5 ms·
Big Mac pricing varies throughout Europe. Dutch McDonald's employees are paid way less than the $22 the Danes get, but our Big Macs are more expensive. There i
by jeroenhd 5y ago
Big Mac pricing varies throughout Europe. Dutch McDonald's employees are paid way less than the $22 the Danes get, but our Big Macs are more expensive.
There is definitely a tradeoff to be made because nothing ever comes for free. However, that 4.73 billion dollar profit can give every one of their 210k employees each an extra 20k per year (regardless of the average income in their respective countries) before it would even turn a loss based on 2020 numbers. And that's not even taking into account the fact that 2020 profits were significantly down.
In a fair system, increases in price would pay for wage increases and vice versa. In practice, price increases flow towards the top.
- liaukovv 5y agoThe company doesn't exist to make money for it's employees.
- spoonjim 5y agoAnd the employee doesn’t exist to make money for their employer’s shareholders, and this entire article shows how employees can capture some of that money if they work in solidarity.
- gruez 5y ago>And the employee doesn’t exist to make money for their employer’s shareholders which is why the employer pays the employee for their service. >this entire article shows how employees can capture some of that money if they work in solidarity. creating a cartel is one way to strengthen your bargaining position.
- spoonjim 5y agoYes. Denmark shows the power of the worker’s cartel. It’s smart business tactics, the kind that the employer would praise in their own management.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- moomin 5y agoThat's an excellent argument in favour of radical unionization.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- IneffablePigeon 5y agoPerhaps it, or some larger subset of companies, should? Co-operative style employee ownership is one way of achieving something along those lines.
- liaukovv 5y agoThis creates inverted incentives: to take as much from the pot as possible while putting in as little as possible. Same reason as why such communal systems never work if they get much larger than one family.
- content_sesh 5y agoInverted by whose standards? You could just as convincingly argue that capitalist enterprises are the ones with inverted incentives: to extract as much value from workers as possible while paying them as little as possible.
- liaukovv 5y agoIn the communal system it is in the best interest of each agent to work against other agents. Tragedy of the commons and all that.
- mrguyorama 5y agoThat doesn't actually change in a traditional capitalist system. The only difference is that owners and upper classes have more power than the individual to make their interest of getting the whole pot for little work happen
- liaukovv 5y agoIn capitalist system owner can enforce cooperation so the pot itself grows. The proportion that workers capture here is of course dependant on external factors, like labour market and laws.
- 5y ago
- nradov 5y agoDoes that standard of fairness go both ways? If a business is losing money should the employees then be required to work for free? Most McDonald's restaurant workers worldwide are employees of local franchise companies which are far less profitable. The main McDonald's corporation is just a supplier for them.
- IneffablePigeon 5y agoPerhaps not for free, but it's not unheard of for labor unions to negotiate temporary lower wages in order to try to save the viability of a business that they want to keep working for.
- toiletfuneral 5y agoWhat “work” does capital do? Like honest question, what do they do all day? Just scheme up ways to replace workers with robots? Chat on their Bloomberg terminals? For how much shit they talk on the worthlessness of labor, I don’t actually understand what work they do.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> However, that 4.73 billion dollar profit can give every one of their 210k employees each an extra 20k per year There are two problems with this argument. First, we do not believe in the labor theory of value. Time has a value. Risk has value, land has value, and there is also value in nature, so if you were to distribute all the profits solely to labor, you would have only labor and no capital. That means no equipment, no burgers, no fries, no land, no buildings, no cash registers, no working capital, etc. Just a bunch of people standing around, not even being able to work because tools are required to work and the moment someone suggest paying for the tools necessary to do work, someone like you pops up and starts complaining that there must be no payments for capital, all payments must be only for labor, and so no tools are ever purchased. No land is purchased. No money is borrowed to pay for any expenses, etc. The second problem is opportunity cost. McDonald's market cap is 180 Billion dollars, and it earns about 5 Billion per year for a yield of ~2.7%. But this is a risky return. Alternately one can invest in 30 year treasuries that are guaranteed and earn 1.86%. So that corresponds to a risk premium of 1% and a real rate of ~1.8%. In real terms, the risk-free rate is actually negative and the McDonald's earnings yield is approximately zero. Thus the earnings accruing to McDonalds are basically just enough to make up for the loss of the value of the investment due to inflation, so you'd get your original money back, with a healthy dose of risk. That is charity. You should be on your knees thanking investors for supplying the 200K workers of McDonalds with 180 Billion dollars of capital that allows them to have jobs while the investors are getting basically nothing back in exchange for taking on that risk. Of course these yields are temporary. Investors may not be getting anything back now, but long term, these types of yields are unsustainable and they will go up. Investors do need to get something back for their investment otherwise the investment wont be made. And getting back just the original amount invested is generally insufficient to motivate investment and is characteristic of a dysfunctional economy that is unpleasant for workers. When yields are so low as to just match inflation, that's when you see things like housing bubbles as investors turn around to buy up real assets like land because there is no point in investing in risky ventures, and that is when more people who don't understand the world start moaning about how unfair all the expensive housing is, while with the other side of their mouth they advocate for zero interest rates because payments to capital are "bad". We would like to live in a world where ventures are funded, where investment in productive capital is funded. We like the idea of SpaceX and Tesla and mRNA vaccines and M1 chips. We like investment. But that means that the investment must be more profitable that merely buying land and holding it to get back your money in inflation adjusted terms. And the greater the reward for investment, the more investment that will occur.
- paconbork 5y ago210k is the number of McDonald's corporate employees. Franchises (which covers 93% of locations) employ roughly an order of magnitude more people