8 ms·
I paid money to cross the Pacific Ocean on a Maersk line, 300 meter cargo ship (us_en here). Many people asked me if I worked to be on board, and the answer was
by mistrial9 5y ago
I paid money to cross the Pacific Ocean on a Maersk line, 300 meter cargo ship (us_en here). Many people asked me if I worked to be on board, and the answer was "no", Maersk did not allow it. The officers were mostly East Germans who needed a job, while the strictly segregated, "A-Bs" were almost all Pacific Islanders of some kind. The conditions were clean and professional, but I got the feeling soon that this was not a desirable job. The officers would spend at least 60 days on duty, often more.. without a vacation day, but had a weekly day "off" or two, except the Captain who is technically working at all times.
I enjoyed the travel and had a good voyage, with many small things to say about it at another time. As I learn about "business" and the world, I understand more about labor abuses, even with "respectable" companies. And, your outrage does nothing, because people who mistreat others professionally are quite used to the complaining, including yours. I am not at all surprised at this article.
- CalChris 5y agoA-B, usually AB, is an able body seaman. This is the lowest level of certification for the deck department of a merchant ship. https://www.mitags.org/course/able-seaman-course/ https://www.mitags.org/course/able-seaman-course/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kaiwen1 5y agoLowest is Ordinary Seaman (OS). This is the entry level rating in the deck department. The only qualifications required are basic safety and firefighting training. The corresponding entry level rating in the engine department is Wiper.
- polishdude20 5y agoHow much did that voyage cost?
- p_j_w 5y agoI'm not OP, but I've looked it up before, and it's actually quite expensive. Ballpark of around $75/night (USD). And, of course, it's slow, so you'll be using a substantial portion of your banked vacation time to do it (if that's a concern for you).
- wolverine876 5y ago> quite expensive. Ballpark of around $75/night (USD) For room and board? That's pretty economical.
- CGamesPlay 5y agoI took a container cruise in 2019 (with this guy [0], do recommend although it's probably not possible in a post-COVID world), and prices for all trans-Atlantic routes I could find were between 150-250 EUR/night. My ship arrived at the starting port 3 days late and at the destination port 1 day late, but the rate was not adjusted. The sole other passenger with me had his destination port canceled, but the company dropped him at a different port and purchased him fare the remaining way on a bus. [0] http://m.freightertravel.co.nz/home http://m.freightertravel.co.nz/home
- duckfruit 5y agoThis sounds fascinating. I'm interested to learn more. How does one go about paying for passage on a cargo ship?
- rudian 5y agoLast time I googled this I found it was quite expensive, basically cruise-level per-night prices, at least in my area. Perhaps if you contact the shipping companies directly you can arrange something cheaper.
- dougmwne 5y agoI have read that too. It seems bizarre that it would be expensive, but there may be a supply an demand issue for the number of people who cannot or will take flight vs. the very limited number of transatlantic and transpacific ship crossings.
- Ekaros 5y agoIt is not their core-business like cruises or ferry companies. So there is probably very substantial overhead in coordination, billing and so on. Same goes for anything from any company, technically they can provide service and even might do, but price it is sensible due to extra work is high.
- fiftyacorn 5y agoThere are probably tax reasons for offering it and they would prefer not too many people to take them up on it
- ksdale 5y agoI assume it used to be far more informal and sort of a handshake deal you'd make with the captain, and then the companies formalized it but it was still cheap because no one knew/wanted to do it, but then as the possibility becomes common knowledge, there are way more people who want to do it than there are spots for, so they raise the price.
- the-dude 5y agoAFAIK you would need papers to be allowed to work.
- atatatat 5y agoFrom the government of the Pacific Ocean..?
- rhcom2 5y agoI'd assume from the government of the country which the vessel is flagged under. For example needing a Merchant Mariner's Credential if a US ship.
- zerkten 5y agoMaersk's insurer, or more likely, legal team wouldn't permit something like this because of the liability they'd carry for enabling it. It wouldn't get past that point to a discussion of region-specific employment restrictions, not that they matter here per your comment.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoAll they (and every other bigco) care about is doing whatever token "due diligence" they need to do. If your papers aren't legit they don't care as long as they don't know.
