24 ms·
DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
- LurkingPenguin 5y ago> “The protocol can easily absorb a loss of $90 million and a lot of it will likely be returned, but the larger issue would be if people lose confidence in the system’s ability to function properly,” said Greenspan. Why would anyone ever lose confidence in a system that sent $90 million to users as a result of a “one-letter bug” in an "upgrade gone epically wrong"?
- quantified 5y agoCan you lose what you never had to begin with?
- Ekaros 5y agoSo code isn't the law? Why does anyone trust these systems that keep failing time after time? If they need to ask money back and really have poor recourse? Didn't current banking and legal system to develop just solve those issues?
- drfxyjhdyfrhgc 5y ago>So code isn't the law? Code is law. This law was just written incorrectly. This is a known risk; it's the reason why defi interest rates are similar to junk bonds.
- automatic6131 5y agoYes, let's turn the [financial|legal](delete as appropriate) system into an obfuscated C competition. Last place prize is: [lose your life savings|spend life in prison].
- beambot 5y agoCurious. I would claim that our current finance and legal system frequently does the very same for the impoverished or disenfranchised... Underbanked get hammered by fees with no safety net for emergency expenses. And large portions of our population get saddled with poor legal representation resulting in de facto indentured survitude in for-profit prisons.
- pavel_lishin 5y agoThat's a fair criticism of the current system, but not a good justification for introducing another shitty, broken system as an alternative.
- sneak 5y agoYou don’t need a justification for giving people more choices that they’re free to ignore if they don’t like the terms or circumstances. More options are better. Nothing about DeFi or cryptocurrencies invalidates or prevents people from continuing to bank as usual. The whole alternative system is opt-in.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoI don’t understand why anyone, even an enthusiast, would dare to touch cryptocurrency lending with a forty-nine-and-a-half-foot pole. There’s no technical measure that can force me to pay back the coins I borrowed if I don’t have them. If you wanted to enforce being paid back in the real world legal system you’d be much better served with normal lending systems, know your customers, and report them to credit authorities. And if it’s not one of those “stablecoins” you’re borrowing something that could conceivably be worth 10x more in a year; that sounds like financial suicide. What do you possibly gain from engaging with all this? Maybe if I built a defi lending platform myself so I could take a lot of loans from my customers and then default. That’d work just fine. Otherwise, run for the hills.
- yokem55 5y agoBecause the only way to get a loan is to put up collateral that is locked into a contract. And that collateral can only be extracted if you pay back the loan. So, if you value the collateral less then your debt, then, sure, walk away. But if the value of that collateral falls to less then the liquidation threshold (an amount some percentage greater then the value of your debt), your debt will be paid back by a liquidation bot and the the liquidator will take your collateral for themselves.
- UncleMeat 5y agoThere is a huge problem with the collateral model: liquidity. If you put up $X in FOO_COIN as collateral and FOO_COIN starts tanking in value, the contract is supposed to auto-liquidate once it hits a certain point. But there is absolutely no guarantee that this can find a buyer. So the "guaranteed" collateral recovery is not exactly guaranteed.
- bhaak 5y agoHow is that different to traditional finance? Evergrande almost went belly-up as the prices of their real state fell sharply because they sold so much of it to cover their credits. The financial crisis from 2007 was because the collaterals were nowhere as sound as they were sold for. Don’t get me wrong I think it’s mostly a house of cards but crypto finance is just traditional finance on steroids IMO.
- sremani 5y agoIf Code is law, the compiler is the judge.
- canjobear 5y agoIf the code is the law how can it be incorrect? It can only be incorrect by comparison with some other law (like "the code writer's intentions"), in which case you are effectively making that the true authoritative law, rather than the code.
- SkipperCat 5y agoAnd that is the crux of the issue. Modern banking has tons of fees and burdensome regulations, but it also has entrenched layers of protection that makes sure both the bank and the customer are not 100% nuked when there is a problem. Bank runs like from the movie "Its a wonderful life" - they don't happen anymore. Currencies devaluating like an exploding balloon - not since the civil war. Sure, it costs you more, but it saves you more. Lotta benefits to crypto, but lots of hurdles need to be overcome (power and security for a start).
