13 ms·
As I understand it, China has hypersonic missiles and nukes, whereas the US does not. Should a conflict in the South China sea break out, China could nuke US c
by echelon 5y ago
As I understand it, China has hypersonic missiles and nukes, whereas the US does not.
Should a conflict in the South China sea break out, China could nuke US carrier groups assuming their satellites aren't taken out first. That spells game over for US projection of power if successful.
China could deploy air and submersible drones to get around downed satellites, but these have the potential of being jammed with EMP, other drones, etc. It could become a game of cat and mouse, and if the carriers get close enough, China's land-based missile defenses are toast.
Is the US developing hypersonics for close combat? How does this fit into a South China sea conflict, or does this assume the battle is closer to home? (If China goes blue water, is this meant to combat their carriers?)
If, when, and where will the theater be? What will the outcome be?
Would the conflict be limited to the coastal regions, or would it spill over into nuclear MAD?
Will either side back down?
I'm super curious about all of this, and I'm interested in more sources to follow. I don't know enough to understand military/navy Twitter.
- masterof0 5y ago> What will the outcome be? Judging by what we did in Afghanistan, not good. I hope we don't send thousands to die and/or kill other people. If they invade the US, we fight, otherwise, we shouldn't be policing the world. I don't see the benefits of a war with China, or any other country at all.
- emaginniss 5y agoWhat if they decide they want to gobble up Taiwan, Vietnam, Japan, Australia, etc? Should we just sit back and say "it's not us, so this is fine?"
- jjoonathan 5y agoDoes Taiwan have nukes? EDIT: google thinks no.
- patagurbon 5y agoNo, but they have been identified as a "nuclear latent state", in that they possess the capabilities to create one. How long that latency is I'm sure no one really knows.
- protomyth 5y agoHasn't the rumor always been that they got a nuke from Israel or South Africa?
- justicezyx 5y agoLegally Taiwan and Mainland are in a civil war for the legitimate government of the one China. One China is the "policy" of US China and Taiwan. Of course, Taiwan want to get rid of that. China will risk a nuclear war to prevent that, and US is OK with either, preferably let China bleed the most with minimal cost. These are as obvious as the sun hanging over the sky. China had no ambition for territorial expansion other than defending herself. That's the pattern for 2 thousands years. China indeed has historical claim over Taiwan and South China Sea. How strong that translate to modern legal system, that's up to debate. But extending China's territorial ambition beyond historical claims is not only disgenious, it's propaganda. Hi, propagandist?
- emaginniss 5y agoPerhaps you haven't noticed that China has been building islands and claiming the sea around them. In fact, they claim the entire South China Sea as territorial waters. They routinely send their fishing fleets into the legitimate territorial waters of other nations. As they are starting to struggle again with the size of their population, expansion will seem like a natural solution.
- justicezyx 5y ago> China has been building islands and claiming the sea around them Of cuz, that's known everywhere. Chinese netizens are ecstatic about this ingenious move that fenced off SEA countries from meddling the water area in any way that could affect China's claim over them. > They routinely send their fishing fleets into the legitimate territorial waters of other nations They are just self directed business man. Just like the numerous business man who invaded almost every Asian countries in the early 1900s. These fisherman would have been invading all-over the places if they were in 1900 as well. Of cuz, not like the 1900s, these fisherman are not going to be protected (very strongly) by their home country when they were caught. > they are starting to struggle again with the size of their population, expansion will seem like a natural solution. Well, almost everyone is expecting the population to be dwindling from now on. A lot have calling the recent census fake, because they all expect a population drop. Not sure why this population driven expansnism holds itself...
- masterof0 5y agoAre they going to gobble up Japan, Australia and Vietnam tho? I'd say nope, doesn't makes sense, for them. What's up with the war fetish? Do you enjoy watching people killing each other? I really don't understand.
- bllguo 5y agoI think citizens of the most violent nation in recent history should do some introspection before projecting their misdeeds onto others..
- throwaway6734 5y agoHow recent is recent history?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoClearly more recent than April 15th, 1989.
- zeusk 5y agoor the on-going uyghur concentration camps
- bllguo 5y agoVietnam, Afghanistan, Iraq, coup after coup in South America - you think Tiananmen was more reprehensible than any of these? I'll also remind you Tiananmen was internal, whereas all of our wars are just that - wars. Directed against other nations. edit: to clarify, I don't see how Tiananmen suggests China will go to war, but I do see how a sordid history of spurring violence across the globe suggests the US will go to war again.
- bllguo 5y agoat least a century?
