11 ms·
Jonathan's Card shut down
- arithmetic 15y agoComments have been pouring in for the last couple of hours on the Facebook page - https://www.facebook.com/jonathanscard https://www.facebook.com/jonathanscard
- yuvipanda 15y agoWonder if the 'iPad hack' had anything to do with this...
- sorbus 15y agoProbably. One of the statuses on the facebook page begins "All we can hope for in life is a strong moral compass that helps guide us in doing the right thing and when something happens that might seem unfair we need to realize that those incidences are in the minority." Of course, since they're saying that "Starbucks has informed me that they will be shutting off the card", it's also possible that Starbucks has some reason to shut it off that's entirely unrelated to that.
- Cushman 15y agoI'd imagine Starbucks was loving the free publicity as long as it was working, but when things started to turn sour they didn't want the controversy and decided to assert their rights.
- mikeleeorg 15y agoThe social media team at Starbucks struck me as being fairly social-media-savvy. I have some doubts - or at least a lot of confusion - over why they'd want to shut this down now. The publicity wasn't _that_ negative. It seemed like they stood to gain a lot for it continuing to work out too. But I suppose we'll never know the true story. Whatever the case, I think it's a sad shame. (I also hope this doesn't kill Jonathan's spirit.)
- Cushman 15y agoI don't think they can, or would want to, kill the idea— I think (assuming it's what happened) they shut down Jonathan's Card, which we know is being actively skimmed, to nip the negative press in the bud, secure in the knowledge that copycat projects will (and already have) swoop in and pick up the torch.
- madiator 15y agoHad to happen, thanks to Sam and other crooks.
- citricsquid 15y agoShh, you can't say that, he's a YC guy! He'll quote some PG to justify it, I'm sure.
- madiator 15y agoI don't know whom you are talking about, I didn't refer to anybody's last name :) Regarding other comments, I agree Sam didn't bring this down single handed, but may be ten years down the line if I tell my kids about this 'starbucks social experiment', I will pretty much remember about 'one guy who messed it up all'...
- birken 15y agoI blame the public schools.
- sebkomianos 15y agoThing is, it was an experiment from the very beginning. Experiments don't have good and bad guys, only observations and results. And the observation isn't a new one: "systems" like that work nicely until the first few exploits.
- Cushman 15y agoI don't buy your logic. If I, as a researcher, leave a car in a bad neighborhood overnight to see what happens, the guy who smashes the window to steal the radio is still a bad guy whether or not that's relevant to my results. Science doesn't concern itself with morality, but that doesn't mean it exists in a moral vacuum.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>as a researcher, leave a car in a bad neighborhood overnight // I think you have to label the car "free car" leaving all the doors unlocked and with the keys in the ignition. Then when someone sells the car and gives the money to charity everyone organises a lynch mob it seems because apparently selling the car wasn't part of the experiment you expected it to be driven. Of course experiments are best when they have unexpected outcomes and it would be unexpected in a "bad neighbourhood" for someone to act altruistically in this way with a free car.
- Dylan16807 15y agoI'd change your analogy to make the label 'free rides', as the intent of this was to get a cheap disposable cup of coffee. And rather than selling the car the guy drains most of the gas out of the tank and takes it. So yes, it's an experiment but the guy was violating the stated rules.
- uname_pword 15y agoMy understanding (correct me if I'm wrong) is the credit on the gift card could only be transferred to another gift card using a PIN. If this is true, Sam Odio must have brute forced that PIN which was clearly not part of the experiment. I'd call that wire fraud. Even if there was no PIN Jonathan himself stated that he didn't want this to happen, that the experiment was in sharing change between Starbucks customers. At the end of the day I find it hard to defend Sam Odio's actions no matter the scope of the experiment. As is often the case, I think he had a potent mix of greed (for money) and ability (to siphon money out of the gift card). Ultimately he ended up with over $500 and gave himself a reality check - anyone in their right mind would feel they have been at least "very surreptitious" if they were in his shoes. Sam wanted an out, and donating the stolen money to charity is the easiest way to spin his actions in a selfless view. From the wording in his blog post you can see he's no better than the so called yuppies he's trying to teach a lesson. The first thing going through his mind was "This is enough money to buy an iPad". Spoken like a true materialist? Not a single mention of the people who contributed that money in the first place. And finally, just what lesson was he trying to teach here? That sharing spare change is greedy? Let's not forget that Sam treated himself to a coffee with his loot. I can't help but feel he's getting what he deserves by having his name plastered on CNN and other media. When we dig beneath the surface his actions are truly revealing of his shady character.
