6 ms·
America’s unemployed are sending a message: Safety and compensation matter
- newaccount2021 5y agoI think its more basic: 1. the restaurant they used to work at isn't there anymore 2. they moved back in with the parents and stopped giving a shit about the future 3. still living off their unemployment and stimulus...it will go to zero one day, but not today 4. even with a substantial raise, most jobs they qualify for will still leave them impoverished, so whats the point America's unemployed need deflation more than they need a raise. A 50% drop in housing costs will serve them better than a 15% raise. The number of Americans who would benefit from a substantial deflation rises every day.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throaway46546 5y agoUnemployment was already cut off on 9/4. There are no more stimulus checks that I am aware of.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoI have another thesis. Take a sample of all the last few major economic crisis. For example the 2008 credit crisis. Check if available jobs persisted open, 18+ months subsequent to crisis. If they didnt, then something is different in this crisis vis a vis all prior crisis. Take a look at confounding factors. What do you see? -Huge subsidy of unemployment via federal checks and unemployment expansions. Pay matters, but pay does not exist in a vaccum. Work pay is assessed relative to other pay, including pay to not work.
- gizmo686 5y agoWe are not past the crisis. Unlike most financial crises, the underlying crisis is still ongoing 18+ months pasts the start
- fallingknife 5y agoIsn't COVID unemployment all over now, though?
- ComputerGuru 5y agoIt depends on state. Red States happen to have recovered better. https://wallethub.com/edu/states-covid-recovery/90947 https://wallethub.com/edu/states-covid-recovery/90947
- newhotelowner 5y agoIt seems like red state like Texas, Atlanta are doing worse. Small/low population red states recovered faster. A lot of blue states - big & small seems recovered faster, except California. California recovered better than Florida. But all other reports shows California economy did better than most states in 2020. In fact, overall it seems that higher vaccinated states recovered faster.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dharmaturtle 5y agoTo be clear: this site defines "recovery" by combining COVID and economic factors - equally weighted. If we look solely at COVID transmission rate, that's a somewhat different picture: https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#cases_casesper100klast7days https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#cases_casesper100k...
- ComputerGuru 5y agoGood catch. Actually, we were talking only about economic recovery. NYTimes had a great writeup on the uneven recovery of the employment sector but I can't find it.
- dharmaturtle 5y agoFair. I was mildly triggered when scanning this thread, so thought I'd make the metric clear to anyone else. Back on topic, if you sort by Leasure/Travel or Economy/Labor, it is pretty clear that red states have the lead.
- mjevans 5y ago[flagged]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pavlov 5y ago> “something is different in this crisis vis a vis all prior crisis” How about that, during this crisis, workers risked catching a deadly disease? Many have seen relatives and friends die. The financial crisis didn’t make going to work potentially deadly. Covid-19 did.
- pessimizer 5y agoThis is a bizarre take. The recovery from 2008 was the slowest recovery in US history (marketed as the longest period of growth in US history), and it probably permanently damaged the size of the workforce. Prime age employment was down IIRC 10% for years.
- dantheman 5y agoI think expecting to get back to 2008 as recovery is misguided. The bubble of 2008 wasn't real growth, it was a bubble.
- thephyber 5y agoI never understood the expectation that the upswing from every debt cycle can be equally fast compared to the last wave. Doesn’t this assume that all economic conditions pre/post 2008 are the same? Financial products and regulation changed. Cloud, gig apps, smartphone apps, social media all changed the work landscape right around 2008.
- steanne 5y agothen the states that cut off the extra unemployment early would have seen greater job growth then the states that kept it up. they didn't. https://www.wsj.com/articles/states-that-cut-unemployment-benefits-saw-limited-impact-on-job-growth-11630488601 https://www.wsj.com/articles/states-that-cut-unemployment-be...
