8 ms·
This fits in with many of the grand old conspiracy theories. What the conspiracy theorists miss is there doesn't need to be a unified agenda behind this process
by h2odragon 5y ago
This fits in with many of the grand old conspiracy theories. What the conspiracy theorists miss is there doesn't need to be a unified agenda behind this process, simple banal human tribalism suffices.
Mr Hanson's "elites" here are just as simple, emotional, and irrational critters as any of the rest of us, and their kindergarten politics are no more (or less) noble than our "who stole my lunch?" bullshit. By being big fish in a smaller pond the waves of silliness they slop go further, that's all.
- bilbo0s 5y agoEssentially, elites come from among the people. People generate elites, who generate policy. Bias flows the same way. In any given nation, the people are very likely biased. Which generates biased elites. Who, in turn, generate biased policy. The problem is not biased elites. The problem is that humans are biased, and little can be done to remove their biases. Much less to ensure they don't manifest those biases in the results of their work.
- wussboy 5y agoI agree with everything except your last sentence. Much CAN be done to ensure those biases do not manifest in the results of their work. More generally, this is the power of our institutions.
- DamnYuppie 5y agoWhich are formed by people with biases who are attracted to other people with biases. It is turtles all the way down.
- h2odragon 5y agoTurtles would be so much simpler, tho. A tortoise will copulate with a boot for hours with no pretense about what he's doing or why. No justifications or excuses. Us hairless apes on the other hand, we'll act contrary to all our good sense in the firm belief that "the job requires it" or "the boss wants it this way" or worst yet "the rule book specifies it thus". We can knowingly compound our stupidity and decry the results. Then expect praise for following the rules. At least the tortoise gets the idea, at the bottom of the hole, "dig up, stupid!"
- IIAOPSW 5y agoInstitutions are error correction. We can form a less biased system out of constituent parts each of which is more biased than the whole.
- popcube 5y agoelites become intellectuals, intellectuals have their solid bias. whenever someone was converted, they will get same bias. e.g., world should be changed to 'better way' by them.
- pjc50 5y agoAt some point you have to acknowledge that not all "biases" are bad; a bias may just be a value you don't agree with. Being biased against the extermination of all human life is a bias, but I think we'd agree it's a good one.
- rrsmtz 5y ago> elites come from among the people ... People generate elites That's just false! In every society, the elite class is overwhelmingly comprised of families who maintain their high social standing and wealth over decades or centuries. The lower classes are similarly static over the generations, and all classes have a class-specific bias. If you need proof, take a sampling of the 'Early Life' Wikipedia section of any elite you can think of. Even tech founders, who are more likely socially mobile than most other elites, have overwhelmingly had an upper-middle class upbringing at _least_.
- rayiner 5y agoYour second paragraph is completely at odds with your first paragraph. Founders coming from upper middle class families is not what a society with stable elites looks like. Zuckerberg for example did come from an upper middle class background. His father was a dentist. His grandfather Jack Zuckerberg was in the Air Force. And his great grandfather came here as an immigrant to Ellis island and worked as a fruit peddler and tailor.
- pen2l 5y agoI see the point you're making (and mostly agree with it,), but I don't know about calling the Zuckerberg family just 'upper middle class', his grandparents came from humble beginnings, sure. But I'd rather say Mark himself comes from a squarely upper class background. Upper middle class households don't quite send two kids to Phillips Exeter Academy or boarding schools anywhere in that price range (50-60k per year). There's a big difference in income between a dentist who owns his practice and has other dentists working with him vs. just a dentist; Mark's dad was in the former category.
- rayiner 5y agoUpper class families don’t have their kids transfer into Exeter after two years at public high school. But I’m fine calling that upper class, the point is that it’s not anything like generational wealth.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- natemp 5y agoThis essay makes exactly the same points as "Yes Minister", except in non-comedic form. "Yes Minister" is widely regarded as a politician's manual and not as a conspiracy theory. But perhaps if the elite BBC makes a series that is surprisingly accurate, it is the truth. If an internet commentator makes the same points, it is a conspiracy theory. Which proves the first paragraph of this very essay.
- vmception 5y agoFrom my experience, many conspiracies are manuals. Like, whether they happened or not, they're good ideas. "Good" in that they can be executed successfully. Obviously this depends no which conspiracy comes to mind when you hear "conspiracy theory", but many can be inspirational.