- iso1210 5y ago> Bank runs like from the movie "Its a wonderful life" - they don't happen anymore. Another example of a bank run is the bank run of Northern Rock on the 14th September 2007. This was the biggest banking problem in the United Kingdom since the banking crisis in the seventies, this was also the first bank run in the United Kingdom in 150 years. Eventually, this resulted in the nationalization of Northern Rock. It is interesting to analyze this bank run because it is one of the most recent bank runs in Western Europe. Furthermore, the bank run from Northern Rock is a special case because it was a ‘reversed bank run’. Normally during a bank run, a lot of depositors first withdraw their money, due to lack of confidence for example, and then the bank will as a result of the huge withdraws get into a liquidity crisis. However, in the case of Northern Rock, the bank first got into a liquidity crisis and as a result of that, depositors withdrew their money from the bank. https://arno.uvt.nl/show.cgi?fid=116241 https://arno.uvt.nl/show.cgi?fid=116241 It certainly looks like a bank run - the scenes in London today fulfilled the dictionary definition. And heading north to Nottingham, and Middlesbrough, the same extraordinary scenes. savers forming long queues to drain their life savings from Northern Rock. Banking -- an industry built on credibility, confidence and trust. But the Rock looks wrecked even in its home town of Newcastle. Deposit guarantees should prevent this. But even after an extraordinary unlimited lending facility granted by the Bank of England and agreed by the Chancellor, customers preferred the sight of real cash. https://www.channel4.com/news/articles/business_money/the%2Bnorthern%2Brock%2Bbank%2Brun/802462.html https://www.channel4.com/news/articles/business_money/the%2B...
- zinekeller 5y ago
- Tenoke 5y agoThat's like asking why people trust sites or banks after some sites or banks have had bugs. In neither case does it invalidate the whole concept.
- endisneigh 5y agono it's not
- wyager 5y agoCode hasn’t been law for “defi” since Ethereum reverted the DAO hack in 2016. Then the DAO went defunct later that year anyway!
- bhaak 5y agoNot “anyway“ but because of the hack. TheDAO was done for after it was hacked. The code was too bad and trust was gone as well. That was clear pretty soon. The only thing to decide was if they would let the hacker get away with at the time 15% of the whole supply. If they did that it would have endangered the decentralization of the eventual proof-of-stake switch.
- wyager 5y ago> it would have endangered the decentralization So they decided to kill it outright?
- bhaak 5y agoYou have to specify what kind of decentralization you're getting at. The distribution of ETH was less decentralized before the hard fork than afterwards. 15% of the whole supply in one hand is quite a concentration in the distribution.
- canjobear 5y ago> it would have endangered the decentralization So the solution to save "decentralization" was for a centralized cabal to literally rewrite history?
- bhaak 5y agoTechnically, there was no rewriting of history. Just a single (but very large) transaction was added to the consensus rules that (IIRC) replaced the TheDAO smart contract code. Given that this incident resulted in the Ethereum/Ethereum Classic split, the "centralized cabal" was not very effective. The community voted with their feet and many went to Ethereum Classic.
- xiphias2 5y agoWhile I'm not into Ethereum itself, lots of the failures you see are happening because the infrastructure for (mostly) decentralized finance is moving at an incredible (and irresponsible) speed. We're witnessing the modern version of old bank robberies that helped create the regulations.
- hda2 5y ago> So code isn't the law? Why does anyone trust these systems that keep failing time after time? If they need to ask money back and really have poor recourse? Didn't current banking and legal system to develop just solve those issues? As far as the crypto itself is concerned, of course it is. The issue here is that the founder is using another system to blackmail users. The fact that this founder had to resort to tactics like these (instead of reverting the mistake on his end) shows that these systems are working as advertised.
- 0x0 5y agoIf you keep 10% and return 90% you still need to report the 10% to the IRS.
- kevingadd 5y agoHe's offering not to tell the IRS though, what's a little tax fraud between friends?
- DennisP 5y agoIt's not like Compound is able to do KYC on its users. There's nothing they can tell the IRS that the IRS can't see by just looking at the blockchain.
