12 ms·
Ireland raises privacy question over Facebook smart glasses
- trebligdivad 5y agoCan we just look back to all the stories about Google Glass a few years back and repeat them?
- foobaby 5y agoThe problem with these is that they're essentially masquerading as normal sunglasses. I don't think most people in public will even notice that these aren't normal Ray Bans. Google Glass wasn't effective in part due to the fact that they were obvious to those around the wearer. That's not the case with these, which is frankly terrifying.
- dmoo 5y agoJust to say, they will notice them in Ireland. There are not that many sunglasses days…
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoYou'd be surprised how many people didn't notice them, tbh.
- rvense 5y agoIt's hard for me to articulate how this makes me feel. As someone who values anonymity and, for no particular reason, would prefer not to be photographed and have my movements tracked, I feel like I am being forced from public spaces. Regulated CCTV coverage of certain areas is one thing. This is untracked, unlimited surveillance by a private company whose goals and motives are completely removed from any semblance of public, democratic influence. Facebook must be destroyed.
- colpabar 5y agoEasy with the conspiracy theories. They may know your height, your eye/hair color, your skin color, your license plate #, where you live, where you work, where you shop, who you hang out with, etc, but you'll still be totally anonymous when they sell that information to whoever pays for it. They swear!
- sockpuppet_12 5y agoI know right? Only people who have something to hide would care if some bespectacled reprobate snaps down-shirt shots of them on the subway to share the 'experience' with their fellows.
- jlokier 5y agoWhen the cameras and processing are good enough, the watchers may also know your heart rate, breathing rate, who you glance at that goes by and which ones raise your heart rate, when you smile, when you frown, your pupil dilation, what items you browse in physical shops even if you don't buy, everything that can be picked out by lip reading, whether you look like you got a good night's sleep; trends in all these factors over time as they see you from multiple cameras across the months and years, and can probably predict when you will lose your job and if you're getting a divorce before you, your spouse and your employer knows these things, and which cancer you have before it's diagnosed (but will use it to raise/deny your insurance rather than actually help you). Of course it will all be presented only to trustworthy researchers with impeccable standards of ethics who have your interests first, such as the advertising unit, and the ministry of happiness and fair opportunity for all. All data requests from law enforcement fishing crews, "surgical" tactical vote manipulators, blackmailers, credit reference agencies, insurance companies, pre-crime detection centres, and religious morality police will of course be turned down, as that would be unethical. No price could possibly be high enough...
- drclau 5y ago> I don't think most people in public will even notice that these aren't normal Ray Bans Most people will not even be aware such devices exist. Here, on HN, there's an assumption that everyone is or will soon be up-to-date with tech news. But, the world outside of HN is way, way larger. I bet most people won't know what is going on even if they notice the eyeglasses have an LED that's on. It's not like an LED is a universal signal for "your privacy is cancelled now".
- MertsA 5y ago> I bet most people won't know what is going on even if they notice the eyeglasses have an LED that's on. It's not like an LED is a universal signal for "your privacy is cancelled now". On decoy surveillance cameras they'll usually have a blinking or solid LED on them because the trope of "blinking red LED means it's recording" is so widespread. That's been used in film, self checkouts, body cameras, surveillance systems, etc. I don't know what indication would be more likely to signal a recording in progress short of a loudspeaker screaming "YOU ARE BEING RECORDED RIGHT NOW". I think it's far more likely that the general public will be unaware of the existing ways they are being surveilled.
- a5aAqU 5y agoPeople who are concerned about it will stop talking to people who wear Ray-Bans. I could see this having a negative effect on Ray-Ban, especially since it's easy to say "ban Ray-Bans" or "Ray-Bans are banned" when you're hosting a gathering or event. Customers are going to want to know, "Why do people around me always seem to look angry when I wear Ray-Bans? I get called 'glasshole' a few times every week."
- ajb 5y agoDavid Brin predicted that surveillance would be impossible to control in his 1998 book "The Transparent Society", going on to argue that there are two possible futures: one in which the masses are under 100% surveillance, while elites can act behind closed doors, and one in which the masses can also see what the elites are doing ("sousveillance"). I'm still hoping that there is a way out, but Brin is looking more and more prescient.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoLooks like we'll need to become part of this elite in order to have any peace.
