5 ms·
Personal Googler story: In Ads and in Search, at least as of 2010 or so, Google employed independent companies who hired "raters" to provide "ground truth" for
by AlbertCory 5y ago
Personal Googler story: In Ads and in Search, at least as of 2010 or so, Google employed independent companies who hired "raters" to provide "ground truth" for the ML systems. For example, they would rate proposed ads for a given query, so that the ML system could learn from their "truth". For Search, they'd rate proposed search results for a given query. There was a whole pipeline to bring in the raters' results and use them.
Those "raters" were contractors to the independent companies, and had no Google privileges at all. They couldn't come to campus and eat at the cafes, for example. They had no direct contact with any Google employees. I helped a relative get hired as one of those. This was about 11 years ago.
These outside companies had minimal oversight from Google, by design. My cousin joined the Search rater company and was given a test problem, which was timed and they had max times allowed. When she finished, they said "sorry, you took too long, we're not paying you."
I raised a stink and HR sent a representative to meet with the Search people. I sat in. The Search people were obnoxious little corporate toadies who claimed they couldn't interfere with any particular contractor's case, because of the legal separation requirements.
I so enjoyed watching the HR rep calmly and politely tell them, "That's great! Good job, you guys! But you know... when you hire someone and they don't do a good job, your remedy is to fire them. Not to refuse to pay."
She got paid.
I can't make any general statements about what happens to everyone, but in this particular case, I can't complain at all about HR's handling.
- ForHackernews 5y agoWas it Leapforce or Lionbridge? I used to do search rating for both of those.
- joe_the_user 5y agoI can't make any general statements about what happens to everyone, but in this particular case, I can't complain at all about HR's handling. That's kind of the exception that proves the rule, you think? That is, your outlining of the situation gives a strong suggestion that this sort of thing is common and unless the contractor has pull (say, a relative that works at Google), they can't do anything.
- AlbertCory 5y agoI've always thought the phrase "the exception that proves the rule" is nonsense, btw. There's no such "proof."
- ggm 5y agoThe phrase is misunderstood. Historically "Proof" is contextually meaning the nature of the test, not passing it. "failed the test"-proof has been "disproved" by this exception, which shows a belief does not generally apply. I'm not explaining this very well but a Google search will throw up better explanations. Some how it's morphed to colloquially mean "yes, that one exception aside, I'm right and you're wrong" as if the negative somehow reinforces the positive.. The phrase "the proof of the pudding is in the eating" helps understand this. The pudding may prove to be bad or good. Find which proof by eating it.
- AlbertCory 5y agojerf's explanation makes sense. The negative certainly does not reinforce the positive.
- ggm 5y agoYes. They said it better. It certainly doesn't reinforce the positive, yet people seem to insist on using it as if it does. "Well, yes, that penny did land on it's edge but the exception proves the rule it had to be either heads or tails" type statements abound. No.. the exception proved pennies have three states not two: your argument is busted.
- heavenlyblue 5y agoException proves the rule comes from Roman law: if there is a sign saying you can’t park here on Saturdays, it means that you can park here on any other day.
- 5y ago
- Cederfjard 5y agoSorry, I’m not following. Which company did the HR rep belong to? Which company did the ”corporate toadies” belong to? Perhaps I’m just confused how you were able to have such a direct influence on the internal goings on of a supposedly independent company.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe story does not make sense to me either. Google’s HR should surely know better than to get involved in a labor issue at company they contracted with and claiming are not google employees.
- dwild 5y ago> Google’s HR should surely know better than to get involved in a labor issue at company they contracted with and claiming are not google employees. ... as if it's better if they aren't involved? We are commenting on a story about that... seems like if they knew better, they would actually get involved to makes sure that this don't get out. The bare minimum is to pay the ones that complains, that way you at least minimize the risk of this getting out.
