4 ms·
Since most of the comments here seem to be on the hysterical side: 1. This is not something Apple is rolling out now with their devices and systems. 2. This i
by Jtsummers 5y ago
Since most of the comments here seem to be on the hysterical side:
1. This is not something Apple is rolling out now with their devices and systems.
2. This is research being done by UCLA and BioNTech using Apple's various sensors.
3. There's nothing concerning here (yet). This is a common kind of research using novel sensors (either actually novel sensors or taking advantage of their now-pervasiveness). Webcams were used as part of studies at least 15 years ago (by classmates while I was in grad school).
Other sensors have been used for decades to monitor people in research studies to see if they could be used to detect conditions either after they'd developed or earlier while still developing. The only interesting thing about this is that the researchers are using Apple's sensors, and that's not terribly interesting at all. Last year, Garmin and Oura partnered with DOD and others to use their sensors to try and detect COVID infections before people developed the obvious symptoms, was that terrifying to any of you?
- bfga 5y agoThe pattern is always the same. When an invasive technology or a precursor to an invasive technology is announced, someone on HN sagely points out that everyone should be reasonable and drop the conspiracy theories. Five years later the tech is on everyone's phone.
- m463 5y agoalso, even if "privacy" is assured, once the tech is normalized either the private version can be cracked, or a similar but non-private tech is released everywhere else (with hooks for advertising/data-mining/govt access)
- ashtonkem 5y agoWhich is why all the afib data from watchOS got leaked to increase insurance costs, right? Right? Sometimes the sky does not actually fall.
- snypher 5y agoHow would you know if it was? It was more likely sold by whoever collected it. The very existence of this pool of data is a risk, and just because the sky didn't fall today, do you stop wearing a seatbelt?
- sangnoir 5y agoLess than 24 hours ago, the top story on HN was a tranche of iOS 0-days released by a whitehat who got frustrated by Apple's mismanagement of its bug bounty program. So it's open season on that afib data right now...
- ashtonkem 5y agoIt does not follow that 0 days mean every piece of information in apple’s control will be stolen. Historically apple 0 days have been used to target high level targets, usually journalists, and not appropriate (or usable) for removing all data from all iPhones. Something Apple should fix, sure. But not something that I’m going to delete all my Apple Health data for.
- sangnoir 5y ago> It does not follow that 0 days mean every piece of information in apple’s control will be stolen You're correct in general, but not in this specific instance. If you followed the said thread, you'd have encountered the disbelief that Apple stores health data unencrypted on the iPhone, despite FIPS certification for the watch. Every 0-day, as it stands today, can result in access to health data, until Apple adopts defense in depth.
- knaik94 5y ago>If the research finds that any of that data correlates with relevant mental-health conditions, the hope is to turn those signals into an app or feature that could warn people they might be at risk and prompt them to seek care I am worried about the part of article that mentions that they want to automate the analysis of the data to some degree and move it out a strictly clinical research setting. I have also done some research in the field and my final sentiment is that the data is too noisy to be ultimately useful and the problem is hard to define in a quantitative way. I predict having more data isn't going to show a more clear correlation between things.
- kergonath 5y agoThese things don't do diagnostics. They just give the user a heads up and suggest they see a specialist. The sky was already falling when they did that for atrial fibrillation, and there were lots of people claiming that it would submerge hospitals and doctors under a flow of false positive. The sky did not fall, hospital managed just fine (before COVID, that is), nobody's precious heart rate data were leaked, and a couple of lives were saved. These things gather metrics and suggest to see a doctor. They don't do anything like diagnostics, and they don't replace a doctor. It would just nudge someone to see a specialist, who would then diagnose according to their experience and the patient's symptoms. Noise is irrelevant here.
- knaik94 5y agoJumping from a very clear definition of AFib to very subjective diagnosis of mental health issues isn't something I'm comfortable with. Noise is relevant because the diagnosis is subjective. We're not talking about timing between heartbeats, we're talking about situation where even medical professionals can't do an invasive quantitative test to say how depressed someone is. Using privacy invading sensors doesn't make the diagnosis less subjective.
- selykg 5y agoSo, because you’ve done research that’s the end of it? No one else can possibly do better? Game over guys. The guy on hacker news did his best so everyone else should just stop trying. I for one, as a person that swings around with depression, would love something like this on my wrist.
- solarkraft 5y ago> UCLA and BioNTech Biogen. BioNTech is still pretty focused on mRNA technology :-)
- ashtonkem 5y agoEven if they do roll it out, this is totally fine as long as users are given a chance for informed consent and control over the data. I see no particular issues with the afib detection in WatchOS from a privacy perspective. As long as they handle any new health features similarly, should be fine.