19 ms·
Skepticism is the driving engine behind science. It works well so long as people keep asking questions until they get satisfactory answers. Science is anti-frag
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
Skepticism is the driving engine behind science. It works well so long as people keep asking questions until they get satisfactory answers. Science is anti-fragile. The harder you attack it, the sturdier it becomes. So this is fine.
The only time it really stops working is if people start treating it as doctrine, and demanding that you accept it on faith, and take any questions as evidence that you are an enemy of science. If anything destroys science, it is this line of reasoning.
Skepticism does not require a degree or a license from the government. The only intellectually honest thing is to admit to yourself that you do not know until you are convinced otherwise. Whether other people say they are convinced is honestly quite irrelevant.
- Viliam1234 5y agoProblem is that science is sometimes expensive. Math usually is not, but physics sometimes requires building huge machines, and psychology requires giving questionnaires to thousands of people. You can check the logic of the study, but unless you have lots of money, you need to trust the data. If we no longer can trust the data, and don't have money to gather our own data... well, yes, then the only option is to admit that we don't know.
- sjwalter 5y agoOne thing Heather Heying talks about with some frequency is the bias in science towards "Big Science", that is, expensive science with complicated studies and huge funding requirements and expensive machinery. These are the things our scientific institutions prioritize and highlight. Science can be much cheaper, but nobody's interested in cheap science if it doesn't advance their careers. It's similar to how NASA was obsessed with putting people into space for a long time. That's basically adding a gigantic expense to the exploration of space. When they decided to stop all that shit and use robots and probes and leave the human out of it, the science of exploring space became much cheaper (relatively) and we got far more out of it.
- verall 5y agoWhat about bad-faith skepticism, like cigarettes-cause-cancer skeptics and global warming skeptics? From what I can see, good faith skepticism makes science sturdier, but in bad faith it seduces the less knowledgable and burns the time of the more knowledgeable. On the flipside, most flat earthers don't seem to be arguing in bad faith.
- ethbr0 5y agoTo me, it seems like there's a failure to differentiate bad-faith skepticism. There's malicious "I know what I'm saying is a lie / broken argument, but I'm willing to make it because my righteousness / beliefs justify winning." (Fixable with... nothing?) But there's also ignorant "I don't understand the foundations of this information, and so arrive at an erroneous conclusion." (Fixable with education) One of the failures of scientific proponents (especially pop scientific proponents) has been to treat the second group as synonymous with the first.
- hnaccount141 5y agoThis is a great point, and one that I wish was more widely understood. In my anecdotal experience at least the latter group by far outnumbers the former, and treating the "good faith but poorly informed" group as you would the bad faith group is nearly always counterproductive.
- sjwalter 5y agoYour statement that all, for e.g., global warming skeptics are bad-faith shows you don't have a scientific mindset yourself. I live near glacier national park. In the 1990s, some climate model predicted the eponymous glacier would be gone by 2020. Signs around the parks' entrances were erected boldly stating this claim. In January of 2020, the signs were removed because the glaciers hadn't even shrunk. If there were real scientific interest in climate change, there'd be some interest and funding in ascertaining why that prediction was proven incorrect. But there is no such study, no funding for it, no interest whatsoever. The climate change alarmists have zero opposition in all major institutions. Anyone who says their models are bullshit, or who says maybe the Sun is having a larger impact on the climate than are GHGs, is ridiculed without their arguments even entertained. You belie this with your statement that any such skepticism is "bad faith". When it comes to climate change in particular, a field that seeks to study an incredibly complex collection of phenomena, whose leading experts have raised blood-chilling alarmist calls for action for decades and many of whose forecasts have proven totally bunk, who study a system far more complex than even the economy (are economics skeptics bad-faith too?)... Well, if you think YOU have a lock on what's true, and everyone with varying opinions is an obvious quack or a shill, then I think it's you who doesn't understand science.
- brightball 5y agoThis is the best, concise write up I have seen on this topic.
- Aperocky 5y ago> If anything destroys science Nothing destroy science, people can always opt to not believing in science, sometimes to their own peril. > accept it on faith I accept GNU/Linux on faith, having not analyzed its (public) code or build, because I trust that other people have done their best. And science is honestly an even easier decision.
