6 ms·
Fukushima studies show wildlife is doing nicely without humans
- louwrentius 5y agoMaybe we should take the hint.
- go_elmo 5y agoMost people dont seem to get that the only ones were really destroying are ourselves. Another mass estinction wont end life on this planet, its too robust.
- hktntbvuvu 5y agoIn fact, a mass extinction would be beneficial to the ecosystem by wiping out humans and allowing the rest of the planet to recover and thrive.
- leeoniya 5y agosad that you had to create an anon account to make this comment, as this sentiment gets downvoted here without fail.
- true_religion 5y agoBecause it’s not very useful to anyone with an ego larger than a common house ant (e.g. sees a sense of self beyond the greater glory of the hive). A world without humans, without any human legacy, is not a future that any normative human wishes for. Is it even worth discussing something that 99% of people hate because it literally is a self inflicted apocalypse?
- guntars 5y agoIt’s just a fact - people are bad for biodiversity. I don’t think anyone can argue against it. What that implies is kind of dependent on your values, like you said, but it doesn’t mean we can’t discuss it and need to erase all such comments.
- artificialLimbs 5y agoOk let's discuss. If all the humans that want the entire planet wiped of humans could start by setting the example with themselves, the rest of us will take it from here. Seems to me like one should follow all the way through on those desires or else find some other ways of to live in which one could create value through their existence. To spout off that everyone should all die while not actually following through is one of the most selfish and destructive mind sets outside of murder and suicide.
- guntars 5y agoThat's not what I took from that comment, but there's another by the same poster that I can't see so maybe that's what they were suggesting there. Obviously, I'd personally vote against any such plan, but the issue is that there might not be a vote. By the looks of it we are inching towards one and half the world is in denial and the other half is arguing about how much beef we should be eating. It's ridiculous. Anyway, I have no doubts that life and people will be around for a very long time, it's our current lifestyles that are either going to voluntarily change or be changed for us. So to offer a solution, I think we need to put a dollar value on biodiversity in addition to carbon tax so that these things start to show up on the spreadsheets of people with the actual power to change things.
- true_religion 5y agoI think part of the reason people don’t fight for climate change is that they’d know the planet will recover… if there are few enough people on it. They assume that they or their defendants will be one of the survivors so there’s nothing to worry about. It’s the same issue with trying to prevent war when both sides think they can win. Sure there’s hardship but if you win didn’t you come out ahead? No one considers the trauma of the generation that has to actually do the fighting.
- louthy 5y ago> allowing the rest of the planet to recover and thrive. Are humans extra-terrestrial? How is humans thriving not part of the 'planet thriving'?
- hktntbvuvu 5y agoBy your logic we should allow the coronavirus to thrive too.
- true_religion 5y agoI don’t your argument here is very strong. By your original logic, allowing coronavirus to thrive will be beneficial for the planet by killing off humans, thus restoring the natural equilibrium. I dunno, but if your first principle is “it’s okay for all humans everywhere to die since ______” then you will end up with some really odd inferences.
- bilbo0s 5y agoIn fairness here, the comment said: allowing THE REST of the planet to recover and thrive. Which to me meant that humans are a part of the planet, and if you cut them out the other parts of the planet do "better" by the poster's definition of "better".
- postingawayonhn 5y agoHumans are the only hope for life on this planet. On a long enough timescale the planet will cease to exist. Humans have (or have the ability to develop) the technology to establish life in other parts of the universe.
- go_elmo 5y agoIt is highly unlikely that life - as on earth - does not exist anywhere in the universe. Where the great filter is is a great question, but I am 99.9999% sure that it is NOT basic life with some intelligence (e.g. animals). - The elements CHNOPS are verywhere - including oldest asteroids - enough habitable zone exoplanets - enough evidence of primitive life forming where energy gradients exist - ... so humans really are not that important for the universe, just for ourselves. But this should be enough for us not eradicate ourselves for the mid term benefit of a few.
- pfdietz 5y ago> It is highly unlikely that life - as on earth - does not exist anywhere in the universe. This is a common senitment, but there is no rational basis for believing it to be true. > enough evidence of primitive life forming where energy gradients exist There is no evidence that life has arisen more than once.