- yokem55 5y agoNo, but most folks have addresses (with maybe one or 2 degrees of separation) that have interacted with centralized exchanges that have done the kyc. The only way to truly anonymously get assets in the Ethereum world is to run the funds through tornado cash (slow and expensive) or bounce through the shadiest non-kyc exchanges who very well could just pocket the funds you try to put through them. You might be able to mine your way to anonymous funds, but that is even more expensive in terms of power and equipment costs.
- DennisP 5y agoYes, but my point is that any information Compound could give the IRS is already public on chain. The IRS can just read it themselves.
- cesarb 5y agoI wonder if that's really the case. It's also possible that, if you kept 10% and returned 90%, you'd still have to pay tax on the 100% (that is, the 90% you returned might not be deductible).
- aloe_falsa 5y ago
- Malic 5y agoThis is totally Peter G. Neumann* territory. Something to add to a second edition of his book, "Computer-Related Risks", if he ever makes one. http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/risks/ http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/risks/
- qeternity 5y agoHeadline is misleading: the founder has threatened to doxx and report them to the IRS if they don't return funds which according to the Compound protocol, they rightfully own anyway. Notch it up to another first for crypto.
- ed_elliott_asc 5y agoCan’t the people who have the money just pay the tax themselves? Seems like the easiest way to keep the money and stay on the right side of the threat?
- hef19898 5y agoSo it would seem. EDIT: Also profitable, taxes should be less then 90%. Just out of curiosity, isn't DeFi motivating users to defraud the IRS by promising 10% without reporting it as income? EDIT: Come to think of it, if they are offering 10% without reporting to the IRS, which is obviously less than after taxes, would it be reasonable to assume all revenue / profits have not yet been reported to IRS as revenue?
- nikanj 5y agoCryptos used for tax evasion!?
- hef19898 5y agoWho would have thought, right?
- dangerface 5y agoHow tho? How can i get my crypto into dollars without paying tax or using an offshore business that facilitates the tax evasion.
- pc86 5y agoYou're probably unlikely to have anyone knowledgeable lay out the exact means by which crypto can be used to evade income taxes, but it's a pretty well known that it's used that way.
- Glench 5y agoMan, it feels like this has been happening a lot. I guess this happens when you have what is essentially JavaScript code on the EVM handling vast sums of money.
- bcrl 5y agoIt's almost like there's a reason banks try not to "move fast and break things"...
- snowwrestler 5y agoBanks break things too, but they typically operate within legal structures (laws, regulations, and contracts) that supersede broken code.
- bcrl 5y agoYes, but banks tend to have policies and procedures in place where large transactions require multiple parties to review and approve. When those procedures get broken, it's usually a result of fraud and appropriate legal actions can be taken. While DeFi can implement these kind of policies and procedures, the rate at which seemingly undertested (untested?) code is being deployed and given unfettered access to a large values of tokens definitely falls under the "move fast and break things" category. Clearly the people involved don't grasp the level of risks they're taking or there would be a heck of a lot more emphasis on QA over deployment-to-the-blockchain.
- nathias 5y agobanks break things all the time, thats why crypto exists
- ashtonkem 5y agoThat’s a pretty glib and incorrect way of explaining crypto’s creation. Really, it was created because of the misguided belief that the fed breaks things, not “banks”. Basically, it was goldbug ideology on steroids. If we’re comparing who “breaks” things more, crypto or banks, crypto will lose every single time. So far I’ve never had my bank account wiped out and the website replaced with a single page that says “penis”.
- vmception 5y agoCan anyone shed light into why Robert Leshner jumped into the fray at all? Its not even an issue and some people got rich. People know how to report income to the IRS themselves. edit: okay I see his followup tweet saying he wanted to act on behalf of the community and considered the prior tweet boneheaded. Just normal amateur hour with amateur founders in crypto.
- meigwilym 5y agoSometimes I wonder if crypto is making the mistakes that led to regulation for standard money systems.
- deepsun 5y agoBy all means crypto coins are assets, not currency.
- rsynnott 5y agoI mean, it's making many of them, but DeFi/"Smart Contracts" is a novel mistake. "Due to misdrafting of a contract we have to give all of the bank's funds to a cat" isn't a thing that happens in the real world; while contract mistakes can be expensive, the sheer ridiculousness common in DeFi-world is unique and new.