- elliekelly 5y agoI think ships are a bit like the wild west... one of the last “anything goes” jurisdictions. The cruise industry especially goes to great lengths to avoid regulatory oversight at all costs.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoAn oil tanker is a floating bomb. And another Exon Valdez would cost hundreds of millions.
- 5y ago
- rootsudo 5y agothis is also common on cruise ships and naval around the world. - officers are european, with more lately east european. Then the staff or A-B are usually filipino, Vietmanese or Indonesian. Its more salary then back where they're from - and it has interesting cultural changes in their socities. In the philippines, these are called "OFW" families. daddy is never home, but because he works "abroad" his family can have newer stuff, be in a better neighborhood, etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_Filipino_Worker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_Filipino_Worker
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hunterb123 5y agothis is common amongst all first world industries. whether it's farming, cruises, factories, transportation, etc. not supporting it, but that's the current setup.
- smabie 5y agoWhy wouldn't you support it? Seems like a win-win for most parties involved.
- dylan604 5y agoIt's not a matter of supporting hiring people of different nationalities. It's supporting the current conditions surrounding these employees. If these workers are not of a legal status, then they are easily abused (working conditions/below minimum pay/etc). These workers are more fearful of being deported than the abuse which means they do not report any of the wrongs that may be occurring. To me, this says much more about the employer.
- hunterb123 5y agoDirectly, it usually it leads to poor working conditions when you have non-residential workers, especially ones in a quasi-legal status. For factories, you sometimes have the problem of the factory shutting down after the locals become dependent on it. For migrant working, it's hard on the children of the family and it causes tension between the families not participating. Philosophically, one could argue it's exploitation and is very close to slavery except the small amount of pay. Until this type of work is extinct I don't think one can morally campaign for UBI can you? Currently this type of work is apparently necessary so we've accepted that the system cannot either pay the more wealthy citizen's wage nor up the wage of the foreign workers. Is there a demand to up the wage of these non-represented workers that make far below minimum wage? Is there a demand to up the wage of minimal wage for citizens and are the foreign workers mentioned? Is there a demand for UBI for citizens to not work at all while foreign workers pick up the slack?
- throwaway1777 5y agoJust curious but why specify East Germans versus Germans. Is the Berlin Wall back up?
- goodells 5y agoEven decades after reunification, the socioeconomic differences between areas that used to be East and West Germany are still very apparent.
- killerpopiller 5y agofor example?
- bagels 5y agohttps://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/11/06/east-germany-has-narrowed-economic-gap-with-west-germany-since-fall-of-communism-but-still-lags/?amp=1 https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/11/06/east-german...
- kesselvon 5y agoEast Germans are a lot poorer, the East German economy is a lot lower productivity and investment, and politically the old DDR states lean a bit more right (ripe area for AfD recruitment). Some West germans still look down on Ossies, even though Merkel was one herself. It's a lot like how northern states look down on southern states in the U.S.
- bserge 5y agoWell, I've got a surprise for you
- kataklasm 5y agoInterestingly enough, the east is the most prolific voting area for both far right and the left. Both AfD and Die Linke had their best results in the eastern states. Might be connected to the horseshoe theory, I'm thinking. Where voters don't have a specific connection to any one political mindset so they choose the party that is the most extreme in their mind and won't hesitate to switch to another more extreme party, even if they switch from far left to far right because they aren't affiliated with a specific political mindset.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- unethical_ban 5y agoYou can't toss out a cool anecdote like that and not talk more about how to get on a ship!
- tehjoker 5y agoReally interesting story! Why did you have to pay in order to work, it was a big discount? Just want to point out that yes, companies dismiss complaints, but they don't dismiss it when workers stop working together. Then they get panicked.
- tdeck 5y agoI think OP paid to travel as a passenger. They explicitly didn't get the option to work on the ship for a discount on their passage. Apparently you can just pay to travel on these container ship lines, although it can take more than 2 weeks to cross the ocean and accommodations vary.
- rendall 5y agoYou need to read more carefully. OP wrote they paid to be on the ship and did not have to work.
