23 ms·
Pay Transparency Is Coming
- ram_rar 5y agohttps://archive.md/dVsTf https://archive.md/dVsTf
- lomkju 5y agoThanks!
- r00fus 5y agoWhile I support pay equity, will this simply cause secret renumeration to shift to bonuses/RSUs?
- jdblair 5y agoBonuses and RSU are part of a pay package. If transparency is required, it will include all forms. After all, the IRS already knows.
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agoBut bonuses are typically discretionary compensation that will vary from year to year based on the performance of the firm and of the individual, no? Or even more obviously: what if I advertise a sales job that pays only on commission?
- jdblair 5y agoThis isn't as hard as you make it sound. You know the bonuses you awarded last year. Being transparent means you reveal that. Foo's salary is X, last year Foo received Y bonus, which was Z% of his then salary. A sales job that pays only commission still has compensation data: the commission percentage per salesperson, the commission paid during the previous pay period. This tells you what you are likely to make, and if your commission is the same as others.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoAre bonuses a mystery or do you have actual metrics that you can use to gauge whether or not you might get a bonus? Are they not part of your compensation? Who would take a sales job that doesn't list what sort of commission they'll be getting? And wouldn't average income from such a job actually be helpful if you are deciding to take it? Sure, it is wonderful if you get commission each time you sell a car, but if folks aren't getting paid very much per year, it probably means cars aren't selling as well as the what the "possible income of xxx.xx" is saying they are. These are all things that can be disclosed and if they aren't, do you want to work in places that have secret formulas to give you pay?
- Ekaros 5y agoBonuses should be same for same role and out put metrics. With sales everyone should have rights to same base-pay+ commission structures. They could even choose from a few and be allowed to change them every quarter or year.
- gigatexal 5y agoProbably. But then that too will likely become public. I forget which Scandinavian country this is true for but I think there exists a country where compensation is a matter of public record. I support this 100%. I want everything to be transparent here. I know where I stand skills and competency wise compared to my colleagues so I will be ok making less than those I am less skilled or less productive as. That being said I think I’m underpaid. A transparent pay structure will only benefit the employees as we learn in Economics: the more information about prices there are in a situation the better each actor can make choices.
- thg 5y ago> I forget which Scandinavian country this is true for but I think there exists a country where compensation is a matter of public record. It's Sweden.
- jhrozek 5y agoI think it’s Finland. I’m in Sweden and I’m almost sure that my compensation is not public. What you can do IIRC is to request a credit check on someone which would contain the income and the tax paid but then the person is notified who requested the data. Typically this is done when you apply for a mortgage.
- m_eiman 5y agoPaid tax and taxable income is public in Sweden, just call Skatteverket (Swedish IRS) and they'll send you the info on anyone you can name. Edit: more info in Swedish here: https://lawline.se/answers/ar-inkomstdeklarationer-allmanna-handlingar https://lawline.se/answers/ar-inkomstdeklarationer-allmanna-...
- willvarfar 5y agoIn Sweden, Norway _and_ Finland. The tax you pay is public record. For example, in Sweden, you can get a 'tax calendar' (a bit like an old-fashioned phonebook, but with total pay instead of phone numbers). You can buy relevant pages conveniently online. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxeringskalendern https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxeringskalendern It is a trivial division-by-twelve to determine the salary of your co-workers and neighbours.
- sschueller 5y agoDoesn't make it better. Look at what gitlab and many others that already have transparent wages do. They justify paying you less for the same work because of your location. So you are as qualified as someone else but make way less. On the other side their products cost the same globally.
- kuu 5y ago> They justify paying you less for the same work because of your location. So you are as qualified as someone else but make way less. But now you have that info when applying to the job and it's up to you if you consider that fair or not. So far until now it was a (probably known) secret. Information is power.
- zepto 5y agoNot if everyone has it.
- phaemon 5y agoEveryone having information is called "universal education". It's not a bad thing.
- JohnWhigham 5y agoWell, at least you now know why many developers oppose salary transparency: because they ultimately will get screwed as wages regress toward a mean.
- phaemon 5y agoYes, that's true. I guess I don't oppose it because I don't care. But I certainly know many developers whore highly concerned about their pay.
- the_gipsy 5y agoWell duh, transparency does not mean equality. But it's a huge step forward in information-equality.
