4 ms·
I find it eternally confusing how the narrative is "this change is because of climate change" and not "this change is because we are running out of oil". Oil h
by roenxi 5y ago
I find it eternally confusing how the narrative is "this change is because of climate change" and not "this change is because we are running out of oil".
Oil hasn't been consistently cheap since 2003, it is only going to get more expensive. We've consistently been using more of the stuff than gets discovered since the 1980s. There is only one way the story ends.
- eppp 5y agoYou could see the price decline if electric vehicles replaced the ice vehicles fast enough. That, however, seems unlikely to happen.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- roenxi 5y agoI don't have a crystal ball, but if the demand for oil drops I'd expect prices to hold steady or rise. The economies of scale do a lot for big extraction operations.
- onethought 5y agoI’m always blown away by how inefficient drilling, refining, transporting oil is compared to solar panel to battery. Even if you include the energy used to make the battery and panels… it’s a 1-off thing vs an everyday thing.
- coderenegade 5y agoMarkets don't optimize for efficiency, they optimize for cost and scalability. Efficiency is only useful as a proxy for cost, but it isn't strictly true that a more efficient process is cheaper than the less efficient alternative.
- onethought 5y agoMaking solar panels is way easier cheaper and more scalable than drilling oil. Not sure about batteries, but it seems to me given giga factories exist that it is way more scalable than the refinement and delivery process of oil. Put another way: delivering you a car once every 5 years is way more scalable than delivering you energy in the form of oil every week.
- coderenegade 5y agoDrilling for and transporting energy in the form of liquid fuel has been cheaper and more scalable than transporting it in the form of electrons since the industrial revolution. It's part of why we pipe oil and gas across continents: because a pipeline is delivering continental-scale power that a HVDC line just can't compete with, for a number of reasons. Electricity is generally last-mile delivery by comparison. This is changing with cheap solar and higher capacity HVDC lines, but in order to truly compete with fossil fuels, renewables need a scalable storage medium, because a fundamental weakness of electricity is that it has to be consumed when it's generated. Batteries just don't scale to this level, in my opinion. Sure, gigafactories exist, but it doesn't really compete with being able to add hundreds of GWh of storage at a time in the form of salt cavern hydrogen storage, of which the US has more than 330GWh already in operation. They're just different scales.
- onethought 5y agoThat’s really weird comparison to say “it’s been cheaper since new technology didn’t exist”… well of course. I’m not sure where salt cavern hydrogen came from… Batteries 100% scale better than gas, you don’t need gas stations and we already have electricity running across our cities. We have plenty of lithium and it’s recyclable, unlike oil. I’ma but lost at your point to be honest… my whole point was you don’t need to transport energy (plug a big solar panel into a car), to which you responded by saying transporting energy is inefficient???
- coderenegade 5y ago
- elihu 5y agoI think there will be an inflection point in the not too distant future where EVs become cheaper than ICE vehicles, and that will cause an abrupt change in consumer behavior. Major changes seem impossible until they happen, and then afterwards people say "what took us so long?" if they think about it at all. Batteries are the main problem right now; everything else in an EV is pretty simple and cheap. Apparently there are some major patents on lithium iron phosphate batteries that are about to expire; hopefully that means we'll have a lot more production outside of China. LFP batteries don't require cobalt or nickel, so they can be made in higher volume with fewer resource bottlenecks.
- elihu 5y agoThere is a possible future where we mostly stop using oil for transportation, and then prices fall as supply exceeds demand. In the long term we'll eventually run out, but in the medium term, oil may become rather cheap. If we continue to use transportation fuels made from oil, though, prices will likely remain high for the foreseeable future. There are likely to be weird fluctuations, though. (Remember when oil prices went negative a short time ago because there weren't enough containers to store it?)
- spodek 5y agoThe greater, more immediate problem than running out with fossil fuels is that their pollution is killing people and lowering Earth's ability to sustain life. Around ten million people a year die just from breathing air, which is increasing and only one way they're killing us. Plastic is another.
- jacquesm 5y agoHydrogen proponents have - just like nuclear proponents - latched on to climate change as their best bet for increased funding.
- IshKebab 5y ago"latched on"? That was always the point of hydrogen. Have solar power stations "latched on to climate change" too?
- coderenegade 5y agoThe world needs to be able to make fertilizers for industrial agriculture after we run out of fossil fuels. We currently do this using hydrogen split from natural gas in the Haber-Bosch process. In order to decarbonize agriculture, we have no choice but to make hydrogen at a scale large enough that it becomes attractive for a number of other applications such as steel and cement manufacture, shipping, and aviation. Hydrogen is inevitable.
- r3drock 5y agoOil might last a lot longer than you think at first. Even at the proven oil reserves of 2016 the oil would last for 47 years (https://www.worldometers.info/oil/ https://www.worldometers.info/oil/). Additionally, new reserves could be found. Another potentially very large source of oil is coal. You can make oil from coal via the Fischer-Tropsch technology. As there already are considerably more proven coal reserves than oil reserves, this would probably push out the point of "no oil left" a lot further.
- conceptme 5y agoThat is not very long not even one generation.