7 ms·
Revamped Apple Maps Rolls Out Across Italy
- yosito 5y agoI really wish Apple Maps was available on web or Android so there would be a viable alternative to Google Maps. I love and use OSM apps, but they're lacking any up to date local business info, and often can't find my searches, forcing me to switch to Google Maps to find what I'm looking for.
- SmellyPotato22 5y agoIt is. See duckduckgo.com and check out their maps. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=san+francisco&t=h_&ia=web&iaxm=about https://duckduckgo.com/?q=san+francisco&t=h_&ia=web&iaxm=abo...
- upbeat_general 5y agoWell that’s a stretch. It’s there as a JS embed that requires a paid API (with unknown costs past the free tier). There’s no first party website and the JS embed looks to be mainly just a way to show places on a map, not access most of the place data you’d find in the iOS/macOS apps.
- nojito 5y agoWhat unknown costs? It’s covered by your yearly developer costs.
- upbeat_general 5y ago> (with unknown costs past the free tier). The website directs you to contact them for pricing past the free allotment. Hence "unknown costs" or I suppose more accurately non-public pricing.
- aorth 5y agoApple Maps uses data from OpenStreetMap, so shouldn't it be as good (or bad) as OSM is? On Android, try OrganicMaps. It's a fork of the Maps.me OSM client by the original devs. It's good, but then again I've made thousands of edits to OSM around my city so that's part of it!
- yosito 5y agoI use OrganicMaps. It's fine for road maps and addresses when I have the number. But there's very little up to date local business information. I use maps apps like people used to use phone books. But OSM data just isn't suitable for that in most places.
- habi 5y agoYou can add the missing data yourself (with OrganicMaps), then everyone can profit from it!
- szastamasta 5y agoHmm, I think they are licensing their data from TomTom. Not from OSM.
- toast0 5y agoI'm not super familiar with Apple Maps, but it's common to use a mix of data. OSM may provide the base, but Apple almost certainly has done their own search indexing and may be curating business info from other sources and user reports. Or they may be using OSM in some places and other sources in other places.
- galad87 5y agoThe new revamped maps being rolled out are made by Apple. I guess the older one was as good as OpenStreetMap and TomTom.
- wodenokoto 5y agoUses, doesn’t mean use exclusively. All map providers use osm as a data source.
- aeontech 5y agoCheck out MapKit JS: https://developer.apple.com/maps/web/ https://developer.apple.com/maps/web/
- guruz 5y agoHERE WeGo https://wego.here.com/ https://wego.here.com/ But i agree, Google was smart to have all the POIs
- postingawayonhn 5y agoInterestingly the Android app just got a complete redesign. I assume a redesign of the website will be coming too.
- webmobdev 5y agoHere maps is a great alternative to Google and Apple maps - even allows you to download the map data for offline use. Here WeGo - https://wego.here.com/ https://wego.here.com/
- judge2020 5y agoLooks like they're sort-of working on it. For example, this link to Buena Park works on the web: https://maps.apple.com/place?address=Buena%20Park,%20CA,%20United%20States https://maps.apple.com/place?address=Buena%20Park,%20CA,%20U... Or Houston: https://maps.apple.com/place?address=Houston,%20TX,%20USA https://maps.apple.com/place?address=Houston,%20TX,%20USA
- thih9 5y agoDoes anyone know if there’s any reason why Italy is next?
- formvoltron 5y agoI started with an Apple IIc. It's beyond me why anyone would own an iPhone today.
- amelius 5y ago> I started with an Apple IIc. It's beyond me why anyone would own an iPhone today. I started on an Apple ][. As a hacker, I find any business strategy that locks down hardware appaling. But I understand why uninformed consumers would buy this type of hardware.
- j2bax 5y agoProbably because they don’t care. They just want something that is low maintenance and consistently works. I don’t think it has too much to do with being uninformed. I know plenty of informed users that feel the same way.
- Jcowell 5y agoThey’re not even uniformed. The device perfectly matches what they need and when it doesn’t they have every resource to see what other device does. HM grievances are not reflected of what the general consumer wants.
- dash2 5y agoI've started trying Maps as a substitute for Google on my iPhone. Its map looks simpler while driving, though I've had a few glitches. Meanwhile I use search.brave.com instead of Google search. It seems just as good for almost everything. Is Google falling behind in its key products?
- Neil44 5y agoI like apple maps for navigating around but Google maps main advantage is the search. I can put the name of a clients business or a landmark into Google maps and then hit start. Apple maps search just doesn’t find things.
- bjohnson225 5y agoTrying it in Rome. Visually it’s great, but the data quality is way behind Google. I only checked a handful of places that I know well, but nearly all have some kind of issue. I get: - A very popular local restaurant with incorrect opening and closing times (closes at 10pm according to Apple, 2am in reality and Google) - A supermarket with everything correct - A pet food shop which has no opening hours (unlike Google) - a pasticceria which doesn’t exist (this is one people queue in the street for) - a gelateria with incorrect closing times If the data was reliable I would switch, everything else is better than Google Maps.
