13 ms·
Google’s apps to embrace iOS on iOS
- jb1991 5y agoGood. Whether it’s on a device or on the web, I find material design to be a terrible aesthetic. Any kind of flat design in general is often very difficult to understand, the UI components blend in with things that are not interact-able.
- whalesalad 5y agoI feel the exact same way. Google's design sense in general is terrible. YouTube is a UX nightmare. Gmail and Maps are probably the only two half-decent products but they're both becoming very heavy and bloated these days.
- potatoman22 5y agoI'd argue that YouTube has a better UX than a large majority of sites on the internet. If it was actually terrible, no one would use it.
- whalesalad 5y agoThey have a monopoly. What other video sharing site is even remotely on the same traffic level (not including social networks like fb)
- fabiospampinato 5y agoWhich non-flat design language do you like most?
- unicornporn 5y agoWindows 95, the pinacle of UI design. Honorable mentions: Gnome 2 with Clearlooks or Mac OS 9. On the modern side, SerenityOS is going the right way.
- gsich 5y agoWindows up until the downfall starting with Windows 8.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoOS X circa 10.6 – 10.9. Aesthetically pleasing, with lots of tonal contrast and touches of color to highlight important items. Clickable elements are clearly clickable, and the UI is reasonably dense, but it never looks overcomplicated or busy.
- drevil-v2 5y agoIt is the copious amounts of whitespace that I find so very offensive in Material UI. My secret guilty pleasure at work is shooting down any mention of using Material UI design in any of our software haha.. it is just silly how much pleasure I get from it :)
- cout 5y agoLarge amounts of whitespace became vogue around the same time as skinny scrollbars. I don't mind the whitespace -- it makes it easier to see how things are grouped on the screen. But give me back usable scrollbars on non-touch devices, please! As I age I find it harder and harder to see and click on small things, so these newfangled design languages that make UI elements smaller feel very unaccessible.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoMaybe I'm just nostalgic but I preferred dense UIs of the 90s. At least those which didn't have too much empty space, and communicated grouping with boring stuff like fieldset. Now it seems I must scroll forever and there are no discernible anchors to link to. When studying web design in the early aughts the popular Nielson book ("Designing Web Usability") argued for separate pages over a lot of scrolling. For informational sites I think that approach is superior.
- vbezhenar 5y agoIMO the best approach is some kind of amalgamation between scrolling and paging. For example infinite scrolling, but with clear separation between pages and with URL changing to the corresponding page (so I can bookmark it and return to this page later, for example). Infinite scroll as a concept is good. If I'm at the bottom of the page, chances are high that I want to get next page anyway, so why don't you show it for me already. If I don't need it, whatever. If I need it, it's there.
- nitrogen 5y agoInfinite scroll as a concept is good. Infinite scrolling doesn't work with scrollbars, and somehow people still think it's okay to put important links in the page footer... on an infinite scrolling site where it's literally impossible to ever reach the page footer.
- grishka 5y agoMaybe it's me being biased as an Android app developer, but I find Material very much okay on Android (but very out of place on desktop for example). At a time when Apple just made everything fully flat and had a kid draw their icons, having actual depth with shadows felt welcome. Though I have to admit, I did like the Holo aesthetic more. And I do miss affordances in UIs, and non-flat UIs, in general.
- cout 5y agoFor me, material design evokes feelings of being in kindergarten making crafts with colored construction paper. Material UIs are not perfectly flat; there is usually a shadow, so I can tell an element is distinct from the layer below it. The problem for me is that it often feels about as organized as the mind of a kindergartener. Consistency of look-and-feel is important, but consistency of organization is even more important. How confusing would GUIs in the 90s have been without the File and Edit menus?
- ink404 5y agoCan you elaborate on what you mean by the organization of material design?
- atatatat 5y agoSo what I'm reading is: there's nothing wrong with Material Design aesthetically, but the design choices commonly made when choosing Material Design are regularly poor. That's fair. Unlabeled hamburger menu buttons and gear icons placed every which area (sometimes multiple!) are great examples of (admittedly common!) abuse of what can be a powerful UI concept.