- hamandcheese 5y ago> Second, thanks to the boom in working from home, big national companies that have at least one employee in Colorado now find themselves required to post pay levels for any remote role that could potentially be performed in the state. Some employers tried to get around the new rule by barring Colorado residents from applying for their remote positions. State regulators quickly clarified that such exclusions are illegal, and moved to crack down on them. While I am a fan of pay transparency, something about this bothers me. Does Colorado actually have standing here?
- xmprt 5y agoWhy does it bother you more that Colorado is fighting for their citizens' right to work more than businesses excluding an entire state from being able to apply?
- hamandcheese 5y agoThis particular law is fine. What I find concerning is the notion of <state where I don’t reside> enforcing its laws in such a way that I, a resident of <elsewhere> am affected.
- systemsignal 5y agoThat’s an unavoidable effect of remote work. It blurs the boundaries between states/countries
- Jensson 5y agoAnd is also why full global remote will not happen. Governments will make sure that hiring people in their countries/states will remain annoying.
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoI'm not so sure. I could see the typical response being a compromise where the governments tolerate the unenforcability of their laws' against remote parties so long as the remote employer still pays local taxes. This would be to prevent a "just pay me in cryptocurrency" alternative from becoming popular.
- endymi0n 5y ago> Think about it: Every business, from tiny boutiques to online giants like Amazon, tell you exactly how much each of their items costs. Why shouldn't it be the same when we're shopping for a job? Despite the question being rhethorical, the answer is everything that's wrong about this proposal: Because the most important attributes are very hard to gauge and almost impossible to prove — Grit, dedication, responsibility, excellence and loyalty. I've got people with the same job title with almost a magnitude of difference in actual output. Sure, on paper, they're "doing the same thing", but if someone forced me to shoehorn them into categories, that would mostly serve to punish top performes with little credentials and push them somewhere else. I feel strongly about this, mostly because it happened to myself: After being sold, the first company that employed me introduced a "completely fair and transparent" compensation scheme. After I saw the scheme projected to the wall in the big All-Hands, I realized that without any degree I'd have to wait 10 years for stock options while the PhDs would be in almost immediately. I called a recruiter the next day and was out a few months after. Pay transparency is something that has upsides imho, but isn't a clear-cut win. It can turn out to be a net negative. Some further reading: https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-downside-of-full-pay-transparency-1502676360 https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-downside-of-full-pay-transp...
- naikrovek 5y agoThe "lazy PhD" bit there really undermines your entire point. Have you seen what it takes to get a PhD? I'm sure there are some who somehow skated through, but they are the exception, and not the rule. For the same reasons you cite, equal pay is important. Some employees are better than others, and this is very hard to qualify, and the effect is that those who have less skill at negotiation, are underpaid, completely independent of skill, while those who are better at negotiation are paid more, completely independent of skill. If skill is not going to be a factor in how people are paid, then pay for the role and not the person. Any given person can and will grow in their role, potentially earning more (but not getting paid more) than they did a month prior; even moreso if they don't have to stress about money all of the time, and can just have all of those concerns alleviated even a little by higher pay. Most people want to be better at their career, and are bogged down by the myriad of troubles that tight budgets generally cause. Remove these impediments for those who have reached a point in their career where they've earned the right to be without these troubles, and you will see your people take off, like how plants bloom when they haven't seen water in 10 days.
- bserge 5y agoWith so many people around and remote work, they shouldn't be. Someone will always do the same work at the same quality for less. And with transparency, employers can look up exactly how much everyone is paying elsewhere. Didn't think it only works one way, did you? Bar experienced specialists, it's probably the employees who should be worried.
- toast0 5y ago> And with transparency, employers can look up exactly how much everyone is paying elsewhere. Didn't think it only works one way, did you? Large employers already trade salary range with each other, it's just not detailed to employees. You'll see this when it's survey time for best company to work for and they pitch you the slide that says their pay is good.
- lotsofpulp 5y agohttps://theworknumber.com/ https://theworknumber.com/ It is ridiculous for anyone to argue workers by and large would be disadvantaged by having the same information about the market employers have. I guess everyone likes to think they are above average. But if you truly are, then with or without pay transparency, you should be able to sell yourself into a better paying position.
- Animats 5y agoThat's been the norm for union jobs, government jobs, and military jobs for a century or so in the US. Plus, in the US you have the right to disclose your pay, regardless of whether the employer likes it.
