7 ms·
Financial Secrecy Index
- eutropia 5y agoI clicked on the US and see that it gets loads of secrecy points in all kinds of categories, but 0 points from the category of "Consistent Personal Income Tax". I laughed.
- throwaway6EQUJ5 5y agoI skimmed through the PDF about germany and found this interesting bit >This [federal competition] has repeatedly served as an excuse to engage in ruinous intra-German ‘tax wars’ for lax enforcement, auditing and the hiring and staffing of local tax authorities.6 which i never heard of. So i check the source and got got redirected to just an image. >http://www.taxjustice.net/topics/race-to-the-bottom/tax-wars/ http://www.taxjustice.net/topics/race-to-the-bottom/tax-wars... Some of the listed sources there (https://fsi.taxjustice.net/PDF/Germany.pdf https://fsi.taxjustice.net/PDF/Germany.pdf) are broken but not all, some do link to actual credible thrid parties.
- fblp 5y agoThanks for sharing! I setup a quarterly donation. This is important work.
- helloworld11 5y agoExcellent ranking for those wishing to have a reasonably well researched list of candidate countries for where they could place their hidden funds and avoid future taxes. Bravo.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ccity88 5y agorealistically you need a decent level of wealth to participate in these tax havens. It's expensive to hire a lawyer who knows this stuff, and even more expensive for administration and execution. The people who have the level of wealth to pay for this are already doing it.
- orlovs 5y agoTotally agree. Schemes exists, but they are unavailable for scmucks. As after 2008 financial crysis it was made much more “exclusive” as it was before. For ordinary folks it transformed. For example, in Europe now is popular zero Corp tax on reinvested money.
- inter_netuser 5y agoApart from the Baltics who is doing that?
- top_sigrid 5y agoWell, researching and listing reality is probably not the problem here.
- bojangleslover 5y agoPrivate wealth has already been taxed unfortunately
- lucideer 5y agoThis is a great starting point, but things like BEPs mean this usually more complex than one country's sole secrecy index.
- echelon 5y agoRussia and China score extremely well, and the US is the second worst? Is it fine when the ruling class can get away with moving money? Who funded this?
- dgivney 5y ago> Russia and China score extremely well, and the US is the second worst? This is a list of countries that benefit from capital flight from countries such as Russia and China. > Who funded this? https://taxjustice.net/our-funders/ https://taxjustice.net/our-funders/
- belval 5y agoPage 18 of https://taxjustice.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Tax-Justice-Network-2019-Annual-Report-Accounts.pdf https://taxjustice.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Tax-Justic... It's basically funded by European grants so it does not seem fishy.
- dgivney 5y agoHonestly, I know nothing about them but the largest donor on that list is a USA based NGO.. $2 million Ford Foundation Grant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Foundation
- ksdale 5y agoYes, the US is so secret we know exactly how much is hidden and where. Meanwhile Russia is so transparent, wealth hoarding oligarchs can't even exist. /s
- adventured 5y agoIt's a pathetic joke. The US has very little real financial secrecy. The Feds have trivial access to all financial transactions inside of the US if they have cause to need to look. Beyond that, the majority of US wealth is contained in the stock market and land, both of which tend to reveal the wealthy due to public records (which is how we know how much land Bill Gates has been accumulating and how many shares of Tesla Elon Musk owns). The US has a small number of unknown super wealthy because of that, whereas China and Russia are extraordinarily opaque by comparison. The US also requires its politicians to report their wealth within a range. Now try to get that kind of information from Putin or Xi.
- _uy6i 5y agoThis is pretty stupid if you ask me, the top of the list is just stable countries with a strong tradition of rule of law.
- ksdale 5y agoHaha I thought the same thing. The more I read it, the more it seemed like a list of countries where there's actually due process, even for the bad guys.
- bjt2n3904 5y agoFinancial secrecy, or financial privacy?
- Tehdasi 5y agoOf course, those are two prime characteristics you want in a tax haven. You want it to have rule of law since you don't want your money/assets/secrets expropriated or exposed, and you don't want a new regime to come in to do the previous for their benefit. Just as long as the haven is concerned about their laws, not other countries laws.