- user5994461 5y agoHR is always involved with external contractors. The way contracting usually work is that the contractor must submit timesheets daily or weekly to a supervisor at the parent company. The supervisor must approve the timesheet. The contractor will be paid the hours in the timesheet. The story is a classic example where the manager (google employees) refused to acknowledge the hours for no valid reasons, preventing contractors from being paid. Gotta escalate to HR to get paid and fill formal complaints against the bad manager.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat would be about compensation for the contracted firm itself though, which would make sense. I may have misunderstood the story as Google HR getting involved because the contracted firm did not pay an employee of the contracted firm.
- johannes1234321 5y agoProbably HR did the math how to protect the company. A legal case is bad for reputation and might inspire others. Paying quietly is cheap.
- user5994461 5y agoThere is no maths to do. The company has to pay for hours worked.
- Tenoke 5y agoI've worked for one of those companies and I don't understand this. It was about paying them for just a test problem? During an interview presumably? And you got involved with them through HR even given how completely separate they are? On the actual jobs you get so many timed tasks that a single one wouldn't even stand out, really.
- AlbertCory 5y ago> "During an interview presumably" No. They had an entrance exam, and my cousin had passed it and signed on.
- Tenoke 5y agoBut it was a single task they took too long on?
- gricardo99 5y agoThese outside companies had minimal oversight from Google, by design. Could this be so that the google corporate toadies could bid out the lowest possible price, yet remain isolated from the predictably unethical, shoddy, or even illegal practices of the cut-throat priced contracting companies? It just seems strange that you’re lauding google HR, when your description suggests google was complicit, if not directly responsible, for the whole setup.
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoFor a large company it often makes little sense to directly hire temp employees and/or vet contractors. The fact that a cottage industry of less than law abiding contracting agencies provide services to Google is more an issue of CA's employee protection laws than Google's responsibility. Consider the current/default rate of wage theft via salary employees not paid for overtime despite being eligible; it's rampant in the SE industry because it's logistically easier to pay someone 10% more than to keep track of occasional overtime. Therefore whenever a large company contracts something out to a smaller company, you should immediate expect more shady practices. My point is that Google's only role in this case is making something unknown... known - plenty of small shops unrelated to FAANGs break the same rules.
- Viliam1234 5y agoThe mechanism of distancing yourself from crime is explained here: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/9fB4gvoooNYa4t56S/power-buys-you-distance-from-the-crime https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/9fB4gvoooNYa4t56S/power-buys...
- itsdrewmiller 5y agoFor contractors to avoid classification as employees you need to be pretty hands off - the more you tell them how to do their jobs the more likely they are to be classified as employees if such a question arises. I don’t think immediately assuming bad faith is fair here (or there or anywhere really).
- tsian2 5y agoI used to do this kind of work and found that the worst thing about it was actually having too much time. After a while I had read and understood all of the documentation and had a complete mental model, so tasks would take half the time. However, if I got through tasks too fast I'd just be paid the same and bring down the average time for everyone else. So I had this mind numbing stop-start process that felt so pointless.
- sabellito 5y agoI find it a little strange that this anecdote that paints google in a good light is the most upvoted comment in this story, instead of the comment that highlights the fact that there are emails showing that google knew for certain that this was happening and decided against fixing it to "not increase costs" - knowingly stealing that money from employees.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- trhway 5y agoin CA if subcontractor or supplier don't get paid, even if there is an intermediate contractor layer[s], they still can put a lien on the property. I think it make sense to have a similar system for subcontractor employees to be able to go after the company which their labor was ultimately consumed by thus piercing the liability defense-in-depth layers made up of subcontractor company[ies] . That would make companies like Google to really care what kind of subcontractor they use similarly to how one takes great care choosing contractor for their property.
- ksec 5y ago1. So Google a was evil even before 2010? How strange. 2. Aren't Contractor like these fairly normal in Silicon Valley. Apple are the same as well. Even worst most contractor were told there is a chance of working inside Apple if your job was good enough. 3. Very rare HR does the right thing.
- ls-lah_33 5y agoIt's worth noting that their search and other services rely on something similar: https://arstechnica.com/features/2017/04/the-secret-lives-of-google-raters/ https://arstechnica.com/features/2017/04/the-secret-lives-of...