8 ms·
> We now have better mobile networks and having no internet becomes a rare case even in remote locations. That's simply not true. There is no internet on many
by nicbou 5y ago
> We now have better mobile networks and having no internet becomes a rare case even in remote locations.
That's simply not true. There is no internet on many parts of a train journey. There is no internet in parts of the underground rail network. There is no internet on the plane. There is no internet in nature. There is no mobile internet outside the EU, until you get a new SIM card. There is no usable internet in some hotels.
If you travel a bit, you know that internet is far from guaranteed.
- glanzwulf 5y agoAnd even within the EU, it's not guaranteed. I'm currently in Berlin and the internet here is ass. My current provider dies on me at least once a day and the speeds are atrocious. Mobile network is also weird. Every time I go into a store for shopping I lose my connection. Once I come out I get a cute text message saying "Welcome to Germany, don't forget to get tested"
- nicbou 5y agoI'm also in Berlin. I know what you mean. It became a personal joke to note that the most remote corners of the world have better internet than parts of the Ring.
- pvtmert 5y agoA fellow Berliner here. Never understood this. I live inside the A ring, yet if I am not standing close to window, even the regular call doesn't work.
- masklinn 5y agoSounds like the building is well shielded. My flat is the same, essentially no signal inside, just open the window and I immediately get full strength LTE. Ask your provider for a microcell, if you want to change the situation (and often waste less battery, unless cellular is disabled smartphones tend to dislike not having signal or having poor signal quite a lot).
- jamil7 5y agoYeah same. Doesn’t work in parts of my apartment or Treppenhaus or Hof at all, also doesn’t work in shops for some reason which can be surprisingly annoying if I quickly need to look up something for a recipe or message my girlfriend to ask if we need something. Data is also absurdly expensive.
- tapia 5y agoMore like a German thing... This happens to me in Stuttgart, too. If I want to make a call when I'm at home, I usually just call with Signal over my wifi, because the normal cellular network is terrible.
- ben_w 5y agoI’m curious if this is the location or the building; either way is relevant to me when I next move. Altbau or new?
- scns 5y agoInternet? We don't need that newfangled bullshit, we build the best cars in the world /s
- TeMPOraL 5y agoAlso: there's no Internet in random buildings, underpasses, corridors - even in the middle of a metropolis. For example, a grocery market near me somehow manages to attenuate cellular signals so badly there's no mobile connection more than 3 meters inside. Meaning no Internet when I walk between shelves, and no Internet when I stand in a queue for 10 minutes. (Sure, the building has plenty of wired and wireless Internet connections in it, but I'm not allowed to use any of them.)
- vadfa 5y ago>no Internet when I stand in a queue for 10 minutes That must be hell.
- m12k 5y agoWell, it makes the "download our self-checkout app" posters they throw at you while standing in line pretty useless.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoFor someone not prepared, maybe. But the point is, those 10 minutes are exactly the "low quality" time I could spend doing something useful with your app, instead of using "high quality" time for it (e.g. when I'm in my office). But if your app doesn't work off-line, I can't do that.
- p_l 5y agoYes, it can be hell. Especially when you find out you need to make a quick bank transfer so that the purchase will go through (There's a certain shop in Warsaw which has dead zone for cellular internet near the checkouts, I always need to double check before going to pay...)
- vadfa 5y agoI wasn't being sarcastic, seems like people took it the wrong way :P Personally I would've gotten pretty bored.
- yarcob 5y agoYou are technically correct but the quote you are replying to is taken out of context and does not represent what this article is about.
- nicbou 5y agoIt's the quote used to introduce the premise.
- squiggleblaz 5y agoI think the point is that even if you grant this significant apparent limitation of the premise, it doesn't mean the whole thing is useless. (Nevertheless, the presentation is still incoherent, because it both welcomes and disparages data with multiple current states in semi-independent databases.) Even if we have perfect and constant connections, you still obtain benefits by writing in this model: for instance, if you assume you have a constant and perfect network connection, you can connect a websocket to the server to ensure you always have the current data for each page and data type. Or, you could follow the offline first model and have a singe update/subscription system to mirror the database locally. I'm very nervous about their presentation. It says "offline first" and "websites lie because they show you the current state of the data at the last time you had a network connection". If the latter is a problem, a lie, then you can't possible write offline first. You might write using a model that works equally well online and offline, but you necessarily accept forking data and multiple current representations if you allow a computer to show the data without being connected to the authoritative repository of that data. I think the author has many good ideas, and might have a very good implementation of a very good set of ideas, but this intro page reads like the sort of thing that gets misinterpreted a dozen times and you end up with something worse than current interpretations of "premature optimisation is the root of all evil".