- richardw 5y agoAnecdote-not-data warning: I gave an Android tablet to a 90-something year old. She got on ok but there were a few frustrations. Stuff would close when it shouldn’t, button here just hard to reason about or get to etc. She asked if it was an iPad, obviously some brand awareness there. Switched to iPad as a bit of a fun surprise, and most issues went away. More stuff was where she thought it would be. (She has a feature phone from 14 years ago so it’s not iPhone preference.) She just turned 101 and you can’t take her iPad away from her. Loves it. We can all get used to whatever. Try it on the edge cases and your opinion might shift because that’s where the differences emerge. I’m holding back a lot of iOS rants here :) Selecting a single word is often many clicks. I’d love to be able to forget individual words that it insists on autocompleting to.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoSure, material design is not perfect. Its just all other design systems for mobile are worse and less consistent. Apple's own UI is very lacking in components and guidelines are mostly absent.
- leroman 5y agoI find that flat design was the answer to having too much emphasis (in my opinion) on design and designers being too involved in the process which (again, in my opinion) collided with the engineering work..
- 1cvmask 5y agoI could never understand the hatred of skeuomorphic design. Material design seemed to me to add an unnecessary overhead to interaction especially with colors bleeding in. I love a strong, and arguably ugly, contrast ratio of 7:1
- varjag 5y agoIt all comes down to the fact that doing a skeuomorphic design is a lot more work than blurting a few colored rectangles.
- DenisM 5y agoIt’s a generational change - much easier to make a career by discarding what came before rather than competing with it. You will see this in a lot of areas of society.
- Oddskar 5y agoIt's funny how a "generation" left Apple and suddenly they're rolling back all kinds of changes to how they were before that generation "made their mark".
- tinus_hn 5y agoIt also gets a lot of emphasis because armchair ui architects think it’s cool to show they know this ‘big word’.
- 5y ago
- kstrauser 5y agoI couldn’t agree more. I can’t stand using Google’s own apps on iOS because they look jarringly out of place to me, like running a Mac app that looks skinned to look like Windows. Obviously not everyone agrees and that’s OK. I acknowledge this is purely a personal preference thing. But for me, I detest Material apps on my phone and iPad.
- vmception 5y agoYeah every time Chrome accidentally opens on iOS I cringe at the shoehorned design choices This probably happens because i clicked a link in gmail
- tonymet 5y agoLet’s hope they adopt iOS performance and responsiveness as well.
- beyondcompute 5y agoGood news!
- jikbd 5y agoI have no doubt Google will not use iOS default GUI components. They will come up with some sort of abomination that superficially looks like the native iOS components but are off in every way when you look closely, like Qt does.
- jamil7 5y agoThey already do that for Flutter with the Cupertino Widgets.
- zaphirplane 5y agoBut … you have to pick widget per OS, not automagically rendered differently by OS
- Leherenn 5y agoI was very surprised and disappointed when I discovered that. It didn't really felt cross platform anymore if for every component you need to do a platform check and render it differently. It sounds like flutter is more about having the same (custom or material) UI on both platforms and not having the framework do the "nativification" for you.
- planb 5y agoDoesn’t sound like this is the case from the linked Twitter thread: „App bars become UINavigationControllers. Standard controls just need light branded touches. Lists can align with modern UITableView and list-based collection view APIs. Menus are just UIMenus.“
- sbaildon 5y agoMy expectations mirror your own, but a few of Jeff's thoughts imply that they won't take this path: > App bars become UINavigationControllers. Standard controls just need light branded touches. Lists can align with modern UITableView and list-based collection view APIs. Menus are just UIMenus. > And the best code is often no code :) > The time we're saving not building custom code is now invested in the long [...]
- domenukk 5y agoWhat about flutter apps?
- mikevm 5y agoI guess they don't think Flutter is a good experience for iOS apps. When you don't eat your own dogfood, why would you expect others to do so?
- dskloet 5y agoWell, eating their own dogfood also means not using an iPhone.
- amelius 5y agoYou can eat two brands of dogfood.
- tgv 5y agoCan you build native iOS apps in Flutter?
