9 ms·
I’m willing to read these articles, and even sort of willing to consider other viewpoints, but this is mostly garbage. What stands out is the authors’ favor of
by Aeolun 5y ago
I’m willing to read these articles, and even sort of willing to consider other viewpoints, but this is mostly garbage.
What stands out is the authors’ favor of natural immunity being better than vaccination.
It may well be, but it has this small caveat that you need to have had the virus to become naturally immune. E.g. you need to take that 1-2% of not surviving entirely, and if too many people take that chance at the same time, even higher.
- CodeWriter23 5y agoOnly one problem with your 1-2% risk calculation. In the US at least 100M people have survived infection. Subsidized vaccination of these people amounts to nothing more than payola on a massive scale.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoWe actually don't know how many of these people have a current immunity, for several reasons, starting with when the infection happened and not ending with knowing who had what strain of the virus. It's also not clear every one of the 100M people would be able to reliable prove he had Covid-19. Or that it is possible to prevent people from somehow faking that proof. We do know that a vaccination after recovery results in even better immunity than natural immunity alone. So it's much cheaper to just vaccinate them and KNOW they are immune, rather than indulge in a massive bureaucratic nightmare about test results...
- CodeWriter23 5y agoStraw man argument detected: if one has to show a pass to get in somewhere, the bureaucratic load for assigning an “approved” status is equivalent whether is a test result or a proof of being jabbed.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoNope, there are three vaccines, and (in the US) only one kind of document that proves vaccination with them. On the other hand, you'd either have to prove positive infection and recovery (with multiple test results) to someone (whom?) or to standardize some kind of antibody testing which also has to take place soon after the infection, because those antibodies don't last very long. The immunity might last longer, but the kind of antibodies that are modestly easy to detect, don't. But because of the nature of those kinds of tests, every single lab would need to be certified individually and there would need to be another step to actually issue some kind of certificate. So yes, to me it sounds massively more complicated and expensive than just getting two harmless vaccinations.
- belter 5y agoNatural immunity is better, but politically the CDC cannot accept it. "Covid Confusion at the CDC" https://www.wsj.com/articles/covid-19-coronavirus-breakthrough-vaccine-natural-immunity-cdc-fauci-biden-failure-11631548306 https://www.wsj.com/articles/covid-19-coronavirus-breakthrou... "...The CDC’s failure to report meaningful data has left policy makers flying blind. In the absence of good data to answer the basic questions Americans have been asking, political opinions have filled the vacuum. Strong data might have prevented much of the polarization over Covid. Sound data from the CDC has been especially lacking on natural immunity from prior Covid infection. On Aug. 25, Israel published the most powerful and scientifically rigorous study on the subject to date. In a sample of more than 700,000 people, natural immunity was 27 times more effective than vaccinated immunity in preventing symptomatic infections..." "...Despite this evidence, U.S. public health officials continue to dismiss natural immunity, insisting that those who have recovered from Covid must still get the vaccine. Policy makers and public health leaders, and the media voices that parrot them, are inexplicably sticking to their original hypothesis that natural immunity is fleeting, even as at least 15 studies show it lasts..." "...The CDC did put out a study on natural immunity last month, forcefully concluding that vaccinated immunity was 2.3 times better than natural immunity. The CDC used these results to justify telling those with natural immunity to get vaccinated. But the rate of infection in each group was less than 0.01%, meaning infections were exceedingly rare in the short two-month time period the agency chose to study. This is odd, given there are more than a year of data available. Moreover, despite having data on all 50 states, the CDC only reported data from Kentucky. Was Kentucky the only state that produced the desired result? Why else exclude the same data from the other 49 states? Some public health officials are afraid to acknowledge natural immunity because they fear some will choose infection over vaccination. But leaders can encourage all Americans who aren’t immune to get vaccinated and be transparent with the data at the same time..." "Comparing SARS-CoV-2 natural immunity to vaccine-induced immunity: reinfections versus breakthrough infections" https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.24.21262415v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.24.21262415v... ------------------------- Conclusions: "This study demonstrated that natural immunity confers longer lasting and stronger protection against infection, symptomatic disease and hospitalization caused by the Delta variant of SARS-CoV-2, compared to the BNT162b2 two-dose vaccine-induced immunity. Individuals who were both previously infected with SARS-CoV-2 and given a single dose of the vaccine gained additional protection against the Delta variant." -------------------------
- ifyoubuildit 5y agoA lot of people already have had the virus though. From the article: > During lockdowns, essential and frontline workers bore the brunt of COVID-19 cases while affluent professionals stayed home, teleworked, and ordered delivery. These workers were once called “heroes.” Now the Zoom class labels the same workers “anti-vaxxers” if they prefer to rely on the natural immunity many of them have already acquired from previous infections.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoGetting vaccinated after successful recovery even improves immunity against Covid-19 reinfection. So there is a medical benefit in vaccinating the recovered. Also, it is extremely hard to scientifically and politically account for recovery as proof of vaccination. In some European countries, it sort of works, when you have good standards on how exactly to determine and track infection and recovery. Even then there are tradeoffs, because the immunity after vaccination is much better studied and much more predictable.
- protomyth 5y agoNo one is advocating for people to get infected, but many front line workers have already had COVID while they were doing their hero work. Since studies are now showing they have better immunity than those who have received a vaccination, it is foolish to have them vaccinate. If you've had Measles, you aren't required to get a vaccination, so there is a well established precedent. The politicalization of the vaccine is foolish and unscientific.
