8 ms·
Treasury Dept. Seeks to Track Transactions of Personal Bank Accounts over $600
- rektide 5y agothis feels so icky. there's probably many good reasons but i hate seeing an administration i want to do good increasing the survelliance state in such a critical, serious way.
- quantified 5y agoDon’t forget that Obama expanded the surveillance state more than GW Bush did. This will also increase the cost of government to track it all. I expect it will disproprtionately focus on the lower-to-middle income businesses and people, not the high-end deadbeats, since it’ll be easier to grab pennies from many than millions from a difficult few.
- rastafang 5y ago> I hate seeing an administration i want to do good They call it a democracy, but both sides work toward one goal: give more power to the Government.
- quantified 5y agoThe proposal seems wrong, but the article is a bit off too. > As Mises noted, capitalism suffocates without loopholes. The definition of “loophole” here, though, is actual tax avoidance. Wrong tack to take. I’ve worked in small and marginal businesses, we paid the taxes. No sympathy here. The article refers twice to the idea that the reporting will be on movements of $600 or more- is that right? A plain reading of the text (below) suggests that the account balance is of $600, and the movements will be of any size. The text, which is short and could have been included, is: > This proposal would create a comprehensive financial account information reporting regime. Financial institutions would report data on financial accounts in an information return. The annual return will report gross inflows and outflows with a breakdown for physical cash, transactions with a foreign account, and transfers to and from another account with the same owner. This requirement would apply to all business and personal accounts from financial institutions, including bank, loan, and investment accounts,2 with the exception of accounts below a low de minimis gross flow threshold of $600 or fair market value of $600. Other accounts with characteristics similar to financial institution accounts will be covered under this information reporting regime. In particular, payment settlement entities would collect Taxpayer Identification Numbers (TINs) and file a revised Form 1099-K expanded to all payee accounts (subject to the same de minimis threshold), reporting not only gross receipts but also gross purchases, physical cash, as well as payments to and from foreign accounts, and transfer inflows and outflows. Similar reporting requirements would apply to crypto asset exchanges and custodians. > Separately, reporting requirements would apply in cases in which taxpayers buy crypto asset from one broker and then transfer the crypto assets to another broker, and businesses that receive crypto assets in transactions with a fair market value of more than $10,000 would have to report such transactions. > The Secretary would be given broad authority to issue regulations necessary to implement this proposal. The proposal would be effective for tax years beginning after December 31, 2022.
- matt123456789 5y agoI don’t know what the author was hoping to accomplish by all but advocating for tax avoidance, but wow, what a poor argument against this proposal. The real issues are that this 1. would cause the creation of another billions-of-dollars citizen surveillance machine, and 2. creates a crushing regulatory burden on small businesses.
- walterbell 5y agoWSJ: https://archive.is/jdXf7 https://archive.is/jdXf7 > ... compelling banks to share data on customer accounts, a move that requires congressional approval, would amount to just an initial step in narrowing the gap ... The IRS would need to figure out a way to use the information to decide which business owners to audit and what questions to ask them. The plan also includes billions of dollars for technology and staffing so the IRS could digest and analyze that information. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9973671/Bidens-plan-let-IRS-SNOOP-bank-accounts.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9973671/Bidens-plan... > One key prong of President Biden’s plan to bankroll Democrats’ $3.5 trillion budget plan is to monitor gross inflows and outflows from an individual’s bank account ... some are concerned that it might run up against the Fourth Amendment and those who can’t afford to fight tax audits or move their money into offshore accounts ... The proposal would require banks to report to gross inflows and outflows to the IRS, including transactions from Venmo, PayPal, crypto exchanges and the like ...