- DharmaPolice 5y agoBut isn't the rest of the article more true if reliable internet access isn't available? Their opening remarks about poor internet access now being rare is followed by >So do we even need offline first applications or is it something of the past? Their premise isn't "now internet access problems are solved we should use offline first ", it's "even if we we say that internet access is solved, we should still use offline first".
- tasogare 5y agoThose are country development and political choice issues. Last time I took the train (this weekend) it provided a free wifi access all long and I hadn't any cut. I can't remember last time I took a subway and hadn't 4G connectivity. Oh, actually I do, it was in Paris but I wouldn't dare using my iPhone there anyway. There technology is there but Western governments at all administrative levels are more busy bullying their citizens than providing comfort options like East-Asian administrations and companies are.
- nicbou 5y agoI'm not moving to another country to get better cellphone reception. What's your point?
- Hauntingjackal 5y agoTheir point is probably that improving the reception in your location is a political rather than technical issue. I.e. it can be solved.
- pfranz 5y agoIn my experience, subway connectivity got markedly better when the city hosted the Olympics and spent time/money attracting tourists. This was in line with more open wifi access or sim card availability.
- owlmirror 5y agoThat buildings shield reception is not a political issue but a physical limitation. When I'm in my super market I know that I will not have reception in the back, same in the underground part of my fitness center.
- vkk8 5y agoApparently it's not. I live in Finland and I've never had my internet connection cut off in a supermarket (or any other large building). This has happened to me sometimes in Southern Europe, though. I don't know if they boost the reception somehow in large buildings here or if the building materials are just somehow different.
- BatteryMountain 5y agoHe should make a few trips to Africa. Some MNO base stations are powered by solar and only operate a few hours a day, sometimes a full day and sometime a partial night (depending on batteries, if they have). Not everyone has electricity, so people walk to town to charge their phones at spaza shops for a few minutes/hours. Fiber/POTS is non existent. Outside of larger town and cities, reception is non-existent or spotty at best. You might get reception near a highway.
- pfranz 5y agoMy understanding is when a cellphone has weak service it boosts the signal to try and reach a tower. In my experience, it feels like it drains the battery incredibly fast. Are there OSes or phones that accommodate this?
- Tor3 5y agoThat's correct - if the signal is weak the battery is drained quickly. I'm not aware of any OS or phone which can mitigate that - is there any other way than to give up on the connection?
- safanycom 5y agoAn extra phone or device as a hotspot
- pfranz 5y agoIf you're battery constrained and not expecting a signal most of the day I imagine you could put the radio to sleep for 5-30m. I kinda understand a weak signal getting boosted and draining a battery, but when there's none at all? It just seems like a use case they didn't care enough to address. Since it sounds like this is the primary use case, I figured someone might have tried.
- BatteryMountain 5y agoTrue. I notice it when out camping in the mountains where there is no reception. On airplane mode the battery can easily last 2 to 3 days max but if you leave airplane mode off, it will die within 1 day.
- hansor 5y agoAmen brother! Nothing worse then some JS based APP using 2G/3G in Africa. Its not about speed but latency and packet drops :/ No one optimizes for this stuff. Makes the internet unusable even if you have nice bursts of 100kb-2mb/s sometimes.
- WA 5y agoYou can write wonderful JS-based offline-first apps.
- NullPrefix 5y agoThe question is not whether you can, but whether you will.
- scns 5y agoWhether others who wrote the app you need to use did?
- remirk 5y agoYou should read the rest of the article and realise the author actually agrees with you. The comment you are replying to is taking the quote out of context.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoExactly. And even if there is, there may be: - a small bandwidth - a limited contract - a huge ping - regular network errors And even with a good, unlimited network, local will always be snappier than doing a round trip.
- goodpoint 5y agos/ping/latency/
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoI've always been unclear of the difference between all the terms. Whats the diff between "ping", "jitter" and "latency"?
- adrianN 5y agoping is what the ping program reports, which, depending on the QoS settings the provider has, can be very different from the roundtrip time of packets you actually care about.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoCan you explain to me why and how this can be different?
- adrianN 5y agoYour provider can for example filter out all ICMP packets giving you timeouts for "ping", but you can still reach the host just fine with other protocols. Similarly your provider probably prioritizes protocols that require low latency like VoIP over ICMP packets.
- Dylan16807 5y agoAlternatively, they might prioritize small packets and ping will be misleadingly fast compared to bigger data flows.
