14 ms·
Apple’s app review prevents developer from submitting fix to game for the blind
- PerkinWarwick 5y agoOh well, that's what you get when decisions are made by a combination of algorithm and sweatshop call center. I have to admit that software for blind people sounds like a fascinating specialty. I'd love to get into it but being not-blind (came close though) probably gives one false theories on design. I love the angle of making software that requires only a microphone and a speaker, it would be an amazing way to rethink the world.
- SSLy 5y agoI believe quite a few of those blind-accessible apps also use touchscreen gestures, accelerator, and buttons for inputs.
- PerkinWarwick 5y agoBecause it works better that way? or because it's a way to make a visual app more accessible? My guess is that ground-up software for the blind would work differently at fundamental levels. Really, what an interesting problem.
- SSLy 5y agoBoth to answer your questions, but more of the first one. Blind users still can tap and use gestures as good as everyone else, they just can't find particular buttons.
- zepto 5y agoIf you follow apple’s accessibility guidelines, your iOS app is already accessible by the blind.
- matsemann 5y agoPeople say that about the web, too. "If you write semantic html and use aria tags, it's accessible". In theory, yes, but in practice it's probably a very bad experience unless actively worked on. For instance, I worked on a "seat chooser" once, that actually was very keyboard friendly and worked with screen readers. But trying to actually use it to select a specific seat for a blind was impossible. A seeing user can just press the seat directly, or tab quickly until the correct one is selected. But with voiceover it had to read out "seat 7B, $5 extra, not occupied, extra leg room, aisle, power outlet". An actually useful way of selecting a seat would be to specify a seat directly, or some kind of filter for wanted features, a table or whatever. Not just take a visual way of presenting something and slap on some voice data.
- zepto 5y ago> People say that about the web, too. "If you write semantic html and use aria tags, it's accessible". The two aren’t comparable. It’s not even close. I take it you haven’t actually built an iOS app. That said, for sure, you can build a custom UI that is inaccessible, but with iOS if you build something that is close to conventional, you’d be surprised by how well it works.
- jtsiskin 5y agoHow would iOS fix the seat selection example they gave?
- zepto 5y ago> for sure, you can build a custom UI that is inaccessible Provide a non custom UI alongside the custom one. Use tabs to offer ‘graphical’ and ‘list’ views. The comment I replied to said this: > In theory, yes, but in practice it's probably a very bad experience unless actively worked on It’s also not even clear that the UI they described was that bad for blind people. The voiceover information is relevant to making a selection, and the blind person can’t see that data so it needs to be read to them at some point. Of course it’s not as easy to use as if you can see it. They describe a search function, and I propose a plain list, but there isn’t a lot of evidence that either would require less interaction.
- gtirloni 5y agoIf you get a permission to publish on the App Store the first time, shouldn't that be permanent? Why do developers have to justify _every_ new update?
- saagarjha 5y agoBecause apps change.
- croes 5y agoBut you can't suddenly rate it as spam just because other similar apps exist. Certain criterias are only valid for the initial release and not for updates.
- Closi 5y agoBecause developers will just submit a first version which follows the rules, and then just put anything non-compliant in the update.
- peterburkimsher 5y agoThat would be treachery of Epic proportions ;)
- shreddit 5y agoIn theory, you could do a 180 turn on the content of your app with every update. So a permanent green light would do more bad than good
- lozenge 5y agoI was going to write a snarky comment about upgrading too early, but: "Exploring images with VoiceOver: Explore people, objects, text, and tables within images in more detail with VoiceOver. Navigate receipts and nutrition label values intelligently in logical order. And move your finger over a photo to discover a person’s position relative to other objects within images." "Voice image descriptions in Markup: Markup lets the user add image descriptions that can be read by VoiceOver. Image descriptions persist even when shared and can be read in a range of supported apps on iPhone, iPad, and Mac." "Per-app settings: Customize display and text size settings on an app-by-app basis. Bold or enlarge text, increase contrast, invert colors, add color filters, and more for only the apps you want." "Magnifier app: Magnifier finally becomes a default app on iOS, so you can use your iPhone as a magnifying glass to zoom in on objects near you."