- imtringued 5y agoPeople love talking about how government spending causes an artificial boom. In my opinion it just increases flexibility in the debt market by giving unemployed people access to government debt via unemployment benefits. Of course, it's still a band aid and we should figure out other ways like sharing work by making the hours per week one can work flexible according to what happens in the economy. The fact that entire people end up unemployed and then need to be bailed out by the state is just grossly inefficient compared to e.g. firing 50% of their work hours. I say this because every human contributes a baseline of demand for things like housing and groceries. Firing workers also fires the consumer that demands housing and groceries which leads to a downward spiral that is much worse than just the inefficient production of goods and services that nobody wants.
- kleinsch 5y agoThe unemployment expansion ended July 31. Yes, it’s relevant, but the article is about this month, not two months ago.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zeckalpha 5y agoThere was a series of stimulus from 2008-2011.
- 0des 5y agoAn otherwise insightful (but somewhat crass) comment seems to have been immediately [dead] upon being posted, but I think they might be on to something. Readers: I hope you don't mind me momentarily intervening in the voting process, but I will post the comment below for others who may not have show-dead turned on to see. EDIT: Even more curious, the majority of this accounts otherwise normal posts seem to be [dead] as well. Is this a result of HN shadowban, or is this outside influence by a very motivated dissenter? Curious what I've stumbled upon here, as there are quite a number of accounts like this I'm noticing lately. https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=newaccount2021 https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=newaccount2021 https://imgur.com/1CUqXja.png https://imgur.com/1CUqXja.png 0 minutes, dead. ---- newaccount2021 [dead] [–] I think its more basic: 1. the restaurant they used to work at isn't there anymore 2. they moved back in with the parents and stopped giving a shit about the future 3. still living off their unemployment and stimulus...it will go to zero one day, but not today 4. even with a substantial raise, most jobs they qualify for will still leave them impoverished, so whats the point America's unemployed need deflation more than they need a raise. A 50% drop in housing costs will serve them better than a 15% raise. The number of Americans who would benefit from a substantial deflation rises every day.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoVery similar to the "Lying flat [Tang ping]" movement in China [1] [2] [3]. [1] https://www.brookings.edu/techstream/the-lying-flat-movement-standing-in-the-way-of-chinas-innovation-drive/ https://www.brookings.edu/techstream/the-lying-flat-movement... [2] https://www.sixthtone.com/news/1007589/tired-of-running-in-place%2C-young-chinese-lie-down https://www.sixthtone.com/news/1007589/tired-of-running-in-p... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tang_ping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tang_ping
- indymike 5y ago> A 50% drop in housing costs will serve them better than a 15% raise. The number of Americans who would benefit from a substantial deflation rises every day. Except servicing existing debt would become nearly impossible as wages went down, but that pesky car payment stayed at $500/mo.
- nostromo 5y agoChildcare will continue to be a problem for the foreseeable future. The cost will keep parents, mostly women, out of the workforce. Childcare used to be cheap, but overregulation at the state and local level have made it extremely expensive. For example, extreme caregiver to child ratio regulations really drive up costs. On top of that you need a lawyer and a pile of permits just to open up a daycare center in several states now. Childcare could be a good job for lots of low-skill people, and could free up parents to re-enter the workforce. Instead I imagine we’ll take the easy way out like we always do: print money and give it to parents and caregivers, which will not solve the problem and will just drive up childcare costs further.
- 01100011 5y agoHow many of the unemployed have kids? Seems like something we should have data for.
- golemiprague 5y agoWe should rethink the value of women in the workforce, sometimes I get the feeling that a housewife contribute to the economy much more than most women in the workforce. An average housewife who actually do the housework can do a lot of things in parallel, she can cook, clean, take care of children, help with school work, gardening, laundry and taking care of older family members. If you think about the amount of outsourcing one need to do in order to get all those jobs done it comes up to a cost which is much higher than the average woman contribution in the workforce. Taking into account that women almost don't create new businesses and therefore hardly create any new jobs, that a good chunk of them work in tax payer financed governmental jobs which their sole purpose is to replace the housewife, all those types of caregiver jobs for example, and that even in the private sector a lot of them do secretarial jobs with fancy names (I am looking at you "HR officer for diversity and inclusion"), it is safe to say that we need to look again at the role of the housewife in our society. Granted, it is an individual decision of each woman but I think society and culture should encourage women, especially with young children, to stay at home and be housewife. In parallel we should encourage different time line for men and women in terms of entering the job market and when to study. Women are best suitable to bring children to the world in certain ages, we should give them an opportunity to study during their child bearing days, namely their 20s and accept that they will enter the workforce in later ages when their kids are older and don't need so much care. A woman in their mid 30' still got about 30 years to work and can develop a serious career without the pressure of balancing home and work.