- joe_the_user 5y agoAnd, your outrage does nothing, because people who mistreat others professionally are quite used to the complaining, including yours. I am not at all surprised at this article. I enjoyed your post until this sentence. The article describes a situation gradually deteriorating into a crisis. The barrier between people complaining and things actually happening are indeed high but I still believe taking note of a crisis is a first step to acting.
- chmsky00 5y agoA whole lot of people take the “I lived through a real crisis…” then detail their life during the gas shortage or something. Unfortunately most do not see anything as a crisis until a literal one of sufficient scale is upon us.
- indigochill 5y ago> taking note of a crisis is a first step to acting. Yes, in the same way overcoming denial is the first step in personal recovery. The trouble is, like a depressed alcoholic who doesn't care that drink's ruining their life, it's not that those running the company are in denial about the way they're abusing their employees. It's that they know it and don't care. What's the path from here to them caring, though? One thing that might help is if their clients stopped doing business with them, but do their clients care?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe shipping company’s clients will stop doing business with them if the shipping company cared, by switching to their competitors who do not care and will sell to them at lower prices. The only solutions are political, with some combination of giving those people being subject to abuse better options so that the abusers are not able to abuse, and by making said abuses illegal.
- indigochill 5y agoSuppose Denmark/the EU passes laws that require Maersk to operate ethically. Maersk and all other Danish shipping companies now need to charge their customers more, so won't what you said in the first line just happen at the international level, with clients switching to, say, a Chinese shipping company?
- ddoran 5y agoI enjoyed "The Cargo Ship Diaries" [1] by Niall Doherty about his time traveling as a paid passenger on merchant ships. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/21868783-the-cargo-ship-diaries?ac=1&from_search=true&qid=8HaHMYuVf5&rank=1 https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/21868783-the-cargo-ship-...
- burmer 5y agoYeah, that's why so many ships are registered to specific countries too, so they can operate with looser restrictions. It's basically "offshoring" but for the regulations. When I worked in fisheries, I remember seeing so many boats registered to Panama, and never knew why: http://www.pmacertification.com/advantages-of-registering-a-ship-in-panama/ http://www.pmacertification.com/advantages-of-registering-a-...
- Y_Y 5y agoAt least a lot of ships actually go to Panama. Many are also registered in Liberia.
- wolverine876 5y ago> your outrage does nothing It's a trendy thing to say these days, but history shows that outrage and public opinion do quite a lot, and that is why people work very hard to manage it (including, these days, to try to appear unbothered). There are plenty of labor laws that the public has passed, and you can see, for example, SV companies responses to publicized labor abuses in their supply chains.
- PicassoCTs 5y agoHistory shows that outrage does something, when it turns into laws. Todays outrage is managed ressource going nowhere.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhat about the effects of #Metoo, racial injustice protests, LGTBQ+ marriage, transgender protections (and discrimination - outrage results in bad laws too), gun rights outrage, voter ID laws, etc etc etc. Lots is happening. Also, outrage doesn't need laws to be effective: Plenty of corporations do things that aren't legally required, in order to please the public. The NFL didn't have to address racial injustice, but it did. Bad things happen too - lynchings, for example.
- ethbr0 5y agoOf those that have made a difference, the majority are via laws, which was parent's point.
- wolverine876 5y agoThe GP says, > Todays outrage is managed ressource going nowhere. I'm saying that it definitely went somewhere, it created major changes, including laws.
- ethbr0 5y ago> History shows that outrage does something, when it turns into laws. Todays outrage is managed ressource going nowhere.
- namenotrequired 5y ago> The officers would spend at least 60 days on duty, often more.. without a vacation day Note that after X weeks on this schedule, the officers commonly get X weeks off at home as well. (Source: my brother is one.) The ABs though are a different story…
- CGamesPlay 5y agoI did an Atlantic crossing on CMA CGM and it was similar. The officers were almost 100% French and everyone else on board (officers and crew) was Filipino. The longest-serving seaman had been on the ship for 18 months, but typical tours are in 6 month blocks. The most interesting observation I had was that although there was an "officer's rec room" and a "crew's rec room", it ended up being a "French rec room" and a "Filipino rec room". The long tours don't particularly bother me, I think that's somewhat expected with maritime work.
- jacquesm 5y ago'East Germans'? This was in the 80's then?
- canadianfella 5y agous_en?