- GeoAtreides 5y ago> there is no rational basis for believing it to be true. Denying that humans and their blue little planet are in any way special is such a rational basis.
- pfdietz 5y agoIf origin of life is uncommon, then any place it does arise will necessarily be special. You are simply asserting, as an axiom, that life cannot be uncommon. The core of your erroneous thinking is that you have not taken into account observer selection bias. https://www.fhi.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/W6-Observer-selection-effects.pdf https://www.fhi.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/W6-Observer-sele... Your sort of reasoning also led people to think in the 1700s that all the other planets in our solar system had intelligent life on them.
- concordDance 5y agoAn extinction event that wipes put humans would wipe out every large animal too. Humans are incredibly versatile and adaptable.
- corkle 5y agoPerhaps in the short term, but I don't think it would be beneficial long term. If humans are wiped out, which species would save or relocate planet earth's biosphere from the coming destruction by the sun going red giant in a few billion years? Humans can potentially preserve the biosphere through either stellar husbandry/engineering or travelling to the stars (or both). At a certain point, the solar radiation may get so intense as to boil the ocean and destroy the atmosphere. Then it is predicted to envelop earth which would seal the deal for any potential subterranean life.
- masklinn 5y agoPretty much the same thing observed in the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone, except more so as the fallout from Fukushima's disaster was so much smaller (at least overland, no red forest or equivalent). It shows quite flagrantly how much human activity damages wildlife, that radioactivity-infested nuclear exclusion zones become biodiversity hotspots over just decades.
- mrweasel 5y agoWhat both exclusion zones show us is how much nature benefits from small unmanaged areas. One complaint here in Denmark is that we can't really set aside any meaningful areas to unmanaged nature, because we don't have the space. Both Chernobyl and Fukushima indicates that we might not need as much spaces as we think, but it does need to be one large chunk of land. Sure a Chernobyl size area might be a bit much, but half the size would still go a long way.
- masklinn 5y agoIt also shows two things things I think most ecologists are well aware of but which are harde to explain to laypeople, under quantity having a quality of its own only going so far when you actually need quality: 1. having 1000 sq km of total reserves but highly fragmented over the territory is better than nothing but almost certainly worse than having only 500 at a single location, because in the fragmented version you'll basically have lots of copies of "edge" ecological niches, but will be missing the "deeper" niches entirely 2. areas being "undeveloped" is not sufficient, and possibly misleading, because it's really the human activity which is disruptive to wildlife, if you decide to have wildlife refuge you need complete removal of humans for it to truly be effective
- shoto_io 5y agoThe same thing happened in Chernobyl: https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/story/how-chernobyl-has-become-unexpected-haven-wildlife https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/story/how-chernobyl-ha... https://theconversation.com/chernobyl-has-become-a-refuge-for-wildlife-33-years-after-the-nuclear-accident-116303 https://theconversation.com/chernobyl-has-become-a-refuge-fo...
- HenryKissinger 5y agoAnd the Demilitarized Zone between the Koreas, although it doesn't belong to the same category as Fukushima and Chernobyl. But it's a biodiversity hotspot. Lesson for humans: All we need to do is get out of the way.
- xwdv 5y agoThis article buried the real story here: Radioactive Terror Pigs. These mutant pigs are deadly and dangerous, pigs are already pretty intelligent, these are probably even more so. They could be the first step toward actual Orcish hominids someday. Never fear though, we will be long dead.
- hakre 5y agoYes, unless you start talking about the article _after_ reading it. As the article is referencing the other, earlier article about the terror pigs in the same publication. It is similar entertaining btw.
- marcodiego 5y agoOne thing we can learn from Fukushima and Chernobyl: humans are more dangerous to wildlife than nuclear accidents.
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoWhich is why I love Agent Smith's quote from The Matrix: "Every mammal on this planet instinctively develops a natural equilibrium with the surrounding environment; but you humans do not. Instead you multiply, and multiply, until every resource is consumed. The only way for you to survive is to spread to another area. There is another organism on this planet that follows the same pattern... a virus."
- hktntbvuvu 5y agoWhich is exactly why I do not worry about so called "invasive species" (cats, kudzu, english ivy, ...) Only humans are truly invasive.