- evilos 5y ago"What if X happens?" "Shut up, Y is bad." Uh.
- bllguo 5y agoOkay, then give me the reasons to believe in imminent Chinese military aggression. And why I should take the word of a nation that has been basically ceaselessly at war for decades, off the heels of yet another senseless conflict in Afghanistan. I think you are projecting the warlike tendencies of the US onto China.
- mrlonglong 5y agoOn the other hand, if China was to adopt the Taiwainese constitution and embrace democracy then yes, they could reunify.
- newaccount2021 5y agothere is no chance a US carrier could be nuked without a proportional response
- justicezyx 5y agoThe hypersonic missle won't carry nuclear war head. The impact is enough to render a CV lose combat capability. The modern weaponry are delicate machines. A 50s computer might withstand an earthquake. The modern one probably won't survive a drop less than 1 meter.
- lampington 5y agoA 50s computer would have been largely glass vacuum tubes and dropping it would cause quite a lot of problems. And a modern computer would be fine in an earthquake if it didn't fall off something or have something heavy fall on it.
- jamiek88 5y agoYeah was just thinking that! That analogy may have worked 20 years ago but everything, including notably storage, is solid state now and way more durable.
- post_from_work 5y agoThe US Navy does shock tests, where it detonates large explosives underwater close to its carriers, for exactly this reason. These ships are way more durable than you give them credit for. https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/41181/shocking-images-americas-newest-aircraft-carrier-endured-explosive-tests-off-florida https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/41181/shocking-images-...
- sudosysgen 5y agoLol, no. The water stops explosions. A direct hit by a 10 ton mass going at Mach 7 will destroy any ship. the Navy won't make tests for that because it's a foregone conclusion.
- mzs 5y agoDF-17 + DF-ZF & Xingkong-2 https://gjia.georgetown.edu/2021/01/27/chinas-hypersonic-weapons/ https://gjia.georgetown.edu/2021/01/27/chinas-hypersonic-wea...
- 3pt14159 5y agoFollow Arms Control Wonk. There's a bunch of OSINT folks in the podcast slack channel including friends of mine that have been interviewed by magazines like The Economist. I'm there more for the cyberwarfare takes, but from what I understand nobody is seriously worried about a power imbalance between China and America regarding missile speed since interceptors aren't accurate enough, but that's just me regurgitating what I see tweeted around and talked about. Edit: And don't be intimidated by people reverse engineering sidewinders in the Slack. The community is very open to humble, curious newcomers. They'll teach you how to analyze satellite imagery for free, haha.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- justicezyx 5y agohttps://openosint.slack.com/?redir=%2Fmessages%2Fosint%2F https://openosint.slack.com/?redir=%2Fmessages%2Fosint%2F This one?
- 3pt14159 5y agoShould have mentioned, it's a private slack for supporters, mostly to keep the quality high. https://www.patreon.com/acwpodcast https://www.patreon.com/acwpodcast
- PerkinWarwick 5y agoGenerally, I'd say that anti-carrier strike group tactics involve simply (well, maybe not so simple) overwhelming the defenses. Quantity can work as well as quality. You might look into Russian missile work. Of course, as a land power (and not as invested in trade as China), their answers are different.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe answers of China and Russia are pretty similar. Use air power or submarines to locate the carrier, fire hypersonic missiles.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 5y agoIs the premise here that carrier groups would be survivable in the absence of hypersonic missiles? They... aren't at all, are they?
- WrtCdEvrydy 5y agoCarrier groups are supposedly survivable except for the stealth subs and hypersonic missiles but noone has tested that theory. I wonder if the future will be just a cheap ship with a large number of single-use missile launchers.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoHow are the hypersonic missiles guided and what is their range?
- sudosysgen 5y agoThey are guided by active radar, passive radar, and optical sensors. Their range is anywhere from 5000-700km, but many can be air-launched.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoIf they are hypersonic in the atmosphere then they have radio opaque plasma around them. How do they transmit and receive radar pulses? How do they see with optical sensors?
- sudosysgen 5y agoThat is not how plasma stealth works. The temperature of the plasma determines the minimum frequency of RF that gets through. So you have to use a higher frequency radar and make sure the temperature of the plasma is not too high in front of the radar. You don't have to put the radar on the nose. For optical sensors you would be imaging off-axis. So you can put the sensors pointing, say, 30 degrees below forwards relatively far back and there will not be much plasma in front of the sensors as it comes from compression and not friction. There's a NASA PDF floating around that cites ~7000 K as the temperature of a plasma in front of hypersonic aircraft and concludes that radar is feasible then.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Should a conflict in the South China sea break out, China could nuke US carrier groups If China wants to start a nuclear exchange, sure. The US probably wouldn't go nuclear in response to an invasion of Taiwan, but it absolutely would in response to a nuclear attack on US forces.
