8 ms·
This is what drives me nuts. Why do they keep messing with the UI? Nobody wants that! Even Apple and Google have both figured out that screwing around with U
by cogman10 5y ago
This is what drives me nuts. Why do they keep messing with the UI? Nobody wants that! Even Apple and Google have both figured out that screwing around with UX every release is a recipe for making your customers HATE you.
What I, and probably non-power users want out of windows is for it to be faster and use less power. I'd honestly be happy to go back to a Win95 interface with the latest kernel.
Microsoft needs to fire the idiots that keep messing around with the UX. It's not broke, stop trying to fix it.
- GiorgioG 5y ago> Why do they keep messing with the UI? UX folks don't get paid to leave things alone.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoNobody gets paid to leave things alone and maybe that's a big problem with the world.
- dylan604 5y agoFarmers can get paid to not grow crops.
- saurik 5y agoDamn... the idea that maybe we should be banding together as a democracy and cutting deals to subsidize the engineering work of companies that are willing to "lay fallow" their design teams is fascinating.
- FridgeSeal 5y agoBonuses paid to design teams that are a direct function of the length between unprompted UI adjustments and redesigns? Iteration on designs is of course permitted, but there’s more pressure on “get it right” rather than “dirty MVP”. Once launched, changes can’t go to prod-lest they lose their bonus-and emphasis is more on more in-depth and longer-term user research and refining the design. This way design teams are still doing valuable work, and there’s no crunch to both design something and then get it out ASAP. The next time front-end teams come back to work on any kind of UI refresh everything is already sorted and ready to go.
- beamatronic 5y agoAnother one would be paying Wall Street bankers not to create innovative banking products, like synthetic CDO's
- blondin 5y agothis is so true! apple podcasts is a fine example, among others, of this conundrum. on every iteration an "improvement" makes the app less usable. on the last iteration they decided that i should now "follow" shows and not "subscribe" to them. what's worse is that some screens had the old and the new names resulting in extreme confusion. on that same iteration, someone decided that the way i was deleting episodes wasn't cool enough. so they replaced a working feature with a half-working one! please leave the podcasts app alone.
- vehemenz 5y agoInteresting. The Podcasts app was a disaster when it was released. I honestly can’t imagine how it could have gotten worse. I’ve been using Podcruncher since 2010. Manual downloads, no hiding episodes, custom playlists. All in a straightforward interface. It is amazing that Apple with its resources can’t deliver anything comparable.
- ryandrake 5y agoIt's definitely a big problem with software. This "need to constantly pay developers" is part of the justification for moving towards subscription payment instead of one-time payment. The logic goes: One-time payment won't pay for future changes, and developers are always making changes, and they need to be paid for. But, what if I don't want future changes? For almost all software I've ever paid for, as a user, I just want the goddamn software exactly how it is today, forever. I'd maybe be willing to pay for security updates, but that's it. But, noooooo, the company decides developers must perpetually change the software and designers need to perpetually change the UI, and therefore you must continue to pay for it, regardless of whether you want any of those changes.
- usrusr 5y agoFunny, I was just thinking to myself that maybe a paid subscription Windows could be a solution to undesired UI change. Because it would take away the lure of the upgrade sale licence. 64 bit w2k? Yeah, I'd totally pay for that. If I were in charge of Windows product strategy I think I would create competing subdivisions that replicate the model of Linux distributions but on the NT kernel. Sworn to binary compatibility but inspired to try different monetization schemes.
- skeletal88 5y agoWindows is not selling upgrades anymore, 8 to 10 was a free upgrade
- usrusr 5y ago8 too? I was going to write something about this, particularly in how that's the reason why I don't really disagree with GP despite pondering the exact opposite "what if". But the sudden appearance of an 11 that nobody asked for gives me the impression that the culture that was fostered on the paid upgrade is still very much alive. Meanwhile my mind has taken a deeper dive into the rabbit hole fantasy of competing Windows distribution divisions. I'd expect it to seem like a total failure : the surface. E.g. with Steam users refusing to get lured into the "gamer Windows" (something with an X in the name), the "crippled version that is entirely ad-funded" (10, basically) drawing too much hate for the entire brand while still not being crippled enough to push people to paid options and the one you can get with the Office subscription being a little too incompatible for employee lockout reasons with the plethora of in-house essentials required to run at customers. But Microsoft could still come out stronger, having a well defined place for bad ideas to go to die. And who knows, one of the niche distributions might be essentially sysinternals with a kernel and a package manager.
