5 ms·
Is the federal government going to provide employers with the same legal immunity granted to pharmaceutical vendors via the PREP act? Does this mandate incorpo
by walterbell 5y ago
Is the federal government going to provide employers with the same legal immunity granted to pharmaceutical vendors via the PREP act?
Does this mandate incorporate the Sept 2021 CDC definition of vaccine, https://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/coronavirus/article254111268.html https://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/coronavirus/article25...
> Before the change, the definition for “vaccination” read, “the act of introducing a vaccine into the body to produce immunity to a specific disease.” Now, the word “immunity” has been switched to “protection.” The term “vaccine” also got a makeover. The CDC’s definition changed from “a product that stimulates a person’s immune system to produce immunity to a specific disease” to the current “a preparation that is used to stimulate the body’s immune response against diseases.”
- lalaland1125 5y agoWhy would employers need additional immunity? Do schools usually need legal immunity when they require vaccines?
- walterbell 5y agoThe MMR vaccine required by school is sterilizing, once and done. Intramuscular Covid vaccines provide blood/serum antibodies that can reduce the risk of severe disease or death, but they are non-sterilizing. They never promised to prevent infection and the CDC has updated their definitions to make that clear. Why would employers need legal immunity? Their lawyers may want to look closely at the legal immunity protections of the PREP act, which extend to healthcare professionals who recommend "countermeasures".
- lalaland1125 5y agoWhy would that change liability requirements? My fundamental question is that schools already have tons of vaccine requirements, so why should this one be considered special?
- walterbell 5y agoBecause it alters the risk/benefit calculus. A sterilizing vaccine that stops transmission in its tracks, has a clear public health benefit to every part of society, even if there are risks. A non-sterilizing vaccine does not provide that society-wide public health benefit, leaving the employer to bear risks without benefit.
- lalaland1125 5y agoBut the COVID vaccine does provide a society-wide public health benefit. Our best available data indicates that it reduces the risk of transmission, even for Delta [1]. 1. https://www.acsh.org/news/2021/09/07/covid-19-vaccines-prevent-delta-transmission-yet-another-study-shows-15787 https://www.acsh.org/news/2021/09/07/covid-19-vaccines-preve...
- walterbell 5y agoReducing is not the same as stopping, which is the definition of sterilizing vaccines, which is the common layman perception of "vaccine", including your original example of school-mandated vaccines. Fortunately, the CDC's Sept. 2021 updated definition makes it clear that non-sterilizing Covid vaccines should not be conflated with the transmission-stopping track record of sterilizing vaccines (e.g. MMR) mandated for school & travel.
- lalaland1125 5y agoReducing is still a society-wide public health benefit.
- walterbell 5y agoReducing does not have the same scaling effect as stopping, e.g. society must continue to pay an ongoing price for mitigations. Stopping means society can move on after a one-time vaccine cost. There are intranasal (e.g. inhaler) vaccines under development, which may provide nasal/mucosal antibodies. Until those are available, recovery from natural infection will provide both nasal/mucosal and blood/serum antibodies. This path is available to both the vaccinated and unvaccinated.
- tfehring 5y agoIsn’t the varicella zoster vaccine, which many schools have required for decades, also non-sterilizing?
- BurningFrog 5y agoWhat does "sterilizing" mean in this context?
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y agoIt means that for people with an immune system that's functioning within the normal range, the vaccine entirely prevents infection (100% effectiveness). Population-wide effectiveness isn't 100%, but for most individuals it is.
- BurningFrog 5y agoThanks. Now I know another term. I'm a bit confused by the term "infection" here. Let me split some hairs: Vaccines work by teaching the immune system how to fight an intruding virus, so it doesn't have to spend days or weeks figuring it out while the virus destroys your body. That means vaccinated people get viruses as often as unvaccinated, but defeat it much faster, usually before you notice any symptoms. My confusion is that I would call the time my immune system spends fighting a virus in my body an "infection", but apparently that is not the established use.
- sn9 5y agoYour confusion is warranted. These aren't terms that are 100% agreed upon and the scientific understanding is still evolving as our tools get better. The Atlantic just published an article about this very topic: https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/09/sterilizing-immunity-myth-covid-19-vaccines/620023/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/09/steriliz...