- rsj_hn 5y agoSuperficially, the mistakes are different, but the evolution is the same. E.g. the original goal of bitcoin was to be a digital form of cash. Cash because the transaction is just between you and the buyer - cash is a bearer instrument. With ACH it's a custodial relationship with the bank, and the bank's interest may not be aligned with yours. They can decline transactions, freeze your funds, monitor what you do, etc. So there was less "ownership", and this true ownership combined with digital payments was the original vision. Except that true ownership is really limiting. Sometimes you want the intermediary or need money held in escrow and that's when you want a custodial relationship. So enters Etherium and the notion of contracts. Now it's no longer payer and payee, but you have the contract sitting between the two, much as the bank. And just as the bank, the contract can act against your interests. Now it's true, the specific ways that you get screwed by the smart contract are different than by the bank. Next up, we are seeing the need for adjudication/rollback for when the custodians screw up, as people want to unwind errors in smart contracts or make policy changes. So this will be like re-inventing the court system. Soon, someone will be able to sue you and put a lien on your digital currency, using smart contracts, for example, with appeal to an adjuticating system that can force you to enter into the contract against your will. Then we will be back to longing for the days of bearer currencies.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- m00dy 5y agoAs of Today DeFi has 83B as total value locked in. 90M is just a small fraction of it.
- cryptica 5y agoIMO, if the project is truly decentralized as they claim, then the recipients of the tokens should be entitled to keep the funds. That said, I hope the SEC will investigate this to rule out a scheme in case the bug was an intentional way to launder tokens to insiders.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> Compound is the world’s fifth-largest DeFi protocol with a total value locked of $9.65 billion, according to DeFi Llama, which provides ranking and metrics for DeFi protocols. So they lost 1% of the total funds due to a bug. And their solution was to threaten to dox the users.
- vmception 5y agoCompound is a YC company, lol, can you cancel that CEO to force greater decentralization? He shouldnt have said anything, their protocol already allows for user contributed code to get merged in so its already distributed enough and doesn't need him. They can find someone else to click “Merge Pull Request” and redeploy contracts.
- danfritz 5y agoI have never had "bugs" from my bank or money that suddenly got stole / removed from my account. Yet in crypto land this seems to be daily news. Far too much trust and too little control in systems like DeFi. It all sounds wonderful in theory but we fail to see the big impacts of human errors.
- naasking 5y agoNever had fraudulent charges on your credit card?
- robjan 5y agoThere's a mechanism for putting that right
- NullPrefix 5y agoComplaining on social media isn't really a sound mechanism.
- cortesoft 5y agoEvery time I have had fraudulent charges on my credit card, it was the credit card company who spotted it and reversed the charge before I even notified them.
- NullPrefix 5y agoGood for you. Everytime there was a virus on a computer, the antivirus spotted it and reversed its actions before I even noticed them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thehappypm 5y ago
- icris 5y agoif i were them i would rather invest it and return later w/ interest
- driverdan 5y agoConsidering what it was created for Solidity is a very poorly designed language. It has many foot guns and unsafe defaults. I really hope something much better replaces it. DeFi has so much potential but running on Solidity makes it high risk.
- alfiedotwtf 5y agoYou might be interested in Tezos' Michelson
- version_five 5y agoIt's so weird to see these scams running in full view of the public and casually discussed as if they're not basically just criminal ponzi or mlm schemes dressed up with some jargon. Hopefully when this ends up collapsing, it will be public and clear enough that "tokens" etc will have the same credibility as a Nigerian prince asking to help transfer money, but in this case I feel like there is always more lingo to keep dressing up the scams as something new, e.g. NFTs. I don't generally like government intervention, but I do hope the "real" financial system is sufficiently isolated from these scams so their collapse won't cause problems.
- Sebb767 5y agoThe housing and stock market are not that much better at the moment. Just look at the market cap of Tesla.
- space_rock 5y agoWhat a pathetic comparison
- acdha 5y agoTesla provides things people outside of the auto industry want to buy. You might quibble about details (FSD in particular) but there is no shortage of people wanting to buy Tesla’s cars to use, not resell. Cryptocurrencies have failed to do the equivalent – that’s why the pitch is “buy in now or you’ll wish you had later” rather than talking about things you could actually do that you can’t do as well now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Sebb767 5y agoTesla's value is approaching a trillion USD, approximately six times the value of the whole Volkswagen group. You can believe in Tesla or not, but that valuation is clearly hoping for a future where Tesla dominates multiple industries. I don't see much difference to people investing in any insanely valued coin because they think it's the future of payment.