- paxys 5y agoUnpredictable enforcement of rules is the biggest problem with the App Store today. As a small time developer you have to be ready to jump through every hoop Apple puts in front of you, what else can you do really? But then in the next update you get a different reviewer who goes "no those hoops you jumped through were wrong" and penalizes you for it. Rinse and repeat.
- friedman23 5y agoAccording to all the apple apologists on hackernews that think having an open app store ecosystem is bad, "apple knows what's best for me" is the response they should be giving right about now
- ogomez92 5y agoHi, I am the developer of the app in question, accessible hangman, as well as the other games I hve made for iOS. I am a blind developer myself, that is why I thought htat making games for the blind would be the best approach for me. I chose Apple's platform, instead of Android, because of the way that SwiftUI lets me write the UI via code and change visual appearance of buttons, etc just by adding button shapes, icons, etc. Now, I do understand that every app needs to go through review every time it is updated, of course. But this is verion 2.5 of the app, this is in no way the first or second version. So yes, Apple seems to find a new issue when someone just finds a little light in their brain clicking into place, the first version had no such issue. But after 4 or 5 versions, oooooh wait, your app does not comply with blah blah blah. So, yes, I think this is unfair. Anyway, I have some news regarding this whole hing, the update was pushed through and approved finally so I'm a bit less worried, they still say I should talk to them on the phone so they're going to schedule a call with me. Let's see how this turns out. Thanks all.
- cwbrandsma 5y agoI’ve had this sort of thing happen to me as well. Often different reasons, for example: one reviewer didn’t like my permission text for camera access. Twice now I’ve had to appeal the review. Each time the appeal worked in my favor and I was able to publish again. Keep in mind, as part of the appeal process they call you, so you will need to be answering unknown calls for a while. But the people I’ve talked to that handled the appeal process were all very nice.
- LanceH 5y agoWell, it's nice that they eventually allow people to install software that they want on phones they own.
- Whitewoodwonder 5y agoSpeaking of accessibility, do you know how insistent they are on calling? I'm not an iOS dev so it's a hypothetical question for me. However, I can't speak on the phone and I'm amazed by how many problems that's still causing me in the age of jetpacks and 3D printers.
- mlang23 5y agoApple killed one of the best voiceover enabled single-player poker simulator about 2 years ago. THETAPoker was absolutely great, and the author invested a lot of time and energy to make the game perfectly self-voicing. Until Apple review falsely identified it as a gambling-app which needs to be banned. The author tried to get someone to listen at apple, and was totally ignored. Now, Apple has a similar poker simulator, called hold'em, which is by far not as good regarding VoiceOver support. It feels like a scam to kick someone from the AppStore who did a very good job just to make your own botched copy-cat app more prominent. That said, Apple VoiceOver is still one of the best shipped-by-default accessibility systems. However, we have to thank Steve Jobs for this. If it were only for Tim Cook, apple wouldn't even know how to spell accessibility.
- bangonkeyboard 5y agoApple's Texas Hold'em actually dates to 2006.
- robocat 5y ago> Apple VoiceOver is still one of the best shipped-by-default accessibility systems Which is frightening, because two years ago I had a terrible experience trying to modify a web app to be accessible using VoiceOver (I gave up after over a week of solid effort). We couldn’t afford[1] to pay a third party to modify our 100% custom HTML framework[2], and VoiceOver seemed the most approachable for me to try and see how far I could progress on making our web app accessible. VoiceOver just felt so very buggy - although perhaps the issue was the integration of VoiceOver within Mobile Safari (my dev experience is that Mobile Safari is a steaming pile of problems - current example is that iPadOS15 Safari crashes twice on many pages then goes blank so you can’t use it!). As a dev, there also needs to be some better online training for using VoiceOver, since small teams do not have easy access to a colleague that uses it. [1] We could pay 100% blind users to give us feedback, but couldn’t afford to pay a skilled team to consult and do the work. [2] Custom framework because we started our product before reliable frameworks existed. Modern components are often designed to support accessibility out of the box, which is far preferable!
