12 ms·
Mister Rogers had a simple set of rules for talking to children (2018)
- BiteCode_dev 5y ago> Rephrase any element that suggests certainty So underrated. Certainty brings sad situation when reality doesn't match the words of a trusted person. That's probably one of the reason Mr Rogers feels so honest and reliable: it's the reverse of the salesman.
- asxd 5y agoAgreed. Part of gaining the trust of another person is being honest about uncertainty. He subtly emphasized that authority figures are your best bet for advice, but they still don't know everything. It's a nice gentle introduction to what can be more bluntly phrased as "in the end, you will need to use your best judgement."
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThere should be more of that, but a lot of people are afraid of telling - or hearing - certain phrases. I do believe this is the case even more in software development and IT, because we know what we don't know, we know there's a lot of uncertainties, and we have trouble being certain about things. "When can you finish this?" "Well it depends..."
- imbnwa 5y agoSadly many, dare I say, most adults, have an immense thirst for certainty.
- foolinaround 5y agoIt would be cool to imagine Dr Fauci speaking in Freddish!
- Aeolun 5y ago“A vaccine may save your life. It is good to consider the feelings of the people trying to make you better.”
- fidesomnes 5y agoThe only problem is it's an experimental gene therapy with zero study on the long term effects on the inoculated. It is the biggest experiment performed in human history and trying to make you better does not seem to be the endgame.
- dreadlordbone 5y agoHonestly would be more productive than the current message.
- tomtimtall 5y agoIs it really too much to expect the American adult population be receptive to communication above that targeting preschoolers? It would even matter if Fauci was talking to the anti-van population as if they where children. The reason they aren’t listening is not due to them not understanding the message of being scared of drains.
- cybernautique 5y agoI don't know. The rules seem to revolve around simplicity in communication. I've always found it powerful that, although every member of the US Armed Forces is expected to have a 12th grade level of knowledge, all of our military manuals are written to a 7th grade level. Choosing simplicity is not necessarily degrading. Speaking to people with the same kindness, conscientiousness, and simplicity exemplified by Mr. Rogers' brand might not be such a bad thing. This isn't to disagree with your points. I agree that American adults ought to have facility with communication that falls outside of these ideals, and I don't think these edicts would obviate any or all of the problems we have today. But I do think there's a reason to value such communication, and it would be interesting to see it applied to the communication of public affairs.
- tommymachine 5y agoThe most effective marketing copy is often written at a 5th grade level. Some who have studied copywriting have found the reverse correlation between sales figures & grade level to be the highest of anything they could measure in terms of the copy itself.
- WalterBright 5y ago"This Side Toward Enemy"
- josh_today 5y agoAnother simple set of rules for talking to children is keeping fixed vs growth mindset approaches in mind Edit: this was a positive intentioned comment. Not sure why the downvotes
- OscarCunningham 5y agoThe studies supporting the usefulness of a 'growth mindset' have been failing to replicate, and it's unclear how useful the concept actually is.
- andai 5y agoMy mom always told me I had no talent for math, and that I shouldn't invest energy into things that don't come effortlessly the first time I try them. It might sound silly, but it took me until my late 20s to realize that I can actually learn hard things by just practicing them a lot. One of the things that encouraged me to start relearning math was hearing about the growth mindset and reading some books about it.
- josh_today 5y agoFor me, it works (on myself and for kids) with using different ways to praise, for example- “you’re so smart” vs “you really thought of creative solutions to that problem”
- DoreenMichele 5y agoThe show’s final cuts reflected many similarly exacting interventions. Once, Rogers provided new lyrics for the “Tomorrow” song that ended each show, to ensure that children watching on Friday wouldn’t expect a show on Saturday, when the show didn’t air. And Rogers’s secretary, Elaine Lynch, remembered how, when one script referred to putting a pet “to sleep,” he excised it for fear that children would be worried about the idea of falling asleep themselves. Rogers was extraordinarily good at imagining where children’s minds might go. The more I learn about him, the more I feel he was underappreciated in his time.