- InvertedRhodium 5y agoThis is HN, everyone is trying to become part of the elite here.
- tellersidd 5y agoI welcome these because it is all the same problems with Google Glass + a bunch of others. This obviously goes too far and we might even get some sane legislation out of this.
- rsynnott 5y agoNo repeat of the Robert Scoble photo, please!
- Animats 5y agoAt least with Google Glass, you had a display. These don't even have that. It's mostly a music player, really. Let's call them "fDweebs". ("iDweebs" were those Apple earbuds with white wires.)
- siva7 5y agoThese glasses look ridiculous, i can’t understand how a brand like ray-ban throws their name in for what looks like spy glasses https://www.ray-ban.com/usa/electronics/RW4004%20UNISEX%20RAY-BAN%20STORIES%20|%20WAYFARER-Black/8056597489478 https://www.ray-ban.com/usa/electronics/RW4004%20UNISEX%20RA...
- SomeBoolshit 5y agoI'm a little confused by your comment. The glasses pictured in the article look like a pretty standard pair of modern Wayfarers.
- rootsudo 5y agolitereally like ebay-chinese esque ones too. https://www.amazon.com/GoVision-Sunglasses-Resistant-Lightweight-Titanium/dp/B07YBZ7FX5/ https://www.amazon.com/GoVision-Sunglasses-Resistant-Lightwe...
- neetfreek 5y agoJust to comment on your take about the brand itself. Ray-Ban is owned by the Luxottica Group, who are set to merge with Essilor - looking at ~25% global value of eyewear. This means they own enough to possibly a) start normalising this whole thing by pushing out with other brands and b) Ray-Ban now bombing could be a credible calculated risk.
- dmoo 5y agoFor context https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/may/10/the-invisible-power-of-big-glasses-eyewear-industry-essilor-luxottica https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/may/10/the-invisible-p...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jtsiskin 5y agoThey look… exactly the same as these? https://www.ray-ban.com/usa/sunglasses/RB2140%20UNISEX%20original%20wayfarer%20classic-black/805289126577 https://www.ray-ban.com/usa/sunglasses/RB2140%20UNISEX%20ori...
- andylynch 5y agoSurprising it’s the DPC piping up. They aren’t generally known as an aggressive regulator
- croes 5y agoMaybe just a proactive move. The DPC asks, FB answers, all is good, no privacy problems. And the indicator LED can easily be hidden with tape or these laptop camera stickers, if you are more into the ironic touch.
- vmoore 5y ago1984 was a warning, not an instruction manual. It is good to bring up privacy issues with this. Essentially these glasses are a cheap version of what spies have been wearing for decades, so of course it's going to raise eyebrows. Putting surveillance powers in the hands of everyday folk invariably leads to bad things.
- lmkg 5y agoThe Irish regulator is the one with jurisdiction, so they're the one that's on point for this topic. They're also quite proactive in offering guidance, material, and feedback. Their cookie sweep from a few years back is something I still reference on a regular basis for the contours of "strictly necessary." They just don't actually regulate. They offer a lot of guidance and ask a lot of strong-worded questions, but those don't turn into fines.
- jsudi 5y agoWhat is “L1N2QC2KU”?
- jobigoud 5y agoOnly place I can find it is in variants of this article. Maybe the author of the original pasted their password by mistake while they were working on it and the proofreader thought it was a code name or something.
- anderson1993 5y ago“Smart” is almost an exaggeration in this case. They don’t have any AR, so it’s just a camera basically, as far as I heard.
- rusk 5y agoThe glassholes have returned. This time incognito.
- siva7 5y agoSo am i the only one where this would be social suicide wearing such things? Maybe someone can explain
- ramphastidae 5y agoAgreed. If someone I was with was wearing these, the conversation would end immediately.
- copperx 5y agoIt is a good thing that these glasses are tinted, otherwise, people would wear them indoors, in private spaces.