- xmcqdpt2 5y agoMainly it's countries with easily setup legal anonymous LLPs or without directories of ownership, that are economically stable and where there is little political pressure (internal or external) to decrease secrecy. Lack of internal pressure is common when the country strongly benefits from being an offshore secrecy location (Switzerland, Singapore, HK) or when it's not very susceptible to international pressure (US, UK). Whether it's "stupid" or not depends on how much you weigh bank secrecy and privacy against the fight on money laundering, corruption, terrorism financing and sanctions evasion. Either way, the degree of secrecy you get is also usually a lot higher if your assets are not in your home country, which means that bank privacy is much higher for the global rich.
- howmayiannoyyou 5y agoReality check: - US haven status undermines despotic regimes by denying them data on citizens hedging their bets with offshore accounts. This provides the US leverage, intelligence, foreign direct investment & tax revenue. - Offshore dollar pools (eg. Eurodollars) are problem enough for the US Treasury & FED's monetary policy. Absent US haven status this problem would be far worse. - The secrecy doesn't much apply to US citizen and less so once the Democrat's $600 bank account reporting requirement is passed into law.
- melony 5y agoAh, so it's not money laundering when we are the ones doing it.
- kyleee 5y agoThat's not what was said... uncharitable response such as yours is unhelpful
- throwaway472927 5y agoA longer way of saying the same thing might be: The 2nd argument is a benefit only to the US so not relevant to outsiders deciding whether they're "playing fair". Arguably this applies to the first as well, or at best only US allies. And the third... Again kind of self interest - one rule for your own citizens and another for everyone else's. IMO there are two ways to view this: the US acts in its own interests, everyone else does too, fine. It's only hypocritical if the US expects a higher standard from others, "rules based international order" etc, but seeks to exempt itself - edit: in which case the world just sticks with the previous view, which, hey, every other species does too.
- billiam 5y agoEither erroneous conclusion or made in bad faith. The despotic regimes (like Jordan, Russia, Kenya, and many others) are some of the biggest launderers, according to the Pandora Papers! These regimes are propped up by the United States trust law race to the bottom, not undermined by it. It's an internationalized criminal enterprise.
- trident5000 5y agoMore like a map of where oppressive regimes want total control over your finances.
- cookiengineer 5y agoHonestly this index seems flawed. Where's Monaco, Malta, or Liechtenstein? When we speak of finances, these countries are the top of the top and literally where politicians from all over the world hide their money.
- sellyme 5y ago#109, #18, and #52 respectively. The website provides extremely extensive breakdowns of the exact index contributors for each country, presumably those will illuminate why the rankings are what they are.
- Uberphallus 5y agoMonaco is impractical for most tax evasion purposes, since most advantages require to be resident. If you're not resident, Monegasque banks will send your financial information to the country where you're resident. Malta, Liechtenstein, or most "classic" European havens are largely the same: within the EEA your residence country will have all the bank information about you. They sure have advantageous tax rates to promote certain types of residency/investment, but the financial secrecy isn't really there, which is what this index is about.
- TacticalCoder 5y agoI honestly don't know how to read it: does this mean that the Cayman Island, ranked 1st, are the most secretive or the less secretive in the world? (according to this ranking)
- Proven 5y agoIt's best for financial privacy. Good for them. And equally so for anyone who escapes globalist & socialist busybodies like AOC and takes their money to a safe place.
- young_unixer 5y agoAnd at rank 0: Monero.
- Proven 5y agoThat site is bullshit. Tax justice my ass. Globalist thugs. Is there such a thing as Literal Secrecy? You know, when you share personal info with a provider and they aren't supposed to leak it? No, that's called privacy. I live in one of the high ranked countries and I think the more financial privacy is available, the better. That's how it's supposed to be and if someone oppressed (financially or otherwise) from abroad uses local services to escape that oppression, good for them. If you have a high tax or reckless spending problem that makes your people take their money out of YOUR country, spend less.
- dveeden2 5y agoNPR did a podcast where they setup a shell company and where they look into the top countries for this. https://www.npr.org/2021/10/06/1043746410/we-set-up-an-offshore-company-in-a-tax-haven-classic https://www.npr.org/2021/10/06/1043746410/we-set-up-an-offsh...