- hammock 5y ago>From my experience, most conspiracies are manuals. Figuratively true, and sometimes literally. Take the Operation Northwoods manual for instance: http://www.smeggys.co.uk/operation_northwoods.php?image=01#tt http://www.smeggys.co.uk/operation_northwoods.php?image=01#t... >Operation Northwoods was a 1962 plan by the U.S. Department of Defense to stage acts of simulated or real terrorism on US soil and against U.S. interests and then put the blame of these acts on Cuba in order to generate U.S. public support for military action against the Cuban government of Fidel Castro. As part of the U.S. government's Operation Mongoose anti-Castro initiative, the plan, which was not implemented, called for various false flag actions, including simulated or real state-sponsored acts of terrorism on U.S. and Cuban soil. The plan was proposed by senior U.S. Department of Defense leaders, including the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Lyman Louis Lemnitzer.
- WJW 5y agoI don't think anyone in the UK sees "Yes Minister" as a manual. Its comedy derives from exposing things that everybody perceives to be true (politicians want to have morals but are forced to let them go during election season, civil servants know they're supposed to be supporting the current government but will also need to work with the other party when the political tides change again, etc) but saying so in public is "not done". It doesn't need to be a manual because it is accurately describing human weakness in the face of a complex world, and the results are (as in the real world) often highly absurd.
- retrac 5y ago> What the conspiracy theorists miss is there doesn't need to be a unified agenda behind this process There doesn't need to be a mind behind a process. Many things, including some of society's worst troubles and the confluences of malfeasance in politics, are simply emergent properties of large social systems. No intent necessary.
- techbio 5y agoThis is an incredibly important point that I agree with. I would take this further to separate "legal person" from "mind", as I understand the mind is itself an emergent and self-supporting adaptive process[1], very common to find among any persistent complex systems. Politicians don't make politics, it's the other way around. [1] I use this phrase to replace "intent", because outside of requiring the "intender" to be person who can be held to account with punishment or reward, the reward mechanism is the same environmental pressure.
- h2odragon 5y agoThere's an interesting other side there too: corporations are our "slow AI", if we take a more realistic approach to their legal personhood perhaps we can all benefit.
- unyttigfjelltol 5y agoReminds of research of termite mounds. A researcher mused that maybe mounds are best understood as a composite animal that in some sense, itself has a soul. One particular scientist "imagined that eventually the mound would evolve into a being that could move across the veldt – very slowly in its dirt skin – a monster hybrid of soil and soul."[1] [1] https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/sep/18/a-giant-crawling-brain-the-jaw-dropping-world-of-termites https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/sep/18/a-giant-crawlin...
- teddyh 5y agoThis is a very old idea; see, for instance, the “Aunt Hillary” character from Gödel, Escher, Bach (written in 1979).
- akyu 5y agoThe simplest strategy for "simple, emotional, and irrational critters" to adopt is to conspire together. You are just proving the point.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoIt is a tribe, but one that can destroy you with more expensive lawyers.
- bilbo0s 5y agoNo difference between them and the tribes that can destroy you with guns. And no difference between the ones who can destroy you with guns and the ones that can destroy you with baseball bats. In the end, it's all the same, their tribe employs deadly force against you. One tribe gets fancy lawyers to speak eloquently in defense of the deadly force employed against you, another may just kill you and go home to have a beer. Either way, you're still dead.
- notahacker 5y agoThe detail of the paper, rather than the headline, actually undercuts most of the traditional conspiracy theories. The views of the 90th percentile "elite" are highly correlated with those of the median voter, and largely uncorrelated with business lobby groups. Paper is at: https://sci-hub.tf/10.1017/s1537592714001595 https://sci-hub.tf/10.1017/s1537592714001595 Another quirk is that it appears even supermajorities often don't get their way (the graphs show that if 80-90% of the elite favour a policy, it is enacted a little under half the time. Which is better than the probability if 80-90% of the median voters favour it, but still means they usually don't get their way...) The headline finding is their model which essentially suggests that the median voter doesn't have much influence except where their views align with wealthier people and/or interest groups, but the thing is, they usually do align with one or other and none of the groups actually get their way that often! It'd also be interesting to see the findings disaggregated by administration and by policy area. It is not difficult to imagine that some of the most consistent disagreements between the median American and the elite American regards issues like upper tax brackets (which elites pay and median Americans don't). To what extent politicians are seeking the favour of 90th percentile Americans when they (sometimes) don't raise upper income tax brackets even when the average American supports it and to what extent they are simply pleasing themselves and following their preferred economic theory are open questions. Disaggregation would also help evaluate other theories, like one of American's political parties being aligned with the elite, or the reverse causation hypothesis where in a political environment where proposed change often fails, the 90th percentile American is [incidentally] happier with the status quo.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Zababa 5y ago> The detail of the paper, rather than the headline, actually undercuts most of the traditional conspiracy theories. > Another quirk is that it appears even supermajorities often don't get their way (the graphs show that if 80-90% of the elite favour a policy, it is enacted a little under half the time. Which is better than the probability if 80-90% of the median voters favour it, but still means they usually don't get their way...) I think those two things oppose each others.
