10 ms·
I've becoming increasingly convinced that this "update culture" is really about encouraging rather than preventing forced obolescence. If they would just make i
by userbinator 5y ago
I've becoming increasingly convinced that this "update culture" is really about encouraging rather than preventing forced obolescence. If they would just make it work right the first time, the way software used to be developed, maybe we wouldn't have this continual update cycle of fixing-and-breaking things every time, but then they wouldn't be able to sell you anything new. Instead, by conditioning the population to accept and even demand continual updates, companies maintain more control over their products and can change them however they want --- which of course can include making them less functional and more user-hostile.
It's the same reason why anything "smart" or cloud-dependent is best avoided. For example, all my white goods are several decades old and most of them don't even have any electronics.
No, we don't "need software updates forever", despite how much the corporatocracy tries its best to persuade you onto the treadmill.
- Laremere 5y agoI agree that better technology shouldn't need continuous updates, but I do think there are two more likely drivers than planned obsolescence, differing from early technology. Firstly, security. Older devices weren't connected to the entire world with bad actors attempting to exploit anything they can. Until people start writing software that have zero security exploits, anything connected to the internet needs an update path. Secondly, most apps in use today have a server component. Maintaining a perfect backwards compatible server for all clients ever released is a very tall order. Also, I think it's a strong indictment of current OS technology that updates are in question at all. If everything was as modular as it really should be, you'd have the core components of the kernal, the drivers for the hardware bits, (both of which really should be secure and not rely on servers) and then everything else should be in the user's complete control, to update or not as they please.
- selfhoster11 5y agoPeople could just not connect some devices to the wider world. Make them offline, or support airgapped usage patterns, or support a 1:1 connection only with a management interface (like a KVM), or support fully online use but with as simple a protocol as you can to reduce surface area.
- judge2020 5y agoYou can’t create perfect software no matter how hard you try. Security updates especially need to be a forever thing, lest some major RCE comes along and is used on tech support scam sites to cause actual harm to the user.
- choeger 5y agoRead OP's point again: You don't need security upgrades in many cases. Neither my dishwasher nor my fridge are, or should be, connected. I could imagine them having some kind of protocol for remote maintenance (showing power consumption, warning about damage), but that's it. Software for utility devices should not be a selling point. It should just be there and do its job and maybe get an update every five years or so. Why does my TV need updates nowadays? My car? Do I have to download updates for my clothes or my bed soon? How about the toilet? These updates are indeed just a way to turn products you once used to buy into leased stuff. Every business loves to lease: There's much more profit in it and the customer has no say about how long they use a particular device. But as a customer I hate it. Here's just one instance: I had an old kindle paperwhite. I loved that thing for piling all the stupid, cheap scifi on it that I would otherwise have bought as cheap paperback and that would then clutter my apartment. Literally two weeks after the device went out of the warranty, amazon decided to push an over-the-air upgrade. And it bricked the device. Now customer care was nice enough to send me a new one, but what if they didn't? Who is legally to blame? I would have to explain the concept of over-the-air upgrades and how software can sometimes destroy hardware to a judge and that judge would have to apply law from a hundred years ago to that situation. In a court case over maybe $100 - good luck with that.
- bigiain 5y ago> Why does my TV need updates nowadays? My car? Do I have to download updates for my clothes or my bed soon? How about the toilet? Those things don't all need software to exist. But good luck buying a new TV or car these days that isn't 100% reliant on software to keep doing what you bought it to do. (And I'm sure there are clothes/furniture/toilet manufacturers looking very closely at John Deere's current business model to try and see if they can turn "buyers" into "recurring licensees" of their products.) But I think that's missing the article's point. It talks about "some old gadgets" and "each booted up successfully" and "Two perfectly good pieces of electronic gear have become useless, simply for want of software updates." - it's clearly not talking about clothes or beds, probably not cars (although arguably they count), and probably is talking about modern TVs (many of which het thrown away when the ancient Android version they run can no longer update to new versions of that apps the TV came with). I'm not sure whether "We should mandate that device manufacturers set aside a portion of the purchase price of a gadget to support ongoing software maintenance, forcing them to budget for a future they'd rather ignore." is the only/right answer. but the article certainly eraises an important question.
