18 ms·
Windows 11’s first update makes AMD CPU performance even worse
- causi 5y agoWindows 11 fixes exactly zero of my problems and creates several new ones. Wake me up when the Windows Update team stops testing on VMs instead of actual hardware.
- aniforprez 5y agoNot seen baby performance issues with this I'm more completely put off by all the half baked UI decisions especially with the task bar and the explorer. They're really really bad. I hope updates will fix it. I don't mean "oh this is ugly" I mean "this feature I used to use is just gone or takes multiple clicks to use now"
- jerf 5y agoWindows has been running an "every other one is good" process for a while. I think it may actually be causal; Microsoft has a "good windows", which lasts for 3-5 years, it gets overconfident internally as everyone just becomes accustomed to dominance and starts thinking it has a platform it can do something other than "be a good operating system" from, so it designs a piece of crap and gets humbled for a couple of years. So they take the time to make a good OS. Then repeat. Windows 10 was a good windows. Not perfect, but it's been pretty good. I thought maybe we escaped from this cycle when they announced Windows 10 would be the last windows, but I've expected 11 to very likely be a pile of crap since I first heard it announced. Windows 12 will be the one to look out for. (They do have a platform they can do something other than "be a good operating system" from... it's just it rests on the foundation of having a good operating system. They seem to neglect their foundation every other major release.)
- II2II 5y agoIs it actually a case of every other version being good, or is it a case of the market settling upon every other version? Nearly every version of Windows had its critics, yet the "bad" versions typically had such a short life those issues couldn't be address or users couldn't be accustomed to the changes, so the bad is what people tended to remember.
- klodolph 5y agoIt’s only Me/Vista/8 that people didn’t like. Me was just a buggy piece of trash, maybe it would have gotten fixed, but XP was around the corner. Speaking purely from personal experience—had a desktop running Me, it’s the only time I ever saw Explorer crash. Vista’s actually a decent Windows. The changes to security that broke a bunch of apps and made pop-ups everywhere stuck around, they just got polished a bit in later Windows, it would have been fine if Vista had a longer life. Windows 8 had the Metro UI and introduced a ton of misguided changes around the assumption that people will be using touch—changes which were often half-implemented at best, so even if you had a touchscreen (I developed for these), you had to constantly switch between the Metro and desktop interfaces. A lot of those changes got unwound in 8.1 and 10. IMO the bad ones are Me and 8. Anything that fixed 8’s problems would have gotten a new version number.
- occamrazor 5y agoIn my memory also 98 was horribly unstable until 98 SE.
- klodolph 5y agoEarly XP was also a horrible experience. If you installed an early version Windows XP and connected to the internet to update, you might get malware from remote vulnerabilities before the updates finished downloading.
- xxs 5y agolikewise w/ 95 osr2. To me 8.1 is the better version - no telemetry junk compared to 10.
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y agoProbably a bit of both. The market settles on a version that's "good enough" and it gets patched until it's "good". But Windows 8 was around for quite a while, and never got to be particularly good. 10 became good over time. 8 was crap, and stayed crap with 8.1. 7 became good over time. Vista was crap. XP became good over time.
- benbristow 5y agoWindows 10 started off pretty funky. I was using it before RTM. The updates afterwards made it the solid OS that it is now.
- vadfa 5y ago7 was much better than XP, but 10 is much worse than 7, so I'm not sure if I'm ready for a 12 that is much worse than 10.
- snarfy 5y agoI think the UI decisions make perfect sense if you consider using your PC like it's a giant phone.
- APock 5y agoWhy would I EVER even want that? Windows on phones is dead and tablets/hybrids are perfectly able to display the regular UI in a usable way.
- Mindwipe 5y agoNobody sane would, but this taskbar rewrite was started for Windows 10x and that was the modus operandi for it. Then during yet another fundamental internal change in direction it got foisted on the desktop OS, and then they got told to ship it six months before it was finished, so we've ended up with this mess.
- tssva 5y agoExcept for not being able to move the taskbar location I find the UI to generally be an improvement. As for explorer I find the UI to be a great improvement from Windows 10.
- swozey 5y agoIf you do a lot via right click they nuked it, but you can add it back in. The fact that I can't right click the taskbar to open Task Manager without getting that horrible full screen "LOG OUT/SHUTDOWN/OPEN TASK MANAGER" thing is my biggest frustration. I'm opening the taskbar because I'm getting poor performance, don't make me take multiple steps to do it. Not to mention I had no idea what the right click icons meant when I first starting using it, is that copy? Is that paste?
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoDoes Ctrl+Shift+Esc still open task manager directly?