- 5y ago
- sillysaurusx 5y agoUnrelated, but if you tweet photos, please take a moment to add alt text. I started doing it a few months ago and it's remarkable how easy it is not to (and how much of an impact it can make when you do).
- jollybean 5y agoThe asymmetry in power between 'everyone' and Apple, Amazon, FB is a problem begging for regulation. If companies are making byzantine and ridiculous claims against other participants, it's bad for business. This is completely outside the issues of Apple's right to manage apps - if it's going to do so, it has to fairly clear policy and way to redress grievances. Things like: 'business review' and 'technical review' are separate so that bug updates don't trigger a business reviews. If a complaint is raised to level 2 and there are problems, it goes to some kind of level 3 mediation, possibly by an outside party. It also might be reasonable for Apple to require a small fee for new feature release review i.e. $100 to release a new version and have the business review. They could even consider having 3rd parties do the reviewing and only have Apple weigh in if there is a conflict. Etc.. Arbitrary and bad business operations are not good for anyone in the long run.
- oauea 5y agoWatch Apple suspend this developer now for violating their policy (causing more "spam", a term apple loves to use, to be sent to their accessibility inbox).
- lisper 5y agoThis is particularly evil in light of the fact that security updates are bound to OS versions. I tried to update my iPhone the other day to iOS 14.8 for the security patches, but it wouldn't let me. It would only let me upgrade to 15.0. So now I have a choice: I can either have the security patches, or I can have this (previously approved) app. I can't have both. This specific app is not an issue for me (I'm not blind) but there is another app that I do rely on that has also not been upgrade to 15.0 so I'm still faced with the same dilemma. And unfortunately, this particular app (Foreflight) is iOS-only.
- b3morales 5y agoDid you try via your Mac or the phone's own Settings? FYI, the latter is where you will find the 14.8 update offered.
- lisper 5y agoI tried both with the same result. Weirdly, my phone is one of four devices that I tried to update at the same time, all of which were running the same version of the OS to start (14.4.1). Three of those devices let me upgrade to 14.8. Only one (my phone) did not. It's weird. My guess is that I got stuck in some sort of A-B test. I contacted Apple tech support and they have so far escalated through two levels. The ticket is still open.
- b3morales 5y agoThat sounds annoying. Good luck!
- varenc 5y agoWhen you upgrade an iOS version you can only proceed after an Apple signing server approves that version of iOS for your devices unique hardware identifier. When their server stops signing an iOS version everyone is locked out of installing it. In the jailbreaking world you can save these signatures allowing you to install that iOS version later at your leisure. That said, Apple appears to still be signing iOS 14.8. You can check the signing status here: https://ipsw.me/iPhone12,3 https://ipsw.me/iPhone12,3 (But look up your device model in particular. Sometimes there’s inconsistencies)
- oauea 5y agoApple always does this for all kinds of apps. It sucks, and I don't understand why people keep on happily suffering under their abuse.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoBecause AppStore is a monopoly and if you want to publish apps for iOS users, you have one course: obey to their draconian rules and arbitrary review processes.
- VortexDream 5y agoThis is the issue I was hoping the Epic case would solve. They all missed the plot though, so we're stuck with this bullshit.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoBecause Epic didn’t launch the lawsuit out of the kindness of their souls, I doubt they even have what passes for a soul. They also put their case into jeopardy by knowingly breaking the rules first and then complaining the rules were bad. But they have definitely stirred some publicity (including nongeek audience) around all these practices, which is good, maybe someone is going to have a better case riding this wave.
- simonh 5y agoThe fact that one reviewer missed a potential policy violation is no good reason to ignore a policy violation when it’s found. If violations got automatically grandfathered in, you’d get devs pulling tricks like sneaking barely functional violations into the app so it’s unlikely to be spotted then when they got it approved make it fully functional. In any case, it looks like Apple is already engaged with the dev to sort this out. They’ve made some major changes to review appeals in the last year or two.
- adolph 5y agoIt’s regretable that so many bigcoes have to outsource their customer service exception pathway thru HN.
