6 ms·
We have seen this story before. Person joins Facebook thinking they can "help". Then quits. Facebook is a public company whose purpose is serve advertisers.
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
We have seen this story before. Person joins Facebook thinking they can "help". Then quits.
Facebook is a public company whose purpose is serve advertisers. Online ads is the only way they can generate revenue. It is not some woo-woo about connecting the world, giving people a voice, or whatever. That's what the internet enables, not a single website controlled by someone else. Facebook tries to take credit for what is good about the internet.
Facebook is a barrel of fish, the website is the barrel, users are the fish (ad targets) and advertisers are the shooters. For advertisers and FB investors,^1 things are going great. Except for the bad publicity.
1. Attempts to oust Zuckerberg, the root of the problem, will always fail.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/betsyatkins/2019/06/07/facebook-strong-arms-investors-who-want-zuckerberg-out/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/betsyatkins/2019/06/07/facebook...
There is nothing to fix. As other commenters point out, the "solution", for users, is to stop using Facebook and use other means to communicate over the internet that do not require middlemen, third party intermediaries and interlopers that seek to sell online ad services and are determined to conduct ever-increasing levels surveillance and personal data mining.
- temp8964 5y agoIf what you said is true, how is Zuckerberg "the root of the problem"?
- salawat 5y agoHe has majority control of the company. There is no balancing input. As long as Facebook is around with Zuckerberg at the helm, he is by definition the root of the problem.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- moonchild 5y ago> use other means to communicate over the internet that do not require middlemen The internet is a middleman.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoThen any communications medium is a middleman — postal mail, telephone, even telegraph. Maybe the only exception is speaking face-to-face. There’s no middle-man there.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoSound waves are the middleman, only direct telepathy will do.
- torgian 5y agoBut here, air is the middle man, so maybe the solution is skin to skin contact.
- fredgrott 5y agothe solution is re thinking the business model, we already have a successful model its called Discord. No ads, just premium services for users.
- the_fire_friar 5y agoI will be pleasantly surprised if Discord could reach a $1 trillion dollar market cap on that business model.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoOh yes, an IRC service and a blog really need that kind of $ to thrive. /s
- nabaraz 5y agoI think OP is making the case that all ultra-successful companies eventually gives up on ethics and their founding principles.
- ipaddr 5y agoDiscord has reached a phase where many users would like to replace them and other startups are looking for a way to replace them.
- turminal 5y agoSelling user data to third parties is no better than showering them with ads.
- ineedasername 5y agoDiscord doesn't appear to be profitable yet. Or, at least they don't appear to have ever said they were, and have taken about $500m in funding w/ about $220m in revenue since 2016. They seem to be on a solid path, but I think it's too soon to hold them up as an archetype of a social networking service that can be massively successful on a freemium/subscription revenue model. I also can't think of any company close to the size of facebook that is free for "users" rather than charging for their software/services. That doesn't mean it's impossible, but we're looking for a black swan event to change that, and it's unclear if Discord is going to have the hockey stick growth to make that happen, or if its recent increase in revenue is even sustainable as Covid becomes less disruptive.
- xwdv 5y agoThey really need to filter out these kind of people in the hiring phase. Edit: And there goes the last bit of my karma. Incredible that I once had close to a 1000 karma, and then one day slowly but surely it dwindled down to nothing.
- reginold 5y agoThe "Mother is a priest" filter
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chrismcb 5y agoFacebooks purpose isn't too serve advertisers. Most for profit companies propose is to make money. Facebooks primary way of doing that is asking ads. But they can't sell ads without plenty of eyeballs. Their FB needs to also pay attention to the users.
- ineedasername 5y agoUsers are a supplier, an input, a resource used to make the actual product. Facebook cares as much about that supplier as a company cares about any other supplier. They'll push for the lowest possible prices and push the supplier as hard as they can without breaking the relationship. Facebook will do as little as possible to benefit users, min/maxing as close to the breaking point as they can without going over the line.
- lukestevens 5y agoIt’s a strange pattern [0]: [Sophie Zhang] joined Facebook in 2018 after the financial strain of living on part-time contract work in the Bay Area had worn her down. When she received Facebook’s offer, she was upfront with her recruiter: she didn’t think the company was making the world better, but she would join to help fix it. “They told me, ‘You’d be surprised how many people at Facebook say that,’” she remembers. [0] https://www.technologyreview.com/2021/07/29/1030260/facebook-whistleblower-sophie-zhang-global-political-manipulation/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2021/07/29/1030260/facebook...
