11 ms·
Clean environment could become U.N. human right
- nixass 5y agoBritain is making rather poor choices lately
- jefflombardjr 5y agoThe US and Britain aren't saying no to a clean environment - BP, Chevron, and Exxon are.
- bottled_poe 5y agoAnd by further proxy, the public are.
- pjc50 5y agoPotato, potahto. (Of course, this is the problem with the traditional synechdoche of a country name for the policy of one particular government at one particular point of time...)
- blacktriangle 5y agoThey're saying no to a Chinese puppet org (the UN) using clean environment as an attack on them while China does nothing to address their environmental impact.
- z3ncyberpunk 5y agoChina has more renewable energy than any one in the world
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoAnd what fraction of their energy is that? They probably have more coal plants than anyone else in the world too. Citing raw numbers is pointless when China is involved since everything is so numerous there.
- chki 5y ago> while China does nothing to address their environmental impact At least it proves that this statement is untrue.
- cptskippy 5y agoAnd they also have the most lax environmental standards. Green energy is nice but allowing business to dump whatever they want into the environment isn't.
- lodovic 5y agoDoes that mean China and Russia approve of making a clean environment a human right?
- respondo2134 5y agoBetter this toothless, vague "human right" than any of the more basic, legitimate and critical ones from their perspective.
- selectodude 5y agoI would imagine China will demand a clean environment be a human right and then turn around and say they have no duty to help with it because they have been and always will be a “developing nation”.
- 5y ago
- oytis 5y ago> Washington also referred to legal concerns as well as worries that recognising new rights could dilute traditional civil and political rights, according to sources following the talks. Totally makes sense to me really. It's just enables genocidal dictatorships to go full "what about" when called out for their crimes. Yes, we just exterminated a small nation, but look how much U.S. companies pollute!
- girvo 5y agoI mean this as an honest question: why does that matter? Diplomatically, why would any other country care about a genocidal dictatorships pronouncements of hypocrisy? That already happens, and it already doesn’t stop sanctions and other consequences, from my limited understanding of geopolitics.
- oytis 5y agoIt matters as much as recognizing anything as a human right formally matters. U.N. is not good at enforcing human rights really, but it's better than nothing, and diluting it further is a step to "nothing" in my opinion.
- adventured 5y agoIt's not better than nothing. Entirely corrupting the definition of human rights by routinely putting the worst human rights offenders on the human rights council, is worse than doing nothing. It gives sanction to those human rights offenses by pretending those nations deserve to be on the human rights council, that they have earned equal representation on such a matter. The UN would be doing the same thing if this context were to become real. Nobody will be inspecting China, Russia or 37 other dictatorships for environmental human rights abuses.
- oytis 5y agoI agree it is a problem, but by "nothing" I mean the state before UN declaration of human rights, i.e. before 1948. I think we can agree that as of 2021 humanity has made some progress since then?
- mlindner 5y agoIf you declare too many things to a "human right" it removes wiggle room for good policy making. Also, the US already has stronger rules against vehicle pollution than the EU (in terms of pollution that directly damage health like NOx and PM). If it's going to become a "human right" then countries who propose it should be leading it in the first place.
- croes 5y ago>US already has stronger rules against vehicle pollution The whole US or only same states?
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoGenerally the rules are stronger and the (post sale) enforcement is weaker (because turning the screws on the poors over a check engine light isn't as tractable for us as it is for Europe, generally speaking).
- yostrovs 5y agoThe discovery of cheating by European manufacturers regarding emissions happened in America. But yes, the little guy can drive with a check engine light in my state without worries.
