvmask 5y agoThis Facepay scheme humorously brings to mind this biometric payment spoof of paying by ass for the Money 2020 conference held in Vegas in 2014: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U2brZQocmMc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U2brZQocmMc
- fuoqi 5y agoIt's not fears, it's the fact that the system is used for tracking people and the Facepay capability looks like a simple cover for the true purpose of the system: massive scale surveillance. The authorities claim that they have apprehended more than 900 suspected criminals since the last September with the system help. You can imagine how easy it would be to add additional "features", if they are not in operation already.
- dane-pgp 5y ago> how easy it would be to add additional "features" I suspect the next big milestone planned is to link it to a "social credit" score, i.e. an opaque system of extra-judicial punishment where the government can hide behind an official excuse of "the AI decided" every time a wrong-thinker complains about their oppression.
- tryauuum 5y agoI don't believe in capabilities of russian government IT services to design such a thing, to be honest
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoI think that you can "sell" catching criminals to Russians, but I don't think the population will accept the social credit system.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> the next big milestone planned is to link it to a "social credit" score, i.e. an opaque system of extra-judicial punishment where the government can hide behind an official excuse of "the AI decided" every time a wrong-thinker complains about their oppression Moscow has no qualms about overtly oppressing its opposition. What advantage does the ambiguity of such a system bring to the table? If anything, Putin's flamboyant campaign of pursuing dissidents puts as much emphasis on messaging as physical outcome. Softening the message--if you oppose the Kremlin, it will hurt you--is counterproductive.
- wbsss4412 5y agoEvery system of overt oppression has its limits, no matter how seemly compliant the population is or how iron fisted the current regime may be. The displays you mention are just that, displays. For population scale control you really do need to be more subtle and pervasive. Which is what makes this type of surveillance so much more insidious.
- dane-pgp 5y agoIt would be quite expensive for the Russian government to poison everyone who ever went to a protest, or who socialised with the wrong sort of people. Also, if it's cheap enough, the government can apply low-level incentives/nudges at the top of the dissent "recruitment funnel" as well as high-level high-profile actions against the few brave people who make it all the way to becoming leaders of these groups.
- kgeist 5y agoIf the government wants to apprehend you, a face recognition system in the metro is the least of your concerns. They will get you anyway, sooner or later. It can only make the life of FSB easier, so they can learn about your habits for blackmail etc. by just looking at some footage downloaded from a server, instead of actually putting some effort
- golergka 5y agoPeople have already been arrested after this winter's protests with the help of facial recognition, so these fears are a bit late. Also, just a couple of days ago it's been announced that local Moscow officials turned over all photos uploaded to the city's portal to law enforcement to be used for this.
- fernowens 5y agoWhy are they afraid of this one? Smartphones are already implementing this feature as a way to unlock the screen. It doesn't make sense that they're not batting an eye to that one.
- HideousKojima 5y agoThey feel (incorrectly) like they control their smartphones. As far as their fears about this being used for privacy violations and/or mass surveillance, they are 100% justified. The Snowden leaks, as well as what we know from leaks about pretty much every major and a lot of minor tech companies, have shown that if it can be abused, it will be abused. By the state, tech companies, or both.
- onemoresoop 5y ago> Why are they afraid of this one? Smartphones are already implementing this feature as a way to unlock the screen. Now not only your phone knows your location, you're also being filmed all the time with a tag attached and could be traced anywhere. This is extremely scary, especially that Kremlin persecutes its population into submission. Not only is the Kremlin regime anchored deeply (no possible fair elections), now this makes it even more impossible to have an alternative. Let's say you and a segment of the population wants a different leader. Let's say you as dissenters amount to even 70% of the population. Your voice won't matter as elections are highly rigged. Back in the day you could take out to the street to protest and if numbers are too great it sends a clear message. But this type of surveillance makes you think twice about it, you can go to an unauthorized protest (no authorization would be ever given for a dissenting protest) in the morning and be arrested in the evening.
- crispyambulance 5y agoAside from privacy concerns, which are serious, is anyone else surprised that they think it can work efficiently? I mean, how often will this thing get the facial recognition wrong? Will people just end up with metro charges from their "lookalikes" (I almost said doppelganger). Or has the state of the art in facial recognition recently zoomed ahead to where this is feasible for such a high throughput process?
- cm2187 5y agoor fast. You need a fast system at peak hour.
- bobthepanda 5y agoI found out the other day that it isn't uncommon in some countries (China, India) for metro systems to have security lines, which to me just sounds like a great reason to drive instead.
- dkirill 5y agoThey are definitely not doing identification (1:whole_database) for payment, that would be ridiculous. I'm sure they are matching against very small subset. Most likely they are getting data from mobile phone operators on who's currently around the entrance
- aga98mtl 5y agoI'm also skeptical it would work decently without something else like your cell phone signal to reduce the number of possible faces. I think the real value of this system is the intimidation factor. It really pushes the idea that the state can identify anyone anywhere is Moscow. It's useful to discourage both terrorism and political activism.
- mordechai9000 5y agoI wonder about the guy at the Houston Astros game recently. The FBI got a tip that a long-vanished white collar criminal (John Ruffo) was at the game. They located the ticket holder and interviewed him to determine he was not the guy after all. He was reasonably close in appearance, allowing for age progression. So I have to wonder: Was the tip a high probability hit in a facial recognition database?