- siva7 5y agoI am sorry to disappoint but they are available with clear glasses and therefore also with prescription glasses
- sbassi 5y agothere are not tinted models, with only blue light filter, or with prescription glasses. https://www.ray-ban.com/usa/electronics/RW4003%20UNISEX%20ray-ban%20stories%20%7C%20round-black/8056597489645 https://www.ray-ban.com/usa/electronics/RW4003%20UNISEX%20ra...
- C19is20 5y ago...if you noticed them.
- shever73 5y agoThis is exactly what I thought when I first saw them. The LED can be easily covered, and they look too much like normal sunglasses for the average person to notice. Day after day, my loathing for Facebook grows.
- pmoriarty 5y agoUnfortunately Facebook is far from the only company that regularly invades and has contempt for privacy. That contemptuous attitude and attempts to profit from privacy invasion is almost omnipresent among companies these days. On the subject of glasses that can record what you see, wasn't Google the first company to market them? There was a similar backlash against them too back then.
- agency 5y agoAt least with Google glass there was little danger of mistaking my them for “normal” glasses. These Facebook/Ray Ban ones are designed to blend in.
- noptd 5y agoYeah, this reminds me of a product you'd find in a spy museum. Cue the chilling effect of having to worry about being recorded whenever you're talking around someone wearing Raybans in public. And before the claims about it not being worse than everyone having a smartphone, etc, it absolutely is - it's far more obvious if someone has their phone in hand.
- FridayoLeary 5y agoIt's not FB. It's progress. You can replace them with any other name in the world. It just happens to be that Facebook announced this rather obvious technology.
- eps 5y agoYou must've missed the first eposide of this show called "Glassholes".
- 5y ago
- wortelefant 5y agogreat, so my RayBan wayfarer glasses will soon be regarded as suspicious
- noident 5y agoThis is why I've completely ruled out buying another pair of Ray-Bans again, and I've owned several in the past.
- kmlx 5y agowhat’s the difference between these glasses and the snapchat spectacles? https://www.spectacles.com/ https://www.spectacles.com/
- siva7 5y agoThe new Spectacles are not for sale. They’re built for creators looking to push the limits of immersive AR experiences.
- kmlx 5y agothe new spectacles aren’t for sale. the old ones are. and the fb glasses look like spectacles v1. maybe i’m missing something, but it feels like fb just launched a product that was already out there for a while now.
- fsociety 5y agoAnd what is the end goal of Spectacles? Surely to do more than just be exclusive for creators.
- annadane 5y agoIt's just bad optics, no pun intended. They know the privacy concerns surrounding Facebook yet they choose to release smart glasses
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aierou 5y agoI don't mean to go too much against the narrative in this thread, but aren't cameras on glasses necessary to achieve AR? Are people concerned about these glasses just because it's Facebook, or is there broader opposition to AR technology?
- briandear 5y agoFor me, it’s because Facebook. They have no track record of trust. I work for a significant Silicon Valley tech company and have seen up close the types of shenanigans that have been attempted by Facebook — especially with their mobile apps. Don’t trust them.
- e3bc54b2 5y ago> They have no track record of trust. Its worse. They have a consistent track record for asking for trust and then breaking it in most abusive way possible, then issuing a non-apology only after getting caught and then repeating same process all-over again. Oh, I forgot mentioning FB getting rich in the process, so it somehow becomes justified and has zero chance for change.
- aierou 5y agoAren't all recorded breaches of trust (outside of admittedly predatory data collection schemes endemic to the software industry) the result of unprecedented attacks on social networks as a construct? How would one anticipate such attacks? I think it's fair to say that Facebook grew too quickly to mitigate the issues inherent to social networks at scale. I don't think that makes them abusive or evil, just naive.
- freeone3000 5y agoRemember the time they asked for your phone number for 2FA and then used it for contact linking?
- bobthepanda 5y ago
- fidesomnes 5y agooh yes Ireland, the great bastion of privacy concern trolling.
