4 ms·
I'm also an Australian living in the US; this omits the enormous, multi-decade, apparently recession-proof rise of the Australian real estate market a bit. http
by ceejayoz 5y ago
I'm also an Australian living in the US; this omits the enormous, multi-decade, apparently recession-proof rise of the Australian real estate market a bit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_property_bubble https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_property_bubble
- AnotherGoodName 5y agoIt doesn't change the median to mean discrepancy though. Australia has a smoother wealth divide and that's purely policy. I was shocked when i found out there's no 0% tax bracket in the USA. All that paperwork to collect tax from those who are struggling. Meanwhile the federal tax caps out at 37% and doesn't even consider very high wage earners. The higher minimum wages in Australia are also clear cut.
- ceejayoz 5y agoOK, but you've highlighted the difference between US and AU median wealth; a lot of Australian wealth is tied up in this real estate. My relatives who own property (purchased cheap decades ago) can hop from enormously expensive house to enormously expensive house; the ones that don't can only dream of home ownership anywhere near a major city. There is functionally a 0% tax bracket in the US, because everyone gets a default tax deduction. In general, I agree with you - particularly in the realm of healthcare and college educations - but there's a lot of nuance in the details.
- giantg2 5y ago"The higher minimum wages in Australia are also clear cut." Do you have any links to studies around this? From what I've heard of the past couple years, most economists believe only a marginal increase to around $10/hr would be beneficial. I'm not arguing against that, but $10/hr doesn't seem like it would afford those workers the opportunity to build wealth, and increasing it further is supposedly not going to provide any additional benefit to that group.
- dntrkv 5y ago37% for federal, and another 13% in places like California, bringing it to 50% (vs 45% in Australia)
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoDo you understand how marginal tax rates work? Let's say you make $1,000,000 a year in California. Your effective tax rate is 11.78 percent because the top 12.3% rate is only applied to income you earned over $599k. (13.3% applies only on income above $1,000,000, which you are too poor to pay yet). Same with federal taxes, that $1,000,000 earner is going to pay an effective rate of 33.3%. Combined, you are paying 45% state and federal income tax.
- dntrkv 5y ago...Yes I understand how they work, thank you very much. In California, the highest possible tax rate on earnings, would be 50%. In Australia that tax on the highest earnings would be 45%. Nowhere did I claim that all your income is taxed at the same rate. I was replying to the quote "federal tax caps out at 37%" which ignores the significant 13% additional tax in CA.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoYou would have to be making $5,000,000 a year before you are paying 50% in California (see https://smartasset.com/taxes/california-paycheck-calculator#W0pit2R4qS https://smartasset.com/taxes/california-paycheck-calculator#...).
- dntrkv 5y agoSure, but that doesn't change the point of my comment which is that the income tax rates in some US states will actually exceed Australia's in higher earners.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> I was shocked when i found out there's no 0% tax bracket in the USA. That isn't exactly true: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2012/09/18/161333783/romneys-wrong-and-right-about-the-47-percent https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2012/09/18/161333783... Yes, the bracket isn't zero percent, but after deductions and the child credit, it effectively becomes that. That doesn't include payroll taxes however, which are much more regressive (in the case of social security with an income cap even more so). Does Australia exempt low earners from payroll taxes as well as income taxes?
- RhysU 5y agoI often see that payroll taxes are regressive. But the benefits from payroll taxes are progressive... Replacing a top 1% income or standard of living with unemployment or social security doesn't happen in the US system. Are payroll taxes regressive relative to the benefits paid from payroll taxes? I genuinely don't know.
- knubie 5y agoThe median to mean discrepancy is not particularly interesting though, given that median disposable income between the two countries is almost identical (in other words there are no winners with a "smoother wealth divide," only losers). Given the other comments about the real estate situation in Australia it seems problematic to compare median wealth instead of disposable income.
- acchow 5y agoThe US gives deductions which can make your effective tax rate 0%.
- dntrkv 5y agoExactly what I was going to reference. An Aussie with a $1M home, and a $500k mortgage will have $500k in "wealth." But if that wealth is tied to their home, and all other homes cost the same or more, what good does that do them? We're seeing the same happen in many US cities.
- kiba 5y agoIs wealth in a home an illusion, then?
- ceejayoz 5y agoTo some extent, yes. It's fairly illiquid, and unless you're willing to be homeless, move from the city to a rural area, or take a serious cut in living style, you're likely going to need to buy a replacement at similar cost. It's certainly not the same thing as having that wealth in the bank, or as stocks.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoIt does help with loans.
- ceejayoz 5y agoIf I take a $100k loan, my wealth doesn't go up $100k.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoTo the OP's question, the value in a home is not an illusion if you can do things like borrow against it.
- lowercased 5y agomaybe not a full 'illusion', but it's just not liquid. when using 'net worth' calculators, I severely underestimate the value of my home - between delays, fees in selling, and the cost of moving someplace else, there's probably 10-15% gone from whatever paper 'wealth' the raw number is. It doesn't really help me in any meaningful way with respect to planning. Most of my stocks are liquid. There's a potentially similar hit re: taxes, but... I can buy and sell $1000 of stocks tomorrow, I can't buy/sell $1000 of 'house' tomorrow (REITs notwithstanding).
- fulafel 5y agoLike the first sentence at the WP article says, > The Australian property bubble is the economic theory that the Australian property market has become or is becoming significantly overpriced [...] IOW bubbles can only be called historically asset prices fall dramatically and even then typically in housing they don't fall that much. Housing prices have been rising much faster than inflation in a lot of places due to historically cheap financing. The alternatives to "bubble popping" are that they plateau, or continue rising, or decrease moderately over time.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe point is that the difference in wealth between AU and US is, to at least some extent, due to a vast amount of largely inaccessible paper wealth. If I'm willing to sell my house in Sydney and move to rural Queensland, I'm wealthy. If I'm not, selling my $1M house means I have to go find another $1M house now. (And yes, the median house price in Sydney is over $1M.)
- fulafel 5y agoI think big cities have diverged from the country average globally and the impact on country average metrics then depends on the degree of urbanization. According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization_by_country the urbanization rate in AU is ~2x the US, so people are moving to cities at a much bigger rate? Even in the face of the high prices. But yep I still see what you mean, on the country-averages level the AU prices seem to have been constantly rising faster in AU than US.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe median home price in Melbourne is nearly $1M as well; between the two cities, that's about 40% of the population of Australia that needs a million bucks to own a house.