6 ms·
Gambling addiction does seem to be a modern problem; not just unregulated forex and options trading, and not just in bitcoin, but also gatcha games and good old
by pjc50 5y ago
Gambling addiction does seem to be a modern problem; not just unregulated forex and options trading, and not just in bitcoin, but also gatcha games and good old fashioned sports betting.
Perhaps this is why Netflix Korean lethal gambling TV series Squid Game is so resonant in the West.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Reason077 5y agoIt's always been a problem. Religions and governments have historically banned or heavily regulated gambling, going back at least as far as Ancient Rome, Ancient China, and Ancient Egypt. The modern problem, perhaps, is that now we have new forms of gambling (crypto! day trading! spread betting apps!) which are perhaps not as obvious, are not as visible in society, and fall outside of existing regulations?
- vanderZwan 5y agoThe growing wealth inequality probably also produces more desperate people willing to risk it
- usrusr 5y agoIt's not just desperation, wealth disparity has also contributed to the erosion of any value that used to be given to where the money comes from. The spectrum from speculation to gambling used be be linked to a certain kind of stigma (more so for straight up honest gambling, but also for speculation), these days it's more like "hard-earned? you got no-one to blame but yourself!" And how could it not erode? It's difficult to take pride in your hard-earned cash when it's all coming from a stack of advertising media fueled by advertising media, as if all the way down.
- Consultant32452 5y agoDo you believe there’s more wealth inequality in America today compared to medieval Europe or ancient Egypt?
- mgamache 5y agoBetween the very top and bottom? Yes. https://voxeu.org/article/europe-s-rich-1300 https://voxeu.org/article/europe-s-rich-1300
- Consultant32452 5y agoDo you believe the pareto distribution of resources/wealth has changed, or that the over-all growth in total wealth maintaining a similar pareto distribution results in the chart you posted?
- mgamache 5y agoI think that resources in stable system (for example peacetime) tend to be increasingly horded by successful competitors. When rent seeking from those at the top becomes too expensive there is sometimes a reset that is usually violent. Sometimes the reset (war or plague for example) can be from external sources, but is still violent.
- Consultant32452 5y agoThis is how I would put it. Do you agree? Pareto distribution is the norm, marked by brief transitional periods during which the people at the top of the pareto distribution change. These transition periods correlate strongly with wide-scale disasters such as war or plague.
- hnbad 5y agoMedieval peasants weren't told their place in life is a matter of personal responsibility (within reason), they were told the hereditary social hierarchy is divine will and can't be overcome. "Trading" is the ultimate example for the opposite, since it promises to directly translate "skill" into wealth. Wealth inequality is an important factor but expecting everything to boil down to one simple factor is overly simplistic.
- flooow 5y agoThis has to be a key factor. Your average 20-something has terrible life-prospects. If they have a little political nous they will correctly deduce that their parent's generation stole their wealth and wellbeing (through a house price bubble, destruction of pensions, wages growing slower than inflation, climate crisis round the corner, student debt coupled with credential inflation, national debt, privatization, knee-capping of unions, a ruinously expensive military-industrial complex, etc etc). Could you blame them for thinking that anyone who works for a living is a mug, paying for the lifestyle of kleptocratic boomers? Cryptocurrencies provide an emancipatory (and entirely false) narrative. Why not gamble, and try to defeat the system?
- Consultant32452 5y agoThose 20-somethings are strong proponents of at least half the things that are screwing them over. The biggest thing robbing people of generational wealth is Social Security that takes 7% of your earnings for your entire life and when you die you have nothing to give to your children. One of the largest contributors to wage stagnation is immigration policy. Previously a path to higher wages was higher education. Except those Universities (and big business partners) bring in immigrants to perform their high skilled labor and call them "graduate students" to crush middle class wage growth. Another path to wage growth was previously to start your own small business. Try having a discussion with a group of 20-somethings that with very little money they could buy a pressure washer or other relatively inexpensive equipment and start a small business making $40/hr+. You'll be barraged with responses about how it's crazy because not every person in the country can get a job doing the thing I happened to give an example of, or how starting a business is really hard, or insurance, or licensing requirements in the state that they support. You're absolutely right that the Boomers have fucked their kids and grandkids. But those grandkids, already in a hole, are shoveling down as fast as they can.
- lm28469 5y agoWe now have forms of gambling in videos games for the last 5-10 years, a good way to teach kids from the beginning, that probably doesn't help either
- qeternity 5y agoI think the devastating problem today is that because investing and trading can be done responsibly, that all forms of investing and trading are ok even if it’s nothing more than gambling. People see a few success stories like DFV and it becomes a new American dream: get rich quick by shrewdly allocating a bit of capital. But most people are just being fooled by randomness.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhat is DFV?
- ddorian43 5y agoDeepFuckingValue is his username
- tux3 5y agoThe person behind the Gamestop (GME) saga.
- djbebs 5y agoDFV stands for /u/deepfuckingvalue a reddit user who became famous for his bullish investment on gamestop which resulted in him becoming a multi-millionaire. You may know him from his part in the congress hearings regarding gamestop.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThanks.
- bko 5y agoI can't find a meaningful distinction between gambling and investing. It's not about knowledge / skill (picking index funds blindly is actually recommended form of investing these days) It's not about odds (lottery with positive return is gambling, and insurance with negative return is not) It's not about frequency (we're encouraged to contribute to 401k on every paycheck but not to play the lottery every week) And to top it off, if you have a positive expected return on gambling (pro poker player, hedge fund manager), it stops being gambling either. https://mleverything.substack.com/p/gambling-versus-investing https://mleverything.substack.com/p/gambling-versus-investin...
- danjac 5y agoIt comes with the adrenalin rush. Similar addiction some have to extreme sports, or people who shoplift even when they have plenty of money. I heard that in Iceland after the 2008 financial crash wiped out the banks traffic accidents went way down, as there were fewer traders speeding when driving home from work, as they were still buzzing with the adrenaline rush while trading (could just be of course their cars were all impounded to pay off debts...)