5 ms·
Interesting deep dive on switching power supplies. I didn't see the need to frame it by attacking Apple.
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
Interesting deep dive on switching power supplies. I didn't see the need to frame it by attacking Apple.
- retrac 5y agoAt the time, "Apple invented the switching power supply" was a notion going around in bad tech/sci reporting circles, so it deserved dismantling along with the power supplies.
- fortran77 5y agoIt's only right to clear up a falsehood promoted by Steve Jobs himself. He's not above scrutiny.
- amelius 5y agoFake it till you make it.
- fortran77 5y agoWell, he’s dead and I’m still here. I don’t think he made it.
- type0 5y agoMaybe he would still be alive if he didn't try to fake his cancer treatments https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/alternative-medicine-extend-abbreviate-steve-jobs-life/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/alternative-medic...
- perl4ever 5y agoYou don't have to like Jobs, I never did when he was alive, but shitting on him (as is now a cliche) for his choices of treatment is an awful reason. The peanut gallery is not to be trusted on how curable his cancer was, and this article says nothing firm about anything. If someone chooses not to be tortured for their last weeks of life, in order to have those weeks, that doesn't make them unscientific or suicidal.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> If someone chooses not to be tortured for their last weeks of life, in order to have those weeks, that doesn't make them unscientific or suicidal. Yes, if that's the motivation. But if the reasoning is "I have a better treatment, [insert nonsense here]", it does.
- perl4ever 5y agoI remember reading something by Art Spiegelman, whose father was a Holocaust survivor, about how his life felt unimportant because nothing could compare to what his father went through. But then, he rhetorically asked, if surviving the concentration camp was success, did that mean the vast majority who didn't were losers? And I think his father said something to the effect, that it was random, there was no "survival of the fittest", so no, matter of factly, the dead were not ones who failed.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoOh you're absolutely correct about that. Jobs in particular needs to be scrutinized. But if that was the point of the article a few paragraphs under the section "History of switching power supplies to 1977" already accomplished that. The article reads like it was written by a power supply enthusiast (who knew?), and the author did a good job of drawing me into the history, technology. It would have still been an interesting read without the "bookends".
- smoldesu 5y agoJournalism doesn't become any less interesting by making connections to the greater outside world, especially when it's timely/contextually relevant.
- CamperBob2 5y agoA couple of good examples of (much) earlier switching supplies from Ken's site: 1) 1960s-era tech used in the Apollo Guidance Computer: https://www.righto.com/2019/08/reliable-after-50-years-apollo-guidance.html https://www.righto.com/2019/08/reliable-after-50-years-apoll... 2) Mercury thyratons used in 1930s-era Teletype hardware: https://www.righto.com/2018/09/glowing-mercury-thyratrons-inside-1940s.html https://www.righto.com/2018/09/glowing-mercury-thyratrons-in... Might be some other candidates as well, but those are a couple of the more interesting ones he's gone over.
- kens 5y agoThe motivation for the article was to investigate Steve Jobs' claim, so it would be strange to remove that.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoI do wish your blog articles had the published date at the top.
- kens 5y agoIt's my subtle protest against the HN belief that people need to be warned against articles from previous years. That said, it's a bit alarming to realize I wrote the article 9 years ago.
- segfaultbuserr 5y agoHi, kens. This is my n-th time rereading this article, this time I noticed a small typo. Footnote 90, "More recent VMR specifications" should've been "VRM".
- kens 5y agoThanks! I've fixed it now.
- otterley 5y agoThat’s a curious stance, considering that “News” is in the very title of this site, and presumably a description of its content and intent.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI think it's just context to help people better understand what they are reading.
- darkteflon 5y agoAgree - a date is often absolutely essential to placing what you’re reading in context. I always look for one at the top of any article I read, and assume based on past experience that the lack of one is usually indicative of clickbait (although clearly not in this case).
- Hello71 5y agothe first sentence of the article: > The new biography Steve Jobs it was a response to the new biography.
- echelon 5y ago> I didn't see the need to frame it by attacking Apple. Other posters have already pointed out that this article seeks to clarify the history around Steve Jobs' (not entirely accurate) claims. I want to focus on the fact that people find a need to protect Apple. Apple is a 2T+ market cap corporation. It is not a friend, it is not a family member, and it is certainly not beyond reproach. It doesn't care about you -- it just wants you to spend more money on its products and services. Don't feel bad for Apple when people call it out for bad behavior or historical inaccuracies. People should do this. While there are people that work at Apple that legitimately care about making good products, in the macro the predominant factor is still money. It drives the whole enterprise. The very shape of Apple's solutions and good will are fit by an optimization function to obtain money. Brand, supply chain, innovation, fierce competition, fostering loyalty, building a moat. These are the things Apple does. It's a machine that makes money selling products. You might like Tim Cook, Steve Jobs, or many of the other product people and engineers there. That's fine. But don't form a fond bond with the company. And also realize the motivations of the leadership. They're humans -- they can do good, but they can also make mistakes and tell lies to serve their own needs. If Apple makes products you like and enjoy, buy them, appreciate them, and leave it at that. Don't let Apple create a sense of nostalgia, closeness, or loyalty. This is artificial. The company doesn't care about you at all. It can't.
- FpUser 5y ago>"I want to focus on the fact that people find a need to protect Apple." I do not think they're trying to protect Apple. They are protecting their choice. Same as people "protecting" Python, Rust etc.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoThe article is debunking this claim by Steve Jobs: "That switching power supply was as revolutionary as the Apple II logic board was," Jobs later said. "Rod doesn't get a lot of credit for this in the history books but he should. Every computer now uses switching power supplies, and they all rip off Rod Holt's design."’
- ForOldHack 5y agoWhich like the GUI was ripped off from someone else: The GUI was stolen from Xerox, and the switching power supplies were ripped of from an oscilloscope company, Hewlett-Packard. Didn't Woz work for them. Hmmmm...
- briandear 5y agoThe GUI wasn’t stolen. It was licensed. That it was stolen is completely false. And on switching power — did any other computer company think to use it? Apple did. And borrowing that tech did revolutionize computer power supplies.
- kalleboo 5y ago> The GUI wasn’t stolen. It was licensed. That it was stolen is completely false. Not only was it not stolen, several Xerox PARC people moved over to Apple since they wanted to see their ideas actually commercialized and not squandered like Xerox was doing, so a lot of it was even the same people!
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoRead the article. Many computer companies used them before apple. Apple's use didnt revolutionize anything according to the article, because it was already in common use before them. Did we read the same thing?
- giantrobot 5y ago> The GUI was stolen from Xerox Stolen...right. Xerox invited Apple's engineers to tour PARC and then Apple gave them millions of dollars of shares which Xerox later sold for a hefty profit. IIRC they made more off the Apple stock sale then sales of the Alto and Star.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoPushing false or unsubstantiated information is the attack. Investigating it and presenting facts and counter points is defense.
- djmips 5y agoTotally agree, that aspect made me roll my eyes. Very unnecessary even if it provides a skeleton for the narrative.