4 ms·
Ampere Altra Max 128-Core CPU Is Priced Lower Than Flagship Xeon, EPYC CPUs
- formerly_proven 5y agoMichael Larabel probably knows this, but nobody pays list prices in these segments. Especially not for Intel CPUs, not now.
- tmikaeld 5y agoYou're of course right, but this signals that Ampere might negotiate even better batch pricing.
- dogma1138 5y agoAmpere probably won’t see a wide enough adoption to justify volume discounts right now. I wouldn’t be surprised if offer funds for companies to buy into their ecosystem in the first place.
- Retric 5y agoGenerally true, but sometimes individuals and small companies do pay list prices. And of course Ampere can always discount prices for bulk orders etc.
- dogma1138 5y agoSmall companies buy from system integrators that get volume discounts. Individuals at this point probably buy them off eBay especially the “ghost” SKUs that are only available for exascale customers.
- gautamcgoel 5y agoIf I was building a cloud company and wanted 1000 CPUs, how could I go about getting a discount below list price?
- rafaelturk 5y agoI'm still puzzled: Ampere list show at least 16 SKUs, imagine dealing with 16 different fabs, circuits, packages, specs, sales. This feels like Intel marketing shenanigans from 2000's.. Having this insane number of different is a common marketing stuff, that nowdays I found hard to belive ads any value to a business. Moreover, given the current Fab issues, and supply constraints keeping a clean & simple fabrication process, distribution, and sales pipeline actually is an advantage. Can't help remembering Steve Jobs famous quote when re-gained controll of Apple. 4 producs Matrix: Consumer, Pro vs Portable, Desktop. Again kudos for Apple: That continues to design one or maybe two CPUs per year and heavily optimizes, efficiency, scale, logistics, etc.
- drewg123 5y agoIsn't it the same CPU, just differing numbers of cores with different clock rates and different TDPs? I'm assuming that at least part of this is just due to binning, where the best samples are 3Ghz high core count, and the lower samples have cores fused to disabled and run at a lower TDP/clock. Its not like Intel, in that Ampere does not seem to play games with memory channels/clock, PCIe lanes, different accelerator features, etc.
- ksec 5y ago>Isn't it the same CPU, Yes. They are on the same die. ( Or may be two Die, Altra and Altra Max ) You can tell or guess by the same amount of Memory Chanel and PCI-E Lanes across the line up. And also bin for yield as well. So you just fuse off the parts / core with defects.
- delroth 5y ago> I'm still puzzled: Ampere list show at least 16 SKUs, imagine dealing with 16 different fabs, circuits, packages, specs, sales. That's probably not what's happening though -- more likely, this is 1-4 different chips with aggressive yield management and some cores being fused off for the most entry level SKUs.
- kllrnohj 5y agoApple does multiple SKUs, too, such as the 7 or 8 core GPU options for the M1. They can otherwise mostly get away with fewer SKUs by currently not really having either a budget option of the M1 (eg, no 6 core CPU variant) nor a high end option. That'll almost certainly change as they roll out Apple silicon to the iMac Pro & Mac Pro. The fewer SKUs therefore isn't a result of impressive engineering but rather impressive profit margins. They just don't care about salvaging mostly-working silicon as much as Intel, AMD, and now Ampere.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoDoes anyone have some more real-world benchmarks of the Ampere part? The article implies that it performs similarly to the high-end Intel and AMD parts, but the linked benchmarks are mostly synthetic tests like Stress-NG. There are a few Blender benchmarks ( https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=ampere-altramax-benchmarks&num=4 https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=ampere-a... ) but the rest of the tests aren’t really relevant to real workloads.
- kvathupo 5y agoMany benchmarks fail to capture that if one were programming for speed, intel CPUs seem to be the default option by virtue of the intel compiler, unless you use a HDL [1]. It's quite interesting how hardware manufacturers have been able to capture market share due to their software offerings, see NVIDIA with CUDA for almost any deep learning library. [1] - https://www.agner.org/optimize/blog/read.php?i=49 https://www.agner.org/optimize/blog/read.php?i=49
- ksec 5y agoYou could test it on AWS Graviton 2, the benchmarks will be similar given they are both based on N1. The only differences are cache, PCI-E and Memory.
- TheCondor 5y agoFWIW, dollar for dollar, Graviton2 is impressively quick.
- TheCondor 5y agoIf they filled in the low-end a little bit, maybe a 3Ghz 32core part for like $1500, I could see buying this kind of system.
- ac29 5y agoThey do have a 32-core SKU, but its 1.7GHz. $800. Appears to be targeted for power consumption.
- system2 5y agoAnd what can you run with 1.7ghz exactly?
- genewitch 5y agoLiterally everything... I just decommissioned a 2010 40 core Intel that ran around this clock under full load, because the power consumption was outlandish. Replaced with 5950x and it benches within ten seconds on "all core kernel compile" - time make -j16 on new and time make -j40 on old. Realistically I'd be happier with more threads for what I do, 100% of the time. I have "high clock" CPUs for single threaded workloads specifically so I don't fall into this 'ghz matters' trap.
- MR4D 5y agoWould love to see the IOPS/core for this like they did on Intel/AMD [0]. [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28706762 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28706762
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoLooks like the Ampere Altra Q32-17 exists basically as a development board so you can make sure your workload can be moved to the platform. I wonder how it compares to a 5950x... 16c/32t vs 32c/32t but the AMD is over 2x the clockspeed. I wonder how L3 & memory bandwidth compares. It would be really nice if there was a system that could be built for around $2000 that could compile chromium & other massive applications in ~30 minutes.
- rektide 5y agoi really dig the $800 65w 32core. although it has really low clock too. but it seems to have the full 8x ram & 128x pcie4. meaning this could be an intensely good data pusher. and way way cheaper than similar amd offerings.