- tnzm 5y agoWhat if meaningless busy-work is qualified professionals getting paid to leave meaningful problems alone because solving them is bad for the racket?
- johnisgood 5y agoYeah, it is seriously worth thinking about.
- toiletfuneral 5y agoI’ve been doing UI for 20+ years and most of what I’ve worked on is determined by marketing & engineering. I understand & totally sympathize with not liking the results, but in my experience the designers rarely choose what (ui) problems need to get solved. Also I have never worked in an org that shipped “the design”, it’s inevitably compromised by high level management’s personal feelings or lack of engineering attention to detail (I don’t blame eng’s for this, anytime the project schedule gets tight, they immediately cut resources to UI/UX). Anyway, I agree most updated UI’s fail to deliver improvements to end users and let me tell you how shitty it feels to take the blame for stuff you didn’t like either.
- ngcc_hk 5y agoWhilst apple also have its share of this ui change (like keyboard butterfly or no hole in portable etc.), I still think their design team actually work to solve sone user problem. Not just marketing or engineering… I cannot be sure. Just that I thought. Hence not all in the dark side.
- imwillofficial 5y agoThere is plenty of other UI things to be touched.
- abledon 5y agoCough spotify
- k12sosse 5y agoHeh. I used uBlock origin to hide all the podcast elements in Spotify web for a clean desktop web-based Spotify. Every time I open up the app on my phone, I die a little.
- 1ark 5y agoSpotify was pretty snappy in the early days, I guess a decade ago now. Current iteration boots up in 3 minutes and is unnavigable. Went back to Winamp and occasional usage of the web player.
- koziserek 5y agoThere’s a solution, a client software called Psst https://github.com/jpochyla/psst https://github.com/jpochyla/psst
- dartharva 5y agoI largely believe the Spotify folks keep making changes in their apps solely to break the experiences of those who're running cracked (ad-blocked) builds.
- bambataa 5y agoThey seem to be happy breaking everyone else’s experience too though. Even basic functionality fails quite often for me. The absolute worst is the macOS Music app, which doesn’t seem to allow basic things such as dragging from search results to playlists.
- robbedpeter 5y agoUx is snake oil nonsense and has no place in software design. They create change for the sake of change and dumb everything down as if complexity were a sin.
- approxim8ion 5y agoI feel like this takes it too far. Complexity may not be a sin, but it is possible to make things much more cohesive. "Modern" UX does involve a lot of dumb antipatterns and things that break usability, but I don't think we should throw the baby out with the bathwater here.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoNeedless complexity is a sin. But easy/difficult is an orthogonal axis to simple/complex.
- lolcat_cowsay 5y agoShould inherent complexity be simplified?
- alkonaut 5y ago> It's not broke, stop trying to fix it. There could have been better ways to keep it modern, but just leaving everything alone because “it works” isn’t really an option. First comes Unicode, then 4K/High-dpi scaling, then touch support and so on. Once high DPI screens arrived, UIs that scaled poorly literally don’t work.
- foobiekr 5y agoNT 3.1 (that is, the _first_ release of Windows NT in 1993) supported Unicode, at least as far as the UI elements were concerned (that it was UTF-16, well, ...)
- corty 5y agoNope, UCS-2. Which is UTF-16, but just the BMP, so only the first 65k codepoints and all characters are fixed-length 16bits. Only later windows versions at some point learned UTF-16.
- zozbot234 5y agoThe Win32 widgets are scalable, actually. They support device-independent units out of the box, even in Windows 95.