- User23 5y agoAs someone who was a child that grew up watching him, I can assure you that he was extremely appreciated by his target audience.
- edoceo 5y agoLand of Make Believe crew checking in!! Modern Daniel Tiger is a good message and all, but blatant. Fred had that subtlety that let you still find your path to your personal truth, like the best dad.
- travisgriggs 5y agoNewly minted granddad here. I’ve spent a couple hours with the kiddos playing and Daniel Tiger in the background. They watch sometimes. I agree with your sentiment. It seems nice and all, but somethings just meh about it compared to the old stuff. I’m increasingly concerned about a world that has doers and deciders. Fred Rogers was able to be both. He had the skills to do. But he also had a lot of influence and was able to decide. So often anymore, there are a group of creative doers who are placed under the thumb of people less able to do who have promoted themselves as a whole to take care of the deciding, so that the doers, uh, er, uh, have more time to do. Daniel Tiger feels like a well meaning kids show created in just such an environment.
- stephenhuey 5y agoIn defense of Daniel Tiger, even if it can’t fully compete with Fred Rogers while trying to follow in his footsteps, it at least explores childhood feelings in a slow, deliberate & understandable way which is more than I can say for most shows for kids. Too much frenzied action in the realm of kids’ entertainment and Fred Rogers was complaining about that in testimony to Congress long before I was born!
- murasaki 5y agoThis reminds me of a story I heard about how a child was scared to go to school because her teacher kept on talking about what they would do "in the meantime". It turns out she was afraid there was a "mean time" coming up. (Heard on "A way with words")
- Stratoscope 5y agoI had something similar happen when I went to kindergarden. (Yes, I know that's not how it's spelled. Bear with me.) It wasn't scary, just disappointing. I had figured out that "kinder" meant "kids", and I thought they would have a garden for us kids to play in. When I got there, it was just a classroom. There wasn't a garden in sight! But I made up for the disappointment by royally pranking my class. I had been playing around with electrical components, and I had a big fat electrolytic capacitor. Low voltage, but plenty of capacity. It may have been one farad. I charged it up at home to around three volts, and brought the capacitor and a screwdriver to Show and Tell. I explained what a capacitor was and how electricity could kill you, and then I "accidentally" grabbed the two terminals, one in each hand. I twitched and convulsed like I was getting electrocuted! Somehow I managed to let go of the terminals! Then I took the screwdriver and shorted the terminals, with a spark and a loud bang. I told the other kids, "That was a close call! But it's safe now. I discharged it. Who wants to try it next?"
- WalterBright 5y ago"garten" means garden in German. A literal translation is "Childrens' Garden". You weren't wrong.
- mywittyname 5y agoIt's where you bring the children to grow.
- WalterBright 5y agoAt Caltech, the theory was that freshmen needed to be watered for them to grow. So they'd get stuffed in the shower often :-)
- malkia 5y agoHaving worked with linguists on an ads eval platform (human eval), I can definitely appreciate what they've put into formulating questions/answers/documents/etc, such that these do not sound ambiguous, and not only that.
- laurieg 5y agoFred Rogers really appreciated the world from a child's perspective. The idea that when you're doing everything for the first time it can be very exciting and also scary. He often talks about the "drama" of everyday life. Imagine going to get a haircut for the first time, sitting in a chair that moves up and down and tilts in a way that no other chair you know does, experiencing all the sounds and sensations of scissors and clippers around your head. I hope that we all can see the world from a young person's perspective sometimes and realise that we don't need to inject any additional "drama".
- steve_adams_86 5y agoI often think about how nice it is to be an adult in that I can assess, address, and manage that drama. As a kid, my god, it was overwhelming. I came out of it with a distinct sense that the world is unsafe, unstable, and unpredictable. I have a hard time shaking those tendencies. Another great thing about being an adult is that you can provide kids with comfort and strategies to overcome that. It’s sometimes overlooked but such an easy way to enrich life for kids. Also I find your haircut example funny - I recall my first haircut in a public place being incredibly intimidating and uncomfortable. It’s probably why I went bald before my 20s; my body decided by age 6 or so that it didn’t want hair anymore.