- Melting_Harps 5y ago> Generally the rules are stronger and the enforcement is weaker (because turning the screws on the poors over a check engine light isn't as tractable for us as it is for Europe, generally speaking). To be fair the amount of Diesel cars on the road in the EU with abhorrently poor emission systems is shocking; I was at VW during dieselgate, and worked with Bosch and VW during the buy-back program and VW are by far the only violators in the EU and in the periphery countries for lacking emission standards. I was behind mid 2010s diesel Opel for ~35km on my way to Slovenia and I have been in enclosed green houses with diesel tractors so I'm pretty sensitive to it, and it was so absurd that such a thing was allowed on the road. Typical check engine light failures (P14X/0420) are susceptible to modifications to pass if you know what you are doing, visual inspection isn't always as stringent as you'd think even with the STAR test sites in CA, which has the strictest emission laws in the World. When I was in motorsports we had a series of people we could rely on to pass our respective track-built machines on the road, but ultimately you realize that it's not worth the time, resources or risk and that the car (if properly built) no longer belongs on the road anyway. As an environmentalist who has struggled with addictions to 'car-caine' I've since downsized from a revolving inventory of 5-6 cars, and 3 motorcycles to one of each: what I think is even tougher is to actually make sensible policy and regulation regarding them without it being simply a way induce needless consumption. Case in point is the absurd World of the 2-3rd Gen Prius used car market and the catalytic converters, which has always had a lot of theft since it was released but have reached an Worldwide [0] extreme this year due to the astronomical rise in PM prices for those metals (inflationary pressure more than demand) so coupled with the supply chain shortages from Toyota and the rise in sudden demand many cars which were in compliance and within emission specs were simply scrapped because when Toyota couldn't deliver there was no other certified manufacturer for the part and something as simple not having a Toyota stamp was an automatic failure. Even though some owners reported emission testing within spec of counties within WA or OR which have less stringent standards than CA but still worth noting their compliance. Their insurance policies payout wouldn't cover a similar ranged car purchase and the only alternative was to sell it out of state and use that sum (usually half the cost of properly registered Prius in CA) and to buy another used one. 0: https://www.hotcars.com/heres-why-prius-catalytic-converter-theft-is-such-a-prominent-issue/ https://www.hotcars.com/heres-why-prius-catalytic-converter-...
- throwawaybchr 5y agoChina has been denying people human rights daily, what does the UN do to them?
- bamboozled 5y agoChina is a disgusting bully. They’re intentionally rattling people in Taiwan by flying war planes at them to “stress them out”. The UN is a joke. Something should be done.
- caoilte 5y agoThis is unhelpful whataboutery. China isn't directly relevant. I could just as truthfully point out that the USA is a disgusting bully and that would be unhelpful too. We wouldn't think it reasonable if someone on trial for embezzlement asked the jury to acquit because there are other people out in the world committing murder. We only put up with it in news and politics because we have normalized and accepted propaganda.
- bamboozled 5y agoWrong. The US is not flying bombers capable of carrying nuclear warheads at large populations just to intimidate them.
- fellodip 5y agohttps://apnews.com/article/europe-europe-air-force-russia-7ff508110cae77e6edf0ab6d9dc3d256 https://apnews.com/article/europe-europe-air-force-russia-7f... https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.newsweek.com/russia-mig-31-b-52-bering-sea-military-flight-1609890%3famp=1 https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.newsweek.com/russia-mig-31-... US does these things, its just not highlighted front page material in American press when it happens, so it goes unnoticed to American populations unlike when adversaries like Russia fly bombers near Alaska. Also US conducted similar maneuvers as what China did to Taiwan but to Iraq preceeding the Iraq invasion.
- chiefalchemist 5y agoTranslation: USA and Britian are big on globalization, and they don't want to be held accountable for any collateral damage. That is, for example, the Beijing smog, well those countries own a fair percentage of that. Off-shoring manufacturing isn't only about cost of labour. It's also about less (environmental) regulation. The USA is fond of highlighting it's progress on the environment, but it consistently fails to mention the problem wasn't solved, but most often simply off-shore'd. We also love to present as taking the high road on human rights. Something like this would ruin that (false*) narrative. * The USA's incarceration rate comes to mind.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThis article is weirdly devoid of relevant information about the objections. They mention legal concerns from Washington but don’t explain them for some reason. I’m also very confused about this line about halfway down the article: > The United States is not currently a Council member but is vying for a seat and can still join debates as an observer. Are they saying that the US isn’t even a voting member of the council making the decision? It seems like a huge exaggeration to say the US is interfering with the resolution when they’re not even voting yes or no on it.