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThis is warrantless mass-surveillance, and done overtly. The US is still a democracy, and people should push back, and demand that their elected representatives block it. Justice Douglas, in his dissenting opinion on the 1974 California Bankers Association v Shultz case that upheld the constitutionality of the Bank Secrecy Act, provided an excellent argument against warrantless mass-surveillance and the doctrines, like Total Information Awareness, that promote it: It is estimated that a minimum of 20 billion checks - and perhaps 30 billion - will have to be photocopied and that the weight of these little pieces of paper will approximate 166 million pounds a year. 6 It would be highly useful to governmental espionage to have like reports from all our bookstores, all our hardware [416 U.S. 21, 85] and retail stores, all our drugstores. These records too might be "useful" in criminal investigations. One's reading habits furnish telltale clues to those who are bent on bending us to one point of view. What one buys at the hardware and retail stores may furnish clues to potential uses of wires, soap powders, and the like used by criminals. A mandatory recording of all telephone conversations would be better than the recording of checks under the Bank Secrecy Act, if Big Brother is to have his way. The records of checks - now available to the investigators - are highly useful. In a sense a person is defined by the checks he writes. By examining them the agents get to know his doctors, lawyers, creditors, political allies, social connections, religious affiliation, educational interests, the papers and magazines he reads, and so on ad infinitum. These are all tied to one's social security number; and now that we have the data banks, these other items will enrich that storehouse and make it possible for a bureaucrat - by pushing one button - to get in an instant the names of the 190 million Americans who are subversives or potential and likely candidates. It is, I submit, sheer nonsense to agree with the Secretary that all bank records of every citizen "have a high degree of usefulness in criminal, tax, or regulatory investigations or proceedings." That is unadulterated nonsense unless we are to assume that every citizen is a crook, an assumption I cannot make. Since the banking transactions of an individual give a fairly accurate account of his religion, ideology, opinions, and interests, a regulation impounding them and making them automatically available to all federal investigative agencies is a sledge-hammer approach to a problem that only a delicate scalpel can manage. Where fundamental personal rights are involved - as is true when as here the [416 U.S. 21, 86] Government gets large access to one's beliefs, ideas, politics, religion, cultural concerns, and the like - the Act should be "narrowly drawn" (Cantwell v. Connecticut, 310 U.S. 296, 307 ) to meet the precise evil. 7 Bank accounts at times harbor criminal plans. But we only rush with the crowd when we vent on our banks and their customers the devastating and leveling requirements of the present Act. I am not yet ready to agree that America is so possessed with evil that we must level all constitutional barriers to give our civil authorities the tools to catch criminals. Also worth noting that the threshold for reporting transactions when the BSA was passed, of $10,000, was worth $55,490 after adjusting for inflation. Now Treasury wants to decrease it to $600, which is a 92X decrease from the original threshold. If you factor in the 41% increase in real median income since 1974, the threshold the Treasury is pushing for would be 130X smaller, as a share of median income, than it was when the BSA was enacted. The BSA fell down the the slippery slope to total mass-surveillance.
- just_steve_h 5y agoWe would (almost) all of us be better off if we had a financial transaction tax, and the IRS focused on THAT.
- votepaunchy 5y agoHow would the tax be enforced on cash, or is the elimination of paper money a second-order effect?
- adolph 5y agoInflation is the tax or negative interest rate on cash.
- ocbyc 5y agoWhy spend all this effort on direct taxation, when they can print the tax. Plus, inflation acts as a proportional tax. The more dollars you have the more the tax effects you.
- ne0flex 5y agoThere is no doubt in my mind that the elimination of paper money is in our future. There are numerous articles about central banks developing their own digital currencies. Once that happens, say goodbye to any type of financial privacy or autonomy. I'm willing to bet that during times of economic slowdown, similar to China [1], the US gov't will put expiry dates on the dollars in your savings account in order to stimulate the economy, and people will defend that decision. [1]:https://bfsi.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/policy/digital-currency-yuan-comes-with-an-expiry-date-spend-or-it-will-vanish/82059471 https://bfsi.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/policy/digita...
- goatsecxkirk 5y agoThat's ridiculous. Why should I be taxed on every transaction? I get taxed when I make money and then everytime I purchase something/move money?
- anovikov 5y agoResult will be like we see in Russia: deals between US businesses will become deals between their offshores, and just enough money to pay salaries, will be moved into the country.
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoUnlikely. Most American small businesses and individuals can't set up offshore structures willy nilly (it's too expensive and complex), and FACTA makes it a lot harder for them to even if they want to. Lots of financial institutions hate working with Americans and will avoid it if possible in some places because of FACTA. Keeping money offshore doesn't make sense for the little guy. You're required to report it with significant penalties for non-compliance, and the anti-tax-deferral rules for controlled foreign corporations basically make repatriating just enough money to pay salaries a pointless exercise.
- Tycho 5y agoCrypto is offshore finance for the little guy.