- ohazi 5y ago> As a kid, my god, it was overwhelming. As an adult... Still pretty overwhelming sometimes!
- goldenkey 5y agoYou may feel secure but it's only because you don't know what is really happening on a daily basis. Snowden and Assange tried their best to show some of that. I myself was almost killed by the LAPD in 2011. The FBI didn't give a fuck. VICE news didn't give a fuck. And many of the other information packets I sent around the country were ignored. Contrary to what you may think, you can be tortured in America and there will be no recourse. Adult or kid, this country isn't some safe haven. These are the kind of burns I incurred after being hit by a militarized microwave beam [1] [2] for three days in a row, unrelentingly nearly every second of those three days. This device was gifted to Los Angeles by Raytheon and was only intended for 3 seconds of pulsed use in dispersing prison riots. But of course, the device had no misuse prevention mechanisms. I still have scars to prove it. [1] https://youtu.be/CwYvhY-g10A https://youtu.be/CwYvhY-g10A [2] https://www.wired.com/2010/08/pain-ray-rejected-by-the-military-ready-to-blast-l-a-prisoners/ https://www.wired.com/2010/08/pain-ray-rejected-by-the-milit... Below are images of the burns which caused sepsis (blood infection) and nearly killed me: https://i.imgur.com/lBt6kK6.jpg https://i.imgur.com/lBt6kK6.jpg https://i.imgur.com/nyymDmu.jpg https://i.imgur.com/nyymDmu.jpg https://i.imgur.com/LTWYysB.jpg https://i.imgur.com/LTWYysB.jpg https://i.imgur.com/DrMyaS5.jpg https://i.imgur.com/DrMyaS5.jpg https://i.imgur.com/Dwvwrh9.jpg https://i.imgur.com/Dwvwrh9.jpg https://i.imgur.com/OXos1Ji.jpg https://i.imgur.com/OXos1Ji.jpg https://i.imgur.com/duILx9R.jpg https://i.imgur.com/duILx9R.jpg https://i.imgur.com/UkFyQIR.jpg https://i.imgur.com/UkFyQIR.jpg https://i.imgur.com/PDsGaB8.jpg https://i.imgur.com/PDsGaB8.jpg https://i.imgur.com/HcQfgqu.jpg https://i.imgur.com/HcQfgqu.jpg The LAPD is so corrupt their members and even the sheriff have been known to be a part of a Neo-Nazi gang: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynwood_Vikings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynwood_Vikings Lee Baca, the sheriff, was recently convicted for having his men strongarm an FBI agent but his sentence is only a few years. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-02-05/former-los-angeles-county-sheriff-lee-baca-is-now-a-prison-inmate-in-texas https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-02-05/former-l... Who knows, maybe they did get my memo and never responded personally. I'll probably never know. I'm glad something happened though.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y agoMy mother took me to meet him at a book signing when I was very young. She was a kindergarten teacher who studied early childhood development. I got to speak to him briefly, and thought it was neat. Later in life I asked her about it, and she admitted that she only brought me because she knew how much I enjoyed the show, and that she personally found his manner of speaking (on the show) to be a bit grating. However, she said that upon meeting him in the flesh, all her prejudices immediately dissipated, and she could immediately tell that he was one of the most wholesome, honest, charming people she'd ever met. I haven't watched the semi-recent film about his life because I'm a big softie and I'm sure I'd bawl, but I do know that he was a very good man who will be missed for a long time.
- asxd 5y agoI can attest that the film, despite its flaws, had me on the verge of tears much of the time. Imagining someone whose sole goal is to encourage positive development hits me hard, for some reason. He surely had his demons like any human, but he seemed like a fellow that was intent on lifting the rest of us up.
- _def 5y ago> I haven't watched the semi-recent film about his life because I'm a big softie and I'm sure I'd bawl, From the article: "Rogers once halted taping of a show when a cast member told the puppet Henrietta Pussycat not to cry; he interrupted shooting to make it clear that his show would never suggest to children that they not cry." :)
- DavidAdams 5y agoI watched that film on a flight a couple of years ago, and cried, alone with my headphones, on a crowded airplane.