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y agoIf the immune system fights off the invader before it becomes established and starts freely replicating (before any symptoms, before it can be detected, before it can be transmitted) then it's not an infection. It's just some contamination.
- elliekelly 5y ago> which extend to healthcare professionals who recommend "countermeasures" Not quite: > The term “covered person”, when used with respect to the administration or use of a covered countermeasure, means— (A) the United States; or (B) a person or entity that is— [...] (iv) a qualified person who prescribed, administered, or dispensed such countermeasure; Prescribing, administering, and dispensing are very different from “recommending”. https://www.law.cornell.edu/definitions/uscode.php?width=840&height=800&iframe=true&def_id=42-USC-1258700831-306953241&term_occur=999&term_src=title:42:chapter:6A:subchapter:II:part:B:section:247d–6d https://www.law.cornell.edu/definitions/uscode.php?width=840...
- slavboj 5y ago"They never promised to prevent infection" Are we really going to bother digging up the copious video evidence this is a lie? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xcur3kwCyg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xcur3kwCyg
- dntrkv 5y agoLike the MD in your video pointed out, it _reduces_ transmission, it does not completely eliminate it. Nobody has ever claimed that it does.
- rualca 5y ago> Are we really going to bother digging up the copious video evidence this is a lie? It seems you're either a bit confused or you didn't bothered to even watch the very same video you posted. I watched the video and nowhere in it does anyone promise anything about infections magically go away. In fact, the infection disease specialist in the video says quite clearly that the observed reduction in spread was around 60%, and this statement is repeated in multiple occasions throughout the video. The video was also posted over 7 months ago, prior to some of the major vaccines having been approved and made available to the public. Please do not throw baseless accusations of anyone lying when the best proof you can come up with just refutes your accusation entirely.
- slavboj 5y agoDid you read the headline? "No one ever claimed this" except for literally thousands of journalists and government spokesmodels.
- scohesc 5y agoDon't worry, it's "safe and effective!"
- angelzen 5y agoText: Most elephants are grey. Sometimes they can be white. They are definitely not black. Headline: The Science is in: Elephants are White Pushback: No, elephants are not white. Twitter: NO ONE EVER CLAIMED ELEPHANTS ARE WHITE. or STOP SPREADING MISINFORMATION THAT ELEPHANTS ARE BLACK.
- sn9 5y agoFunnily enough, The Atlantic just put out an article describing why the idea of "sterilizing vaccines" itself might be a myth and why that doesn't matter from a practical public health standpoint: https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/09/sterilizing-immunity-myth-covid-19-vaccines/620023/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/09/steriliz...
- maxlybbert 5y agoSide effects from vaccines are rare, but do occasionally happen. Because of the small risk, there’s a government program to pay money to anybody who suffers a serious side effect from taking a vaccine in exchange for granting legal immunity to vaccine producers ( https://www.hrsa.gov/vaccine-compensation/index.html https://www.hrsa.gov/vaccine-compensation/index.html ). So, to answer your question, schools don’t literally require legal immunity themselves, but they do benefit from legal immunity that that the government gives vaccine manufacturers: there’s no need to sue a school for requiring vaccines when there’s a special program to pay out benefits. Last I knew, COVID-19 vaccines weren’t covered, but apparently I missed some news, since it’s the first thing listed on https://www.hrsa.gov/cicp https://www.hrsa.gov/cicp .
- basch 5y ago>pay money to anybody who suffers a serious side effect from taking a vaccine Nitpick, but really it is a fund to pay for anyone who suffered a side effect that it cannot be proven wasnt a vaccine. In this case vaccines are guilty until proven innocent. >approximately 70 percent of its payments are the result of a negotiated settlement “in which HHS has not concluded, based upon review of the evidence, that the alleged vaccine caused the alleged injury.” https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2019/05/vaccine-safety-program/589354/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2019/05/vaccine-s...
- R0b0t1 5y agoI was given the paperwork for this program on my first dose, I got it early.