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoNo it isn't. Once you want to convert to fiat (so you can spend it), you're back in the realm of the regulated financial world. If you're running a small business, chances are you can't a) use your crypto without converting to fiat or b) can't use your crypto without identifying yourself to a regulated financial institution. Since BTC, ETH, etc. are public ledgers, you're basically already giving every government agency in the world the ability to track your balances and transactions without any additional regulation or infrastructure required. Of course, if you're super careful, they might not know it's you yet, but if they really want to, they can find out and make sure you don't sleep very well at night while they wait.
- pentae 5y ago.. Or you could pay in crypto. Or you could convert your crypto to cash in a Wendys parking lot.
- dsq 5y agoThere may eventually be a slowdown of small business activity as ever increasing Panopticon-type surveillance proves a drag on innovation and profitability.
- adolph 5y agoYes according to Coase. Firms exist to economize on the cost of coordinating economic activity. Firms are characterized by the absence of the price mechanism. https://www.kellogg.northwestern.edu/faculty/hubbard/htm/research/ec174/lectures/3coase.htm https://www.kellogg.northwestern.edu/faculty/hubbard/htm/res...
- jl2718 5y agoBut there will be a huge increase in lawyers and accountants and lobbyists.
- drumhead 5y agoWill our "freedom" loving friends in Congress be backing this?
- rmesters 5y agoI wonder how this could work in practice. A Gov entity will have to connect to some bank APIs to streamline the monitoring? Most banks don't have APIs to connect to. It would pretty wild if the Gov had to ask people to share their bank passwords and then had to screen-scrape the data from their accounts to "establish a connection".
- salawat 5y agoNothing so complicated. Compliance departments just start sending reports of all transactions greater than $600 on a monthly basis just like they do with SAR's and large cash value withdrawals. I'm having difficulty seeing how this isn't a 4th Amendment violation, or something that'd have to be gated behind a legislative statute. Make no mistake. The U.S. financial system is one of the greatest "soft power" projectors on the planet. It is most certainly not being utilized in a way that helps you.
- techplex 5y agoI would think the law would require financial institutions to report cash flow in whatever format the gov't demanded
- MrDresden 5y agoIt could simply go the way of the Payment Services Directive (PSD) from Europe, which has spurred (and mandated) the development of open APIs at financial institutions. Lots of fine details to work out there though.
- macNchz 5y agoGenerally with this sort of thing it’s up to the bank to file reports to comply with the regulation. I don’t know the specifics for how the current $10k+ transaction reports work, but usually I think the government doesn’t bother trying to integrate with the myriad software systems out there, instead they just have an XML API of some sort that you can send machine readable versions of paper forms to.
- hirako2000 5y agoThe tax situation will likely become unbearable, gov preparing to attack those who refuse to (or can't) pay. We will live interesting times when the IRS goes after millions who can't find the spare money to fill public funds.
- vgeek 5y agoAt least the government has already gone after the big fish and common loopholes that corporations and the ultra-wealthy perpetually exploit to maintain single digits tax liabilities. Oh, wait....
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoA few big fish is nothing compared to a net of every small fish independent contractor, small business and dude with a side gig who doesn't report that income. The cynical take is that it's not about the money, it's about having the power of arbitrary enforcement coupled with the longstanding ability to freeze accounts and seize assets in response to tax evasion. Imagine if the feds has an "off switch" for most small businesses and self employed individuals they could use to enforce compliance.
- vgeek 5y agoYes, but is it more effective to catch and eat a 10lb trout, of which there are plenty and they're easy to identify using established laws and technologies (tip: they hang around Jackson Hole), or try to dip net and fillet 300 creek chubs scattered all over the place? You are right in that it isn't only about the money. It has to be the surveillance aspect with the revenue generation as an added bonus. If something like this doesn't succeed now, then next time will it be for national security or the safety of the children? We love to enforce the laws against the poor. This just seems like another avenue by which to do so. Look at how frequently crimes like robbery are mentioned in the news-- but what about much more endemic crimes typically perpetuated by the ownership class, like wage theft (https://i.redd.it/grnr8kxbl6zz.jpg https://i.redd.it/grnr8kxbl6zz.jpg), and how little you hear about them.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoIn this case it's as easy as sending automated threatening letters "we see you've done X Y and Z transactions, we think these are taxable, please provide payment amount A or appeal it by doing B" The rich people and rich companies (10lb trout in your example, since it may not be clear to everyone that 10lb is no small trout) have big enough dollar amounts at stake to be worth fighting for and will fight but the cost of running that process will be just a formality compared to all the $100-500 checks they'll receive. I don't think it's about the surveillance aspect or the money except as a means to the end of having more power to control who gets economically marginalized. Look at the difficulty the government had enforcing executive policy and controlling the narrative during the pandemic (compare with the first few years of the war on terror for example). They don't want to get caught with their pants down the next time around.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kumarvvr 5y agoThis is interesting. With enough computing power, and that is already dead cheap, the potential to spy is enormous. As much as I am a fan of Bitcoin, is it not possible to create an alternative currency, where the value of the currency is pegged to the state currency, but transactions are encrypted and untraceable. Sorr of like an underground banking system.
