7 ms·
Windows Package Manager 1.1
- pgeorgi 5y agoOne nice feature of winget that I discovered after the Win11 update is that it doesn't bother with any restrictions on uninstalling Edge, XBox Game Bar, "My Smartphone", Maps and all the other useless fluff that is supposedly not uninstallable.
- tauwauwau 5y agoI can confirm that it's working on Windows 10 too. It let me uninstall Cortana :), lets see if anything breaks after restart or if it comes back in next update.
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoThey should've acquired Scoop. That is a better package manager than I can imagine they'll be able to conjure.
- easton 5y agoScoop was designed to be able to work without admin rights, keeping everything in the user's directory. Which is good for users, but not really for system administrators who don't want six versions of Teams or whatever out of sync on the system. (which is a bad example, because Teams does that anyway even if you use the system-wide installer. I digress.)
- speeder 5y agoThese days someone mentioned this: https://medium.com/@keivan/the-day-appget-died-e9a5c96c8b22 https://medium.com/@keivan/the-day-appget-died-e9a5c96c8b22 That said they DO credit him now on the repository. The whole story still feels really bizarre though.
- iamcreasy 5y agoI wonder if the story would end up any differently if AppGet was closed source.
- bombcar 5y agoIt might have been coverflow'd but is it even (reasonably) possible for something like AppGet to be what it is and be closed source? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cover_Flow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cover_Flow
- 908B64B197 5y agoThis story again? I once interviewed a smart guy from a certain UC across the bay. Still undergrad, he played a lot with Python and wished he could have something similar to pip when doing C/C++. So he wrote himself a "package manager" that could fetch binaries, place header files correctly and add them to his build. Neat little project. That's basically what this guy did. It reads a YAML file and exec() whatever build instruction is in there. The CS102 guy I hired could do it as well. Keivan was brought in by Microsoft for an interview and he didn't get the job. He kept talking about how "he could have patented this" or how it was an "acquihire" but there's nothing new to acquire in there! I mean it's not like he invented package management (NuGet, Chocolatey, Scoop all predate his attempt). But hey, he flunked his interview and got a lot of eyes on his startup thanks to some well placed clickbait on HN...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bobthebuilders 5y agoWow, I didn't know Microsoft was that shady. The original story was bad enoguh, but this makes it even worse. So they took the time to get ideas out of him and do the exact same thing he did, when a CS 102 guy could do the same thing when YAML files and exec... wow. I have no other words.
- 5y ago
- rvz 5y agoIt has been admitted. This is what an 'extinguish' looks like after embracing the idea of a Windows package manager by interviewing the creator of AppGet [0][1] and then dumping him to skip the extend part to full on copy it [2] with little to no credit and bundling it in the OS. This is a rare straight extinguish after an embrace, especially in open source. [0] https://keivan.io/the-day-appget-died/ https://keivan.io/the-day-appget-died/ [1] https://appget.net/ https://appget.net/ [2] https://www.theverge.com/2020/5/28/21272964/microsoft-winget-windows-package-manager-appget-copied https://www.theverge.com/2020/5/28/21272964/microsoft-winget...
- nodejs_rulez_1 5y agoExtinguishing something that has a zero competitive threat? Now that would be evil! I think open-source community needs to decide whether their stuff comes with strings attached or not and use appropriate licences.
- bombcar 5y agoThe "unwritten" rules around open source code/licenses is getting out of control. It's understandable, however, but people really need to decide if their code is "fully open source" and anyone can snap it up and fork it, or if there are other strings attached.
- rbanffy 5y agoThere are people that license software under MIT or BSD licenses that gets upset when someone else runs with it or makes it proprietary. If you don’t want someone else to just dump you and run with your code without upstreaming contributions, you should at least use GPL. It won’t prevent them from forking it and never giving back, but at least you can take their contributions and merge them back into your own.
- bombcar 5y agoYeah, I feel there are many people who license as "MIT/BSD but please pretend it's LGPL/GPL3" - they want maximum adoption BUT ALSO want to remain in control and have code contributed back. To be fair, even the FSF has done the "take the ball and try to go home" with the GPL3 in some ways - not liking aspects of what they previously allowed.
- stinos 5y agoHas anyone used this already, and how does it compare to OneGet with the ChocolateyGet provider?
- Shadonototra 5y agoit's a native program, it is MUCH FASTER and lightweight chocolatey is a powershell script, whenever you run it it needs to initialize dotnet and the JIT needs to do its work one downside: i should be included in windows, and not having to install from the store, like wtf did they smoke?
- chokolad 5y ago> i should be included in windows, and not having to install from the store, like wtf did they smoke? It is included in Windows 11
- smhenderson 5y agoThen it should be easy enough for them to install it to Windows 10 on the next Feature Update. If they can stick a News toolbar on my taskbar with an update than surely something as important and useful as this can be added as well.
- nightski 5y agoIt is available on Windows 10 and takes less than a minute to install. The next feature update is Windows 11. I don't believe you should expect new features in 10 anymore, that wouldn't make much sense.