- angelzen 5y agohttps://www.nature.com/articles/533452a https://www.nature.com/articles/533452a > More than 70% of researchers have tried and failed to reproduce another scientist's experiments, and more than half have failed to reproduce their own experiments. Those are some of the telling figures that emerged from Nature's survey of 1,576 researchers who took a brief online questionnaire on reproducibility in research. If 70% the GNU/Linux installations failed to boot, are you sure you'd take it on faith?
- mcguire 5y ago"“It's healthy that people are aware of the issues and open to a range of straightforward ways to improve them,” says Munafo. And given that these ideas are being widely discussed, even in mainstream media, tackling the initiative now may be crucial. “If we don't act on this, then the moment will pass, and people will get tired of being told that they need to do something.”"
- Aperocky 5y agoIf you installed ALL packages from npm, yum or pip, I wouldn't be surprised if 70% contains significant bugs or won't even start. Afterall, I published like 5 of them out of about 2 weeks worth of work and never looked at them again. But it's not that 70% that matters, it's the stable branch OS that you're running. It's the science that has been there for decades, that is the backbone of that faith.
- josefresco 5y agoHow should we counter coordinated unauthentic or disingenuous skepticism? I think everyone welcomes authentic concern, but what we're seeing with anti-vax/anti-mask/anti-science itself is something else completely.
- pumaontheprowl 5y agoYou counter all skepticism the same way: by a designing an experiment to test the skeptic's hypothesis and presenting the results of the experiment to the skeptic. Name-calling, censorship, and persecution are not going to bring the skeptic to your side, but they will almost certainly discourage future skeptics from presenting their findings. If we allow politicians to turn science into a dogma instead of an investigative process, progress will come to a grinding halt.
- josefresco 5y ago> You counter all skepticism the same way: by a designing an experiment to test the skeptic's hypothesis and presenting the results of the experiment to the skeptic. I've tried this (by sharing data) with friends and family members - it doesn't work/matter. They simply dismiss the data as "fake news" and shift to a new argument. This is why I classify it as "disingenuous skepticism". Their actions (anecdotally) are driven by culture and politics, not data.
- liber8 5y agoThis is not what pumaontheprowl said. You are right, simply presenting people with data doesn't work. If it did, you would never see a fat nurse, or a doctor who smokes, or... the list is endless. pumaontheprowl's suggestion is to design a (thought) experiment that involves the skeptic. There are various ways to do this, but history is literally built on this exact phenomena. Getting people to change their mind on an issue requires that you have a real conversation with them. You can't just shove data in their face and see "See, look dummy you're wrong I'm right!" There are all sorts of people that do this for a living: helping people leave cults/white supremacy groups/etc.
- 5y ago
- mschuster91 5y ago> The only time it really stops working is if people start treating it as doctrine, and demanding that you accept it on faith, and take any questions as evidence that you are an enemy of science. If anything destroys science, it is this line of reasoning. There is another point when "skepticism" as a principle fails, and that is when it is being weaponized by political and/or financial interests. Climate change is the most obvious example with oil companies funding all sorts of quackery, derailments and misinformation (such as BP did by inventing the "individual carbon footprint" in the 70s, see https://mashable.com/feature/carbon-footprint-pr-campaign-sham?europe=true https://mashable.com/feature/carbon-footprint-pr-campaign-sh...), but also the tobacco and alcohol industry - and in the last two years, COVID deniers who branded themselves "skepticists" only to renounce the most basic bits of societal solidarity such as wearing masks and getting a recommended vaccination. Skepticism should always, always come with at least some provable (!) claims - for example, with COVID vaccines, the issues regarding AstraZeneca and blood clots. These claims can then be investigated and validated or disproven. The problem is that modern and/or "alternative" media simply takes skepticist claims and reports them as gospel either because they don't have journalists with a science background any more or (as is the case with OAN/Newsmax/Fox/Murdoch/Axel Springer) they follow their own/their owners' agenda. The root cause at the bottom of weaponized skepticism is the truly horrible state of teaching and the attitude towards science in schools in most Western countries. "Creationism" should not be seen on any curriculum worth its name, the fact that students get ruthlessly bullied as nerds/know-it-alls/autists/<insert whatever label you were bullied with here> without consequences and that such behavior is culturally accepted (e.g. in "teenage movies" and sitcoms, where "nerds" are routinely portrayed in absurd cliches), the total lack of media education (aka what bias is, how it works, and what the pitfalls of modern mass media like clickbait, deceptive ads masked as journalism etc. are)... our societies are rotten from the core.