- fasteo 5y agoHeck, there is no internet a in corner of my kitchen; a couple of steps to the side, and there you go, full 4G coverage.
- Macha 5y agoPeople have been saying this for a decade, and I still sit there realising how different a bubble a lot of commenters here live. I visit my parents most months. They live in rural Ireland. Not like a one off build down a back road miles from civilisation, but a small village of a few hundred people. They absolutely do not have reliable internet, and at this point they've cycled through every available provider. To visit them I take a few hours train journey. For about half this train journey the internet is not reliable, whether edge/3g/4g or onboard service. Before the pandemic, I visited the US a few times a year, United's onboard internet is very limited, expensive, and reliability is "it sometimes works". So I regularly run into cases where I need to prepare ahead of time for no/spotty internet and still get surprises as some app refuses to launch because it decided now is the time it needed to update over a connection that's doing single digit kilobytes per second, or speak to a license server or whatever.
- jcims 5y ago>People have been saying this for a decade, and I still sit there realising how different a bubble a lot of commenters here live. Nearly every thread involving cars or traffic also makes this abundantly clear.
- Enginerrrd 5y agoNo kidding. Not to mention the disdain for things that are nearly essential in rural areas: 4wd trucks and gas/diesel instead of electric vehicles, or the right to carry firearms. I live in rural PNW. Electric is at LEAST 20 years from being a feasible and reliable solution. ...and I say that as a civil engineer with some specialization in creating EV charge stations. 30-50 might be even be more plausible. When I'm in the field, small things can turn into life-and-death situations pretty quickly out here when you're an hour and a half drive from cell reception, followed by another hour and a half drive to town with a small hospital/sheriff station, and you're up a dirt road where a tow-truck simply won't come. And the geology is notoriously unstable and slides/washouts/fallen-trees happen constantly. My clients LIVE in those places, I only visit. They drive big diesel rigs (They often NEED to transport big heavy stuff, and you can store diesel for long time periods in a tank onsite), and a lot of them also have transfer tanks in the back of their truck for extra range. (Because it's needed!) They also almost all carry food/water/shelter/A chainsaw/tools/a gun/etc in their vehicle for a reason. Self-rescue is all you got a lot of the time.
- pdpi 5y agoThere's a few subtle points here. One is that I don't think the article actually disagrees with you — it just assumes internet access is readily available for the sake of argument, and moves on to explain why offline-first matters even despite that. The more interesting point is that "internet access is flaky" isn't necessarily a good argument for going offline-first. Rather, it only suggests that you need your client to be more resilient to being knocked offline in an online-first world. Rather, the article argues that an offline-first is interesting unto itself as a completely different architecture that's closer to a desktop application where the binary is delivered through a browser. Put differently — they're not trying to argue you should make Gmail work offline, but rather that you should consider structuring your application as Thunderbird inside the browser.
- dsizzle 5y agoYeah, I did not expect the comments of a pro-offline-first article to be filled with complaints that he didn't consider lots of places don't have reliable internet!
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoYep, Ikea in Ljubljana (slovenia), vilesse (italy) and klagenfurt (austria)... no mobile reception inside. They have wifi, if you remember to connect to it.
- ldehaan 5y agoWhat's interesting is if you go to Columbia, South America you get signal everywhere, even in the jungle, because when the cellular companies came in and asked if they could create a network Columbia said sure, but it had to work everywhere, even in the mountains and jungle. We could have internet everywhere if our governments gave 2 shits and wasn't corrupt as all get out.
- Macha 5y agoTo be fair, you'd get a surprising amount of the public objecting to building infrastructure for mobile networks in "scenic" areas like jungles or forests
- NikolaNovak 5y agoDon't even have to travel far. We live in "golden horseshoe", the greater Toronto metropolitan area with 10m people and I am shocked how many towns have horribly poor service (and it has also made me realize how inefficient / data hungry most modern messengers are).
- j1elo 5y agoYou don't need to go to a remote area either; there is absolutely zero signal in large parts of the subway in my (European) city. I'd like to see the author enjoying his "better mobile networks" while traveling around there. So yes, offline first is still a very nice thing to have.
- forgotmypw17 5y agoAlso: People who just do not have service for accessibility reasons. I meet many people who only use WiFi either because they can't afford service or can't deal with the paperwork or some other reasons.
- nicbou 5y agoOr because they used up all their data for the month.
- vidarh 5y agoI live in London. There are spots in London where mobile data just randomly does not work. Clapham Junction - the busiest rail station in the country was often a black spot for me just a couple of years ago. The rail corridors in to London often have sections with no 4g and variable 3g.