- qwerty456127 5y agoIt's too late for Moscow to care about privacy. It has already been eliminated. Lack of option to pay with your face doesn't mean the system doesn't watch your face already. I'd be welcoming the face pay if I were them because it's just a convenience being built on top of the surveillance system already working. Let it serve at least one good purpose besides it's actual orwellian function they've built.
- splatzone 5y agoI think this is a bad idea. Welcoming a convenient feature of a sinister system just helps justify the system's existence. This is true of lots of things. Card payments are more convenient than cash, sure, but there's a hidden cost behind that convenience - your spending is easily traced and tied to your individual bank account. Better to let people see orwellian tech for what it is!
- anyfactor 5y agoI think it was inevitable that any form progress made in computer vision will more or less be applied to perfecting facial recognition. Yes, incredible amount of progress has been made in using computer vision to identify diseases but the authoritarian and workplace use case of computer vision is absolutely effective at present time. Orwellian tech isn't sudden, it is a creep, it is comfort, it is an acceptable cost of convenience.
- qwerty456127 5y agoI agree but I feel pessimistic about the possibility of the surveillance being reversed. When you are tied really well and being fucked the only constructive option left is to try to relax and enjoy that...
- zz865 5y agoKinda but I'm guessing the face recognition only works for 90% of people so by making it compulsory gets everyone else.
- 5y ago
- throwawaymanbot 5y agoA Worm trying to hold on to his domain!
- newaccount2021 5y ago[dead]
- StrLght 5y ago"Privacy fears" is a bold description. You can't hide from the government in Moscow. They have all data from mobile operators – they know where your phone is at all times. They've installed cameras on almost every single house entrance. They've been using facial recognition for a few years now, with little to no information on sources of data they used for this. It's not about tracking people anymore, it's about improving the accuracy of said tracking.
- vmception 5y agoThis reminds me how I was noticing similar in Monaco, a constitutional monarchy. My conclusion was that if it had poor people, then it would be seen as an authoritarian despot. But because it does not house poor people or let unhoused stick around outside, it is seen as a wealthy place where anything goes. It just doesn't encounter strife, but if it did it would be seen as authoritarian. Just an interesting inequality about how jurisdictions are perceived.
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoIIRC they (Rosnano) even developed their own AI chips dedicated to image recognition to be incorporated in street CCTV cameras. Stuff that Hikvision is also doing but in China. Scary stuff but I can imagine western governments salivating at these capabilities and doing metal gymnastics on what justification to spin for the introduction of such systems here, as "terrorists" and "think of the children" have been used already.
- Factorium 5y ago'Contact Tracing' for COVID: https://www.9news.com.au/national/wa-police-stand-by-decision-to-use-safewa-contact-tracing-app-in-nick-martin-murder-investigation/9250eb64-b523-46ea-810d-bf09521f1e1f https://www.9news.com.au/national/wa-police-stand-by-decisio...
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoMeh, contact tracing has been pretty much opt-in. There are a lot more insidious surveillance technologies being used.
- Pr0Ger 5y agoIt was never about surveillance (you already can't escape from cameras in Moscow). They can (and will) use this system to restrict movement for "uncomfortable" persons — turnstile will not open for you if government do not like what you said in Twitter.
- bvrmn 5y agoOpposition is not a target audience of FacePay.
- gmueckl 5y agoWait... if the system identifies you as someone else, you get a free ride while some other random person is billed for it? How is this going to be handled?
- 1024core 5y agoHow does it work with face masks?
- White_Wolf 5y agoLet's hope it doesn't work like it did with The Met.
- magwa101 5y ago"pay system"...nothing without government endorsement/control/use/abuse.
- danielodievich 5y agoFew vignettes about paying for Moscow Metro During my childhood in 1980ies the cost to ride was 5 kopecks (0.05 rouble), payable via hefty, sizeable, incredibly pleasant to hold 5 kopecks coin (https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9F%D1%8F%D1%82%D1%8C_%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BF%D0%B5%D0%B5%D0%BA#/media/%D0%A4%D0%B0%D0%B9%D0%BB:Soviet_Union-1989-Coin-0.05.jpg https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9F%D1%8F%D1%82%D1%8C_%D0%B...). With hyperinflation in the late 80ies the costs quickly went up by lots of powers of 10 to first roubles, then tens, hundreds and eventually thousands of roubles. For a while the entry fee was paid via tokens that you bought with money at kiosks, and the tokens were identical in weight and size to 5 kopecks, so same old machines could be used. Some people who had old soviet coin stashes could and did ride for free. Machines that didn't like the coins would slam you sideways hard. I still am instinctively afraid of those that look like one that smashed me when I was about 5. Fast forward to late 90ies and early 2000s, there were single use magnetic stripe and rfid tag tickets that were discarded by people all over the ground, really messy and likely unenvironmental. Haven't been there in a while but seems like an Oyster (London)/Opal (Sydney)/Ventra (Chicago) payment cards would likely be what I'd want to use, just as much tracking but without the creepy factor of face recognition