- schmorptron 5y agoYes. There's also icon "packs" that mimic the iOS style, and I believe you can use different icons for different builds between android and ios?
- grishka 5y agoI wouldn't call it "native" when you bundle half an OS worth of libraries with your app, including one that draws the UI with OpenGL instead of using system anything.
- smoldesu 5y agoI wouldn't call it "native" when you're running a sandboxed app on top of an immutable base system, but our goalposts tend to change pretty frequently in the arena of consumer electronics.
- aabbcc1241 5y agoNowadays folks like to call "hybrid app" as "native app". The bottomline is "native app" is what allowed to be listed on the "app store".
- martini333 5y agoGoogle Material Design is do bad.
- iakov 5y agoHonest question to HN readers: which Google apps are you using on iOS, and why? I’ve bit the bullet and ditched Google ecosystem last year, moving email to Fastmail, buying an iPhone and the like. The only Google app i still use is Maps - they are vastly superior to everything else, with navigation, public transport schedule (extremely accurate in Prague) and reviews/recommendations built in. Essentially its a three-in-one application with no adequate replacement. I wonder if I am missing something good from Google.
- raydev 5y agoGoogle Maps is still better than Apple Maps overall. There are some nice little features in Apple Maps added in the last few years, but my most recent attempt at using Apple Maps navigation led me to an empty lot.
- nicoburns 5y agoI’m still on Photos. I’d like to move to something else, but I don’t fancy being locked into iCloud.
- wodenokoto 5y agoI still use drive and it’s related apps. There are two things that makes them stand out, ux wise: 1. That round button in the lower right corner that has to be there because it’s material, damn the actual need. 2. If a pane has a horizontal bar, it means that pane is dragable - except of course in Googles apps. Then it’s just there to look at. While Google maps is more accurate with data, I find Apple Maps good enough and nicer to look at. I occasionally go to maps.Google as a backup.
- metagame 5y agoIf you're missing "something good" really depends on what you have a need for. They've offered free SMS for years, which is pretty cool, but niche. You sound like you might like trying Waze, which is also owned by Google. I wouldn't recommend using any of it, though. It's Google, after all. Not as evil as they come, but pretty bad.
- simonh 5y ago
- can16358p 5y agoGood to see they embrace that platform's own conventions instead of forcing their own.
- turbinerneiter 5y agoUI consistency is nice, but the reduced design space is also kinda boring. I guess balancing a unified look while keeping enough freedom for developers to express their ideas is a pretty hard job for the toolkit designers.
- 3grdlurker 5y agoDeveloper here. I can confirm that it’s harder and more time/effort-expensive to build a UI framework or design system or custom component than using existing ones. I absolutely abhor working with designers who think that software design is about the freedom of expression of their personal creativities and tastes instead of the pragmatic, simple execution of fulfilling a business need both for the business and the customers. Design systems should not exist in a silo. Design systems should be consistent across a platform, so if you want to practice your freedom of expression, make your own platform. Or, design a website, where there are hardly any constraints.
- sharmin123 5y agoHacking a WhatsApp account with the help of ethical hacking: https://www.hackerslist.co/hacking-a-whatsapp-account-with-the-help-of-ethical-hacking/ https://www.hackerslist.co/hacking-a-whatsapp-account-with-t...
- fredgrott 5y agomiss-labled, Google is not dropping MDC or MD for that matter. This is an independent shop dropping MD
- kryptiskt 5y ago"Jeff Verkoeyen, staff engineering lead for Google Design on Apple platforms, on Twitter now: This year my team shifted the open source Material components libraries for iOS into maintenance mode… The time we’re saving not building custom code is now invested in the long tail of UX details that really make products feel great on Apple platforms. To paraphrase Lucas Pope, we’re “swimming in a sea of minor things”, and I couldn’t be more excited about this new direction."
- jonathanlydall 5y agoGood riddance, I find Google apps on both my iPhone and AppleTV quite annoying because their use of MD makes them different to use compared to everything else on those platforms. The YouTube tvOS App feels particularly egregious to me, its video playback controls seem to behave nothing like all the other installed tvOS video apps that I use (Netflix, Plex, and AppleTV).
