9 ms·
Firefox: Dark pattern consent dialog invites users to share their location
- jandorn 5y agoDamn, I see more negative news from Firefox than Chrome lately…
- intelMgmntEnema 5y agoA 700+point related post from yesterday that was flagged as a dupe because another with 80 points had been posted previously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28783381 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28783381
- perihelions 5y agoI think it's interestingly different from that other HN thread (and its dupe). This story is about this consent dialog [0] -- particularly the sneaky "not now" in the top corner -- that weren't mentioned at all in the (mozilla.org) article submission. I think most HN'ers aren't even aware of it (or at least I can't find any specific comments about it -- in fact I read multiple comments where I believe HN'ers misunderstood the dark pattern, thinking Firefox had automatically opted them in, when more likely they clicked the wrong option. ("Customize in settings", instead of "Not now")). [0] https://regmedia.co.uk/2021/10/07/suggest.jpg https://regmedia.co.uk/2021/10/07/suggest.jpg
- intelMgmntEnema 5y agoInterestingly different, yes. But still related to the barrage of vomit spewing from Mozilla lately, for example: "Firefox Now Sends Your Address Bar Keystrokes to Mozilla" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28804588 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28804588
- brutal_chaos_ 5y agoDoes a serious alternative to Firefox exist? I mean an alternative that is what Firefox purports to be? I'm ready to make the switch. Been with Mozilla since Pheonix, but the user hostility has become too much.
- bloopernova 5y agoYou could give Waterfox a try.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jjcon 5y agoI know some get annoyed with this answer but if you look into what the Brave team is doing they have a lot of really interesting projects in the works. I've had a great experience with Brave.
- throwaway661885 5y agoPlease no https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28746873 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28746873 Edit - Also 'Ublock Origin' works best with Firefox https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26755252 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26755252
- WithinReason 5y agoI couldn't find anything of substance here, just FUD
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoBrave being webkit, it's not an alternative.
- jjcon 5y ago>Brave being webkit, it's not an alternative. Brave is Blink not webkit - Blink has been developed by Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Intel and many others. It is the standard for web rendering just as linux is for web hosting. There is nothing wrong with open standards.
- throwaway661885 5y ago
- perihelions 5y agoThe dark pattern in one image: https://regmedia.co.uk/2021/10/07/suggest.jpg https://regmedia.co.uk/2021/10/07/suggest.jpg I and I think many others chose "Customize in settings" -- but the actual opt-out is that hard-to-see, third button in small print. We didn't "get opted-in automatically" -- it's this dialog we "opted in" with.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoGeez, why doesn't Mozilla simply ask for donations if it needs money for development. Imagine if all free open source projects operated this way. Advertising on computers is a virus. Just when you think you have it eliminated or under control, someone starts spreading it again.
- jrootabega 5y agoIt might make the majority of people lose trust in them, even if they were doing it for the right reasons and were actually going to use the money for the right purposes. People just associate that kind of behavior with scams and poorly run organizations.
- sudobash1 5y agoI would choose that button particularly because the "not now" button sounds like it would prompt us again in the future. It really doesn't sound like an opt-out.
- sharps1 5y agoI don’t even remember seeing this image. It was enabled on three separate machines.
- clircle 5y agoOh my, that is absolutely fiendish. I had to check the image a couple times before I found 'not now' in the corner.
- morsch 5y agoSo what happens when you press customize? From looking at a relevant changeset[1], it seems that only Allow enables the ads (setting suggest.quicksuggest.sponsored), while Customize does not (and the comments specifically says the user remains opted out). The related bug is marked as confidential[2]. Incidentally, here[3] is an interesting list of settings relating to the address bar that may or may not be documented elsewhere. [1] https://hg.mozilla.org/releases/mozilla-beta/rev/6348c24c98c8 https://hg.mozilla.org/releases/mozilla-beta/rev/6348c24c98c... [2] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1693126 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1693126 I may be remembering this wrong, but most bugs on bugzilla are open to the public, this one isn't, presumably because they weren't interested in public discussion [2] https://hg.mozilla.org/integration/autoland/rev/d3de5eaaaa15 https://hg.mozilla.org/integration/autoland/rev/d3de5eaaaa15
- sudobash1 5y agoI'm not sure how long this message has been here, but Firefox does have this note on it's website[1]: > We haven't quite hit our mark. We've received feedback that it's difficult to figure out which Firefox experience you've got enabled. We are hard at work to address this and continue to improve the feature. [1] https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/navigate-web-faster-firefox-suggest https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/navigate-web-faster-fir...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- slater 5y agoEvery 6 months or so, Mozilla's marketing team tries something that is clearly, obviously NOT wanted by Joe & Jane Random User, then quickly posts an "oopsie, who could've known, we'll do better!" blog update. Tiring, and so easily avoidable.