- bb101 5y agoAnd our reality would segue into the storyline of Threads. The 1984 BBC film should be mandatory viewing for all people in positions of power. The bombing is only the start of the horror. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgT4Y30DkaA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgT4Y30DkaA
- wahern 5y agoThe Cuban Missile War Timeline: https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/the-cuban-missile-war-timeline.65071/ https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/the-cuban-mis...
- zionic 5y ago> but it absolutely would in response to a nuclear attack on US forces. But apparently not without phoning China about it first, if recent news is to be believed.
- pmdulaney 5y agoOuch.
- willvarfar 5y agoSomewhat related to a China tech angle, I submitted this article about what Chinese stealth boats look like to the newest commercial radar satellites: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28686121 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28686121
- numpad0 5y agoIs that a big deal? Internet told me the reason why ships go only halfway YF-117 is because surface radar expects sea clutters, and an awkward black patch created by stealth features gives out its position and nature.
- sudosysgen 5y ago... From the top. That is, the exact angle from which stealth doesn't matter.
- throwaway210222 5y ago> China could nuke US carrier groups assuming their satellites aren't taken out first. That spells game over for US projection of power if successful. Incorrect, the USA will probably just shrug, and call in the other 11 super-carriers and 9 amphibious assault ships. At the same time they will invoke NATO article 5 and a few other Asian mutual-defence treaties. 2 UK, 1 Spanish, 1 French, and 2 Italian carriers will arrive soon afterwards. As will 4 Japanese, 3 French, 2 Australian and 2 South Korean helicopter carriers. The trick isn't to take out one aircraft carrier: its to to be able to take them all out.
- Armisael16 5y agoArticle 5 only applies to attacks in Europe or North America. The SCS is definitely in neither.
- throwaway210222 5y agoFair point. 2/3 of the armada (modulo dry dock) is still coming to the fight.
- AlexAndScripts 5y agoFair, though in practice they would join in anyway - China would be going for them next. Better to fight with the US than alone.
- sudosysgen 5y agoPresumably the US would find itself in such a situation because it tried to stop the invasion of Taiwan. China will never have the interest or capabilities of going after Europe.
- throwawaycuriou 5y agoInteresting. Edge case: if French Guyana (off the north side of South America but considered part of France and the European Union) is the victim of an attack by some means, are NATO members obliged to act in its defense?
- Aunche 5y agoFrom what I understand, we aren't particularly afraid of hypersonic missiles because nobody even has defenses against conventional ICBMs.
- HPsquared 5y agoPerhaps hypersonic missiles could play a part in ICBM defense. You need something very fast and maneauverable.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoThat existed from 1975 to 1976 as: [/] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprint_(missile) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprint_(missile) Problem was it needed many of these [\] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safeguard_Program#/media/File:SRMSC_MSR_HAER_ND-9-B.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safeguard_Program#/media/File:... for support. (see caption)
- dd444fgdfg 5y agoIMHO, the risk of nuclear war is higher than we think. Can you imagine the number of expected casualties of all-out-war with China? We've played this game before. Japan/WW2. The US _will_ nuke China and justify it under number of lives saved.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> . Can you imagine the number of expected casualties of all-out-war with China? We've played this game before. Japan/WW2. The US _will_ nuke China Japan didn't have a nuclear second-strike capability with the range to hit the US. (Or, literally, any part of that taken independently.) The US leadership can't even make a remotely plausible argument, after emerging from their bunkers after the exchange is done, to have “saved lives” by nuking China.
- jcun4128 5y agoWould suck "starting over". Irradiated land, regression in progress with fallout.
- tkojames 5y agoChina is not going to nuke a carrier group sorry but that is insane. The second that happened say goodbye to entire world. There is reason we have boomer subs. One Ohio class sub could legitimately end the world.
- throwawaylinux 5y ago> One Ohio class sub could legitimately end the world. Not even close. It carries about 200 low yield warheads. Not even enough for 1 each for 1/3rd of the cities in China if you could spread them out that far. There have been over 500 atmospheric tests, many with vastly higher yield and fallout, the biggest tests had yields equivalent to all 200 warheads combined. One could strike a huge blow to China's capability to carry on war by destroying many of its large ports.