- Viliam1234 5y agoIt is difficult for most people to defend against weaponized anti-science. The reason is that no one can become an expert scientist in one day or even one year. First you learn elementary-school science, which by necessity involves some simplifications, and some things are left unexplained. Then you learn high-school science, which explains some of the gaps of the previous level, and improves some of its simplifications; yet it comes with its own simplifications and gaps. Then you learn undergraduate science... and after many years you hopefully become capable of understanding and evaluating the most complex scientific claims. Weaponized anti-science attacks people with statements that sound credible at their level, and require higher level to understand the deception. This does not happen accidentally; it is constructed so on purpose. So the person with elementary-school knowledge reads the statement that seems to make sense from the elementary-school perspective (it does not contradict anything taught at elementary school), but a high-school students could see why it is completely wrong. So the person can only conclude: "as far as I can understand, it is correct... and there is this one guy saying that it is wrong, but his arguments I can't understand". Similarly, you target people with high-school knowledge with statements involving undergraduate-level deception, etc. This is for me the most frustrating part of debating smart people who believe pseudoscience -- as far as they know (in my bubble that typically means undergraduate level of math, plus high-school level of everything else), the science often checks out. Someone who graduated in given area will be completely frustrated by hearing the "proof", because it contradicts many known and well-tested things... but to convince the person who is ignorant about it all (but is completely willing to trust his own Dunning-Kruger syndrome and Nassim Taleb's twitter over thousands of peer-reviewed papers), you need to hunt for the subtle error in the mathematical proof.
- ethbr0 5y ago> Science is anti-fragile. The harder you attack it, the sturdier it becomes. This is true for the subset of "scientific professionals, devoting significant amounts of time to their field". That's not all of the public. That's not even all of most scientific disciplines. The scientific method is perfect. The scientific method as practiced by fallible and irrational humans is subject to starts and stops, groupthink and cargo culting, and politics ad nauseam. The even more common case of "laypeople, with limited technical background knowledge, devoting limited amounts of time to understanding issues, who want to appear informed and intelligent about issues" is significantly more fraught with danger. And the source of most ineffective outcomes.
- LocalH 5y ago>The scientific method is perfect. Nonsense. Nothing is perfect, especially nothing ever created by a human. The scientific method is the best we have developed, in my opinion, but it's not perfect. The scientific method itself was developed by "fallible and irrational humans". Even with the best of intentions and the utmost in effort, all humans are susceptible to fallibility and irrationality. You are, I am, everyone is.
- rcoveson 5y agoThe word/concept "perfect" was "developed" by "fallible and irrational humans" as well, so we do have the authority to apply it. The 3/4/5 right triangle is perfect. The perfect fifth in music is (tautologically) perfect. "p or not p" is perfect. Perhaps none of these things can be reproduced in the physical world in a perfect manner, but the concepts really are perfect. Anything in idea-space can in fact be perfect, and the scientific method lives in idea-space. In the realm of perfection, there isn't really any difference between "developing" something and "discovering" it. Did we "develop" the scientific method or "discover" it? I think that's a meaningless distinction. It's the loop that describes how inductive reasoning is applied by limited observers to a structured universe. People were doing it before it was "developed".
- angelzen 5y ago
- iechoz6H 5y agoAs Wittgenstein notes in On Certainty ‘A doubt without an end is not even a doubt.’ Bad faith scepticism is of this order, no amount of evidence will convince such sceptics. Science doesn't become 'harder' in the face of the this kind of scepticism, it becomes irrelevant.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoWhy must skeptics be convinced? It is perfectly okay to live in doubt, ask Pyrrho.