- a5aAqU 5y ago> Unfortunately, all major browsers now use a combined address and search bar. So, if you’re typing in the address of a sensitive website to go directly there, your keystrokes as you type will be sent to your default search engine and your search engine may be able to determine the website address you’re typing in manually. That's why it's a good idea to split the search box in the Firefox settings. Ctrl-l takes you to the address bar which doesn't load any remote data, and ctrl-k takes you to the search box on the right, which does send keystrokes to the search engine. Settings → Search → Add search bar in toolbar (check that box) Also uncheck "Show search suggestions in address bar results" Problem solved, for now.
- charcircuit 5y agoMost if not all of the bundled search engines send the data over HTTPS and do not save what you type or assign it to your account. There is nothing to worry about.
- throwaway81523 5y ago> and do not save what you type I think you are dreaming if you believe that.
- charcircuit 5y agoSend a request to Google for all of your data. It won't be in there.
- ectopod 5y agoHow do you know they don't feed it into an ML system before they delete it? That lets them "not save it" while reaping the benefits of saving it.
- charcircuit 5y agoIf it's deleted, then why would you care? It no longer has anything to do with you.
- charcircuit 5y agoThis is panic over nothing. There is no personally identifiable information being sent with your location, and the location is made to be imprecise.
- gnu8 5y agoHow does that make this ok?
- charcircuit 5y agoBecause it's normal in marketing. Most web servers log your whole IP yet people don't freak out about that.
- speedybird 5y agoToday you've told us to use chrome, trust google, and that spyware is okay if it's "normal in marketing". Do you work for google, or are you full of shit takes today for another reason? You clearly don't get what made people like Firefox in the first place. You are so out of touch, it's painful.
- charcircuit 5y agoThings are often a lot more boring than what some people who are paranoid about their privacy believe. These people have trouble trusting others not to do the most evil thing possible and the internet would simply not work if everyone was actually anonymous.
- speedybird 5y agoThe opinion regarding firefox of one who would recommend Chrome is lower than dirt.
- beervirus 5y ago>it’s normal in marketing There’s a reason NOT to do something if I’ve ever heard one.
- userbinator 5y agoThe dialog is an example of a dark pattern, with three options, one highlighted to encourage a reflex click, one in discouraging grey for customising settings, and sneaked in at top right, a small "Not now" link. If there's anything navigating "modern software" for a few years has taught me, it's that you should expect to be treated like the product and "herded", so the most encouraging option is usually the worst one for you, and the least encouraging option is usually the best. This anti-conditioning has become so strong for me that I remember recently being confused upon seeing a page with only a huge green Download button, thinking "this can't be the real one, it feels too fake and obvious" when it was actually the real one. I wonder how many others will be gradually conditioned by these dark patterns to do the exact opposite of their original sinister intentions. But this Firefox one definitely takes the desire to confuse to new heights --- it's probably the first time I've seen "not now" as an opt-out, and I'd more instinctively go for the grey.
- greyhat 5y agoIt was enabled by default on my installation, which is extra surprising considering I have all forms of address bar and search suggestions disabled except browser history.
- thoughtstheseus 5y agoThis should be illegal. Or at least violate some level of software design standards.
- phrz 5y agoMozilla repeatedly extolls Firefox as the safest, most privacy-respecting browser, but keeps carving away at their goodwill with little barbs like this. It's a very odd image strategy, all actual privacy arguments aside. There must be other ways to monetize than becoming the digital version of a used car salesman.
- greatgib 5y agoNo one as any insider info of how this kind of things is going on inside Firefox corp? I find it curious that privacy cautious OSS devs would not complain highly when asked to add shitty "feature" like that. And it is not the first one recently. So, is it like in a big corp where an asshole management executive push down such decision from the top?
- PaulKeeble 5y agoWhat typically happens is that this stuff gets forced from the managers from on high and some developers complain and ultimately leave since their morale compass is being violated and those that can stand it stay. Then whoever they hire and retain fits with this new culture and the entire morale compass is very quickly shifted. What management wants always goes in the end they just slowly expel all those that disagree to implement it one way or the other.
- mattalex 5y agoHow long until we get an " unmozillad Firefox"? I really think that Firefox is a great project with the unfortunate attribute of having Mozilla attached to it. Mozilla really seems like a cannonical in the making (which itself is a Microsoft in the making) I don't think I can trust IT-conglomerates in the making anymore.
- theHIDninja 5y agoAbsolutely fucking disgusting. Something needs to be done to these greedy psychopathic fucks. I don't know what that would be, but something absolutely needs to be done.