15 ms·
USPS Begins Postal Banking Pilot Program
- sandworm101 5y ago>> The post office charged Rothstein a flat fee of $5.95, for any amount up to $500. That is still an insanely high rate for a small check. At 500$ it might seem a small percent but I think many checks in this program will be far smaller.
- jlund-molfese 5y agoInteresting that it’s higher than competitive services like Walmart’s, too. But I guess the USPS pilot system is more accessible if people without IDs can use it.
- goodcanadian 5y agoIt sounds like the clerk was not terribly familiar with the system. It is possible that the correct procedure was not followed. I would be very surprised if you are allowed to cash cheques long term without showing ID. Otherwise, how do they know they are giving the money to the correct person?
- jlund-molfese 5y agoOh, yeah, you’re probably right. But that just makes the value proposition even harder to see.
- bubblethink 5y agoA passport as an ID would likely work, and one would hope that other forms of ID not tied to the immigration system would work too.
- sandworm101 5y agoI think it safe to say that the majority of americans without bank accounts and wanting to cash checks less than $500 don't have passports.
- bubblethink 5y agoThat's true. I was only pointing out that if this is meant to serve people in legal grey areas due to immigration (which may be a significant portion), that section of society may have some IDs although not necessarily a US license.
- jrockway 5y ago> Otherwise, how do they know they are giving the money to the correct person? I guess all those cameras in the post office can be connected to databases containing the necessary information. I am sure the federal government probably has at least a scrap of data about any person who spends enough time in the country to have a paycheck issued to them. Maybe they're using all the spying and tracking data for something good this time? (I don't really believe it, but it is possible. If someone in the federal government wanted to do ID-less check cashing, I bet they could scrounge together the necessary data and software contracts.)
- 8bitsrule 5y agoHopefully this works out well (the P.O. could use the income) and puts an end to the careers of the check-cashing sharks. This piece from 2013 [https://ellenbrown.com/2013/09/23/what-we-could-do-with-a-postal-savings-bank-infrastructure-that-doesnt-cost-taxpayers-a-dime/ https://ellenbrown.com/2013/09/23/what-we-could-do-with-a-po...] showed up on HN just over a year ago. [https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23911696 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23911696] Edit: quote from Brown: "Postal banking systems are also ubiquitous in other countries, where their long record of safe and profitable public banking has proved the viability of the model.... The leader today is Japan Post Bank (JPB), now the largest depository bank in the world.... Rather than using its deposits to back commercial loans as most banks do, Japan Post invests them in government securities."
- grecy 5y ago> the P.O. could use the income The P.O. is a service, it doesn't have need of income. Does the Department of Defence need income? Does Social Security need income? Does the EPA need income? No, because they're services, not for-profit businesses.
- HappyJoy 5y agoYes and no. I don't have to buy missiles from the DoD like I do stamps. It's a service but it's some weird quasi-governmental-business
- NoSorryCannot 5y agoIt's not unique in that respect. National parks, TSA precheck, and every version of the DMV are selling goods and services back to the public that bought them into existence.
- bryanrasmussen 5y ago>The P.O. is a service, it doesn't have need of income. no but it needs funding, has the funding been good over the last few decades?
- jlund-molfese 5y agoInteresting that the article refers to prepaid debit cards as “gift cards”. At first I thought USPS was only allowing checks to be transferred to Starbucks gift cards etc, which isn’t nearby as significant of a step.
- lpolovets 5y agoMaybe a dumb question, but why is the government getting into banking? Is this desirable? IMHO most consumer facing services they roll out are pretty poor. And for what it's worth, seems like Walmart and other companies already offer a service like this -- and for a lower price! See: https://www.walmart.com/cp/check-cashing/632047 https://www.walmart.com/cp/check-cashing/632047
- temp8964 5y ago> Maybe a dumb question, but why is the government getting into banking? I think all you need to do is considering banking as a basic human right, which can include everything. In addition, you can use race / gender / xx difference to make it an inequality issue, which again can include everything.
- helloguillecl 5y agoIt's not a bad idea in some cases: For example in Chile checking accounts were quite difficult to get for the poor until the state's bank [1] started issuing a bank account to anyone who requested it at $0 fixed cost, at a loss. This bank also: - Gives mortgages to sectors of the population in which banks are not interested. - Partners with small shops to offer financial transactions in low-income or very remote areas [2] or where opening a branch does not make economic sense. The social benefits are big and out-weight the costs/risks that would not have been taken by a private party. The bank even has healthy profits of around 350 MUSD per year that go back to the chilean state. Considering that access to financial services is fundamental to participate in the economy, I find it to be an excellent government goal. In this case it looks more to me a bit similar to the Deutsche Post's Postbank in Germany, that leverages their Post offices to offer financial services. [1] https://www.bancoestado.cl/ https://www.bancoestado.cl/ [2] https://goo.gl/maps/R22eAJd8B3LKnz8s7 https://goo.gl/maps/R22eAJd8B3LKnz8s7
- sofixa 5y agoSame in France with the Banque Postale arm of La Poste - you have bank branches in most post offices, so it's got great national coverage, fees are low, etc.