- Dork1234 5y agoThe only people that say Win32 apps are scalable are the ones that haven't dealt with legacy code. There is jut too much legacy code that either doesn't work, or doesn't work correctly with HiDPI screens.
- jussij 5y agoAt a minimum, for a Win32 application to work correctly with HiDPI it needs to tell the OS it is DPI aware. This is done by marking the application DPI aware using the settings found in the manifest file. The manifest file is then embedded into the resource section of the application, which then lets the OS know the application will be handling it's own DPI. So the reason many of those 'legacy apps' don't work with HiDPI is they don't have those required manifest changes in place. That then means the OS does the DPI scaling on behalf of the application and that results in poor scaling outcomes.
- hulitu 5y agoGoogle has not yet learned.
- grishka 5y agoI mean Android 12... Some project manager wanted a promotion this desperately.
- squarefoot 5y ago> Why do they keep messing with the UI? The UI that remains unchanged in a few years is perceived as old and obsolete, hence the purely marketing driven need to change it even when it works. And then there are new courses and new support contracts. Governments are a significant part of MS customer base; every time MS changes something, it's new money pouring in. As someone once said, Windows is not an operating system, it's a business platform.
- GuB-42 5y agoI think I've seen an old article by a Microsoft employee saying "if you didn't change the UI, you changed nothing". They used the calculator as an example, saying that it saw several improvements but since it always looked the same, people thought nothing had changed. Improvements included things like better arithmetics, so that (10/3-3)*3=1.
- mypalmike 5y agoDream job: full time engineer on Windows Calculator team.
- II2II 5y agoDeveloping a calculator that one could be proud of would be a pretty sweet job. By that I mean producing a product that consistently produced correct results, offered useful features, and had a user interface that is more pleasant to use than a four function calculator.
- munchbunny 5y agoDid that at an earlier point in my career, and it absolutely was, but calculators pretty quickly reach a point where "less is more", and at that point it's just better to leave it alone.
- mark-r 5y agoI just use Python as my desktop calculator, it works pretty well.
- SllX 5y agoApple does not have this figured out, and if they do, they don’t care.
- toss1 5y agoYup Taskbar can no longer be moved. That single "improvement" will keep me away for as long as possible. It's the first thing I change when setting up a new Windows environment, and have done it for over a decade. I'm enough not alone that I've seen in mentioned in multiple articles. MS makes all kinds of noise about "reworking the UI from the ground up for true usability" or some such. Yet I have no idea what could possibly be the benefit to removing such functionality. MS says they listen, but obviously not. Unless a developer has a massive and utterly revolutionary improvement in the way we interact with the machine, and it yields 10X productivity improvements (or even 3X) for 90% of the user base - fkn leave it alone!! Marginal improvements are the worst - the time spent relearning, or fumbling while using a different machine is never recovered, and it just makes people annoyed at you. Even if the improvements are "free" the price is too high.
- david422 5y agoI have the taskbar on the left on Mac, Linux, and Windows. Removing this customization makes me wonder who the hell makes these decisions. Do Windows developers not dogfood their own OS? Apparently the person making these decisions only uses the taskbar on the bottom and it must be good enough to disrupt the workstations of millions I'm sure.
- danielrpa 5y agoI'm enraged by the new UI where you can't have multiple instances of the same application side-by-side in the taskbar. It's one of the things I hate in chromebooks, which Windows decided to adopt as their only (non hidden) option.
- moffkalast 5y agoYeah you're not alone there, the stupid idea that windows now needs to be fully tablet capable without a keyboard to the detriment of everyone else using it normally. Literally making the interface less informative and adding clicks, waiting and gestures to achieve actions that should've been a single point and click. I call it the "BIG BATAN" ideology, as everything needs to be a clean oversized button without any extra options or functionality. Stupid mobile OS features creeping into desktop for no good reason. I swear if MS eventually removes the don't group fallback I'm finally ditching Win for KDE and never coming back.
- tasogare 5y agoThis is especially ridiculous when seeing how few tablets are sold by Microsoft, despite them try harding for a decacde or so.