- indymike 5y agoIt's not you. YouTube on Android's previous and next video buttons are where every other video app puts +10 and -10 seconds. When you go to the next video sometimes there is no obvious way back.
- jeroenhd 5y agoI've never had that problem, to be honest. If I recall correctly, Google's next/previous predates the ±10 seconds buttons that have become popular these days. Youtube has the double tap gesture which I actually miss in all other video apps that only have special buttons for it.
- sofixa 5y ago> I felt that Google arrogantly believed that people were first and foremost users of Google’s platforms, and benefited from consistency across those platforms I don't find that arrogant, it's a way of seeing things. It's what I want from apps i use.
- easygenes 5y agoYeah, I am irritated with the inconsistency of the UI of 1Password between MacOS and Windows to the degree now that I'm a couple of free hours away from migrating to Bitwarden.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoAs someone that tried that - it’s not worth it. ;) Also I believe 1Password 8 (in “early access”) right now is much more unified across platforms. I haven’t tried it though.
- macintux 5y agoYes, there was much gnashing and wailing of teeth here when they announced they were abandoning the native experience on Mac.
- foxhill 5y agointeresting. i use it on linux and mac, and presumed it’d be the same in windows, because the app is clearly an electron-based app (and _drinks_ RAM as such). is the windows app native?
- DRW_ 5y agoIt may eventually go that way - but I believe the Linux version was the first electron version. 1Password started out as a (well regarded) native Mac app, that they then developed a native Windows app for. By the time they came around to Linux, they decided on Electron (with a rust backend) - they're now moving the Mac and Windows versions to the Electron versions unfortunately.
- saurik 5y agoI don't actually like Material Design very much, but it isn't as if I like Apple's iOS 7+ "flat" design either (though it has at least gotten better over the years). I think having consistent mechanics is not only useful but "very important", but I also never felt like Google's apps on iOS were particularly "alien": they seem to be using the built-in scroll views (I have a somewhat low tolerance for this, but I honestly am not "super picky" about subtle things that could be different... I have friends who are designers who turn up their noses at a control of weird corner cases that feel like bugs aren't clearly exactly the Apple control, which I think is ridiculously snobby) and their overall layout feels like any other mobile app. I do hate hate hate the Google Docs app, but it isn't because of Material Design: it is because the concept of how the app thinks of editing mode vs. viewing mode is extremely confusing, and I always manage to end up dismissing the very button I need to access the editing mode in my quest to enter the editing mode. (I also often end up adding a comment by accident and my attempts to cancel the comment pass through some workflow where I cancel the cancellation of my comment... I feel like this entire concept of double-cancel is insane.) But they would almost certainly make that app just as difficult to use with any widget set. But the actual design of say, the YouTube app? It is fine. To be clear: I hate it when an app sucks... I am ultra-picky about fine details in products involving the spacing and alignment of widgets, and I find that almost all "bespoke UI" truly pisses me off, as most designers frankly tend to suck at coming up with good components that make sense in context (and then the engineer that builds them tends to fail to push back on them sufficient and you get a cluttered and disorganized mess). But it isn't because I am being snobby about "it has to be an Apple control or I won't accept it": it is because I know a lot of typography (which itself is probably more than a normal user, who wouldn't even care about spacing and alignment!). And seriously: that isn't the YouTube app, nor is it the Google Maps app. And then, at the end of the day, you have to ask whether the vast majority of people with an iPhone are even using Apple's own apps very often. I appreciate some people do; the person reading my comment in anger right now is likely thinking "I DOO!!". But seriously, now: how much time do you think a normal user is using their phone to use Facebook or TikTok or Twitter (which I bet you don't use at all and claim these are horrible apps for horrible people who don't know better, yadda yadda) vs. literally the entire rest of their lives, mess less using the Apple apps? I use Safari (though I wouldn't if I felt I had actual choice... "thanks, Apple" :/), but it doesn't use the standard iOS app bar controls either ;P. Other than that, I still use Messages a lot (though most of my friends gave up on iMessage long ago, and switched to WhatsApp or Facebook Messenger), Notes every few days, and the Phone app once