- Cushman 15y agoSo, this isn't necessarily because of Sam Odio, but everyone's thinking it. And... duh. The take-a-penny, leave-a-penny trays only work when more pennies follow the rules than don't. If somebody comes along every day to empty out the tray — even if they're bringing it right across the street to the Salvation Army — they're going to take the trays away. That's just not what they're for, and if they're not working there's no reason for them to exist. The net result in the end being that the homeless are still homeless, life is a little bit more of a hassle for shoppers who don't have the right change, people are a little bit less connected with each other, and the dick who was emptying the trays feels like he's "made his point," whatever it was supposed to be. But all of that being said: This only applies when abuse makes the system unsustainable. Is it? Craig's Cup thinks not: http://www.facebook.com/Craigscup http://www.facebook.com/Craigscup The "experiment" is far from over.
- abraham 15y ago> So, this isn't necessarily because of Sam Odio, but everyone's thinking it. Are you kidding me? Starbucks doesn't give a shit that someone was syphoning off money. A few hundred dollars is chump change to them. What they care about is the thousands of people "defrauding" their rewards program designed for use with a single customer. I'm sure their TOS restricts use to a single person as well.
- joshfraser 15y agoI'm not so sure based on their public response to the experiment: "We think Jonathan’s project is really interesting and we are flattered he chose Starbucks for his social experiment."
- Cushman 15y agoInteresting. Where are you getting that opinion from? Mine comes from the article Jonathan himself tweeted: "At 7 p.m. PT Friday, Starbucks reluctantly pulled the plug on Stark’s pay-it-forward social experiment following allegations of fraud or misuse. ... Adam Brotman, vice president of digital ventures at Starbucks, phoned Stark earlier Friday evening to inform him that the card would be deactivated. Starbucks, he says, was rooting for the experiment from the sidelines, even though the company’s terms do not permit the use of shared registered cards. 'I’m sad about it, first and foremost, because we were legitimately cheering on this experiment,' Brotman says. ... Once the exploit was public, however, Starbucks felt compelled to deactivate the card." http://mashable.com/2011/08/13/jonathans-card-shut-down/ http://mashable.com/2011/08/13/jonathans-card-shut-down/
- drivebyacct2 15y agoI have read the implication that this experiment was killed off because it affected Starbuck's revenue or profitability. I don't really understand how that would be the case at all. Can someone speculate?
- Cushman 15y agoIf that's true, I expect it's a case of the left hand not talking to the right— the positive buzz and in-store traffic has got to dwarf any marginal loss in profitability by an order of magnitude.
- nchlswu 15y agoWhile Sam's post was admittedly a bit snarky, and his actions did seem a bit 'scummy.' But Sam simply contributed to the experiment. Surely others were going to take advantage of the system. While his actions may run counter to the 'spirit of the experiment,' it's fair game and part of the experiment. Stark didn't enforce any sort of rules for a reason. People who participated in the experiment can continue to pay it forward however they want. I don't necessarily agree with the reasons Sam cited for running his own take on the experiment, but I have to say I'm sort of surprised by the general reaction by so many -- then again, these reactions are just another outcome of the experiment. I find the following and dedication to this movement utterly fascinating. He made a statement regarding people's generosity (or illusions of generosity?) and the resultant attacks on Odio himself are even more intriguing.
- jwilliams 15y agoThere seems to be a habit to define the rules of the experiment - on the basis that there are no rules - and then use this to illustrate a particular point of view as "right" or otherwise justifiable. By your definition it would have also been fine if Sam had actually gone out and bought himself and iPad. Technically fair game? Would that have been ok? Probably not to most people. Not because of the rules, but because we all have our own view of acceptable behaviour. In this case, he gamed the system and in the process poured water on some people that were having fun. I don't buy that it's a social experiment more than someone trying to be clever and game a system. So yeah. Fair game, but I can see why they're annoyed.