- dav43 5y agoThis is the same data quality I face in Singapore. Looks great, but gets simple Things wrong, including wrong routes (doesn’t show several options usually) and business details not up to date. How forgiving do we have to be? Google maps is just better.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- traceroute66 5y agoI don't think its 100% fair to blame Apple for the business metadata - and I'm sure they're aware of it and working on it. The opening times data on Google comes from business owners who create an account on Google and then create a Business Profile (in rare cases, Google scrapes it from the website but it needs to be presented in a specific machine readable form[1] which, let's be honest, most websites do not, especially small businesses). Apple probably just need to spread the word more that they have an equivalent mechanism in place.[2] [1]https://developers.google.com/search/docs/advanced/structured-data/local-business https://developers.google.com/search/docs/advanced/structure... [2] https://register.apple.com/placesonmaps/ https://register.apple.com/placesonmaps/
- bjohnson225 5y agoYes, it’s difficult, but they’re not going to successfully compete with Google Maps until they have good business metadata. They need to find a way. I don’t personally know anyone who uses Apple Maps in Italy, and the low usage is presumably why so many businesses ignore it.
- hiisukun 5y agoIf I don't have any iOS device, or an Apple account, can I still send an Apple maps link somehow to friends or family? In particular, some of my elderly relatives use Apple maps and last time I tried I couldn't figure out a way to send them a maps link to the place I wanted to meet them.
- luxurytent 5y agoYes. https://maps.apple.com/?address=Florence,%20Italy&auid=12516510030195668331&ll=43.776737,11.257311&lsp=6489&q=Florence&_ext=Ch8KBQgEEJABCgQIBRADCgQIBhADCgQIChAFCgQIVRAEEiYpMNQGzOjcRUAxmTrZFxpNJkA5AMYzaOjqRUBBGIivwKGtJkBQDA%3D%3D&t=m https://maps.apple.com/?address=Florence,%20Italy&auid=12516...
- hiisukun 5y agoYou've done the opposite! You've shared a place with me, but I can't select a location to share with my family that use iOS. If I remove your ?address component, I can't find your to browse around or "open maps" to find and generate a link. Did you generate that link on a non Apple device by just filling in the address and hoping Apple knows what it is?
- Freak_NL 5y agoApple doesn't want you to use their map unless you fully buy into their silo. But for what it's worth, it looks like you can just pass coordinates in the URL, so use OpenStreetMap to grab the coordinates (these are in the URL too), and change a / to a ,: https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/43.7697/11.2584 https://maps.apple.com/place?ll=43.7697,11.2584 No idea how you're supposed to share a specific POI. Even DuckDuckGo (which weirdly enough uses Apple Maps instead of something more suitable) hides the search parameters from the URL.
- aikinai 5y agoThe share button works fine on any sort on location in Apple Maps, including POIs. https://maps.apple.com/?address=1-2,%20Oshiage%201-Ch%C5%8Dme,%20Sumida,%20Tokyo,%20Japan%20131-0045&auid=17634390270645965006&ll=35.710010,139.810681&lsp=9902&q=Tokyo%20Skytree&_ext=Cj0KBAgEEAoKBAgFEAMKBAgGEHMKBAgKEA4KBAgQEAEKBAgvEEgKBAhSEAYKBAhVEAsKBAhZEAYKBQikARABEiQpM9h5wOHaQUAxnGuYofF5YUA5M9h5wOHaQUBBnGuYofF5YUA%3D&t=m https://maps.apple.com/?address=1-2,%20Oshiage%201-Ch%C5%8Dm...
- bitcurious 5y agoIt’s been at least a year since cycling directions were announced yet I can’t navigate between Boston and Cambridge. Apple Maps has a nice interface, and I use it often for driving, but it’s a half-assed product for every other navigation category.
- jacobolus 5y agoTo be fair, navigating (by any means) in Boston/Cambridge is pretty tricky. A friend joked that you could uniquely determine a street in Cambridge by comparing its orientation to a compass.
- hcykb 5y agoIt's not that long ago that they launched this in Spain right?
- grishka 5y agoMeanwhile in Russia: still no buildings, only streets.
- mistrial9 5y agoIt seems that Russia views counting, classifying and categorizing internal infrastructure as hostile, and expressly forbids it; similarly with aerial and satellite imaging. Personally, I understand this bargaining position, but I think the built environment (roads,buildings) ought to be fair-use, ala Openstreetmap. I believe modern Apple Inc. is an egregious example of corporate abuse of commons data, so the right answer for the built infrastructure is to build Openstreetmap worldwide. Oddly, I was quite startled to see libre-search somewhere using Apple map tiles last year, which indicated to me that Apple is using low-cost-to-themselves arrangements to further the total viewership, while conveniently overlooking the aims and goals of FOSS participants.
- judge2020 5y agoApple uses data from Tomtom and OSM: https://www.apple.com/legal/internet-services/maps/legal-en.html https://www.apple.com/legal/internet-services/maps/legal-en....
- bob229 5y agoI use apple maps and it constantly sends me to the wrong place. It is awful, the only thing worse would be having the google spies on my phone