- supernintendo 5y agoSome of the reasons Apple comes up with for rejecting developers’ apps are such bullshit. Like I can understand trying to stop scams, malware etc. but this gatekeeping based on Apple’s subjective evaluation of the quality of your app when you have no other option for shipping on iOS is the reason why I just don’t consider it a serious platform. iPhones and iPads are more like iPods to me at this point; cool toys with overpowered hardware that do a few simple things well. There’s also a lot of irony in Apple judging whether or not your app is good enough. Like does anyone actually think Apple is cool in 2021? To me they’ve just become another boring, stuffy corporation like Dell and HP. The iPhone 13 is so incredibly uninteresting and inconsequential that I couldn’t even remember what number they were on when I was typing this comment. That whole launch just came and went.
- cglace 5y agoI seem to be able to use my toy for quite a bit.
- threeseed 5y agoI have developed over a dozen iOS apps so I am sympathetic to the frustration as a developer. But as a user I fully support Apple for curating the App Store experience. Discoverability is a challenge when you have this many apps and it's simply not fun having to wade through so many low quality, user-hostile apps. You only need to look at the Windows Store to know that curation is an integral part of making a store work.
- hellotomyrars 5y agoI agree that there is a lot of good to be done by curating apps but I don’t think Apple is doing a very good job of it in general or in specific regarding this. There is plenty of garbage on the app store and while in this case I’m sure there are a ton of hangman games on iOS, at least this one if offering something the others aren’t. So it’s kind of failing to deliver on the stated premise for the rejection. Also this seems like a pretty bad justification to reject and app update. Nobody benefits from this as part of a curation aspect. The app will still be there, so it’s already cluttering things up if that’s the issue for the rejection. I guess what really bothers me about the App Store review process is that most of the time it feels like the human aspect is ignored despite being enforced (which I think is conceptually good). If you’re going to have people actually review everything, let the people actually act as people instead of rule-detecting machines.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WoodenChair 5y agoNot directly related but another "today" App Store rejection story for rules being incorrectly applied: I had an app get rejected today for referencing MacPaint in the subtitle. It was in the subtitle because one of the major features is that it exports images to MacPaint format. The reviewer cited their rule about not using Apple trademarks in the title or subtitle. Which is fair enough, except that their trademark on MacPaint expired in 2007 (I checked before submitting actually). I ended up changing the subtitle, removing MacPaint, and the app was approved later today. I did call out in the resolution center that the trademark had expired, but of course I got no reply.
- threeseed 5y agoApple still has an active trademark for MacPaint in UK [1]. If you're app is for sale in the UK, which almost all are, then Apple is obliged to enforce their trademark. [1] https://trademarks.ipo.gov.uk/ipo-tmcase/page/Results/1/UK00001254435 https://trademarks.ipo.gov.uk/ipo-tmcase/page/Results/1/UK00...
- WoodenChair 5y agoFair enough, I didn't think to look abroad. But just for context, suppose my app subtitle were "PDF to Apple Pages." I think if it's in the context of a file format, as mine was, there should be some sort of leeway. "Photo to MacPaint Converter" is basically what my subtitle was.
- kragen 5y ago"Enforcing your trademark" does not entail removing claims that a program can export to the trademarked program's file format.
- threeseed 5y agoRather than turning every app submission into a legal dispute I suspect it's easier for them just to say "don't use our trademarks without permission".
- alkz 5y agojust classic apple hostility towards their users and developers
- neilv 5y agoAt a previous company, when I was developing an iOS app, it was difficult to impress upon the business people that there was a very real risk of Apple simply cutting us off. (When Apple wanted to compete in our space, or they cut a deal with a competitor of ours, or they came up with some new idea about "security" or "experience", or simply Kafkaesque random bureaucratic whim with no appeal.) I then had to explain why "the market" hadn't already corrected that, and why regulators hadn't. Separate from my professional career, one of the more personal reasons that the reality of the iron-fisted mad-king Apple iOS app store made me sad is... I had hard-won skills at some tricky iOS things, and it would've been very tempting to moonlight on some creative apps that did something new, while also generating side income. But, for this and other Apple developer-hostile reasons, I'd end up aggravated in my spare time, and always with the risk that at some point Apple will stab me in the back. That's no way to spend one's spare time refreshing from the real job.