- scohesc 5y ago1) How do you prove it was the vaccine that caused your side effects? You can't. It's not provable in court because "my legs went numb a day or two after I got the jab" isn't exactly concrete evidence. 2) No company should have their liability removed for any reason, especially by the government. This thinking was partly why the 2008 recession happened. I don't want the government taking on the liability of a multi-billion dollar industry because if the company messes up, we're paying more in taxes - guaranteed - to pay for all the settlements. 3) This mandate by the government violates every part of a right to personal autonomy when it comes to your health - there is a MONUMENTAL difference when the mandate comes from government as opposed to private business. This sets (further) precedence for future governments to give them carte blanche as to peoples' health. Side note - Just a reminder that government-ran health systems like the NHS makes decisions about your health based on the status of the current system - meaning that people who are too costly to fix/repair/KEEP ALIVE will receive palliative care. That's disgusting to me. (The US healthcare system is a whole other topic entirely, this is just an example of government making bad decisions regarding your health)
- indymike 5y agoIf you cannot sue the maker of the vaccine, enterprising lawyers will sue the deepest pockets involved in making you get vaccinated.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThey'll run up against OHSA's sovereign immunity pretty fast here.
- ecommerceguy 5y agoAre you implying OSHA is 'un-sueable'? https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/07/23/lawsuit-osha-safety-coronavirus/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/07/23/lawsuit-o...
- ceejayoz 5y agoAnyone can sue anyone for anything. Winning is a different thing. Sovereign immunity doesn’t prevent the filing of a suit. The suit was dismissed. https://www.foodprocessing.com/industrynews/2021/meat-workers-suit-against-osha-dismissed/ https://www.foodprocessing.com/industrynews/2021/meat-worker... > But, he added, courts have no jurisdiction to force OSHA to take action and “the remedy lies with the Legislature and not the courts.”
- ImPostingOnHN 5y agoif qualifying companies don't mandate the vaccine, enterprising lawyers will sue the deepest pockets involved in not making sure employees get vaccinated yep, turns out lawyers will find stuff to sue folks for, no matter what so, companies might as well do the right thing and be protected by the federal government than do the wrong thing and have to fight those lawyers all on their own
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Is the federal government going to provide employers with the same legal immunity granted to pharmaceutical vendors via the PREP act They already did for COVID countermeasures in general. In the first declaration that did that for pharmaceutical companies, public entities managing countermeasure planning and distribution, and others in March of last year.
- resoluteteeth 5y agoDo the employers need this if they are just requiring vaccination but not actually administering the vaccine themselves?
- maxerickson 5y agoYes, the other poster hasn't laid out what liability they think employers face from this government mandate.
- pibechorro 5y agogoal posts keep moving to fit the agenda of handing a select few billions of dollars at our expense.
- TOMDM 5y agoUnless you mean a very literal "at our expense" as in dollars paid for a highly effective vaccine, are you implying that the vaccine has been a net negative?
- iammisc 5y agoWhen it first came out, the data made the vax an obviously net positive. Given what we now know about cases amongst the vaccinated and how they can spread it... It's no longer an obvious positive. The vax has made covid more pervasive because of bad data at the beginning.
- TOMDM 5y agoI could maybe buy people being lax about masks and social distancing because of the vaccine, but surely you don't think the vaccine itself has made the virus more pervasive?
- iammisc 5y agoWell what is the effect and purpose of the vax other than to make people lax about social distancing and masks. The vaccine was correctly developed expressly for the purposes of rendering both unnecessary. If the vax had worked to sterilize or mostly sterilize the virus as originally it was sold to us as, then this would be okay. Instead it did not really work, thus spreading covid more. So in the end, we locked down and destroyed the economy in hopes of a vaccine, but the vaz didn't fully work and now we're going to have to open anyway to avert major economic and social disaster.
- TOMDM 5y agoThe vaccine does work. It lowers your chance of getting it and thus spreading it significantly and it severely lowers your chance of having a severe reaction in the case of a breakthrough infection. The only reason it hasn't worked at a societal level is that not enough people have taken it.
- tomrod 5y agoThey have the HRSA in place, right?
- thomastjeffery 5y agomRNA vaccines do not directly stimulate the immune system. They cause the immune system itself to create protein structures that stimulate the immune system. The definition change is simply to more accurately include this vaccine method.
- freemint 5y agoSlightly wrong. They cause any and no particular cell to create protein structures that stimulate the immune system.