- concordDance 5y agoWhy are people up in arms about this? Imagine a transhuman future where we all have superhuman memory and have integrated mind machine interfaces, able to perfectly transfer information between ourselves. Would you insist that people's memories be degraded to be close to the average memory quality? Or would you prevent them from transferring the information via things like degrading their perfect drawing skills? (Or maybe just make drawing people's faces from memory without their consent illegal? Presumably while also making it illegal to do things like sharing a high fidelity memory with a friend or spouse)
- tiernano 5y agoCause it's Facebook... Any other company, sign me up... But fuck you Facebook....
- bobthepanda 5y agoI live in an all-party consent state, and would like to keep it that way. I don't want to be traced through other people's recordings, particularly through something that is easy to always have on.
- pronlover723 5y agoI just reported to my friends that bobthepanda posted a message on hacker news. I didn't ask for your consent to tell them. I also told my sister about a conversation I had with a friend. I didn't ask the friend's permission to share.
- bobthepanda 5y agobut that doesn't scale, and isn't super high fidelity anyways (eyewitness recall is notoriously bad). Just because something is possible, doesn't mean we should make more extreme versions of it possible.
- pronlover723 5y agoIt does scale. People have been writing what other people do in books and newspapers for centuries and spreading the info to millions of people I see it as what right do you have to prevent me from sharing my experiences and memories and what right do you have do prevent me from augmenting that memory? Taken to an extreme your POV seems like it would ban paper. Why I am allowed to take notes about what someone is saying other than in my brain? We should ban paper! Oh, I replaced paper with a computer. Oh, I used a computer to do speech recognition and record the notes. Oh, I videod the speech. What if I augment my brain. People have long been working on making chips to help people with brain damage. What if they get to the point those chips have flawless memory? I get those are hypotheticals, but they help to think about what's the underlying principles. Today I can walk down the street and live stream everything I see so it's not like we aren't there already at some degree. I also saw some people brought up they're in a "consent" state. I don't know of any consent states that prevent videotaping without consent. If they did, all security cameras would be illegal. I do know at least one state prevents audio recording without consent. I suspect that won't last. For one because everyone will have a video camera + mic so at some point the state will catch up to how people behave rather than try to stop them. For 2 because given enough processing and framerate I suspect you can extract audio from video (). For 3 you could use lip readers (or trained AI) to extract conversation from video. () https://news.mit.edu/2014/algorithm-recovers-speech-from-vibrations-0804 https://news.mit.edu/2014/algorithm-recovers-speech-from-vib...
- verdverm 5y agoFor those who worry about the camera and your privacy, how do phone cameras differ in this respect with everyone taking and uploading pictures, videos, snaps, and tiktoks in public spaces?
- bussierem 5y agoI have no skin in this game but the most common answer to this is that it's a lot easier to tell when someone is pointing a phone at you, unless they're REALLY being sneaky. With glasses this becomes impossible.
- verdverm 5y agoI think for the most part, you end up in the background of a photo. How many selfies might you be in? Have you worried about that prior?
- cronix 5y agoHow many Amazon Ring doorbells do you walk/drive past every day without realizing it?
- crakhamster01 5y agoI see this argument a lot as well, and it frankly makes no sense to me. All too often I've been at small to medium sized gatherings (5 - 10 people) where someone will record me/the general group and I'll only have realized later after seeing it on social media. Now imagine how often you're inadvertently captured on camera just walking around in public. I can concede the case of 1-on-1 interactions, where a smartphone is much more noticeable than smart glasses, but IMO the march towards AR glasses is inevitable. Eventually we'll get to a point where either people will be able to recognize smart glasses in those situations based off of prior experience, or indicators to distinguish smart glasses become standardized.
- InvertedRhodium 5y ago> it's a lot easier to tell when someone is pointing a phone at you What are you supposed to do with this information though? Ok, so now you know that you're being recorded (presumably in a public place) - what's the next move, and how does it bring about a result that is practically different to you never being aware of the recording?
- theknocker 5y agoThe time to fight this battle is when it's criminals in the "intelligence community" violating our rights, not when it's private citizens with slightly goofier camera phones, i.e. a long time ago. (Though in fairness, I guess I do think every law enforcement official should have a camera embedded in their forehead.)
- guilhas 5y agoYou can already by hidden camera sun glasses on amazon
- bennysomething 5y agoI don't even understand how this got past the first whiteboard meeting "yeah right you want this to perv at the beach, park etc". It's just a creepy hidden camera.