- CodeAndCuffs 5y agoThe Esquire article on Mr. Rogers, "Can you say Hero?"[1] is one of the best things I've ever read on the internet, and would highly recommend everyone to read. 1: (Esquire page is sign-in only, but I found a mirror) http://www.thedqtimes.com/pages/castpages/other/fredrogerscanyousayheropg1.htm http://www.thedqtimes.com/pages/castpages/other/fredrogersca...
- Animats 5y agoOf course, the next step after Step 9 would be "Obey". Early seasons of Sesame Street on DVD now come with warnings that they should not be viewed by children. Here's Sesame Street, S01E01.[1] There are kids outside doing things without adult supervision! [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9NUiHCr9Cs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9NUiHCr9Cs
- tablespoon 5y ago> Early seasons of Sesame Street on DVD now come with warnings that they should not be viewed by children Do you have a video or screenshot of the warning?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Animats 5y ago"These early ‘Sesame Street’ episodes are intended for grown-ups, and may not suit the needs of today’s preschool child.” Why? Cookie Monster carries a pipe in one recurring parody—and then eats it. Oscar the Grouch is too grouchy and mean. And in the first episode, a grown man—Gordon—asks a little girl to come home with him for milk and cookies… and she does! [1] [1] https://consumerist.com/2007/11/19/early-sesame-street-dvds-have-adults-only-warnings/ https://consumerist.com/2007/11/19/early-sesame-street-dvds-...
- boomboomsubban 5y agoSo it's got nothing to do with kids being outside unsupervised, but not wanting to encourage kids to stick random objects in their mouth or follow strangers home. As someone who went to the hospital as a child after sticking a pipe in their mouth, those seem like fair warnings.
- C19is20 5y agoTranslation of "pipe", into European? Intrigued!
- arp242 5y agoAside: I find it very annoying when people talk to children in a patronizing way as if they're stupid. Children can certainly see things different but they're not stupid. When I was a scout leader I generally talked to children as if they were adults – although I did take care to phrase things carefully, although not going as far as Mr. Rogers – and this works quite well.
- asxd 5y agoNot to get too gushy, but as I grow older I often find myself feeling more like a child again--in that the world is not a controlled place, and none of us know why we're here, and we are all kind of trying our best to make a nice time of it. There's really no instruction manual for dealing with all the curveballs and caveats. Mr. Rogers always gets me emotional, because his messaging strikes me as addressing that exact issue. It's scary being a new human, but in another light, it can also be wonderful. He acknowledges the former, but highlights the latter. I know this was kind of a stuffy statement, but darnnit if I don't appreciate the hard work that man did :-)
- projectileboy 5y agoI was a little kid in the 70s, and it would be hard to overstate what a big deal Mister Rogers was to kids between the ages of about 4 to 8. I had a relatively happy childhood, and even I practically thought of him as an additional parent. His goodbye message to the kids who grew up with him is touching: https://youtu.be/kFVPkn37iFM https://youtu.be/kFVPkn37iFM
- tragomaskhalos 5y agoNot American so unfamiliar with this excellent man, but his careful attention to language is brilliant and seems very ahead of its time. When I was small there was a strict teacher at primary school with a harsh grating voice whom I was very afraid of; my mum tried to help by reassuring me that this lady's "bark was worse than her bite". Of course I had never heard this idiom before so in my mind she transformed into a snarling dog, which naturally made my anxiety a million times worse. I bet Fred Rogers would have caught that faux pas and edited it out!
- bitwize 5y agoI used to be nervous about the drain in the bathtub. But I had a Mister Rogers record, and of course I knew of him from TV. On the record was "You Can Never Go Down The Drain". When I heard that song my anxiety subsided.
- vortico 5y agoThis show was so much better than what I see parents letting their kids watch today, such as this seemingly AI-generated spam. https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=nursery+rhyme+cartoon https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=nursery+rhyme+c... I wonder how this difference will affect the next generation.