- moosebear847 5y agoAs an iOS dev who's had to deal with Apple's lovely rules, could you go more into this part? I'd like to hear more. '... why "the market" hadn't already corrected [Apple's ability to cut people off], and why regulators hadn't.
- xuki 5y ago> why "the market" hadn't already corrected [Apple's ability to cut people off] Because there are a lot of money to be made, iOS users spend a lot more than Android users, that's a well known fact. If you don't build an app on iOS, someone else will. There are always developers who don't know enough, or simply don't care and keep building apps for iOS. > why regulators hadn't. They're starting to notice the problems. Recent regulations from overseas and the Epic lawsuit will draw attention to it.
- realusername 5y agoBecause the market is a duopoly of Apple & Google with very similar rules, pricing & close to no competition, there's nowhere else to go for developers if they are not happy.
- judge2020 5y agoFor everyone visiting this thread, I’d highly recommend this talk by the previous head of App Store review Phillip Shoemaker: https://youtu.be/tJeEuxn9mug https://youtu.be/tJeEuxn9mug
- Jensson 5y agoApple should really dogfood their own review system by applying it to their own apps. Would probably fix these inconsistent things pretty quickly.
- DarkmSparks 5y agoI wish blindness on whoever rejected the update. At the very least a couple of weeks with restricted vision to teach them some empathy.
- advael 5y agoUnfortunately this sort of thing is pretty much inevitable when a large org like Apple makes itself the single bottleneck for all apps. No org that big can actually serve everyone's needs (Cue people whose needs it serves coming to tell me all about it)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AbraKdabra 5y ago> To my surprise, I got an email saying that my app is similar to other apps on the app store and that it is considered spam. Literally. Please tell me this is a joke, this can't be true. So I can't develop an app and upload it if there's one similar already on the app store? What kind of stupid rule is this?
- busymom0 5y agoApple applies their rules entirely arbitrarily. For example- they have rules for app update release notes required to be detailed and rejects small developers apps with generic template update notes. Meanwhile larger developers like fAcebook, Google, uber etc regularly put the same generic update notes.
- arp242 5y agoIn principle it's not necessarily that bad; does an app store really gets better with 1,000 hangman apps? Probably not. And let's face it: there's a lot of "app spam". The problem is that 1) it seems enforced unevenly at best and this doesn't seem like "spam" at all, and 2) it's hard to bypass the Apple-curated app store. Apple can have all the rules in their app store they want – I don't really care – as long as they don't prevent me from running the software I want. It's that part that I find far more objectionable. I don't agree with all the takes the Debian people have on their Free Software guidelines either, and that's not a problem at all because Debian isn't trying to prevent me from running any software I want! Even the more hard-line Free Software-only distros aren't preventing me from installing non-free software (they may not facilitate it or make it easy, but that's different from actively preventing it). Or more eloquently: It's my bloody phone and I want to run whatever software I fucking want.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Crazyontap 5y agoAs a developer I have vowed to never develop anything for Apple nor buy any of the products. I know my mutiny is like a drop in the ocean for a trillion dollar company but I strongly agree with GNU stance that Apple's Operating Systems Are Malware(1). Apple been trying to stifle innovation for profit for a very long time and has been getting away with it. Had it not for the good open-source alternatives I believe computers would just be big dumb bricks with 0 scope of experimentation. (1) https://www.gnu.org/proprietary/malware-apple.en.html https://www.gnu.org/proprietary/malware-apple.en.html
- arp242 5y agoI have an iPhone SE2 for the singular reason that it's the only phone that vaguely approaches a reasonable size (although still too large for my liking) and isn't the most budget of budget phones. I kind of hate it though :-/ I think it's a bit unfortunate that the GNU page mixes some good points with hyperbolic nonsense, and I don't care much for calling them "tyrants" either; seems a bit much...
- silisili 5y agoI think it's slowly shifting. ios is attractive to developers because people pay for apps. ios is attractive to the masses because, among other reasons, the people who can afford to pay for apps use it. More increasingly, that seems to be changing, thankfully. I just wish the world had a better alternative than Android. It's hard to protest an overstep of Apple by giving money to Google.