- nchlswu 15y ago> I don't buy that it's a social experiment more than someone trying to be clever and game a system. That's fair. But would you be more inclined to think of it as a social experiment if it wasn't limited to Jonathan's physical gift card? To elaborate, what if you consider the Jonathan's Card spinoffs and broader reaction to Odio's actions?
- Cushman 15y agoSam literally did the opposite of contribute to the experiment. There is nothing he could have done which would be more disruptive. The "experiment" was to see if a system based purely on goodwill, like take-a-penny, leave-a-penny, can survive. And in fact, it largely can, as the growing popularity of Jonathan's Card showed. That there are people who will abuse the system does not excuse the people who abuse the system— that's absurd. I'm baffled by your surprise at the reaction. Are you likewise surprised by the fact that people don't like the guy who comes up to the bowl labeled "Free Candy" and takes all of the candy, leaving none for anyone else? "But I'm just demonstrating that any system based on goodwill is open to abuse!" Well, yeah. We know. People hate that. "But I'm giving the candy to underprivileged children!" That's good for them, then. We hope they enjoy it, dick.
- bgurupra 15y agoI just don't see what the experiment was about really considering the audience entirely consisted of people who can afford coffee - I just don't get it! The only explanation is a viral marketing scheme in my mind
- ether 15y agoIf you read the post, he mentions examples where people buy someone else who can't afford coffee. That was what he encouraged from the initial post as well. Also I've seen many of my friends actually do something like that.
- gregschlom 15y agoThere's a huge difference between buying myself a coffee and enjoying someone else's generosity. The latter makes me feel happy, and makes me want to be generous, too.
- shabda 15y agoI am surprised at the hate against Sam Odio. Sam had the option of taking the gift card and selling the card and keeping the iPad. He exposed the vulnerability. If he hadnt you would have paid in for the card, but someone would have abused the system, and not disclosed it. Here is a though experiment. There is a widely used piece of software which has a vulnerability. There are bad guys who are going to abuse it. A guy comes and abuse the system, to prove the vulnerability and expose the vulnerability. I s he good or bad? full disclosure vs responsible disclosure
- ahlatimer 15y agoI think we were all aware that the system could be abused. It was based entirely on the honor system since we don't know who was using the card, only that it was being used. The original thread was full of people talking about how it could be abused. As far as what Sam did in particular, it'd be entirely different if Sam came out and said, "Hey, look! I was able to write a script that has syphoned off $625 from the card and put it into Starbucks gift cards. I could then turn around and sell those cards on eBay and turn them into cash. I'll be putting the money back onto the original card, but I just wanted to expose the exploit." Instead, he followed through with turning it into cash and wrote a snarky blog post about how yuppies buying yuppies coffee isn't all that interesting, and he had decided to redirect the experiment to "will someone buy a Starbucks gift card for full price."
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- lotharbot 15y ago> "we were all aware that the system could be abused" I think we were all aware that the system could be abused to buy yourself an extra coffee every once in a while, if you happened to be in Starbucks when the card had money on it. We were all aware that you could overspend, either on yourself or "for charity" (witness Sam's comment about buying food for homeless guys.) If that was the only vulnerability, most of us would think it acceptable -- most of the time money you put on the card goes to brighten an honest person's day, but occasionally someone games the system. Until the exploit was posted, I was not aware that it could be abused by skimming $50 at a time onto your own card within moments of it being deposited on the main card. This is an unacceptable level of exploitability -- if you put money on the card, it's very likely that it will go to a scammer of some sort. I'm glad Sam exposed this far-more-serious-than-most-of-us-realized vulnerability. I'm not pleased with how he went about it (particularly the game he and his brother seem to be playing; Daniel's startup deposited exactly $625, the same amount Sam took.) I'm not pleased with the "yuppies buying coffee" vs "starving kids in Africa" comparison. But I'm glad this particular exploit has been exposed, which means we now have the opportunity to set up a better-and-safer version of Jonathan's Card.