- paulcole 5y agoIsn’t it just easier (and with virtually no risk) to require people to vaccinate rather than debate over who did/did not actually have COVID?
- protomyth 5y agoThere is always a risk with vaccination as with any medication. It's small, but why take it? Taking a vaccine to make other people feel better is emotional and not scientific. There is no debate, there are blood tests. The same logic has been applied to measles.
- sokoloff 5y agoWell, there’s a risk with the blood draw as well. It’s also small.
- protomyth 5y agoThat's not even in the same realm.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoPretty much. There are some indications that myocarditis, the most serious, but very rare and even more rarely fatal complication of the mRNA vaccines, is caused by accidental intravenous injection of the vaccine.
- travisparker 5y agoThat “1-2%” is FAR too high of an estimate. Although regional numbers vary of course, in my state the death rate by county has averaged between 0.0004 and 0.0032 percent. Or, in decimal notation, 0.000004-0.000032 These numbers were calculated based on the Covid data repository maintained by the New York Times (https://github.com/nytimes/covid-19-data https://github.com/nytimes/covid-19-data) and US Census data (http://www.census.gov/ http://www.census.gov/).
- generj 5y agoSomething is horribly wrong with your math. 0.000004 * 320,000,000 = 1,280 deaths for the entire USA. Your higher estimate yields 10,240 deaths. In reality we’ve had at least 700,000 deaths. For those who are infected, the naive Case Fatality Rate is about 1-2%. See for example, https://ourworldindata.org/mortality-risk-covid https://ourworldindata.org/mortality-risk-covid There are reasons to suspect the real rate is lower in several countries - many places under test cases, so the denominator in deaths/cases is too small. Additionally, this rate isn’t static - we were seeing upwards of 10% death rates before effective treatments became known and available.
- pjc50 5y agoDeath rate of people who got covid, not of everyone. Show your working ..
- bayesian_horse 5y agoWith this virus, especially the Delta variant, you can pretty much assume at least 80% of the population to get infected if there hadn't been all these measures. Also not necessarily in the first or second wave...
- lebuffon 5y agoThis whole area might fall into the Sam Clemens quote: "There are lies, damned lies and statistics" Since 30 to 40 percent of humans experience no illness with this thing the denominator can be quite different depending on what you use for it. Notwithstanding that... John's Hopkins Website https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/dashboards/bda7594740fd40299423467b48e9ecf6 https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/dashboards/bda759474... USA Total Cases Total Deaths 44,318,179 712,975 1.6% This is with oxygen support and whatever treatments have been used. In Mexico where health care seems harder to access Total Cases Total Deaths 3,720,545 281,958 ~7.6% So IF you get sick and you don't have modern medicine it's a serious disease. IF you are one of the lucky 30..40% it's a piece of cake. Flip a coin.
- jjtheblunt 5y ago> you need to have had the virus to become naturally immune According to oft cited data early on, many people were naturally resistant (perhaps not immune) from similarly packaged (viral envelope) coronaviruses with less dangerous infections, including a 2019-2020 season variant of the common cold. I don't see those articles anymore. It was also supported by data (and cited by clinicians including at the Mayo Clinic) that folks with current MMR vaccinations and the tuberculosis vaccination given in India tended to test as resistant. Anyway, just data points from real medical data at a research institute of international reknown not cited...
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoCouldn't agree more. It's so frustrating to have topics worthy of debate come up with a shit article where the author tries to cloak his transparent bias in "false righteous rationality". Just look at the first paragraph: > he stated that these measures were necessary to “protect vaccinated workers from unvaccinated co-workers.” But isn’t the vaccine itself supposed to be what protects the vaccinated? Not well enough, apparently. So whose interests are served by mandating a leaky vaccine that prevents neither infection nor transmission of a disease that is chiefly dangerous to people over 75 or with serious preexisting medical conditions? Any competent scientist could easily explain that even with an extremely effective vaccine (which Pfizer and Moderna are, at least in relation to virtually any other vaccine, not the "leaky vaccine" he wants to imply), risk will still be high if there is widespread community transmission. This is not a difficult concept to understand, it's simply basic math with any vaccine that has less than 100% effectiveness (i.e. all of them). Besides, I've always interpreted more of "protect the vaccinated from the unvaccinated" is that our ICUs we're very recently filled to capacity overwhelmingly due to unvaccinated people getting sick, and that has serious negative consequences on everyone.
- nradov 5y agoThe CDC estimated the overall US infection fatality rate at 0.6%, not 1-2%. But I would still encourage everyone to get vaccinated if they can. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burden.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burd...
- JKCalhoun 5y ago> If we fail to resist this establishment now, the harms caused by a medicalized “show your papers” regime will far exceed the threat posed by the virus itself. Author lost me there, I'm afraid.
- rowinofwin 5y agoOn top of that, the evidence is strongly suggesting that natural immunity is actually worse than vaccine immunity. COVID seems to mess with the immune system in a significant way and in doing so makes natural immunity a little shoddy. The vaccines give something that doesn't mess with the immune system, just provides it with the right target. This means the immune system is able to actually learn how to fight covid without fighting and being hurt by covid. Seems like a simple distinction that anyone who "does their own research" should be able to understand but alas, morons.