- nitrogen 5y agoI have used/owned old HP Tablet PCs that ran Windows XP Tablet PC Edition, and one of the bigger Surfaces. The HP with XP was a better experience. Windows 10 on the surface closes the on-screen keyboard after every change of focus from one input field to another. It doesn't open the keyboard automatically. And the Surface's battery swelled up and popped the case open. I'd actually like a modern pen-enabled PC, but they seem to be getting worse at software (and batteries!) over time. And when I'm at a desk with a keyboard, mouse, and large monitor, nothing else from MS beats the classic 2K/XP (7's okay too) UI.
- dotancohen 5y ago> I swear if MS eventually removes the don't group fallback > I'm finally ditching Win for KDE and never coming back. Exactly the switch that I did - get this - in 2005. And I never went back. Even in multiple software development roles, having to interact with Word- and Excel- using colleagues, and having "UX experts" sending me Photoshop files, KDE has pulled me through. I have been using KDE on-and-off since 2001 before switching fully in 2005, and in all that time KDE has had a single disruptive UI switch, going from KDE 3 to KDE 4. The upgrade to KDE 5 went all but unnoticed.
- kruxigt 5y agoWindows used to be good UI but unstable and slow. Now it's stable and quite fast with bad UI. Kind of like how apple was a company with so and so hardware but very appreciated software and are now a company with state of the art hardware and so and so software.
- wruza 5y agoHow do you notice new control panel elements, if not looking for damned “them appliances for interchange connectivity” or whatever bullshit they came up with this time for networking cpl? fire the idiots that keep messing around with the UX Don’t push on them too hard, maybe they are bound by some evil contract. Legend has it, one guy sold his soul to make the new PATH= editing dialog after 666 weeks (~13 years) of negotiations.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoIt is broke - badly. But because they no clue what they're doing they just keep making it worse. There's surely a management book to be written documenting the dysfunctional processes that result in disaster after disaster.
- porknubbins 5y agoThe weird thing is they don’t redesign the old UI as much as put new “simpler” UI over it with the option to use either. I’m pretty sure there are like 3 levels of UI between Windows 10 and the classic Device Manager.
- unclebucknasty 5y agoYeah, it's part of the identity crisis that emerged after someone decided the desktop UI should feel like a tablet or mobile UI. "It's easy. Just add a cog icon for settings!" Then, there's the whole free/ad supported model wherein you need an MS account, etc. I don't want to be integrated into your cloud metaverse. I don't want OneNote. I don't want Teams. I don't want to go through a whole phony tablet-like experience to get to the stuff I need. I just want to use my machine as the productivity/dev tool I purchased. I think they fundamentally no longer understand what the product is or should be.
- userbinator 5y agoI think they fundamentally no longer understand what the product is or should be. On the contrary, I think they know what the product is quite well: it's you. All the ads they're shoving into everything are evidence that even if you're paying for it, you are still the product being sold.
- unclebucknasty 5y agoWell, sure. That part's pretty clear. But, in terms of delivery, form-factor, packaging, etc., they have no idea how to pull it off with any coherence.
- hakfoo 5y agoI wish this was at least quantified. If they want $100 for "Ad-supported Windows", what would they charge for a system without (basically LTSB but intentionally sold as a quantity of one consumer product, I guess) I've always assumed the "let's profile and sell the data" was a either a bubble waiting to pop in the face of something GDPR-alike, or a tail-wag-the-dog scenario where they're gradually killing $100-per-sale products for 30-cents-per-user-per-month of new revenue. Would be fascinating for both consumers and investors to see what dollar figures they're using.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoDunno about that, at least as far as Google is concerned. I was initially put off by the changes to Android (moving from 9ish to 11) because they took away the bottom control bar, but I've used it for a week and am completely comfortable with it now. The gestures are intuitive and easy to use.
- User23 5y ago> This is what drives me nuts. Why do they keep messing with the UI? This is a general problem with corporate developed commercial software. Nobody ever got promoted by saying, "this is great, let's not change it."