- l30n4da5 5y ago> I just wish the world had a better alternative than Android. It's hard to protest an overstep of Apple by giving money to Google. There are at least forks of Android that are open-source. You don't necessarily__have_ to run the Google version of Android. Lineage-OS is one of them, but a few others have cropped up over the years that I have forgotten the names of.
- mdoms 5y agoThe solution is not to browbeat Apple into approving your app. The solution is for us, all of us, to collectively refuse to contribute our software to Apple's platform. Stop developing for walled gardens.
- supermatt 5y agomaybe apple should be prevented from selling phones because there are so many other manufacturers selling phones
- supermatt 5y ago2 days later, and it saddens me that this got downvoted so much, considering its about control of a market. It is literally what apple decide to do to this dev, because it was, in their opinion "just another hangman in the store".
- ogomez92 5y agoHi all. this is Oriol the developer of the accessible game in question here. I do agree with some of your points guys, I mean, I'm not against reviewing app updates at all, but in this case, if the review board really considered the app to be spam or whatever, they should have said so in the first version of the app, when it was first posted in september 2020, not after like 6 updates. That was the main problem here. I have more than 200 users who have spent money on the app, and the new version was just an iOS 15 fix which rendered the game unplayable without this update. Luckily though yesterday the new update was pushed, they still want me to have a call with them because apparently my app does not comply with their guidelines but let's hope I can clarify this. I am a blind developer and I know that my apps aren't super nice, I mean I can't make wonderful icons and whatever and while I do pay for logos I just don't earn enough from making games for the blind to have icons everywhere, my players will appreciate sound effects and music etc much more than they will cool icons. Being blind myself I think I know very well what the needs of my users are, hence the reason why I wanted to make a game for the blind, and it just makes me sad that Apple will consider that this is spam when I know perfectly well there aren't any other hangman games out there made with the blind in mind, and. I know someone said in a previous comment that with SwiftUI the app should be made accessible automagically. While it is true that the interface is accessible if it is properly made with SwiftUI and its accessibility features, this isn't everything. For hangman for example, I have gestures to announce the current word for example if the word was 'hang' it should say h, 2 blank, g. Then there is the sounds, music, etc which other apps of its kind do not do as well simply because they're made with a mainstream audience in mind. I hope this clarifies a bit what some of you were thinking, if you would like to you can try some of my other games, they are also made with accessibility in mind of course. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/choose-your-face/id1537309376 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/choose-your-face/id1537309376 Thanks all for the support.
- giorgioz 5y agoI have experience with the Apple review process. It's very common for an update to not respect rule X since there are literally thousands of rules. First you can appeal/answer them (like you did). In the scenario where they still reject your update you can still make a new executable by bumping up the version identifier. Try to make some change that answer their previous objection. In this case I would add/change a line in the description or title of the app specifying is for blind users. You could modify the feature to their demands but I'm not sure it applies in this case. Then you submit again. You will get a new human reviewer which may have a different opinion from the previous reviewer who rejected you. Be kind and respectful but keep appealing/resubmitting/explaining/asking what you can do. Don't give up. It's very time consuming but usually you will always get meaningful updates published in the end.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoI keep reading about kafkesque nightmares like you just described here, and think back to Apple's "1984" ad. I suppose they're the hero who lived long enough to become the villain.
- xfz 5y agoI'm not blind and I've never played Fortnite for that matter, but this stuff makes me more determined than ever to not buy an iPhone or iPad.
- anomaloustho 5y agoIt seems like some types of rules should be enforced once and other types should always happen. I’d imagine a rule to check the existing market and determine if there are too many duplicates should be on first submission only and not enforced again unless the app category or title has a material change.
- ogomez92 5y agoI got a call from apple.. They want me to change the app icon, apparently that was the issue. I don't believe it thoughh, the appeal responder actually said that "your app has voiceover but the rejection still applies". It doesn't make any sense, they still said oh I'm sorry and we will handle it better in the future blah blah.. Let's see if changing the app icon does something. Anyway the game is back with the iOS 15 update, so if anyone wants to try it out... https://apps.apple.com/us/app/id1528856181 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/id1528856181