- vln 5y agoI said the same thing. It's how I rationalized selling out for a company that does harm to the world.
- mountainb 5y agoIt has to do with how the university educated are socialized. They believe it's gauche to admit to pecuniary interest when looking for a job. They have to make it like a quasi-religious mission for which they are incidentally paid. It's intensely stupid. Obviously Facebook invites it and has consciously adapted its recruiting message. Back in the 2000s before the financial crisis it was popular to portray the young as nauseating money grubbers who just wanted to get a job in banking. That wasn't great either, but I would rather honest greedheads rather than greedheads who lie to themselves and others about what they're doing with their lives.
- raxxorrax 5y ago
- bamboozled 5y agoFacebook is a public company whose purpose is serve advertisers. Online ads is the only way they can generate revenue. It is not some woo-woo about connecting the world, giving people a voice, or whatever. That's what the internet enables, not a single website controlled by someone else. Facebook tries to take credit for what is good about the internet. I truly think it could move away from that model by innovating ? Disclaimer: I don't like FB, work there, I don't use it personally, I do use Instagram though.
- nradov 5y agoInnovating is hard. Companies get attached to existing revenue streams. That's the classic innovator's dilemma. https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Pages/item.aspx?num=46 https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Pages/item.aspx?num=46
- pod9 5y agoThey can break it up. Seperate out WhatsApp and Instagram. Promote competion between all the networks over safety, privacy issues etc Lot of things can be done. Look at what happened to Rockefeller.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> There is nothing to fix. Sure there is: advertising. It's the root cause of nearly all evils in the internet today. Facebook itself is merely a symptom of the advertiser problem. The web and the internet will never be fixed until we get rid of the advertisers. Either we ban advertising or we spread ad blocking technology far and wide.
- manquer 5y agoMore Ad blocking won't solve this in the long term, it will become an arms race. If ad blocking becomes pervasive then there will be more efforts to evade blocks, starting with technically ( operationally difficult) solutions like hosting ads first party etc. There is simply too much money today in it for the industry to go away quietly. Ad-blocking as a tool can help address the security issues with a trusted service hosting all sorts of unknown ad scripts that can potentially have malware and/or scrap your data, but issue of ad's itself can sadly not be controlled with ad-blocking only.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> it will become an arms race It already is. > starting with technically ( operationally difficult) solutions like hosting ads first party Already happening. Those ads are still getting blocked. > There is simply too much money today in it for the industry to go away quietly. Agreed. We need to drive them out. > issue of ad's itself can sadly not be controlled with ad-blocking only Why?
- manquer 5y ago> Why ? Because it is asymmetric battle. Content Platforms ( not only digital) already insert native advertising or do product placement, these are harder or impossible to block technically, and quite hard cognitively to differentiate as well. Also Google is removing web APIs and actively making its browser poorer and controlling the web standards that is making it increasingly technically difficult to block ads, it is much harder to block ads on mobile platforms where most users are, only Firefox supports an ad blocker at all and Mozilla generates 95% of its revenue from Google . We need better regulations not better ad-blocking to protect vulnerable users . More common ad-blocking becomes more aggressive the counter measures will be, given Google's control of Android and Chrome (that also gives them influence of Edge(based on Chrome) and to some extent Safari - Webkit heritage ) they can easily effect changes that makes it impossible or extremely difficult to block ads.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- joelbluminator 5y agoYou are exaggerating. Facebook IS providing real value to some users. For example - when I lived abroad a few years and started missing people from my home country, a Facebook group was there to talk and meet. It solved actual loneliness. Instead of individuals trying to create stand alone websites and invest time and money and effort, Facebook made it super easy to connect. My wife used a pregnant lady / new moms Facebook group in the city we were living in etc etc, it brought a lot of good info and comfort to her. Another example is their market place; it became super easy to buy used stuff in your city (I don't know if it caught in the U.S but in Europe this is becoming popular). People buy less new stuff, save money and help the environment. That's also good right? I can go on and on (for example people who put their business on Facebook and get actual clients). Not all interactions on Facebook are bad.
- whitepaint 5y agohn crowd is living in a specific bubble.