- ta3928283211 5y ago> in the US you have the right to disclose your pay This is the real solution. Lower & Middle class people are being crushed financially in part because they don't talk about money. Lots of rich people keep score, middle class people are too "classy" to do it. ftr Glassdoor data is 100% bullshit. I make about 4-5x what they claim I'm worth. Levels.fyi is a much better resource. You have to take into account the value of offered equity (not realized equity at time of vest!). For many engineers equity is 50% or more of compensation.
- agentdrtran 5y agoEmployers also have the right to fire you at any time for any reason in many states, making all other employee rights moot
- kweinber 5y agoHaving the same job title and having the same job performance are two very different things. If one person is grossly outperforming another do you have to write them a new job title to compensate them for it?
- jgilias 5y agoYes, that would be preferred, I think. Write a new job title with defined expectations, so that other people in the organization would know and understand why this person is paid more, and what it is that they should strive for if they want to reach the same level. Otherwise it just reeks of favoritism.
- terryf 5y agoHow does this work exactly? People have different skill levels. It's not a step function either, it's a pretty smooth distribution in terms of ability to create systems that are robust. I'd need 20 different names for an engineer. That's silly.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoNo. If someone outperforms another person, you have to be able to prove that with numbers. Being upfront about pay does mean that you are upfront about pay differences. For example: Alex has a higher degree or more experience, Robin tends to be finished before the last minute. Things like job performance are harder to measure unless folks are put in very similar situations. For example, if you measure a cashier's performance by the number of customers they serve, the overnight cashier is almost always going to perform badly simply because there are fewer customers at night.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoHow do you measure better soft skills which are crucial at any kind of a leadership role? Almost no jobs are easily measurable by output, we are not working assembly lines.
- NovemberWhiskey 5y ago
- watertom 5y agoIt feels like the Government pay system. Opening up salary information means that everything about salary needs to be equal, fair and objective. Basically the review system will become pass fail. Reviews will become bland and meaningless, raises will be standard based on the job classification, anything else wouldn’t be objective. If everyone isn’t treated exactly the same there will lawsuits galore. Bonuses will also go away, because it’s impossible to give each person unique goals and expectations and fairly assess each person and their custom goals, against everyone else at that same level. Lawyers will have a field day. Time in level determines promotions, not skill, not knowledge, time in level. Time in level is used because it’s the only objective system that works, anything else is too subjective and will open employers to lawsuits If you you can’t move up the ranks based on skills and effort why bother trying to exceed? This salary transparency system will be used by corporate America to suppress wages even further.
- pm90 5y ago> Time in level determines promotions, not skill, not knowledge, time in level. Time in level is used because it’s the only objective system that works, anything else is too subjective and will open employers to lawsuits This seems like a pretty pessimistic take. Employees won’t be bringing lawsuits without merit; if a person has been coasting it will be quite difficult for them to prove that they should be compensated similarly to someone else that did not before a jury. If the differences in contributions are not that significant then differences in compensation do seem unjustified don’t they?
- qsort 5y agoThat's exactly what happens, though. Many countries in Europe enforce collective contracts with very little wiggle room, and the main complaint here is how everyone is paid the same. Of course it's hard to quantify skill, and of course meritocracy is not perfect. But when you take meritocracy out of the equation, you're left with seniority. I guess the grass is always greener on the other side.
- Ekaros 5y ago
- creato 5y agoI think pay transparency requirements should be limited to below some compensation threshold. I can't put a number on it myself (maybe somewhere $100k-500k), but after some point, it becomes impossible to compare the compensation of one employee to another. High compensation is probably a reasonable proxy for this. As a bonus, this might provide some upward pressure on lower salaries. If a company doesn't want to tell the world they pay you $THRESHOLD - $10k, maybe they'll just bump you up to $THRESHOLD. In fact, if it were up to me, I'd probably choose this threshold in a way that this upward pressure affects the most people possible (so, closer to $100k than $500k). The problem with this is that different industries will hit this threshold at different points in their cost structures. FAANG might hit it for entry level software engineers while other industries might never hit the threshold for any employees. I don't know how to resolve this, but I definitely think transparency above some limit will cause more problems than it solves.
- shahbaby 5y agoTransparent pay and WFH will give power and freedom back to the people. Corporations left uncontested will selfishly take as much as they can.