- photojosh 5y ago> Even Apple and Google have both figured out that screwing around with UX every release is a recipe for making your customers HATE you. No they haven't. I hate Windows and love my Mac, but being forced into an upgrade from High Sierra to Big Sur sucks... a ton of the features I used all the time got buried behind click-and-hold etc.
- Wowfunhappy 5y ago> Even Apple and Google have both figured out that screwing around with UX every release is a recipe for making your customers HATE you. ...are we talking about the same Apple and Google? Big Sur? Material You? Sure, maybe it’s not “every” release, but only because they have a faster release cadence than Windows.
- tailspin2019 5y agoI don’t know about Google but I would say that the majority of Apple’s design refreshes are iterative in such a way that someone coming from the previous release is very unlikely to get “lost” when presented with the latest UI. And this is the key. UI refreshes are fine as long as they don’t add unnecessary friction to the user experience. Apple’s refreshes are also generally complete, cohesive and coherent. Yes they have the odd inconsistency here and there but largely the design system feels fully thought out at a high level. (I would perhaps put built-in apps like Podcasts and Music to one side here as I have far less charitable opinions around some of those UI updates - I’m mainly talking about the core OS experience). I’m an experienced user of macOS and Windows and I cannot remember the last time I upgraded a macOS version and couldn’t just immediately carry on with my work without any major reorientation needed. Likewise with iOS. And Apple is iterating on their UI at a much faster pace than Microsoft. And yet I have Windows VMs and Servers that I’ve used for years now and I still cannot fathom where they have moved setting X because it’s literally all over the place. Their UI updates are mostly incoherent, incomplete and just plain baffling. The hash they’ve made of settings is just incredible. I have no idea how normal users navigate that crap. Even if you can stay in the top-level “dumbed down” layer of the settings UI it’s completely unintuitive in many places. I’ve not seen an improvement to the start menu that has benefited my usability in any way since Windows 2000. I’m constantly confused with the various different start menus across servers running different Windows versions. Contrast that to the dock in macOS which has basically been the same simple and usable design paradigm for over 20 years with gentle refinement over that time. The only consistent thing Microsoft seem to keep doing to the start menu is they make more space for ads. FFS. I’m not even going to get into the aggressive, seemingly-can’t-be-stopped forced updates… I’m bullish on Microsoft’s .NET developer ecosystem and mainly positive about their Cloud strategy - the company has made some impressive changes over the last decade, but my god, Windows is a total car crash at the moment.
- coliveira 5y agoThe sad reality is that UX groups don't want to fix existing UIs, they want to design new ones. That's the whole issue here. MS wants to hire and retain the best UI people, but those people don't want to fix a UI that was created 20 years ago.
- phkahler 5y ago>> UX groups don't want to fix existing UIs, they want to design new ones. Maybe they need to check their ego at the door and do the job they're paid to do? There's a reason it's called work and not happy-fun-time.
- PostThisTooFast 5y agoAmen. The Windows UI has descended further into a disgraceful, unusable, and unprofessional shitshow with every release. Windows 7 sucked ass. Windows 10 is, for some people, literally unusable. Its UI is hideously crippled by defects in both function and design.
- CTOSian 5y ago>be happy to go back to a Win95 interface with the latest kernel. I would be happy to be even on Win3 interface with the latest kernel: themes and colors that worked almost on every f application! bonus: thick BORDERS! look now at the pathetic 1pixel borders they have (and NO F way to change that)
- comeonseriously 5y ago> It's not broke, stop trying to fix it. I completely agree. But look on even HN, if anyone mentions a library they're using you get the inevitable comment about how there's not been a PR in 3 months so the project must be dead. Do a search of HN for the word "Modern" and look how many projects assert themselves as such. > Nobody wants that! Apparently, they do. It's just you and I that don't and we aren't enough.
- daitangio 5y agoAnd SerenityOS is the proof an old Win9x GUI+OS can run smooth without taking all screen space & with little memory.