- gregimba 5y agoI think the overall workforce participation rate paints the reality much better than unemployment numbers. The drop was the sharpest in the entire dataset going back to 1950 and while a portion of jobs have returned the possibility we may not see workforce participation return to pre COVID levels within the next 2-3 years is a definite possibility. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CIVPART https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CIVPART Edit: St. Louis Fed quote from article on unemployment > For perspective, in June, we were short by about 7.1 million jobs compared with the pre-pandemic level. This analysis suggests that this gap will only close about half by June 2022. https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2021/october/labor-force-exits-covid19 https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2021/october/labor...
- advael 5y agoCame here to say this. Unemployment numbers are such a joke of a statistic in a situation where unprecedented numbers of young adults left the workforce entirely in two subsequent recessions and we just don't count them
- frankbreetz 5y agoI don't think it's a joke, basically all statistics are useless in isolation. While it's true unemployment doesn't paint the whole picture, I see a declining labor participation rate as mostly a good thing. It implies families with one working parent, people living longing in retirement and more people going to school. If we tried to maximize for labor participation rate like we do unemployment rate, it would be a very depressing society.
- advael 5y agoSure, but we're not just cutting out those desirable cases from how unemployment is reckoned. Unemployment as counted is tied to the system that doles out unemployment payments, and thus comes along with all the quirks of legislation that have been added to most American welfare programs to try to discourage people from using the service. Having personally dealt with the unemployment system, I know for a fact that without a ton of legwork, it's really easy to slip through the cracks and get classified out of the category. Were I not a relatively well-off developer with savings to live off in the interim, it would have been difficult for me to do that legwork, so my confidence that the system as implemented isn't knocking a lot of people out of the pipeline (and thus also the statistics) to avoid paying them is quite low. Also, it definitely is not counting the well-documented swaths of people who, in the post-2008 economy, just continue to effectively live as dependents of their parents into adulthood. I'm skeptical that trying to minimize unemployment, let alone maximize labor force participation, is a good thing for the government to devote resources to do. Optimizers tend to take shortcuts that don't accomplish the real desired goal and have seriously undesirable side-effects, and we see that play out in the unemployment situation as well as others, like standardized tests in schooling, when the government tries to be one. However, even in basic fact-reporting, I think the unemployment statistic is a joke. It's been so overtuned to functioning as a means-testing mechanism for a welfare program that it doesn't actually give anyone not interested in that very useful information
- newhotelowner 5y agoLets break it down who is missing from employment. - Almost million died due to Covid. - A lot of olders or those who can retire, left the workforce - Some took flexible jobs - like uber/lift or food delivery or groceries or amazon delivery - Legal immigration is closed for year and half. That is almost 2 million working individuals - Few people that I know who got covid, and are in 40s & 50s don't feel that they are recovered 100%. After 10 months, my manager can't smell as she used to. - People like my wife who don't need to work are staying home. I am sure there are few other groups that I don't know about. That is a lot of people missing from the workforce and won't show up in unemployment data.
- nradov 5y agoThe vast majority of COVID-19 deaths were in the 65+ age group. They were mostly not employed and their deaths, while tragic, didn't significantly reduce the labor pool. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burden.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burd...
- Ekaros 5y agoOne could even argue that many of the deaths lessened the demand for things like geriatric care. Thus it could theoretically even increase labour pool.
- TexanFeller 5y agoI’m very annoyed that they mention safety so prominently. With miraculous vaccines available to all ages at significant risk, and data showing those vaccines continue to be effective at preventing bad outcomes from Delta, I just don’t think safety is an issue anymore except for exceptional cases like the immunocompromised.