- rich_sasha 5y agoWe’re just as invasive as the other ones, exploiting our own environment as much as we can.
- grncdr 5y agoWhich, while making for an excellent bit of dialogue, is unfortunately not the case at all. The idea that natural systems reach an equilibrium is a fiction imposed by humans who invented the concept of “ecology” in the 20th century. Every attempt to measure an equilibrium has revealed that the system being measured is constantly changing and there is no stable configuration.
- kzrdude 5y agoOne of the first tenets of evolutionary ecology we learned in school is that all organisms need to be able to grow exponentially, to fill their niche. That's what everyone does, it grows when it's able. And humans mostly do that too.
- amelius 5y ago[1] comes to mind. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_gardening https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_gardening
- eitland 5y agoThanks! I never heard about "Atomic gardening" before and with that I learned one thing and got one idea: - radiating plants have actually produced a number of useful mutations. - idea: can this be the inspiration for why a number of superhero stories include a hero or villain or something getting irradiated and get fantastic properties?
- keewee7 5y agoBecause the consequences of nuclear accidents have been exaggerated by the anti-Nuclear lobby and hysteria.
- jgalt212 5y ago> Now, children, come on over here. I'm going to tell you a bedtime story. Are you sitting comfortably? Then I'll begin. Once upon a time, there lived a magnificent race of animals that dominated the world through age after age. They ran, they swam, and they fought and they flew, until suddenly, quite recently, they disappeared. Nature just gave up and started again. We weren't even apes then. We were just these smart little rodents hiding in the rocks. And when we go, nature will start again. With the bees, probably. Nature knows when to give up, David. Dr. Stephen Falken
- pfdietz 5y agoAmong the lessons I think should be learned from Fukushima is: nuclear power plants should have vents with cesium filters. Almost all the long term dose from a nuclear accident is from 137Cs. So, if you can vent steam (and hydrogen) and trap the cesium, you can avoid much of that dose. The cost of doing this shouldn't be very high, and it would have helped a lot at Fukushima. It might even enable the other safety systems (like, the containment building) to be made cheaper/smaller. This idea is somewhat in the spirit of the famous "Cockcroft's Folly" at Windscale.
- varjag 5y agoIs cesium filter something that actually exists?
- pfdietz 5y agoAlso filters iodine. https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1224/ML12248A021.pdf https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1224/ML12248A021.pdf
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoI don't believe that would've helped in the case of Fukushima because of the hydrogen explosions that would've expelled radioactive dust. I'm not a nuclear engineer but it seems to me that we should try to find an alternative material to zirconium. It can decompose water into hydrogen gas. It's why hydrogen built up inside Fukushima Daiichi and it's suspected that's why Chernobyl Reactor 4 had two explosions, one of them being hydrogen. Alternatively, we could try to circulate another liquid through reactors which won't decompose into hydrogen, possibly something with a higher thermal capacity too, but that might be expensive.
- jl6 5y agoWhat is the role of cancer and birth defects in the animal population in these areas? Those are very significant issues for humans that make us very scared of radioactive contamination. Are animals impacted less (maybe due to shorter reproduction cycles or larger litters?)?
- concordDance 5y agoI think it's that a 10% chance of dying of cancer before old age is unacceptable to humans but won't have a big effect on population. Similarly, a 10% chance of birth defects isn't relevant to most species as a large proportion (often more than half) of their young die before adulthood anyway.
- akiselev 5y agoIIRC animals living in the Chernobyl exclusion zone have a 20-30% lower lifespan on average with a high variance (some animals lives’ might be cut in half while others may be better adapted and live more or less the same amount). That’s fine when the alternative is extinction but not when one wants to meet their grandkids.
- suction 5y agoIf I was animal, I'd like Japanese people to stay away from me as far as possible, too.
- pvaldes 5y ago> "Studies show that nature is fine" Must be ghost studies taking in mind that theregister never cite them or shown any in the article. Who says that? Without any real name or organization and the usual '"scientists" say that' bullshit plus the usual "9 Yo girl cute history" to appeal to feelings... I will assume that this is just either wishful thinking or a PR stunt.