- deltaqueue 15y agoMaybe I'm getting too cynical and pessimistic about society, but an abuse of the system seemed like a guaranteed result of this project. Jonathan's card is simply a redistribution of wealth based on the honor system (masked by words like "karma" and "good will"). Some people will throw ten bucks on the card because it makes them feel great, but leeches will always take part in the project, and at some point there will be more leeches than seeders. People have been abusing programs (government or otherwise) that do the same thing for generations, even without the honor system. *I enjoy volunteering, donating, paying it forward, etc., I'm just trying to illustrate a point.
- awakeasleep 15y agoYou're right, and at the same time the card existed for a couple weeks and it made a bunch of people happy while giving everyone a lot to think about! You're right, and at the same time we have a functioning society where people love and grow and the sun's still shining, and I experience kindness more frequently than the opposite!
- robryan 15y agoWould be great if Starbucks took up on the theme and made a card designed for sharing but allowed the creator to define a single purchase limit. I don't think a system like this could ever be completely locked down to abuse but at least it could take away the gift card thing.
- ajays 15y agoNow that's a great idea. Have a card that is limited in certain ways: max purchase of, say, $5 (I don't know if $5 will buy anything in $tarbuck$, since I haven't been there in many years). Limit purchases to coffee (or tea) only. No transfer allowed from one GC to another. No more than, say, 30 uses per location. It would be an interesting series of social experiments to limit the card in these various ways, and see which limitation helps the uptake, and which hurts it. Fascinating!
- flocial 15y agoAll in all a brilliant experiment illustrating the possibilities and pitfalls of social gifting. This is something a company like Foursquare can improve on.
- nazgulnarsil 15y agoMy take-away: append moral statements with "unless you could get an ipad."
- nakedslavin 15y agoSucks it didn't work.. I know Sam decided to send all the money to some charity or something like that, but the fact is, if he really wanted to do something useful he could have done it himself, but not basing his 'ebay-experiment' on that project. But again,that would require being creative.
- ronnier 15y agoThis is similar to our tax dollars. Pay in, and others use them as fast as possible. No matter how much money was put on Jonathan's card, people were there to take it.
- TeMPOraL 15y agoIt seems that experiment is live and running: http://www.facebook.com/Craigscup http://www.facebook.com/Craigscup http://www.facebook.com/dccupofjoe http://www.facebook.com/dccupofjoe http://www.facebook.com/notes/paying-it-forward/paying-it-forward-with-starbucks-how-it-works/118639894901035 http://www.facebook.com/notes/paying-it-forward/paying-it-fo... It's so wonderful that people picked the idea up! Another interesting result of Jonathan's social experiment! :).
- Mz 15y agoI've missed something. Can someone give a link to the back story? Who is Sam Odio and what exactly did he do? (Or just "what did he do?" -- I don't really need a bio with a pic of his two dogs or some such.) Thanks.
- bitdiffusion 15y agoIt might be slightly off-topic, but I used to work in the same building as "Save the Children" at a swanky address in central London (this is the charity where the money ended up iirc). The employees dressed better than us and I could see (when the lift opened on their floor on the way up) that their offices were pretty awesome. Anyway - how much of the donation actually ended up feeding starving children I guess is neither here-nor-there; at the end of the day giving to charity is usually about how it makes you feel.
- lylejohnson 15y agoAccording to Charity Navigator, "Save the Children" is a four-star charity, with about 90 percent of their budget going to program expenses. That seems pretty reasonable. http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summary&orgid=4438 http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summary...
- delinka 15y agoNo one has mentioned the obvious legal snags for Starbucks in this whole "experiment." Starbucks is not a money transfer service and therefore is not registered with the US government as such. If Sam could siphon off that much money so easily, how long before the Bad Guys learn that Starbucks can be used to move money? Or maybe they suddenly realized themselves that criminals could have been moving money through them for years. I'd say it's almost certain that a Starbucks lawyer pointed this out and the executives didn't like the idea. Watch for changes to Starbucks' money card program.