- duxup 5y agoSkepticism requires discipline to actually look at the outcomes of exploring that skepticism and reevaluating. Sadly I see a lot of skepticism expressed that I think is just driving to a result people already believe.
- cletus 5y agoI understand what you're saying but skepticism is also a tool for manipulation. We now have a significant number of people who are rejecting the Covid vaccine because they're "skeptical" or "waiting for the evidence" or, the worst, they've "done their own research". Hint: some random guy talking about this in his basement and putting the video up on YouTube is not "research". The fact of the matter is that we simply can't be skeptical about everything and research everything. It's physically impossible. It's why we delegate authority to people and institutions who do actual research and have credibility. It's why I listen to the CDC about diseases and CERN when it comes to physics. "Skepticism" these days is often a euphemism for confirmation bias.
- JoshuaDavid 5y agoIt's when those institutions lose credibility that things fall apart. If CERN came out with a press release tomorrow that said that actually the theory of relativity was wrong and the universe operates by newtonian mechanics, I would not only doubt that press release, but also everything else CERN put out recently. If a certain group started calling anyone who asked questions like "well how are GPS satellites so accurate" and "why does Mercury's orbit precess instead of being a perfect ellipse" was called a "science denier", well I would start doubting the credibility of that group.
- loudmax 5y agoSkepticism is indeed healthy, but beware of selective skepticism. Humans have a tendency trust people that they like or who make them feel good about themselves, and distrust people they don't like or who challenge assumptions they'd rather hold onto. So yes you should be skeptical, but you do need to keep yourself grounded. How are you to convince a flat-Earther that the world is round? You can show photos of Earth taken from the moon, but clearly you have to trust NASA. You can show global flight traffic patterns that only make sense if the Earth is a sphere, but then you have to trust the FAA or wherever you're getting the airline data. You can dig up whatever evidence you want but at some point you'll need them to relinquish their skepticism and accept that these institutions are not part of a vast conspiracy to hide the shape of the Earth. Now apply that to vaccines, climate change, election results, economic theory and everything else that matters. Institutions are imperfect. They have their own agendas and sometimes they happen to be wrong, and sometimes they flat out lie. If you only trust people that you like, you're liable to fall prey to charismatic charlatans. If you demand absolute certainty, you'll never get past a bedrock reality of cogito ergo sum. You have to make some sort of reasonable balance between trust and skepticism and accept that sometimes you'll be wrong.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- forgotmypw17 5y agoYou're correct that institutions are imperfect, just like individuals... But there is another factor here: trustworthiness or credibility. If an institution or an individual is caught more than once being dishonest, putting their agenda above the truth, etc., should they be trusted again, or should anything they say or do be treated as a curiosity and thought experiment at best, until it is agreed with by someone credible and trustworthy?
- lordnacho 5y agoThe problem is it all comes down to authority in the end. There, I said it. But it does. In the end all evidence in the public sphere is second hand. If you don't already trust the scientists, there's an alternative universe of quacks who will give you what you're after.
- nitrogen 5y agoAnything independently reproducible doesn't come down to authority. Reproducibility is fundamental to science.
- lordnacho 5y agoAnd nobody can realistically reproduce anything outside their own little niche. "I injected the boys with fluid from cowpox victims, and they didn't get smallpox later." "I don't believe you" Turtles all the way down. At best we can say the quacks hold everyone else's evidence to a higher standard than their own.
- apetresc 5y agoHe's talking about "the public sphere." Among the general non-specialist public (probably 95%+ of the population), virtually nobody can even do things like prove the Pythagorean theorem. The idea that science is substantially different from religion for most people because they "could", in principle, reproduce the studies is laughable.