- rrsmtz 5y agoIt's not conspiratorial to believe that humans create organizations with common goals and agendas - they exist everywhere, from unions to NGOs. Here's a short list of organizations (off the top of my head) who discuss and advocate for policies that benefit the extremely wealthy over others: * Davos * WTO * IMF * World Bank
- rayiner 5y agoThe IMF and World Bank shouldn’t be on that list. They help third world countries replicate the practices and systems that have made developed countries wealthy. I remember reading an article in 2000 from some Brown professor encouraging Bangladesh (my home country) not to listen to the World Bank and IMF and instead do indigenous agriculture or something like that. Good thing nobody gives a shot what Brown professors think because Bangladesh has developed tremendously over the last two decades thanks to following those policies.
- FormerBandmate 5y agoThe World Bank and the IMF have led to flawed outcomes in some places, but they’ve also led to phenomenal outcomes (e.g. the Four Asian Tigers, post-war Europe, and Greece recently). Their failures are largely the fault of elite preconceptions rather than open malice
- rayiner 5y agoWhen World Bank and IMF policies fail it’s more often than not due to the lack of political and personal virtue in the implementing countries.
- julianapostate 5y agonot sure why shouldnt be on the list, the IMF discussed and advocated it, and the Bangladeshi gov followed their lead. the definition of a conspire is to "work together to someone else's detriment", im sure from the perpective of someone who didn't benefit from that economic development they "conspired".
- pessimizer 5y agoI think what's missed is that there doesn't have to be a conspiracy behind a unified agenda. People whose goals and interests converge can coordinate without actually colluding.
- karaterobot 5y agoThere wasn't anything in this article that made me think he was suggesting a conspiracy. In fact the word 'bias' (repeated twice in the title) sort of implies it's not a conscious process. The way I read it was that everybody acts in their own interests, without coordination, and trends emerge, with "elite status" being a label you apply to a set of completely unrelated people. No conspiracy, just bias. Looking at the author's CV, he's an economics professor, and that's a very Econ view of the world. So, I would not be surprised if he doesn't feel like he needs to explain that perspective on his blog.
- vmception 5y agoOne time I was in an uber in Paris, and the uber driver felt it was his duty to tell me about all the shadow groups that control the world. The only problem is that they were Parisian versions of shadow groups that would therefore have to be in direct competition with the American shadow groups that control the world. Anyway, nice to see the filter bubbles working so well. Haha, localized versions of controlling groups. No, but really, the flaw behind these master controlling group theories is that there are so many of them that would have to compete that its the same as none existing.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> No, but really, the flaw behind these master controlling group theories is that there are so many of them that would have to compete that its the same as none existing. Andrew Gelman has made this same observation, which he calls "the piranha problem", in the context of sociology and psychology papers. The typical paper identifies a random-looking stimulus that nevertheless has a large effect on some behavior like voting or accepting a romantic partner. And the problem is, there are so many of these papers, all showing large effects, that it's impossible for any of the effects to be reliable, because even if the effect a particular paper identifies is real, there are so many other effects influencing the same outcome that the effect described by the particular paper cannot have any meaningful influence.
- int_19h 5y agoOh, it gets better. Once the conspiracy theorists discover each other online, they interact and mesh their theories together, including those "shadow groups". BTW, it can be rather amusing to see how the culture of different societies is reflected in their respective conspiracy tropes. For example, in US, we have "sovereign citizens", while Germany has "Reichsburgers". Both groups make broadly similar claims - asserting inapplicability of most laws to themselves etc. But while sovereign citizens are completely decentralized and don't even claim any legitimate central authority, the Reichsburgers have an ostensible shadow government-in-exile (although they disagree on which of the many is the legitimate one). And said "government" actually issues documents such as IDs and driver licenses, that are anathema to the sovereign citizens as a matter of principle. Ordnung muss sein?