- filiperui 5y agoYes.
- kirel33 5y agoYou can right click on the start menu and get (most of?) the old menu
- timemct 5y agoI know it's a little petty, however not being able to move the taskbar has zeroed out any interest I had in using Windows 11. I'm a huge fan of moving the taskbar/dock to the left vertical side of the screen, especially so on a 16:9 screen.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoIt isn't petty, it is indicative of an incompetent development team. We have been able to move the taskbar since Windows 95, but apparently whoever Microsoft hires to work on Windows UI these days can't figure it out. Lord knows what else those yahoos have fucked up.
- Guillaume86 5y agoI'm not updating until they bring back taskbar ungrouping. Not interested in adding more clicks/reducing button size for something as important as switching between windows...
- Mindwipe 5y agoI honestly can't fathom for the life of me why taskbar grouping is even the default, or what problem it was supposed to solve. It is a terrible UI pattern.
- Guillaume86 5y agoI suspect every person that is aware of the option to revert has reverted, but a lot of people are used to deal with defaults and just don't want to waste energy fighting their OS and research stuff like that...
- daemin 5y agoExactly. The central menu is a good idea for ultrawide monitors, but forcing grouping seems to go a step backwards, especially if you cannot move the taskbar and you're on said ultrawide monitor.
- idiotsecant 5y agoOh no, they finally did it. I feel like Windows has some kind of fascination with taskbar grouping, every new version you have to specifically shut it off. They've finally gone and removed the choice. There is nothing in windows that annoys me more than taskbar grouping, I don't even have a rational basis for it, it just immediately annoys me when I see it.
- Guillaume86 5y agoIt's not irrational IMO, it's a hassle in several ways compared to the "classic" behavior.
- jerf 5y agoHow is this possible? Is it that Windows 11 is constantly running code and/or using data so that it consumes more of the L3 cache all the time? But only on AMD? Is this really a linear slowdown of cache speed as the article's wording implies, or is it some more complicated slowdown that they've benchmarked with something that intrinsically measures it linearly? Problems with the thread migration to certain classes of CPUs I can kind of understand, that's still fairly new code for windows, but how it can slow down the L3 cache in the described way is a bit of a mystery to me.
- h2odragon 5y agoTotally ignorant guess: sounds like they're invalidating too much sometimes, like having one core clear all the shared cache instead of just the lines it stepped on or something. There's big hairy problems down in the tiny little details there that are easy to have come out and eat you.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TillE 5y agoThis is the actual interesting question here. A simple constant slowdown seems physically impossible, and explanations which apply equally to Intel CPUs can presumably be discarded. So I would guess, as the previous reply does, that it's probably somehow linked to the threading issue.
- geodel 5y agoBut at least Windows 11 brings family and friends together with new Teams integration in OS. So all is forgiven.
- thrower123 5y agoI have seen nothing but people ripshit that this isn't actual Teams, and so they can't log in to their work or school Teams tenants which they actually need to use. It's like the completely self-inflicted footgunning that they already committed a few years ago when they bought Skype and then immediately renamed their not-compatible enterprise chat system Skype for Business.
- geodel 5y agoTO be fair may be it is Microsoft's subtle way of telling that Office or School colleagues are just that and not family or friends.
- Someone1234 5y agoWell of course, that makes sense Windows 11 is an unfinished beta product, right? Wait, they went RTM? Four months after the first public insider builds? Without fixing most of the bugs/issues/complaints? By the way, this comment is posted from Windows 11. Trust me when I tell you that this isn't ready for most of the general public. It is still for early adopters willing to suck up problems. I'd wait until March 2022 or more, and then see where it is at. While they've made some positive moves forward UI wise, this still definitely feels like an insider build. I've had the DWM crash a few of times, requiring a hard reboot twice (even CTRL+ALT+Del or Win+Ctrl+Shift+B didn't work, while my mouse cursor still moved). That's more times than Windows 10's entire life. Plus it is missing very "101"/polish features (e.g. just today I discovered that moving pinned start menu icons between pages was impossible, you have to move it to the start of the second page then delete icons from the first page).
- hoseja 5y agoI hope it'll be feasible to skip this version, as is tradition.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y ago> It is still for early adopters willing to suck up problems. AKA suckers. Why do free beta testing for Microsoft?
- bserge 5y agoWith Windows 10 updates, they made everyone a sucker. Updates that can lead to unbootable systems, loss of data, and hardware failure. We've seen it all.
- charwalker 5y agoADHD aka is it New, Interesting, Challenging, or Urgent. It's new, interesting, challenging if you hit problems, and you can get in early. It is a direction change and if you could run it in a VM on older hardware I would. The official launch ISO won't boot while a dev version from the week before launch loads up in Hyper V fine.