- grandpoobah 5y agoDoes anyone know what the one letter bug was, or can anyone speculate as to what that one letter bug might look like?
- addingnumbers 5y agoSomeone upthread claims they had a > where a >= should be, but didn't provide a source.
- bigodbiel 5y ago"Tradition is a set of solutions for which we have forgotten the problems. Throw away the solution and you get the problem back. Sometimes the problem has mutated or disappeared. Often it is still there as strong as it ever was" Substitute tradition for "regulations" and you have "Uber of X" or "hot start up industry disruptor" in a nutshell.
- admax88qqq 5y agoWhile that's true, often times tradition and regulation are not the best solutions to the problemx certainly not as technology has evolve. Not to mention much of the time regulation is not a solution at all but rather just means to protect incumbents. Edit: To be clear, I agree there is tons of bullshit going on in crypto and DeFi, but I also believe that the existing players are ripe for disruption if they weren't regulatory protected. There's no reason why I shouldn't be able to do a bank transfer instantly, or why I can't pay a a small business electronically without a large fee going to Visa.
- fouric 5y agoI'd like to add nuance: tradition seems to oftentimes be a mix between actual solutions to problems, and legacy cruft that can be safely removed without undoing the fix to the problem. Large, active codebases have to be occasionally refactored to keep them understandable, and this refactoring can often be done without a loss of functionality - why would the law (or tradition) be different? In particular, it feels like much of the legal system is a bunch of hacks grafted onto existing (oftentimes much older) laws, and that there's an opportunity to rewrite the laws and merge the hacks in to form a cohesive whole.
- alfiedotwtf 5y agoCode is Law* * unless core developers are adversely affected
- ludamad 5y agoCode is law! also vigilante justice by powerful actors, though
- optimalsolver 5y agoI still don't get how the Ethereum core devs can look themselves in the mirror after undoing the DAO hack. All smart contracts are immutable, but some are more mutable than others.
- swapneeltr 5y agoCode is not law and never has been, consensus is law. The Ethereum community (technically, node operators) as a majority decided to rollback the blockchain and it would have been impossible to do so otherwise. The community was tiny barely three months after launch and this would be much harder to orchestrate today.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> The price of Compound’s native token, COMP, initially plunged nearly 13% in a day on news of the bug That’s it?
- seibelj 5y agoIt's actually up 7.5%
- throwdecro 5y agoI wonder if the price is being supported by people opening accounts in COMP hoping to get free money from the next mistake.
- ctvo 5y agoIf this isn't incentive to sign up for as many half-baked crypto platforms as possible, I don't know what is.
- stemlord 5y agoCould have just as easily taken 90 million from users tho
- ctvo 5y agoIn case anyone reading this is unsure, DO NOT deposit 90+ million USD into half-baked crypto platforms.
- danuker 5y agoIt's enough if 9 million people fall for $10.
- CobrastanJorji 5y agoYou're both right. We need to run a meta-scam where we create a visibly half-baked crypto currency in the hopes that a million investors hoping for a windfall from a software bug invest $10 each. Announcing CobrastanCoin. Motto: "Commits are forever!" For security, code changes are pushed instantly and can only be rolled back after 30 days. Our crypto dev team is our founder's brother's son Doug, who we hear is a whiz with computer things. We're looking into hiring someone to review Doug's code, send us a resume if you're interested. Our Coin IPO auction is in two weeks.
- paulpauper 5y agoNo way he getting anywhere close to the $90 million back.
- paulpauper 5y agoThe IRS is the most understaffed, underfunded, overworked of the major agencies. Its alleged power is mostly an illusion of the media. I know someone who made over $1mm in a year and didn't pay taxes. just kept delaying it and got a lot of letters. A decade later still has not paid it. now the FBI and Secret Service are way worse though.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nielsbot 5y agoThat 10% “white hat” bonus is also taxable as income, right?
- mcintyre1994 5y agoPay back 90% or I'll make sure you have to pay massively less than that in tax doesn't seem like a particularly strong threat?