- stillbourne 5y agoThere has been an attitude through the entire duration of my career in IT that it is taboo to share the details of how much you are making with your fellow coworkers. I have been unabashed in sharing that information though because keeping it to yourself only benefits your employers not your coworkers.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoSalary is a negotiation and companies will low ball you as much as they can. I don’t see how this helps productive people.
- boulos 5y agoI'm surprised by the counter arguments here to publishing pay bands. It seems most folks are assuming transparency would mean Norway-style "here is each person's compensation" rather than a salary / compensation band (as Colorado does). The per-level data from levels.fyi being publicly available has been great for workers. Expanding that data to more roles and more companies would be strictly better (for employees) than the current system.
- ta3928283211 5y agoOne issue is if you believe yourself an outlier and you'll get forced into a tighter band. Lower performance employees will become resentful of lower compensation for perceived same task, cue the chimp study w/ cucumber & grapes... those who fail to bargain well (for whatever reason) will likely get better salaries due to information of starting points. Those who were doing well to maximize their compensation likely will get worse salaries because of strained budgets with lower priced employees coming up...
- ziroshima 5y agoAny sort of bureaucratically enforced 'fairness' is going to be good for a certain type of person, and bad for another type of person. It will disincentivize high performance, for better or worse.
- WaitWaitWha 5y agoUnder communist regimes the salaries are dictated by the government, and are publicly known. The idea was to be "fair, and equal". That is how it supposed to be. Alas, that is not how it ever turns out. Employees would race to the bottom with performance. Why work hard, when I will get paid the same if I do little? Result is high rises that sink and collapse, cars that fall apart, medicine that is tainted, etc. So how would things get done right? Bribery. Bribery became the differentiator. Officials will only perform their duties if they are bribed. Workers will only do the job right if they are bribed. Most post-communist/socialist countries struggle with bribery for generations. (source: first hands, both hands)
- robotburrito 5y agoI have friends who have worked at some rather large tech companies. They created shared documents where everyone could share their compensation along with what they do and their past experience. I thought it was interesting.
- literallyaduck 5y agoNow make location pay discrimination a crime. Want to hire a dev in India? You must offer the same as if they lived in NY or San Francisco.
- yakshaving_jgt 5y agoYay! Free money for everyone!
- voxl 5y agoPay based on location is idiotic, if your pool is the entire world then your pay scale should reflect that market and average out. This means developers outside America get more purchasing power than San Fran devs, but that's the market you've entered. It is simply artificial price fixing to pay based off location.
- yakshaving_jgt 5y agoAveraging out means that SV developers won't be accepting offers for those jobs because they will feel they are underpaid.
- luckylion 5y agoThen they won't work. I hear SF has great social programs, so... yeah.
- gowld 5y agoIt's the opposite of artificial price fixing. It's natural markt forces of supply and demand.
- robocat 5y agoSometimes there are reasons why the world acts like it does. When you disagree with the world, sometimes it is because of your own naïveté: maybe open your mind a bit more? Your comment doesn’t reflect well upon you IMHO. This is commonly called Chesterton’s fence https://www.google.co.nz/search?q=chesterton%27s+fence https://www.google.co.nz/search?q=chesterton%27s+fence
- jay_kyburz 5y agoIf you want people to be fairly compensated for the work they do, forget salaries, look at the companies growth and profits. I think all employees should get a taste of any dispersal of profit, divided evenly, based on time served since the last payout. (Annually?)
- yakshaving_jgt 5y agoShould employees also forego income to enjoy their share in a company’s losses?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jay_kyburz 5y agoInvestors risk losing money and should be rewarded for the risk. But its only money. Employees risk something far more valuable, their time. You can never get that back. Employees would forgo _some_ money (their bonuses) and they would have wasted all that time working for an unprofitable business.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoThat's what most of us in silicon valley with stock based compensation experience. If your company goes from $1 earnings per share to -$1 earnings per share, then your total comp can be cut in half as your vesting stock becomes worth less.
- aantix 5y agoDivided evenly? Even if there's an order a magnitude difference in productivity between workers?
- OldTimeCoffee 5y agoIt's why standard base pay plus 'incentive/commission' tends to work the best. Let me expand. Everyone gets paid the same base rate. Then you give an incentive based on KPIs that AREN'T easily manipulated by an employee. For example, a good KPI might be on Time delivery of a project or ticket. Bad KPIs would be things like lines of code or number of tickets closed.