a week or so; I go into the Settings app a lot, I guess, which feels weird, but it is what it is ;P. I used to use Camera a lot, but in addition to also being fully bespoke UI, I don't go outside anymore as all the events I go to are cancelled or virtual :( so I have nothing to take a picture of anymore) I am actually going outside today, but probably not many: I don't actually consider fleet week to sound like an exciting photo op). I use Calendar, which uses normal iOS UI for the editing of stuff but then uses seemingly entirely bespoke UI--that I don't think is very good, BTW--for everything else. And hell: I think "normal" users don't use even the Calendar app, as 1) the only reason I am using shared calendars is because I have a fancy white-collared job, where other people insist on using calendars constantly with meetings they want to remotely manage, and 2) I am one of those rare weirdos (that are over-represented on Hacker News) that prefers to keep all my data locally and so I liked how the Calendar app was only on my phone... most everyone else I know uses Google Calendar, and I bet most non-tech people just go into the App Store to get the Google Calendar app to access it (I know the other fancy white-collared people I work with do this, because they are always confused at how my Apple Calendar renders stuff when I ask them questions, but I still believe fancy white-collared people are weird so this isn't a great data point). But so then, for real: despite being "old" (almost 40) and "out of touch" (I don't ever post because I feel a bit weird doing so) even I use Facebook and TikTok and Twitter (oh and Instagram!) more than all of those Apple apps combined... and none of them seem to think Apple's stupid iOS 7+ navigation bars make any sense and so they all have something more similar to Material Design's app bar. I think this is a good thing; and, even if I didn't, I will claim I would have been unlikely to think about it much as these are the apps I--and I continue to bet most normal people, even way way more so than I--use most.
- kall 5y agoThat‘s great news. I‘m guessing big apps like Maps and Youtube will become a lot nicer while the small ones will be mediocre Flutter versions.
- bullfightonmars 5y agoMaybe youtube will finally get a “back” button on ios!
- CharlesW 5y ago> I‘m guessing big apps like Maps and Youtube will become a lot nicer while the small ones will be mediocre Flutter versions Flutter will undoubtedly adopt (and benefit from) this new UIKit-based Material Design implementation too.
- featherless 5y agoEdited title is a bit sensationalized. Key elements of Material will still be important parts of the design system on iOS; it’s about acknowledging when the platform solution is sufficient for the intended purpose. I’m sure that there will still be gaps that need to be filled, but many don’t need custom solutions anymore :)
- njhaveri 5y agoI think there may be some confusion here. Reading the original tweets from @featherless, I don't see any intent to actually change the end-user design. For example: > This evolution of how we approach design for Apple platforms has enabled us to marry the best of UIKit with the highlights of Google's design language. I'm reading this to say that custom UI components will be replaced with UIKit components that will be customized to have Google's design language. But at a high level, the apps will continue to look the same as they currently do.
- CharlesW 5y ago> I'm reading this to say that custom UI components will be replaced with UIKit components that will be customized to have Google's design language. But at a high level, the apps will continue to look the same as they currently do. Yes, going back to the source Twitter thread I also believe that's the correct conclusion. Jason Snell and Steve Troughton-Smith misinterpreted the deprecation of this Material Design implementation to mean that Google was deprecating the use of the Material Design design language on iOS. In reality, Google is building a new Material Design implementation on UIKit to get better OS integration and a bunch of capabilities (such as accessibility features) "for free".
- kall 5y agoYeah, I don‘t expect a drastic shift, but I would expect some details, like the weird material tap animation, to change for the better. Maybe the youtube app will support all iOS screen sizes with their safe area insets and properly sized toolbars. That‘s the kind of thing that the people who write about apple care about.
- darren_ 5y agoYes, the blogpost (and most of the HN comments here) are completely missing the point. This is just about deprecating a library for implementing material design on iOS, not deprecating the design language itself. It's possible (likely, even) that parts of the design language will become more iOS-y (for example: I would bet that Material 'action sheets' disappear and get replaced with system-default ones on iOS, this has already happened on Chrome for iOS). But the material design language isn't going away.