- bob229 5y agoCrypto is absolute garbage. Just an idiotic solution to a non existent problem and only used my cranks and criminals. Get a life people
- optimalsolver 5y agoWhat's the average amount of loss that gets rugged crypto individualists begging for an intervention from Big Daddy Government?
- NelsonMinar 5y agoThis is good for Bitcoin.
- alangibson 5y agoThe article implies it's common for recipients to return a lot of the tokens in cases like this. Anyone have any clue why? I would thinks there is 0 incentive to return free crypto.
- elliekelly 5y agoJust a wild guess: To maintain faith in the system? I don't know anything about Compound aside from what I've read today but I would imagine whatever you've got invested could quickly go to zero if the crypto-investing public decides the protocol is too risky. (Assuming, of course, there exists an upper-limit to their risk tolerance.)
- swapneeltr 5y agoReturning the money elevates the hacker to "hero" status within the crypto community. By keeping the funds they risk getting doxxed and having serious legal action taken against them. Additionally, if the funds are a sizeable portion the entire project might fail rendering their token useless.
- joshstrange 5y agoI have no current interest in DeFi not do I have any DeFi related crypto (Full disclosure: I have very minor Doge/ETH/BTC holdings). I know it's fun to kick DeFi when it's down and make fun of "code is law" and the like but all of this leaves me with a very queasy feelings especially when the same comments praise our current financial system as if it has figured this all out and only idiots try to reinvent the wheel. All I can think of is 2008 and how all our financial institutions royally screwed us and almost no one went to jail and no one was held accountable (I think 1 person went to jail and they were a small fry). Does the exact issue that happened here happen in our current systems? Yes, but it's fixable. That said, much worse things happen and they can be swept under the rug/ignored. I don't put much faith in DeFi but I also put very little in "fiat"/"regular" financial institutions.
- qwerty456127 5y agoAt least in some European countries you can sue a person who refuses to return the funds transferred by a mistake and win inevitably. I have been such a person who got money this way (from a particularly rich company which earns its money a legal but morally questionable way so I have no remorse) and has been forced to return + pay the legal expenses (which can be pretty affordable in Europe). I never meant to actually keep the funds forever but used the lucky event as a loan :-)
- Zitrax 5y agoI am also a bit confused by this. I have definitely read before that you can't keep money payed by mistake. Is this different in the US or is this some difference with cryptocurrencies vs normal banks?
- arisAlexis 5y agoImagine how far this is from a utopia where all finance is running in defi. Singularity will come first.
- tfang17 5y agoCode is law.
- sam0x17 5y agoWho thought Compound would give us accidental UBI
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoThe founder "threatened" them by telling them that if they don't return it, it'll be reported to the IRS as income. Crypto is a weird place when this comes across as a threat.
- 9935c101ab17a66 5y agoUh, what? > “Keep 10% as a white-hat. Otherwise, it’s being reported as income to the IRS, and most of you are doxxed."
- gigatexal 5y agoHaha. Bank error in my favor. Hell no am I giving anything back. It’s getting converted to fiat ASAP end of story.
- mdoms 5y agoCryptocurrency is a circus.
- olliej 5y agoI have a couple of questions that I hope someone more versed than me can answer: * Isn't the rule of crypto currencies and the like that the code is explicitly the contract, so if the code says to give people money then that is "legally" binding? * Doesn't the IRS, etc still consider crypto currencies to be assets, not currency, so you'd only declare income on sale of the asset, not acquisition?
- jl2718 5y agoTL;DR: Reward pool drained (5% of COMP). User funds safu.
- princekolt 5y agoCryptocurrency bros are hilarious. In one breath they’ll claim the government is evil and they’re building tech to circumvent government control, and in the next they’re threatening people to weaponize the government against them if they don’t fix their massive fuckup.
- 9935c101ab17a66 5y agoI unfortunately just spent some time on Twitter reading about this debacle, and the number of crypto bros attacking anyone remotely critical of DeFi was astounding. They're all throwing around the term 'TradFi' as a pejorative — it's so weird.
- curiouspear 5y agoAs father always used to quip, “possession is nine tenths of the law”. Good luck with your endeavours, Compound /s
- quadhome 5y agoBank error in your favor