- 5y ago
- dncornholio 5y agoYou're better off skipping every other version of Windows and it seems to still hold true.. Windows NT good Windows 98 bad Windows 2000 good Windows Me bad Windows XP good Windows Vista bad Windows 7 good Windows 8 bad Windows 10 good Windows 11 bad
- tssva 5y agoThis listing makes no sense. Some of these operating systems were targeted at completely different markets and shouldn't be lumped together. Also you have lumped all the versions of Windows NT together as one operating system when there were 4 different versions of Windows NT. Windows 95 came after 3 of those versions had been released but doesn't appear on this list at all. Also Windows 98 is not generally considered a bad operating system for the time.
- dncornholio 5y agoI lumped them together according to Microsoft versioning. I only named the Windows i've used as a consumer (hence no 2003). Following just the initial release of the major versions it holds. I know 8.1 is a completely different OS to 8, but according to Microsoft it's not :) Most Windows were fixed later though with service packs etc. So this list should be taken with a grain of salt of course
- pitdicker 5y agoMaking generalized statements and lists like this is only possible if you selectively ignore versions. From the Windows 3.11 to Windows ME/2000 era there where the DOS and NT kernel editions, both available at the same time. I believe the missing Windows 98 SE was generally considered good, and the version many people kept using while XP was popular. XP was not considered good at first, but had substantial improvements in SP2 and SP3. Windows 8.1 didn't leave much of an impression, but was pretty workable.
- danielheath 5y agoWhere does 95 / 98se fit into that? (more seriously, iirc NT/2k were a substantially different codebase which got merged with the 95/98/me line to produce XP)
- _l4jh 5y agoI honestly don't understand Microsoft's plan with Windows 11. 6 years ago, with the release of Windows 10, it was all about "this is the last version of Windows!" and they went with the rolling release model. A little strange but they stuck with it for 6 years until suddenly this summer they announce Windows 11 and they went hard talking up how it was a huge change to Windows but in reality it isn't. At all. It has a new visual layer sure but the applications are still the old Windows 10 (and so really the old Windows XP?) ones with that new look. They introduced a new store and support for additional stores such as the Amazon Android app store. I guess what I am saying is I don't get why now they are calling it Windows 11? They could have just carried on calling it Windows 10. They have introduced big UI and feature changes in previous Windows 10 updates (perhaps not quite as big as the new taskbar and Explorer changes). It is a free upgrade for Windows 10 license holders (consumer anyway, not sure how it works for Enterprise?). It just all feels so rushed and messy and the end product is just not very good as we can clearly see here. I don't want to hate on Windows, after all they have introduced some really interesting new things since Windows 10 initial release such as WSL. It is just there didn't appear to be a want or need for a Windows 11 and this rushed mess makes it look like Microsoft didn't (doesn't?) know what it is doing with Windows either. Shrug.
- wolpoli 5y agoWindows 11 is indeed rushed. Since Apple released MacOS 11, Microsoft needs to release a new version as well. It's obvious[1] that Microsoft took the features made for Windows 10x and glued them into Windows 10. [1]: https://twitter.com/vhanla/status/1434730813183209472 https://twitter.com/vhanla/status/1434730813183209472
- mattl 5y agoApple was doing Mac OS X forever but then it went to 11 and soon 12 (in reality still Max OS X)
- fbelzile 5y agoProbably some marketing experts thinking that Windows 10 would seem out-of-date now that Apple decided to stop versioning macOS at 10.x forever.
- easton 5y agoHow is there a rumored release date for a emergency driver update? Isn't it just "release after it passes the tests", or at the very least, "release after we run it for 24 hours and it doesn't light the machine on fire"? Having a date implies they already have the fix and they're waiting on something else.
- MrBuddyCasino 5y agoHow can the OS influence L3 access times? I would have thought this to be entirely internal to the CPU.
- cute_boi 5y agoI think OS can clear L3 cache constantly which can cause high latency?
- nassimsoftware 5y agoOk so I may be a rare exception but I have a laptop with a Ryzen 7 4800 CPU and an Nvidia GPU GTX1650Ti and honestly I'm having a better experience on Windows 11 compared to Windows 10. Before upgrading to Windows 11, I had all kinds of problems with Windows 10. - When I a turned on the computer it took longer to log into Windows. - Apps would open more slowly sometimes I would even have bugs with the Xbox app lagging. - When I put my computer to sleep by shuting the laptop's lid and come back later sometimes the laptop wouldn't even turn the screen on and I had to forcefully shut it down.