- cronix 5y ago> The only time it really stops working is if people start treating it as doctrine, and demanding that you accept it on faith, and take any questions as evidence that you are an enemy of science. If anything destroys science, it is this line of reasoning. I wonder where we'd be today in science/physics if the Catholic Church (the authority of the day) was successful in stopping Galileo Galilei, in 1615, from "spreading misinformation/disinformation" that the Earth circled the sun, and pushing back against the prevailing "science" of the day. If he were alive in 2021 and pushing something that went against "current wisdom," of that magnitude, he would be banned from media, ridiculed, and cancelled. It was a lesson I had thought the West had learned. It appears not. Censor and treat science as a religion at your (our) own peril.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoNot being snarky, but it started with Aristarchus (his parallax work) and Ptolemy (the other one), so I'm pretty sure it would have continued in countries that weren't under Catholic oppression of science. Persia was pretty much the engine of science while Europe languished. To say this would not have progressed is to ignore the important work of non-European scientists.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoScience actually progressed in Europe as well during the supposed dark ages. The whole notion that science just laid dormant between the fall of Rome and the renaissance is enlightenment-era propaganda that unfortunately has become part of the western cultural narrative. Ironically the notion of a Muslim golden age of free thought and science followed by a long dark age of no progress and oppression is also largely imagined.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoCorrect. Which is why I said "languished", in comparison to what immediately followed with the Age of Enlightment, and what came before it, in Greece and the early Roman empire. It also is a bit of a misnomer to blame it all on religion, it was mostly just an assload of war.
- orangepurple 5y ago“The seeker after truth is not one who studies the writings of the ancients and, following his natural disposition, puts his trust in them," the first scientist wrote, "but rather the one who suspects his faith in them and questions what he gathers from them, the one who submits to argument and demonstration and not the sayings of human beings whose nature is fraught with all kinds of imperfection and deficiency. Thus the duty of the man who investigates the writings of scientists, if learning the truth is his goal, is to make himself an enemy of all that he reads, and, applying his mind to the core and margins of of its content, attack it from every side. he should also suspect himself as he performs his critical examination of it, so that he may avoid falling into either prejudice or leniency.” ― Ibn al-Haytham
- cogman10 5y agoThis is all well said, but I'd put a caveat here, science, by it's empirical nature, is fuzzy. What that means is that for nearly any generally accepted position, you can find studies that invalidate that position. This all comes into the need for looking into meta analysis over single studies. The perfect example of this is climate change. There are, literally, thousands of studies supporting the notion that human made climate change is real. However, there are 100s of studies that call it into question. That is where you can get 2 individuals saying "I'm following the science" that talk past each other because each is clinging onto the set of studies that confirm their beliefs. Skepticism is fine, however, if you aren't challenging your own position you aren't being a skeptic, you are simply using it as a cover for what you want to believe. The example here is flat earthers that would all describe themselves as "skeptics".
- simorley 5y ago> The only time it really stops working is if people start treating it as doctrine, and demanding that you accept it on faith, and take any questions as evidence that you are an enemy of science. If anything destroys science, it is this line of reasoning. Agreed with everything you wrote. We should be especially vigilant when politics/media gets involved in science. Science is just as corruptable, especially in the short term, as any other field. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piltdown_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piltdown_Man The more obvious example being the purging of "jewish science" from germany during ww2.
- mcguire 5y agoOnly if the "skeptic" is acting in good faith. Consider the skepticism regarding the health effects of smoking cigarettes.
- Traf444 5y agoI agree with what you say in general, but... One of the problems today for me is that most people is skeptic because they cannot understand the answer to the question they ask. Sooner or later I have to rely on an expert in most areas of science. Which would be fine for me if I could trust that the expert actually answers in his expert opinion and not because he was bought to give a certain answer. Schooling is mandatory up to a certain level in my country. I'm going to pull dates out of my ass, because I'm too lazy to compare them to what you actually learn in school, but the level of math for the average person is probably 19th century of science, as well for chemistry and physics, with some basic knowledge about stuff from the 20th century. Most people are not equipped with the tools to understand most of modern day science. They approach it with opinions based on feelings or what their random favorite actor/actress or singer thinks. And we cannot expect them to be equipped with the right tools either. Reality doesn't change even if people deny it, but is science as a field really resistant if most people just flat out deny science, especially if politicians starts doing it and deny funding due to it?