- thebean11 5y agoDAI satisfies that, is is pegged to the dollar by a smart contract that issues loans, expands, and contracts the DAI supply to keep the peg. It is not backed by real dollars*. It's not untraceable, same as Bitcoin, but that's been solved by things like Monero. I bet the two concepts are compatible. *It is backed by traditional crypto, in addition to USDC and other stablecoins which are in turn backed by real dollars, so it's partially backed by dollars.
- rangoon626 5y agoIts funny that I was discussing the last election with someone who said the old "government moves slow" and "checks and balances." My response: "not this time." They looked shocked, but everything that has happened since the transfer looks like an operation warp speed towards authoritarianism.
- Proven 5y agoWhy not? Everyone here seems to be in favor of full taxation according to the law. Let's get those transaction to the IRS to increase honesty in reporting.
- helen___keller 5y agoDirect link to the source material: https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/131/General-Explanations-FY2022.pdf https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/131/General-Explanati... The proposal under discussion is under the header "INTRODUCE COMPREHENSIVE FINANCIAL ACCOUNT REPORTING TO IMPROVE TAX COMPLIANCE", page 94 of 114 in the PDF, labelled page 88 in the source document
- MrWiffles 5y agoThis is extremely disturbing.
- joelbondurant 5y agoTime to exit the communist hasbeen USA.
- exabrial 5y agoI'm not so concerned about transactions for the common person over $600. I'm very concerned about the transaction over $600 for every government official though. Funny where their priorities lie.
- hnburnsy 5y agoThe headline and article are misleading, the proposed requirement is to report annual inflows and outflows. Here is a better analysis... Biden Tax Plan Leans on Banks to Help Find Unreported Income https://www.wsj.com/articles/biden-tax-plan-leans-on-banks-to-help-find-unreported-income-11619701380 https://www.wsj.com/articles/biden-tax-plan-leans-on-banks-t... >The proposal would require banks to report annual account inflows and outflows to the Internal Revenue Service. The requirement would also extend to peer-to-peer payment services such as Venmo but wouldn’t require individuals and businesses to report any additional information to the government, according to people familiar with the plan. Financial institutions already must report interest, dividend and investment income, and the IRS can get bank information during audits.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- walterbell 5y agoHow is the headline misleading? Banks would be doing the reporting and it would be a dramatic increase over and above the data they currently report. Here's a statement by community banks: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28562153 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28562153
- mleonhard 5y agoThe fee.org website seems to be extremely biased.
- walterbell 5y agoWall St. Journal coverage of the same topic: https://archive.is/jdXf7 https://archive.is/jdXf7 Source document: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28566846 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28566846
- nazgulnarsil 5y agoReminder that the bottom 50% of the income distribution pays 3% of the tax receipts and after accounting for the costs of enforcement it is clearly theater.
- kaminar 5y agoYou'll find it on page 94 of the PDF document (actual page 88), under "Proposals".
- jl2718 5y ago“Fair” enforcement of a legally-enforced tax system is impossible. A just system would be physically impossible to cheat, not legally precarious. Shifting that burden of legal compliance onto the individual is crippling for the society. The problem with ‘surveillance’ is that there is nothing positive about it for the productive honest people that have a lot to lose, and it’s really not much of a problem for the dishonest criminal with nothing to lose. I don’t think it’s possible to have a fair income tax. It’s also irrelevant. Bond issuance almost entirely funds the government already, it requires zero enforcement, zero taxpayer burden, and it’s impossible to cheat. Income tax is mostly an excuse for legal surveillance of other matters. Some of those might be reasonable and good, but the voters should decide that.