- shabble 15y agoI'm probably missing something, but the exploit was all about filling up a Starbucks gift card. It was touted as "Enough to buy an iPad", but at no point was one actually bought. The $500 card is now being eBayed for charity, which (for profit), would be one way to close the loop and get cash out, but surely that applies to any business operating a gift-card scheme. Are you normally able to redeem these cards for cash? My (limited) experience is not only no, but sometimes the amount is rounded up to the nearest $currency_denomination as well.
- sstrudeau 15y agoI don't believe most retailers will redeem cards for cash (if they can avoid it) but gift cards are use widely as a money laundering and value-exchange system amongst criminals: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stored-value_card#Money_laundering http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stored-value_card#Money_launder...
- savrajsingh 15y agoHere's a free idea for Starbucks: issue gift cards that only allow purchase of a specific product, like a tall chai/coffee. Scenario: I want to thank someone. Instead of giving them a gift card with an arbitrary dollar value that they will inevitably need to round out with their own money, I can give them a gift card and say "your next drink is on me." And I get billed/deducted in the background. This would make Jonathans card work as intended. Incidentally I have previously pitched this idea to employees at Starbucks corporate, to the Starbucks "idea" forums, etc over the last two years. My core scenario is I want to have a stack of these cards and give out free drinks to random people. :) $5 gift cards make things too cumbersome.
- iamscanner 15y agoI actually waited in line at a bank for about 15 minutes once, and when I got to the teller the manager said "hey - want a coffee?", and handed me a Tim's card (reloadable gift cards for Tim Hortons). I had no idea what the value was - but it turned out to be $2 (just enough to buy any size of coffee at Tim Hortons). Having it be $2 was a lot more useful than having it be for a large coffee - I don't drink coffee, and I ended up using the $2 to subsidize a bagel.
- kidh0 15y agoI really don't know why Starbucks shut down the Jonathan's Card, it was a free ads, Starbucks was still profiting...
- kens 15y agoInterestingly, Sam Odio's sale of the $500 Starbucks card on Ebay is currently at $3950. Unless the bidder is feeling really charitable, I assume someone is sabotaging Sam's "experiment" with massive overbidding they won't pay. Ebay sale is at: http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=160636718148#ht_500wt_1156 http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=16063...
- paulnelligan 15y agoSocial gifting is cool. The only problem with it is that the people who REALLY need the gift are the ones who can't afford smartphones, tablet devices, or computers. So i'd rather give my gifts the old fashioned way. But i still like the idea in a symbolic sense.
- shabble 15y agoPrint a bunch of tear-off QR codes and tape it to your nearest lamp-post? Or have a bunch at the desk of a homeless shelter maybe?
- LiveTheDream 15y agoSurprised no one has mentioned it, but I'm impressed with Starbucks for contacting Jonathan and telling him what they were going to do with the card, and when.
- lurker19 15y agoThe thing about computer security flaws is that unless someone makes a point of publicly exploiting them, others will go around quietly exploiting them. It is almost certain that someone was quietly siphoning Jonathan's card. Would all the donors really prefer to have their donations be embezzled like they are at a skeezy charity front like Palotta or Komen? Why, just for smug satisfaction of feeling good about giving, without any concern or accountability regarding whether the gift is doing the good you give yourself credit for? There is no use in condemning Odio unless you have a plan to fix the security hole he highlighted. Otherwise you are going to shutdown the open and honest takers and willfully ignore the quiet and dishonest takers.
- shabble 15y agoBeing able to mark a card as "only purchases @foodstuff products", or being able to blacklist it from refilling gift cards would be the easiest way to close this particular hole. If you could only purchase actual physical objects (ideally, only fresh food, rather than, say, a coffee-maker), that would go a long way toward preventing misuse.
- daniel_reetz 15y agoI read the writeup. This is a great example of a classy way to end an experiment in the face of enormous snark and doubt. Jonathan had every opportunity to become defensive and flame out, but instead he kept it cool and emphasized the positive. A lesson taught by example. Great work.
- kevinpet 15y agoAm I the only person here who thought the whole "experiment" was "how much publicity can I buy for $100 initial investment?"