7 ms·
I'll admit that I was wrong about GitLab. I had the chance to invest in them way back in the day, and passed. My thought at the time was that no open source c
by jedberg 5y ago
I'll admit that I was wrong about GitLab. I had the chance to invest in them way back in the day, and passed. My thought at the time was that no open source company had ever been super successful except RedHat, which was more of an outlier than a pattern. And my other thought was that they are competing against GitHub, which was extremely popular and well funded.
I honestly didn't think they stood a chance.
I'm happy to have been proven wrong. Congrats to the whole team on their successful exit!
- altdataseller 5y agoIs Gitlab 100% open source?
- wizzwizz4 5y agoIt is not. They're better than most – and I know that's not a high bar, but they clear it by a wide margin. Nonetheless, their software is better described as "open core".
- pestaa 5y agoRedHat is not 100% open source either (although the differences are important).
- pankajdoharey 5y agoOpensource isnt such a problem the software should be great, i fail to see how Gitlab is better than Github.
- dragontamer 5y agoGithub is a website while Gitlab is software.
- bityard 5y agoGitlab is both actually
- robinhood 5y agoGithub is actually a web application, like Gitlab.
- dragontamer 5y agoCan you download Github and host a private Github instance? No? Then its web-only. Like Google Docs is web-only, while MS Word is offline. Gitlab is hostable software. You can buy and host Gitlab on your own servers, in private. That makes it a fundamentally different market than Github.
- Kranar 5y ago>Can you download Github and host a private Github instance? Yes, that's what Github Enterprise Server is: https://docs.github.com/en/enterprise-server@3.2/admin/overview/system-overview https://docs.github.com/en/enterprise-server@3.2/admin/overv...
- upheaval7276 5y agoGitlab always felt like a set of checkboxes to appease non-technical managers. In my experience, most features are half-baked. Even the code review/MR experience is frustrating compared to GitHub. The UX for security scans is _really_ rough.
- mr_tristan 5y agoIt's really "open core", but they use one code base, so commercial-licensed code is "available" but not under an open source license. https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/marketing/strategic-marketing/tiers/#sts=Open-source%20vs.%20source-available https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/marketing/strategic-market... NOTE: I'm not associated with GitLab at all I just found the topic interesting. I don't know of many other projects that actually do things this way, with all the commercial licensed code mixed in with the open source code. This was kind of an interesting speech I found searching around: https://www.heavybit.com/library/video/commercial-open-source-business-strategies/ https://www.heavybit.com/library/video/commercial-open-sourc...
- secondaryacct 5y agoDont worry, as a corporate user, it's a nightmare: it wont last.
- systemvoltage 5y agoIt’s really bloated but it’s gonna live and get better over time. Gitlab feels super slow compared to GitHub but it also has more features. I’m personally extremely pro Source Hut but it’s not ready yet: https://sr.ht https://sr.ht
- Aeolun 5y agoSourcehut will always be niche by definition.
- pankajdoharey 5y agoI am always reminded how not so great ideas or even clones when executed well lead to good outcomes.
- nodesocket 5y agoI’ll echo a sentiment I also had but perhaps I was wrong. I believed that users of GitLab used GitLab because they didn’t want to pay a premium (or pay at all) for GitHub; thus I viewed it as a cheaper alternative in the same vein as buying a Hyundai vs buying a Mercedes. I assumed only frugal “developers” were using it, and surely any legit companies would opt for the superior GitHub.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mr_cyborg 5y agoInteresting comparison with cars, I would think a Hyundai is much more reliable and less expensive to maintain than a Mercedes, and Hyundai is now being positioned as a more premium brand than it once was. On topic, GitLab is great at CI/CD and awesome for self-hosting things.
- maxsilver 5y agoJust one user here, but I definitely prefer GitLab over GitHub. Not because GitHub is bad in any particular way, I just like the feature set and UI of GitLab better. Less of a "Hyundai vs Mercedes" thing, and more of a "Ford vs Chevy" thing. They're both decent and they both have approximately the same level of "premium-ness". They're just feature-wise and aesthetically slightly different in arbitrary ways. And some people either do or don't vibe better with the one or the other.
- Lorin 5y agoThat'd be me, but I stuck around because issue management on GitLab is miles ahead of GitHub - however... if GitHub added scoped labeled I'd have a hard time convincing myself to stick around as the sheer number of users + discovery features blow GitLab out of the water.
- lmm 5y agoIsn't there a PG article on how being the cheap alternative undercutting the high-end incumbent is a good place to be?
- specialist 5y agoAny takeaway lessons for evaluating future FOSS startups? Like maybe place higher weight on rate of adding new users?