- Razengan 5y agoFuck Google: • YouTube has deliberately crippled Picture-in-Picture and background audio on iPad/iOS for years, but apparently not on some Android phones. • YouTube has AutoPlay (next video) but no Auto-Repeat. What the fuck? • On iPhone, Google.com has Dark Mode option (without signing in) only when you Request Desktop Website, but viewing the default mobile site has no option Dark Mode. • Google apps try to hijack voice dictation to their own servers instead of using the built-in iOS dictation. • Signing into any Google app will also forcibly sign you into Google Search on Safari. You have to manually delete Google cookies to sign out of Search but remain signed in on the YouTube app, for example. • iOS/iPadOS features like Dark Mode and Split View still not fully supported in some apps. • “SafeSearch” (censorship) cannot be disabled in some countries (at least not without signing in, allowing your search terms to be associated with your account). Really. Why do the biggest companies struggle so much with such basic UX issues? Serious question.
- smoldesu 5y agobecause iOS is considered a second-class citizen compared to native Android devices during development?
- jw1224 5y agoThe YouTube app on Apple TV is absolutely atrocious. I can’t believe either Apple or Google think it’s acceptable — it must be one of the most-used apps on tvOS, and is easily the worst I’ve ever come across. It seems to be built with Cobalt [1], so it’s basically HTML5, pretending to be a native app. A short list of flaws which have infuriated me for months: • Scrolling is completely broken. Scroll down a playlist, and it stops after 10 or so videos, hangs, then loses your scroll position. • When you start watching a video, the UI is almost completely unresponsive for the first 5 seconds exactly. You can exit the video, but the title/channel/details are totally hidden for exactly 5 seconds, for some bizarre reason. • Navigating the app is like wading through molasses, even on the newest Apple TV 4K. It’s so unbearably slow. • Even if your YouTube account is verified, age-restricted videos refuse to play. You’re told to “switch to your primary account” to watch them, but, I’m already in my primary account! • A few times I’ve left the app open on a paused video. 20 minutes later, with the Apple TV screensaver now running, the video randomly starts playing again. YouTube is my primary source of video content — I can’t remember the last time I watched an actual TV show. Many of my friends say the same thing. Come on YouTube, get it together! [1] https://cobalt.foo/ https://cobalt.foo/ (I hate to be “that guy”, but seriously — if Steve Jobs was still around, he wouldn’t have accepted this. There are stories of him calling Google execs because he didn’t like the colour on one of their buttons. Anyway, I digress…)
- Shank 5y agoI’m so glad you mentioned this. Trying to navigate to a channel from a YouTube video you’re watching is significantly impaired by the fact that the default behavior is to scrub rapidly in the video timeline, and you have to provide a very distinct “break away” gesture to navigate from the scrubber to the channel controls. It’s also extremely difficult to like and dislike videos in the app. You have to break away from the scroll bar, then hit a gear and then navigate to the like/dislike button. I’m glad it’s not just me who hates this.
- marcellus23 5y agoMost frustrating thing for me: in every other app, you hide the scrubber UI just by touching the touchpad. In Youtube, just touching does nothing, you have to press Menu/Back. That's bad enough, because I can't rely on muscle memory to hide the scrubber. I need to remember if I'm in YouTube or not, because if I hit Menu in any other app, it'll exit the video. But the scrubber in YouTube also auto-hides after a few seconds. So it's happened a few times that I've reached to press Menu on the remote, and by the time I've done it, the scrubber auto-hid and I just exited out of the video. And of course, it lost my progress. Really amateurish stuff. edit: oh, and video titles get truncated after two lines, but there's no indicator that it's been truncated, no ellipsis, nothing -- and no way to view the full title. So if a title contains critical info, you're SOL.
- swman 5y agoThat’s good for the consumer. Awesome
- occz 5y agoGreat! It was never a sensible choice to use foreign-looking design on iOS. Now, if only every other company in the world would do the inverse and stop using iOS-style design on android, which I consider to be a much more prevalent issue.