- rtkwe 5y agoAny resolution from the UN has to get approval from the security council iirc so if the US or UK object it'll never be formally adopted by the UN. > They mention legal concerns from Washington but don’t explain them for some reason. Odds are they haven't actually been spelled out because they amount to "it'll cause huge disruptions to business because they'll all suddenly be suable for their decades of environmental damages". The government is maximally vague on these things so it's harder to actually refute.
- chki 5y ago> Any resolution from the UN has to get approval from the security council iirc so if the US or UK object it'll never be formally adopted by the UN. That's not correct. The general assembly can adopt resolutions and is meant to adopt resolutions by itself. Those resolutions are non-binding however. The security council needs to agree if the resolution touches on security relevant topics. And the security council is the only UN organ that can issue binding resolutions.
- aabaker99 5y agoWas going to say this and I'll further add that the GP, when referencing US or UK objections, is referring to the veto power that the permanent members of the security council, often referred to as P5, have on security council resolutions. Any one P5 member can veto to block the adoption of security council resolutions.
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> "At national level, this right has been shown to empower people, particularly those most vulnerable to environmental damage or climate change, to drive change and hold governments to account" Right, so one of the consequences would be that the US gives a bunch of activists permission to use the legal system to harass anything that they like — not just new projects, but everything that exists in the world. Perhaps we could go all Keystone XL on some Google data center for polluting the world with CO2 and global warming. You don't even need to believe in the cause, you just need to hate Google. Meanwhile nations like China spewing godawful particulates all over Shanghai will surely WILL FOLLOW THE SPIRIT OF THE LAW AND ALLOW THE LITTLE GUY TO SPEAK UP AGAINST THE ABUSES OF THEIR STATE RUN INDUSTRY. Mmmhmm. it's all stupid power games in the end, and this is NOT an effective way to get kids out of the NYCHA apartments slathered with lead paint (to use a local example)
- hikerclimber1 5y agoEverything is subjective. Especially laws.
- wayoutthere 5y agoSo because China won’t follow the rules, they shouldn’t exist and we should all spew as many particulates in the air as we can? Those activists are the only thing standing up for the interests of the people; the corporations have all the pull in the legislative world. Nihilism is a good way to justify acting against the common good, which is exactly why we need more drastic positive action against climate change. China will do what it’s gonna do, but we can choose a better path for ourselves.
- trasz 5y agoExcept that China is building nuclear like crazy. They are definitely not ignoring the climate change.
- zohch 5y agoHow does china building nuclear imply that they are not ignoring climate change? They could recognize that nuclear is a better source of power than coal, which most people would, and still not give a damn about the environment and/or climate change.
- rdxm 5y agoThe UN is truly a joke / shambolic entity. Just look at who sits on Human Rights council. As a US tax payer, I'd like to see the expense of supporting that entity move to some other nation state...we get zero value out of having it in CONUS, and it can't move the needle on anything.
- bob229 5y agoScrew the UN. It’s a morally bankrupt organisation that no self respecting nation should be involved with
- aaron695 5y agoJust because you want something doesn't make it a human right. A healthy environment for people is arguably a human right. A clean environment is not, and pathetic mental health arguments do not cut it else everyone gets whatever makes them happy. Biodiversity is also not a human right. Have we lost our minds and not understand English words? I guess the UN has become joke and the US and Britian are correct to ignore it. It's pretty disgusting behaviour give the billions of people missing real human rights still.
- RandomLensman 5y agoThis would be the ultimate blocking right to any large scale environmental engineering and change. But we will need that ability for change, the latest in a billion years or so... I don't understand the short-term, anti-growth thinking that has taken hold in recent years (we have been there before with forecasts of impending doom, of course).