- KronisLV 5y agoI made a blog post under the humorous title of "Never update anything" which does sound a bit like what you're suggesting: https://blog.kronis.dev/articles/never-update-anything https://blog.kronis.dev/articles/never-update-anything It's probably a bit chaotic, but some of the arguments that i made were that "updates" is too broad a term to be meaningful, since you might be interested in security updates without any other sorts of breaking changes being forced upon you: Types of updates are the problem The problem here is that we never differentiate between the types of updates properly: - major leaps in the development of the software which add new features - security updates that don't change any actual functionality apart from the security fix - bug fixes that should not alter any functionality in significant ways - small backwards compatible feature updates that are essentially opt in Essentially, you might want stable and secure software and not much more, since if it was enough for you at a certain point in time, then it might be the same way in 10 years, instead of needing new features that break your logic numerous times over that period. But perhaps the current situation that we're in is simply a reflection of the current industry and market conditions, where companies try to have their products remain competitive. You can't sell stable software (or hardware) that has a new feature once every 10 years, when there are products out there that release new stuff monthly - at least when it comes to the layperson, otherwise we wouldn't have enterprises like Google or Facebook make significant UI/UX changes, since none of those make sense from a purely engineering oriented point of view. Of course, that's just my interpretation after applying Occam's razor - for some reason we don't hear much about extremely stable products as success stories.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agosome functionality might only be possible by being insecure, thus a security update may have to remove functionality.
- KronisLV 5y agoIn that case, we're probably (hopefully) talking about air gapped environments, like medical devices that aren't networked or internal corporate networks with very particular host access rules. In those cases, you might truly want no updates of any kind, with which i agree - updates should always be compatible with the "opt out" approach, or even do "opt in" (like Debian has an unattended upgrades package, for example: https://wiki.debian.org/UnattendedUpgrades https://wiki.debian.org/UnattendedUpgrades). That said, due to the world that we live in, it's risky to forgo any sorts of security updates, especially in the context of networked devices and systems!
- forty 5y agoI want a right to repair. Both for hardware and software. If the makers doesn't want to provide fixes forever, they should at least allow me to fix it if it breaks. I'm happy if they just provide the source code with a nice OSS licence.
- creshal 5y agoStrictly speaking, for a pure right to repair, it doesn't even need to be OSS licensed. Germany's Left Party (inspired name, I know…) is lobbying for that constellation e.g.: License can be restrictive, as long as users are given source access and permission to fix bugs themselves.
- cfn 5y agoThis is a very simplistic view as the source code alone may not be enough to build/fix most complex closed source application. You have IDEs that may be costly and expensive components that you cannot release the development builds, etc.
- southerntofu 5y agoI find it funny that a Left Party would not promote/defend copyleft tooth and nail. Sounds more like a "pro-social Right" party :)
- forty 5y agoPolitical left and right have very very different meaning depending on where you live in the world :) As a French person, anything which defends environment and customer rights (vs corporate interests) sounds lefty enough.