- WorldMaker 5y agoThere is still a 21H2 update for Windows 10. (It's a strange confusion that seems like it should have been avoidable that 10 and 11 will both have [different] 21H2 versions.) Also, winget is slowly getting installed automatically on Windows 10 (all the way back to the Anniversary Update if machines are still running 1607 for some reason but also still getting Microsoft/Windows Store updates, to my understanding).
- _8j50 5y agoI cannot stress how much I do not want a package manager on windows. If it is like chocolatey (optional) I am ok with it, but if it turns out to be like Linux where you install from repos and then you add multiple repos and then you have dependency resolution issues because that's what the package and version needs and the upstream and down stream devs need to sort it out and... ugh that is one part of Linux I hate with passion. I mean it works ok on Linux given who is using it but on windows it is normal, even a requirement for regular users to install apps (repos too in this case). And without AWL , even if you restrict this, people will install "portable" apps. I like Macos's way best to be honest. Bu this is one practice Windows should not learn from Linux, different audience and requirements. It looks like yet another competition to chocolatey for now.
- bombcar 5y agoPackage managers are wonderful if you stick with what your distribution packages. But once you step outside of that it can get fun real fast. And many things now basically do what Apple does anyway and bundle all libraries, etc with each app - Go does this explicitly I think. Space is cheap.
- Isthatablackgsd 5y ago> Space is cheap. That is subjective. Yes generally the drive storage is cheap. Apple storage in other hands are not cheap at all and charging a premium for it. Looking in MacBook Pro catalog, they are charging $200 for 513 GB SSD to 2 TB for $800. Most of the SSD of that range is in $50 - $150 USD. Drive storage is cheap, Apple storage are not cheap.
- wongarsu 5y agoThe "app repository" is a github repository [1]. I'm not sure how I feel about that. It worked for appget, it's easy to audit, nobody can do any shenanigans without obvious traces. But the UX could be better, for example this is what publishing a new version looks like [2]. I guess we can always build a separate UI. 1: https://github.com/microsoft/winget-pkgs https://github.com/microsoft/winget-pkgs 2: https://github.com/microsoft/winget-pkgs/pull/30035 https://github.com/microsoft/winget-pkgs/pull/30035
- erichurkman 5y agoFWIW this is how Homebrew, the most widely used package manager on macOS, does it. As an example, check out the 'formula' for installing Zoom: https://github.com/Homebrew/homebrew-cask/blob/master/Casks/zoom.rb https://github.com/Homebrew/homebrew-cask/blob/master/Casks/... I used to maintain a few packages and it was pretty dang easy to publish, test, vet, and distribute this way. Everything else is in Git, why not this, too?
- arrakeen 5y agothose PRs are appalling.. bots talking to each other, commenting to run bot commands, bots adding and immediately removing labels. as if the github PR user experience weren't bad enough
- sseagull 5y agoBlast from the past: Around 2004 I made a package manager for windows with that same name. I had a prototype, but I quickly got in over my head, since I wasn’t the greatest programmer at the time, and was in college for something other than programming :) It was written in awful C++ and used GTK. I even had the winpackman .com/.org domains ! I was so naive back then.
- HeckFeck 5y agoDon't feel ashamed for thinking big. I'm sure it helped propel you into things you never expected =)
- KayL 5y agoDoes the repo block installer to sideload ad-like software?
- rbanffy 5y agoIt seems the manifest file requires an installer. This is pretty much why package managers in other platforms are cool - they install the programs, solve dependencies, and so on.
- TillE 5y agoIt's probably a lot easier to make a useful product when you work with what's already out there rather than asking thousands of other developers to make new packages, or doing all the work yourself and only having open source software. Anyway, Microsoft already has their own package format with MSI, which is not particularly elegant, but it's a reason to avoid reinventing the wheel.
- wongarsu 5y agoAnd Microsoft already tried making a better package format (msix) for their other centralized package manager (Microsoft Store), complete with sandboxing and everything. It wasn't exactly a roaring success.
- rbanffy 5y agoMicrosoft's power to dictate what developers should do and how is curiously small considering their market share in the personal computer market. Apple, OTOH, has no issues deprecating functionality when they consider removing it (and disabling applications that rely on it) is beneficial to their ecosystem.
- renata 5y agoIsn't Microsoft's backward-compatibility widely considered a reason for their overwhelming share of the PC market? You get more developers and more useful programs when people don't have to rewrite them for the new hotness every year.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- em3rgent0rdr 5y agodoes this use vcpkg at all?
- zulrah 5y agoWow, I've just tried it and it's really good. As mentioned in the article, I already had winget in my PC. So I was able to use winget upgrade and it listed all the apps that I can upgrade(None of them were installed using winget but it still worked). It's a huge improvement over downloading new version of VLC from their website for example.In total it upgraded 10 applications. The only annoying thing was that it still had to open GUI installers for updating applications. I'm also not sure how does it handle applications that are currently open during the update
- Tarucho 5y agoA rainbow progress bar? Were the usability engineers on vacation at the time of development?