- pjc50 5y agoModernising the US banking system into the 19th century. > The move puts the USPS in direct competition with the multibillion-dollar check-cashing industry, which operates storefronts to allow unbanked or underbanked residents to cash their paychecks. I mean, great, but why are there all these unbanked people in the first place? Why are they having to pay a whole six dollars for something that could be a free instant direct deposit? Edit: I've just realised that the magic word may be resident. Let me guess, there's a significant fraction of (mostly nonwhite) US residents who can't produce enough proof of nationality to get bank accounts?
- bethling 5y agoYou also run into the situation where banks check your credit/banking history and may deny you an account based on that. My partner couldn't open a bank account for years because they forgot to stop an auto payment after they closed the account and moved. Those payments bounced, leading to fees, which kept compounding and even after taking care of that, it took a long time to figure out how to clear the mark on the report (I don't know if we did, or it just eventually fell off due to time)
- sofixa 5y agoIf it's a regular checking account, with no overdraft, the bank loses nothing from having a person like that as a customer. The only money they can use is their own that they deposited there.
- jonahbenton 5y agoIn US banking, many customers are relatively costly, with low balances, requiring branches with expensive people to service them. Overdraft happens often with them, and is a cost to the bank. They cannot be given credit, and are not otherwise candidates for other services by which banks make money. So fees- overdraft, deposit, withdrawal, desk usage, account- it is.
- nradov 5y ago
- encryptluks2 5y agoThe USPS doesn't need more money. It is broken from the inside. It is the last organization I'd trust keeping my financial information safe. Heck, if they offered email hosting they'd sell your data to spammers for next to nothing cause that is already what they do with postal mail.
- cowsandmilk 5y agoTons of people use the USPS every day for money orders every day, which require more trust than cashing a check…
- encryptluks2 5y agoYou know who else offers money orders? Walmart, Safeway, gas stations, and maybe McDonalds. Offering money orders is not banking.
- 542354234235 5y ago> It is broken from the inside. Mind elaborating on that one? A postal service that delivers 47% of all mail on the planet and serves millions of Americans that are unserved or underserved by other services. They did this for decades as a self-sufficient service that funded itself, and its current deficit 100% caused by Congress forcing them to pre-fund the health and retirement benefits of all of its employees for at least a half century in the future, something literally no other company or business has to do. Of course it was actually a plan to use that money to reduce the federal deficit.
- tryptophan 5y ago>literally no other company or business has to do. Actually every other company and business HAS to do this. Ever wonder why private pensions went away? I also am always amazed at how people point to this funding requirement as a bad thing. So it is now bad...to actually set money aside for benefits you are promising????
- 5y ago
- AussieWog93 5y agoI thought this was a parody at first. Is this really what banking looks like in the US?
- hathawsh 5y agoThis is how banking looks in the US if you can't maintain a balance of at least around $1500. This video is eye-opening: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aLwRZibUqL0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aLwRZibUqL0
- AussieWog93 5y agoYeah, most of those problems (with the arguable exception of the food deserts, at least in urban areas) exist down under too, or at least did until the banking Royal Commission a couple of years back. That video reminds me too much of my wife's experience before we got settled down. I wonder why nobody's solved this problem by now.
- thinkharderdev 5y agoI think part of it is that we've had near-zero interest rates for the last dozen or so years. So banks can't make any money from small balance checking accounts, hence the ubiquity of minimum account balances. The traditional business model of factional reserve retail banking just doesn't work that well with super-low interest rates.
- micromacrofoot 5y ago>I wonder why nobody's solved this problem by now. You can extend this thought to poverty in general. Very little would need to change to eliminate it entirely.
- AussieWog93 5y ago>You can extend this thought to poverty in general. Very little would need to change to eliminate it entirely. To be fair, many of the "rough edges" of poverty have been sanded down over the past 100 years or so in most developed countries. Poor people no longer face debtor's prison, starvation, lack of access to health care (with the exception of one notable country), a complete lack of education, lack of plumbing/utilities etc. In addition to this, much of Asia and parts of Africa and South America have graduated from dirt poor to middle or high income nations. That's not to say we couldn't do more, but the trend seems to be favouring the elimination or at least a sharp reduction in (absolute) poverty for the forseeable future, both in developing and developed nations.
- fredgrott 5y agohmm same lack of service that gov entities offer? And this is a good idea? Oh yeah we can get out of losses by making it up on banking fees?
- nceqs3 5y agoUSPS should expand into other services like Registered Agents, corporate bank accounts, etc.
- zikduruqe 5y agoDownvote this to oblivion, but I would love to see the USPS adopt some type of dollar backed crypto and put it into place with this. From inside their own processes it would be easy to implement and not as burdensome for their infrastructure as some other monetary software, and for the end users, any wallet app that would support whatever crypto would work, so that USPS didn't have to build their own.