- southerntofu 5y ago> Political left and right have very very different meaning depending on where you live in the world :) I'm curious if you have resources on that topic. It was my understanding that the left/right division used to designate the French national assembly, where royalists and other reactionaries would sit on the "right" and various stripes of progressives on the "left", that this model was imported to other newly-founded so-called "democracies", and that the words took new meaning when communism (whether authoritarian marxism or libertarian anarchism) began spreading in the mid-19th century. > anything which defends environment and customer rights (vs corporate interests) sounds lefty enough As a french person myself, i don't agree with this interpretation. Not so long ago, a "fair capitalism" system was a selling point of the centrist movement, and was advertised by a considerable segment of the "droite sociale". The left was defined by promoting the abolition of the capitalist system with further sub-classifications: socialists promoted reforms as a means of achieving communism (which arguably fails every time), communists promoted dictatorship of the proletariat to build communism (which arguably fails every time, and produces results very similar to industrial capitalism), anarchists and libertarian communists promoted decentralization of power and workers/citizens self-organization to build communism (which arguably succeeded every time, but was shortly crushed by authoritarian reaction [0]). In the 80s, the Socialist party rose to power and abandoned all socialist ideals, until it adopted market economy as official policy some time in the 90s if i remember well. Likewise, the Communist party seems to have abandoned most campaigning around expropriation, instead focusing on the much diluted/vague "workers/citizens rights" concepts. Today, apart from the NPA (Nouveau Parti Anticapitaliste), i don't see any mainstream (>1% votes) leftist party in the public discourse. I don't see an abundance of further-left initiatives from the bottom-up (not political parties) though, in the forms of ZADs, self-organized workers coops and unions, squats, and other collectives for social struggles against racism, patriarchy, etc.. Of course they're not the ones the media would tell you about, or as the old 68 saying goes, "the revolution will not be televized" :-) [0] 1917 revolution in Russia started as a libertarian communist movement organized around local "soviets", before Lenin Trostky and other power-hungry tyrants moved in and killed everyone (see "Constadt" or "Makhnovtchina"). Likewise, 1936 revolution in Spain was mostly led by anarchist discourse and practice, until USSR-backed communist party (which had considerably more weapons despite having much less popular support) massacred everyone.
- 123pie123 5y agoI was asked about 5 years ago to help to keep an application alive that was running on NT, it was doing an extremely important function and could not be replaced easily. Nobody knew how long it had been running and the developers obv had long gone I suggested we immediatly isolate all the servers, clients and the network. Create snapshots of the hards disks (on isolated disks) - and try and virtualise the images so they're not tied in to the hardware. as far as I know that thing will keep going forever to the point the tech will be (or already is?) so old not many people could hack it
- selfhoster11 5y ago> as far as I know that thing will keep going forever to the point the tech will be (or already is?) so old not many people could hack it You're underestimating young people's ability to grasp and enjoy obsolete technologies. I am personally fascinated with DOS and Palm OS despite definitely not being around to witness their heydays. Give me a few years and the binaries/manuals people had back in the day, and I will hack it one way or another.
- 123pie123 5y agoyou're right, I personally think the more people who have this way of thinking the better. but the number of people who can be motivated to do this stuff along with the time required is a much smaller group I've done my fair share of reverse engineering machinecode in the past - I do see it as a puzzle to be solved
- jfrunyon 5y agoYou're overestimating anyone's ability to spend years trying to hack a single target with documentation that likely no longer exists when there are likely both easier and more profitable targets out there.
- selfhoster11 5y agoThe documentation and software is still extant if you know where to look, including in archives created specifically for this purpose. If I didn't have either of those, then obviously I couldn't get very far.
- jayd16 5y ago>If they would just make it work right the first time, the way software used to be developed Was this ever true? Was there really some golden age where everything worked or were we just blissfully ignorant to the problems?
- nikanj 5y agoGenerally most of my electronics that contain a microcontroller but no internet have been bug free. I think part of this comes from the much smaller testing surface - my old vacuum cleaner has one button for power and one dial for suction power, so it's quite simple to write a bug-free implementation. Same for my dishwasher, laundry machine, etc. They generally come with a very limited number of inputs, and a microcontroller that runs through a state machine based on the inputs.
- darkmatterrat 5y agoI don't know how old you are but things pre-internet electronics just worked, because there it was assumed that there was probably connection. Before everything was internet connected. Yes everything did just work until component failure. * Games consoles and games were plug and play. Until the PS3 (late 2000s), none of the game consoles required any sort of updates. Yes there was hardware revisions but what you bought in the box was what you got. * Most computers before the PC was dominate in the UK, just switched on and you operated them. * Mobile phones didn't require updates, the only thing I need to do once was restart the phone because the sim needed to update a setting because I wasn't receiving SMS. These old nokia phones still work btw and my newer smart phones many don't work or can't be updated now. * Almost all my media was on VHS and/or Cassette. As long as the player worked, my media would play. I tend to do a lot of retro-gaming / retro computing now and all this stuff that is pre-internet and doesn't assume an internet connection just works (even on modern operating systems) without much interference. There was of course bad products, but they didn't require an internet connection either so it was just a bad product that you replaced with something better if you cared to.