- caseysoftware 5y agoWhat if it's not "short-term, anti-growth thinking" and simply "pro-control thinking"? Do the various statements, proposals, and policies make more sense?
- maccolgan 5y agoA "clean" environment is so subjective and temporal, I don't understand how it can be a "human" right... Why does UN keep digging into this hole of irrelevancy and bs?
- FredPret 5y agoAlso, if it is a right, who is to provide it?
- maccolgan 5y agoYeah, that too, it feels like this very easily can be used to violate sovereign rights...
- gnomewascool 5y agoWho is to provide, say, "a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family", which is also a basic human right, as listed by the original (1948) Universal Declaration of Human Rights[0]? The fact that there's nobody to provide it, doesn't mean that it's not a basic human right. [0] https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-huma...
- colpabar 5y agoI think people take issue with rights that must be provided by some external party because if said external party is not providing said rights, what do they really mean? Part of the argument is that human rights should only include "rules" that say what cannot be done to you, like us-style free speech, where the government cannot put you in prison just for saying something they don't like.
- gnomewascool 5y agoWhat about rights like the right to freedom from slavery or torture which, on the one hand, are about things not being done to you, but on the other may depend on third parties (for instance a government) from preventing people from doing these things to you? The declaration on human rights is not really government-centric, so the US-style free speech comparison makes little sense. > what do they really mean? They're a yardstick to measure how well we as humanity, and, more specifically particular regions or systems, measure up to what we, as humanity, consider to be the things that every human should (expect to) have. (Sorry for the bombasity.) For instance, if we lived in a libertarian/anarchist utopia, with no government, it would still make sense to ask whether people's human rights were being met.
- a_diplomat 5y agoHi. Diplomat working with UN issues here. The issue at hand here is not this resolution in itself. It's the fact that opening up human rights to "new" rights sets a precedent. And that precedent will be used by other countries to shift the language on human rights in a more authoritarian direction - or dilute human rights as such. So it's basically about using one set of issues, which in substance are hard to fight, to weaken human rights as a whole. But it could just as easily have been about something else, like the "right to development", which has been pushed by authoritarian countries for years.
- eli_gottlieb 5y ago> Hi. Diplomat working with UN issues here. The issue at hand here is not this resolution in itself. It's the fact that opening up human rights to "new" rights sets a precedent. And that precedent will be used by other countries to shift the language on human rights in a more authoritarian direction - or dilute human rights as such. You mean sorta like... the past 50 years or so?
- tomrod 5y agoSounds like this is why we can't have nice things! I'm pretty clueless when it comes to diplomacy. What is the drive for authoritarians? How do you negotiate with them, or otherwise limit their influence? (and is that desirable?).
- a_diplomat 5y agoLegitimizing their own models of governance, both internationally and domestically, would be their main driver in multilateral settings. In some cases, such as the ITU, it could also be about getting technical norms approved that mirror their state goals (https://www.justsecurity.org/75741/chinas-dystopian-new-ip-plan-shows-need-for-renewed-us-commitment-to-internet-governance/ https://www.justsecurity.org/75741/chinas-dystopian-new-ip-p...)
- mensetmanusman 5y agoWhere are there any reports that discuss concerns such as these? E.g. why is it hard to find the argument for why environmental rights could be at odds with civil rights?
- stooliepidgin 5y agoIn the US, TSCA grandfathered-in thousands of chemicals without any evidence of safety for purely economic reasons. Also, new substances aren't required to be tested for safety beforehand, so it's a "closing the barn door after the cow escaped" situation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toxic_Substances_Control_Act_of_1976 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toxic_Substances_Control_Act_o...
- sysihyk 5y agoUN can't even provide the very first human right, the freedom of expression. Neither can prevent acts of illegal war. Hence, this is just cheap populism exploiting current hype on "green" agenda.
- Proven 5y agoBullshit. The UN has no right to give privileges or take away rights. Globalist scum.