- dncornholio 5y agoEvery fresh install feels better the first few days. It's possible you'd have the same gains with a fresh W10 install?
- nassimsoftware 5y agoI bought my laptop only 4-6 months ago and it was a fresh W10 install.
- fartcannon 5y agoSo skip it? Build your products on and for Linux. Live the dream of never having to wonder if this kind of horseshit is intentional or not?
- petargyurov 5y agoObligatory "I switched to Linux" comment. But no seriously, after having Windows as my main OS for my entire life I finally switched to Linux (Pop!_OS) a few months ago. Got tired of nonsensical UI decisions, terrible search functionality, user-hostile behaviour, privacy issues, ads... aaaah! That's not what an OS should be like!
- lostmsu 5y agoI would do the same, but Windows is technically superior in one regard: it actually enables and does proper GPU scheduling (Linux only does CPU and I/O). Super important if you want to do anything on your machine while some neural network is training.
- coolspot 5y agoI would imagine distracting GPU with interface rendering significantly reduces ML performance. On Linux you can use integrated video while your RTX 3090 is 100% loaded.
- lostmsu 5y agoIf you have an integrated video that is sufficient. I don't even know if iGPU can handle 3 monitor setups, let alone smooth experience or any kind of gaming. ML tasks being delayed by a few minutes is generally a drop in a bucket, but the machine would be barely usable for hours if not days. I honestly don't know how ML enthusiasts do their bidding on Linux.
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoIt sounds like they implemented some Spectre/Meltdown type security feature involving cache invalidation that are 'currently' unnecessary for AMD. For some reason none of the articles make it clear if it's only seen on Zen 1/2 or if Zen 3 is affected since the memory topology of Zen 2 has caused issues in the past. This is quite bad considering how Microsoft was upfront about Windows 11 being better designed for Intel's Alder Lake CPUs which have two distinct core types. So it's incredibly weird that Windows 11 would interfere with AMD's preferred core technology since it's comparatively normal. It's pretty obvious that regression testing on AMD platforms just wasn't done.
- bobcostas55 5y agoDo they literally not have a QA department or what? You'd think this sort of thing would be caught by automated testing.
- pram 5y agoThey famously do not.
- n8cpdx 5y agoThey fired all their SDETs ~2014, and the decline in quality since then has been very noticeable. https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-layoffs-operating-systems-group-chief-myersons-memo-to-the-troops/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-layoffs-operating-sy... There's lots of criticism about how that role was structured, but putting devs in charge of their own code's quality is a recipe for poor quality software. It works on my machine doesn't work with a product like Windows.
- nly 5y agoMeanwhile I can't even upgrade from Windows 10 20H2, which I dual boot with Arch Linux, to 21H1. I get a useless and unhelpful error message and then the update rolls itself back. Microsoft have been seriously failing on the Windows Update front for decades.
- qayxc 5y agoI upgraded an 11 year old laptop (1st gen Intel Core, no UEFI, no TPM) no problem. It's unsupported but works just fine. The trick on how to do it is embarrassingly simple. Just download both the Windows 10 and Windows 11 ISOs, replace the "install.wim" in the Windows 10 ISO with the one from the Windows 11 ISO (it's conveniently the same file name) and run the setup. The upgrade works just fine since the Windows 10 installer doesn't check for supported hardware, TPM or secure boot. Really goes to show how all that TPM, secure boot and CPU support business is just a marketing ploy to increase hardware sales...
- nly 5y agoI'm talking about upgrading Windows 10 to Windows 10
- qayxc 5y ago> I'm talking about upgrading Windows 10 to Windows 10 I assume you meant Windows 10 to Windows 11? Because that's exactly what I described. The setup on the Windows 10 ISO (once you replaced the "install.wim" with the Window 11 file) will perform an in-place upgrade. All programs, data and settings are preserved.
- baseballdork 5y agoNo, GP means upgrading from one Win10 release to the next. 20H2[1] to 21H1[2]. 1 - https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/whats-new/whats-new-windows-10-version-20h2 https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/whats-new/whats-new... 2 - https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/whats-new/whats-new-windows-10-version-21h1 https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/whats-new/whats-new...
- 41209 5y agoWhen it comes to OSes, I want them to stop screwing with it. No one uses a computer to stare at OS UI design. No one cares about your new taskbar. I want to start Windows up, launch my applications and not crash. Give me security and performance fixes without messes with what works
- Gulfick 5y agoNo surprise there.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoWindows is a joke, if only Microsoft didn't have such a strangehold on the enterprise market we could see see progress on the workstation front.
- mickotron 5y agoSolus Linux is rolling release. No worries for me.