- fxtentacle 5y agoPlaystation 2 games were generally bug free. Same goes for Nintendo cartridges.
- greggman3 5y agoI know of almost no software that's ever finished. This is not some conspiracy. It's just a fact of life. Examples, image editors need to load new formats. Old computers didn't have cameras, now they do, many softwares would suck without support for them. New input devices come out (mice, touch screens), software needs an update to support them. Old old computers didn't have networking. Once networking exists plenty of software will be effectively obsolete if not updated to take advantagae. Old software was ASCII only, then the net connected us to the world and not all that old software needs to support full unicode. Old software didn't support useful rich copy and paste, new use cases appear (copy and paste text, images, audio clips, video, URL links, rich text, structured graphics). Old software that can't handle this is obsolete. Old software didn't handle multiple resolutions. Try running some non-HD-DPI aware Windows software on an HD-DPI screen. Good luck reading the text. Old software thought it could own the machine. OSes realized they needed to put the user in control. Now the software needs to be updated to ask for permission instead of just crash when it fails to access something. Most software has to be updated, period.
- andrewchambers 5y ago> Examples, image editors need to load new formats Alternatively, they could be designed to support plugins.
- creshal 5y agoSomeone still needs to write those, and you'd need to be a psychic to succeed in making an immutable API that can handle all possible future requirements. E.g., up until a while back, 32-bit ARGB as exchange format would've been sufficient, but is now insufficient to handle 10 bit channels and/or stuff like HDR. What if we get a standard for 3D images? It gets worse if you want to handle animated images as well, whatever exchange format you specify will break once a decade at least. And god forbid someone tries DRM for images again…
- selfhoster11 5y agoAmiga did it. We can do it again. Besides, such an API is a slow-moving target, so still better than status quo.
- omegalulw 5y agoSecurity updates alone pretty much refute your entire premise. Not to mention that if you don't have software updates all your options for repair are costly and leave you without a device for a while. Scaled to everyone that's mountains of electronic and time wasted. The problem is not software updates.
- npteljes 5y ago>"update culture" is really about encouraging forced obolescence >If they would just make it work right the first time What makes contant updates unavoidable is the ever-connectedness of the current world. If you miss out on security updates, then your sensitive data is at higher risk to be harvested, or the device can be joined into a botnet. This is why we can't return to the old world of doing software. Also it's not like software was written to be perfect, like, ever. Product versioning is not new to the current era.
- southerntofu 5y ago> It's the same reason why anything "smart" or cloud-dependent is best avoided. For example, all my white goods are several decades old and most of them don't even have any electronics. I would definitely welcome regulations dis-incentivizing IoT crapware like connected fridges and toasters and whatnot. However, for devices that are intended to run software (general-purpose computers) shouldn't it be a requirement that all data sheets and source code be released under a copyleft license? Can't we have the best of both worlds?
- blitzar 5y ago> If they would just make it work right the first time, the way software used to be developed Back in my day kids were respectful of their elders, politicians didnt lie and the sun shone gloriously every day.
- dgb23 5y agoExactly. Remember Windows95? There always has been stuff that was made to work and last, and there always has been tons more stuff that was a bug ridden "worse is better" kind of deal with great marketing.
- blitzar 5y agoI remember windows 3.1. Back in those days, the way they shipped - mmm it was a thing of beauty. I had to reinstall it every 2-3 months it was that good.
- idispatch 5y agoOTOH, if it wasn't that good we would be using something else, good and better that win3.1 and the history would erase Windows.
- blitzar 5y agoThe big lie started when they conned people into calling the next version, 3.11 three point one one. Its pretty obvious now with the benefit of hindsight that is an eleven and big tech had to hide the fact they were transitioning from completed code to incomplete code in the unreleased versions 2 through 10.