- jedberg 5y agoI've found that my bar for investing is the same no matter what kind of company it is -- how quickly can they sell me on investing? As much as us engineers hate to admit it, the most important skill for a founder is the ability to sell. Besides the obvious of having to sell to customers, they also have to sell their vision to VCs, sell their company to potential employees, sell their vision to journalists and potential customers, etc. If I'm not convinced to invest after one meeting, I usually don't invest. On the other hand, if I'm convinced after five minutes, I'm usually asking where to send the wire by the end of the meeting. Armory is a good example of an open source/open core company I did invest in. They had me convinced in just a few minutes. They had an answer for every one of my objections and made me feel like I'd be missing out if I didn't invest. And so far they're doing really well and it's one of my best investments to date.
- moneywoes 5y agoWhat do you find is the “best way to sell”?
- jedberg 5y agoHave an answer to every objection. First figure out all the ways you would object and make sure you have an answer, then note down any objections you don't have an answer to during your process and make sure you have a good answer next time. And if you're selling a product, make sure you know your competitors well because a lot of objections will be in the form of "but competitor X does this, how do you solve that problem?" and "what do you do that X doesn't do?". So you better know X really well because the person you're talking to already does and will know if you're making stuff up.
- ignoramous 5y ago> ...how quickly can they sell me on investing? As much as us engineers hate to admit it, the most important skill for a founder is the ability to sell. Besides the obvious of having to sell to customers, they also have to sell their vision to VCs, sell their company to potential employees, sell their vision to journalists and potential customers, etc. As cynical and hollow as it sounds, pretty sure this advice is consistent with what I have heard in multiple videos and blogs from YC. See also: "create investor fomo", https://html.duckduckgo.com/html/search?q=create%20fomo%20investors https://html.duckduckgo.com/html/search?q=create%20fomo%20in...
- killerstorm 5y ago> My thought at the time was that no open source company had ever been super successful except RedHat Sun bought MySQL for 1 billion USD in 2008, does that not count as successful? Also, MongoDB, Elastic and many many others...
- jedberg 5y agoI meant there were no successful public companies based on open source except RedHat in 2015.
- ZetaZero 5y agoMongoDB and Elastic are successful because they are locking features behind a paid license. Does that make it a successful open source company?
- strzibny 5y agoBut GitLab is the same concept...
- codetrotter 5y agoGitLab has features in the Enterprise edition that aren’t in the Community edition don’t they?
- polote 5y agoIf every investor was apologizing when a company he passed on became successful they would not have any time to do investing anymore. For any criteria (open source or github as a competitor in that case) you will find some company that became successful. Even the worst one.
- taytus 5y ago>which was more of an outlier than a pattern If you are looking to invest in patterns what makes you special? I thought the idea was to look for outliers.
- jedberg 5y agoVCs are the most risk averse people you will meet. They pretty much only look for patterns. That's why it's so hard for minority/female founders -- because it doesn't fit their pattern. I actually invest mostly in minority/female founders for exactly this reason. Also, I never said I was any good. :)
- klysm 5y agoI think if GitHub simply gave free private repos sooner, GitLab would’ve had a way harder time.
- polote 5y agoGithub is initially B2B SMB and B2C and Gitlab is B2B Enterprise. 10% of Github employee are sales , 25% for Gitlab. I would say they are not even competitors
- jbergens 5y agoGitlab was earlier/better at letting companies install a version on-prem.
- mcronce 5y agoTheir CI story was also a lot better until Github added Actions
- bitexploder 5y agoWe have been happy customers for many years. It has been a breeze to manage and upgrades, backups, and DR have been very good for us. For an on prem software of this complexity it is quite a feat. It has also always been at a very reasonable and affordable price point for enterprise-y on prem software. As an infosec consultancy that used it for projects and code we always appreciated being able to manage the security of our installation.
- paxys 5y ago
- MarkMc 5y agoSounds to me like you were only wrong in hindsight. At the time it was a reasonable decision to pass on GitLab in the circumstances.
- ano88888 5y agoIPO success. But still unprofitable as a business though
- orlovs 5y agoIf you take out their aggresive marketing spending to ack more customers they would be profitable.
- dehrmann 5y ago> no open source company had ever been super successful... I guess the trick is for it to also be a SaaS offering that no one wants to host themselves or whose moat isn't the time to write the code.
- jedberg 5y agoYeah that seems to be the trick. If I only I knew then that that would be a successful business tactic. :)
- eru 5y agoNot investing might still have been the right choice, given what you knew at the time about the odds. (For all we know, their 'true' odds of success might have been really slim, and they just got lucky.) I just stick my money in widely diversified, low-cost ETFs, since I don't expect to know more than the market.