- Lazare 5y agoBut...why crypto? It feels like such a poor fit. A digital central bank currency, sure, excellent. What do you gain from adding a distributed ledger to this?
- jononomo 5y agoAdopting crypto would send the USPS stock price to the moon -- and everyone would benefit in that scenario.
- danielhlockard 5y agoUSPS stock price? Remind me which stock symbol that is.
- standardUser 5y agoCongress has a shameful record of completely failing to regulate the check cashing industry. Even when they went after predatory credit card practices during the Obama admin, check cashers were somehow spared. It's reminiscent of how despite massively overwhelming public support, there never seem to be enough votes to reduce prescription drug prices. It would seem some lobbies are just too powerful to be overcome by compassion, sense or even mass public support. In light of those difficulties, this seems like an excellent back door solution to bury a corrosive industry that preys on the poor.
- 1-more 5y agoI've often thought about just setting up a table in front of a check cashing store and offering to cash checks for free with my mobile banking app. I HATE how expensive it is to be poor. Yeah I'd end up ripped off at some point but whatever.
- gruez 5y ago>I've often thought about just setting up a table in front of a check cashing store and offering to cash checks for free with my mobile banking app can you deposit other people's checks?
- sct202 5y agoPeople can endorse the check over to you on the back, but most banks won't accept it on mobile. And then if you want to deposit it in person at the bank, they may require everyone involved to be present because there is the risk of fraud. Last year someone stole a check from my mail, forged the signature and endorsed it to themselves and it got cashed successfully.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 1-more 5y agonever tried with an endorsed-to-me check since that has never happened in my life. Would be fun to try. Or a huge hassle.
- ilamont 5y agoI've seen successful postal banking running for decades in Taiwan, but this pilot looks extremely limited. In addition, the USPS has a hard enough time handling its core mission. It doesn't have enough staff, its budget is a constant state of crisis, and its technology is a kluged-together mess (as anyone who has used its website and app can attest). I really worry that this will be a distraction to counter staff and an additional bureaucratic and technology burden upon the agency itself.
- kadoban 5y agoIt would do its core mission a lot better if it can get an income stream that's independent from what Congress can fuck with easily, so this could very well help instead of hurt.
- aidenn0 5y agoThe US had a postal banking system for 55 years. It was dismantled by congress[1] 1: https://uslaw.link/citation/stat/80/92 https://uslaw.link/citation/stat/80/92
- Corrado 5y agoFYI, this happened in 1966. §5225. Discontinuance of Postal Savings System " (a) The closing date for the Postal Savings System is the thirtieth day immediately following the date of the enactment of this Act. On and after the closing date no deposits shall be accepted in existing postal savings account and no new postal savings account shall be opened. After the closing date the Board of Trustees of the Postal Savings System shall not be required to maintain the 5 per centum reserve of postal savings funds otherwise required to be maintained by section 5214 of this title nor to apportion deposits in banks in accordance with sections 5215 and 5219 of this title. "(b) Interest on deposits in the Postal Savings System shall cease to accrue on the anniversary dates of the respective certificates occurring in the twelve-month period starting with the closing date
- sschueller 5y agoSame here in Switzerland. The postal bank has existed for decades and works very well although constrained by law what it can do. Therefore you also don't hear their name in the news every time a tax evasion or some other financial scandal is in the news.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoGood. I'll just give a for-example. I was one of those dumbass kids who thought that I was going to be fine racking up a bit of credit card debt in college because I'd get a nice, high paying job the second I walked off campus. Then the tech industry imploded and it took a couple years (Katrina also happened in the mean time) and I ended up having a cratered credit score and on the business end of a lawsuit. So when I land my first dev job, I proudly walk into the local bank and ask to open an account. My credit score wasn't good enough. But I needed a place to store my money. The answer for me was Netspend, company of choice for most check cashing places, who charges you to hold on to money for you. Now, it could very well be that Netspend needs to charge that amount because people who use their cards aren't really people who can save much, but it seems like an inadequate way to service the population given that people need a practical way to interface with electronic banking regardless of how much they have or what their credit score is.
- someonehere 5y agoI was in the post office the other day. Understaffed and security cameras bigger than a shoe box. I did see a newer WiFi enabled webcam there, but it looked out of place. I think the Post Office makes an excellent choice (in theory) for banking. There’s almost one post office in every town, it can have better rates than traditional banks (through legislation or rules), and could be just as safe as a traditional bank. Then again the government will kneecap this somehow and fail the program.
- kube-system 5y agoThat’s because of regulatory capture that intentionally kneecaps it. Not because the government couldn’t run a good bank if they were allowed to.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThis is so damn frustrating: Certain group of politicians: "Government never works and should be minimized!" Same group of politicians: Completely kneecaps management and/or funding that would be needed to actually ensure government program works. Also same group of politicians: "See, government programs never work!"
- generalizations 5y agoSounds like a response to crypto, now that its starting to become useful for unbanked people (e.g. El Salvador).