- zachlatta 5y agoWe make our finances 100% transparent, including pay, at https://bank.hackclub.com/hq/ https://bank.hackclub.com/hq/. I think other nonprofits should do the same. We also open source almost everything we do at https://github.com/hackclub https://github.com/hackclub.
- frankbreetz 5y agoFor Washington and Toledo, OH it says you have to tell salary "Upon request after job offer". Do people get jobs offers without knowing the salary? How is that even possible? Is it a accept the job and we will tell you the pay situation?
- gknoy 5y agoI suspect that once they make the offer, you can then ask them for the salary before accepting the job, unless I misread that phrase.
- frankbreetz 5y agoYeah, I agree, but why does this need to be a law? Are there people who would accept a job without knowing the salary?
- motohagiography 5y agoThe idea we should share our salary information presumes that work and value are fungible, a premise which is absurd. Why not just run a website where people can report their company, role, and salaries? (e.g. glassdoor) And if you can't solve that effectively, I guarantee regulating it into existence isn't going to be any better or have fewer perverse incentives.
- djoldman 5y agoAs usual, the details are lacking. What does "pay scale" mean? Does it mean that the employer has to provide an exact salary for every person at the company who has the title the prospective employee is applying? Does it mean a min-max scale? What if it is a new position? In the extreme and assuming the min-max scale, employers will now be incentivized to give everyone either totally unique titles or exactly the same titles, such that it will remove any disadvantage. In the more likely scenario, this will probably raise the bottom payouts, while incentivizing more aggressive negotiating on the part of the employers. One can imagine many more take-it or leave-it scenarios, as the higher pay for the lower end has to come from somewhere. Good? Bad? Blend of both?
- monocasa 5y agoIt means that on a job posting they have to post a range of salaries for that job. And the range can't be so broad as to avoid the spirit of the law, so no '$1/yr to $1M/yr'.
- woobar 5y agoI used to work for a company from Colorado. Internally they were sharing Salary range and Target Bonus for your position for as long as I remember (~10 years?). You will get this information in Workday or on paper once a year. From what I can tell from their current job postings they make this range public and include in the job description. It is not super helpful though. The range for a mid-level SWE is something like $100K-$150K. Almost as useful as Glassdoor.
- lostdog 5y agoI like how it works at big tech companies nowadays. Publicly, you know what level you and other employees are, and the bands for the levels are mostly known (at levels.fyi). This means you have an idea of where your salary relates to others, but not a perfect idea. You can coherently talk about when you should be earning more, and have a direct conversation about how your ability compares to employees at other levels, but you don't know the pay amounts so precisely that you can be disgruntled by a single other person, or worried that someone else will be secretly annoyed with you. I think it's a healthy level of transparency.
- tyjaksn 5y ago> Every business, from tiny boutiques to online giants like Amazon, tell you exactly how much each of their items costs. Why shouldn't it be the same when we're shopping for a job? This is the opposite to how a job should be thought about. Shopping for a job seems to imply a business already owns my time, skills, etc. when they are really the ones searching. And transparency would further exacerbate that idea, as the job candidate is now bounded without even being able to show what they are capable of. On the flip side, my employer is fully transparent about salaries from the c-suite all the way down and nobody seems to mind.
- angmarsbane 5y agoPay transparency isn’t just useful for people currently in their careers, it is useful for young adults getting started. So many kids get degrees or pursue careers that they are then shocked to discover don’t support their lifestyle desires/needs. Imagine if kids could look at job postings and see salary ranges and add that data point into consideration.
- legerdemain 5y agoThe reality is that coders are systematically underpaid and mostly fungible. The cliche is that you get a raise when you switch jobs (and your new employer knows the least about you). Not that you get a raise when you stay at your old job and differentiate yourself more and more from those other, less competent people who have the same title and qualifications as you, but are somehow worth less to the company. Coders will never voluntarily allow their salaries to become public. Every coder thinks that he is better than average, and that the salary that he is paid uniquely reflects his superior technical and negotiating abilities. In a misanthropic industry, coders feel that the other employees are their enemy, out to prevent them from being secret ninja superstars.
- lylo 5y agoCompanies disclosing employee salaries is a major thing, but for me the first step for companies is to provide transparency for *salary bands* for each role, internally and externally. Funnily enough I wrote about this earlier this week https://headey.net/salary-roulette/ https://headey.net/salary-roulette/