- sbassi 5y agothere are hundreds of hidden cameras on glasses, Teddy bears, hats, pens, and so on, just to to Alibaba and other Chinese vendors.
- pronlover723 5y agoI know this will get DVed but this seems like one of those things we'll look back on in 20yrs and "mostly" wonder what all the fuss was about. AR cameras seem inevitable. They're strange today but ask any 2006 non-techie if they'd consider carrying a pocket computer and they'd laugh at you. Now they all have one and you'd likely only get them to part with it from their cold dead fingers. The privacy issues are a huge consequence but IMO they won't stop the march of progress. Too many positives. First is they enable AR which full sci-fi AR seems eminently useful. 2nd, they'll likely help prevent all kinds of crime, especially once implanted or put in contact lenses. Rape, Muggings, theft, seem like they'd all go down in a world where AR cameras are as ubiquitous as smartphones. How do backroom deals, government conspiracies, corporate malfeasance stay private when everyone in the room is recording it? You could say "they'll be told to turn it off to participate" but I suspect as we get more and more dependent it will become near impossible to ask people to turn off their connections. They won't be able to effectively participate in the meeting with all referencing all the stuff their AR display gives them access to. Police brutality? All of it recorded. Further, as a 2021 person used to privacy it scares the crap out of me for all my private activities with others to be recorded. But a generation of people that grew up with the AR will likely have no such reservations. They'll be used to having every sex act recorded. So, while the privacy issues are real I feel like it's mostly like commanding the waves to stop crashing. Impossible. Better to just accept that it's coming and figure out how best to deal with it. I don't believe laws telling people they can't have it or use it will work. I know if you value your privacy that sucks but I doubt anything can be done to stop it from coming and I so I think it's better to embrace its arrival.
- 123pie123 5y ago> Better to just accept that it's coming and figure out how best to deal with it. No - I massively disagree with this we're still at the forefront of the internet revolution , if we simply cave in on things like this, then all the subsquent generations will get the pain. We can stop it if we say no - it is 100% NOT inevitable, we can choose as a society
- revolvingocelot 5y ago
- yawaworht1978 5y agoMalicious actors could just place them on a balcony near an ATM, this whole thing is a terrible idea as far privacy goes. Massive infraction.
- meh2frdf 5y agoMy prescription glasses are ray bans, I need a new pair and I’m quite tempted to get these. I like the built in headphones and I’m interested in being able to take pics of my kids easily or even anything else to be honest, but I’m not a creep and have no interest in taking pics of random people. Yet, will it be assumed I am a glass hole for wearing these, peer pressure from the paranoid! Done nothing wrong yet judged and punished ...
- yawaworht1978 5y agoYou know these kind of aggressive under the alcohol or party drugs people who will start a fight with zero hesitation if they think someone looks at their partner? If these individuals just think you are filming them or their partner or families, this will end ugly. This depends on the location and culture, but I have seen people having a gun stuck in their face for a single wrong look. This is just one of the many, many potentially disastrous outcomes, not even mentioning the smart glass users with malicious intent.
- rapjr9 5y agoHow about a light, a beep, and an RF broadcast? When the camera is on, the LED on the glasses lights, the glasses beep, your phone beeps, and the glasses send an RF broadcast to all nearby phones so those phones beep. In fact, the nearby phones could reply with a message that says "do not record" preventing the glasses from recording. Everyone within range would have to approve the recording. If someone new moves into range their approval is also needed, so the glasses must continually send "can I record?" queries to surrounding devices. Anyone who does not want to be recorded can get a cheap RF badge that replies to all "can I record?" messages with "No". The RF could be range limited so that people far away do not get a vote. Maybe the RF range would have to vary depending on whether the glasses camera is zoomed in or not. All cameras could have this approval system making approval/disapproval automatic. The same could be done for audio recording. "Virtual Walls: Protecting Digital Privacy in Pervasive Environments" https://homes.luddy.indiana.edu/kapadia/papers/walls_pervasive07.pdf https://homes.luddy.indiana.edu/kapadia/papers/walls_pervasi...