- roguas 5y agoSo we are doing a transformation from: It is dangerous to play in the street. To: Your favorite grown-ups can tell you where it is safe to play. It is important to try to listen to them, and listening is an important part of growing. In all honesty going so verbose appending additional context etc. Let's consider this function should also take a parameter of age. I would be annoyed as 10 year old if people talked to me like that - it is super condescending. It might work for a 3 year old. I generally think kids appreciate treating them like small adults and indulge in discussion.
- pocketgrok 5y agoMr Rogers never sounded condescending to me. I think it helps that he really owned it. I’d say he came off as a little boring but nice and caring.
- triceratops 5y ago10 year olds were not the target audience. I think I stopped watching the show after I turned 7.
- Graffur 5y agoDoes anyone else find this beyond silly? How did we survive, grow and build the world without these sacred rules
- pocketgrok 5y agoThe rules aren’t “how to talk to children” they’re for the show’s dialogue. Mr Rogers needs to be more careful than regular people in real life. He’s talking to thousands of children at once and can’t read the room or clarify things for them, but doesn’t want to be misunderstood. Also, he’s well aware that every word he says is being recorded to be scrutinized for ages to come.
- Graffur 5y agoOh. Thanks for clarifying.
- kosasbest 5y agoOne life-skill you can master is being able to switch up your language depending on who you're talking to. I talk to my son differently than I do my best friend (obviously). We even have an Internet slang term for this: ELI5[0] [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/ https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/
- rvbissell 5y agoWe also have a meat-space academic term for it: code switching.
- dilap 5y agoIt's interesting seeing how many people loved Mr Rogers as a kid. To offer a contrasting experience... As far back as I can remember, I hated Mr Rogers. And in general, I did not enjoy it when adults spoke differently to me than they spoke to each other. To this day, statements like > Your favorite grown-ups can tell you where it is safe to play. It is important to try to listen to them, and listening is an important part of growing. strike me as incredibly weird, almost like a verbal version of the uncanny vally.
- drdeadringer 5y agoKids can tell when they aren't being given straight answers. Kids may not understand that they're doing "The 5 Whys", and//or that doing so may be annoying for the umpteenth time. But non-answers like "because" as the be-all & end-all has an expiration date. That bill comes due for somebody. If that somebody ends up being your grown-up kid when it's time to pay, I wonder how much sympathy I'll have and for whom.
- castlecrasher2 5y ago>I did not enjoy it when adults spoke differently to me than they spoke to each other. Seeing the Mr Rogers documentary that came out a few years ago, I realized that he basically spoke the same with everyone.
- dilap 5y agoOK, that's fair! He spoke very unlike the adults and kids around me, though. :-)
- jgwil2 5y ago> > Your favorite grown-ups can tell you where it is safe to play. It is important to try to listen to them, and listening is an important part of growing. > strike me as incredibly weird, almost like a verbal version of the uncanny vally. I don't think that you have to talk to kids that you know like this, but it was important on the TV show that they not make assumptions (like that the child knows their parents) because they are broadcasting it to a huge number of kids with different life circumstances.
- refracture 5y agoThe more I learn about him the more sad I am that I never watched his show as a child.
- alickz 5y agoAs a European I never grew up with Mister Rogers, but his testimony to the Senate Subcommittee on Communications is very impressive to me. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fKy7ljRr0AA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fKy7ljRr0AA
- pomian 5y agoThanks for that. It shows how a simple passionate speech, can bring about positive change. I also grew up without Mr. Rogers, but your link led me down a rabbit hole, and I recommend this speech, when he was older, especially the last half, for students young and old; together with a special version of: "It's you I like." https://youtu.be/907yEkALaAY https://youtu.be/907yEkALaAY
- songzme 5y agowow thanks for sharing the speech. Great speech. I had to learn after college to appreciate who I was and stop trying to "do sensational stuff" to get people to like me.
- bborud 5y agoThese rules are even more applicable when talking to adults who can't be treated like adults.