9 ms·
Even Epik says the Texas abortion “whistleblower” site violates its rules
- duxup 5y agoThis whole concept where citizens track each other / report personal information about others ... and then sue them / possibly profit (or just collect money) for events that seem to have nothing to do with them seems insane at every level.
- LanceH 5y agoLook to the ADA for inspiration.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Look to the ADA for inspiration Don’t think it’s comparable. If I have perfect vision, I don’t think I can sue a site for being unusable by blind people. Actual injury must be shown.
- coredog64 5y agoCalifornia has a cottage legal industry whereby lawyers will file Unruh Act accessibility claims against businesses. There’s a very low standard on Unruh claims, to the point that some lawyers will work with the same plaintiff repeatedly looking for things like being inches off on doorways etc. Similarly, Prop 65 allows for direct, private civil suits. Although it has seen some reforms in recent years, it took some really egregious settlements before that happened. TL;DR: You can thank Californians for importing their crappy legal theories into Texas.
- wetmore 5y agoWhich Californians were responsible for the new Texas laws?
- lliamander 5y agoI find it curious that the law itself allows for civil suits. Why aren't these just criminal prosecutions?
- detaro 5y agoBecause states can't prosecute it, they already lost that one before the Supreme Court. So the hack is that the state isn't the one enforcing it.
- jcranmer 5y agoBecause abortion is a constitutional right in the US, and it would immediately be enjoined as a flagrant violation of constitutional rights (at least pending the current court's likely, but not certain, overruling of Roe v Wade and Casey). Instead, this is a way to get around constitutionality since it's not the government who is violating the constitution. Never mind all of other constitutional bits about due process that are being horribly trampled on (such as allowing people to sue without standing...).
- splitstud 5y agoWould you care to go on record as asserting that limits can not be placed on Constitutional rights?
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoThis just shifts enforcement to the courts, which are part of the government.
- smt88 5y agoIt's a legal trick to prevent federal courts from immediately ruling the law unconstitutional. It is certainly the end of medical privacy in the US, but it may even be the end of the Supremacy Clause, which gives the federal government the ability to pass laws that override state laws. It's difficult to overstate how much of a threat this law is to the US Constitution. https://www.texasmonthly.com/news-politics/meet-the-legal-strategist-behind-the-texas-abortion-ban/ https://www.texasmonthly.com/news-politics/meet-the-legal-st...
- sk2020 5y agoThat’s the core value proposition of being a paid informant.
- jandrese 5y agoThe fact the Texas legislature came up with that completely ridiculous scheme is not that surprising. They just aren't that good at making laws and have elected a number of people who show no concern with the general welfare of their constituents. That the Supreme Court basically rubber stamped it is absolutely insane. Even operating on the assumption that the conservative majority on the court wanted to overturn Roe without having big headlines saying "Roe Overturned" choosing this absolutely insane law to do it is not going to do them any favors in the long term. The chance of this backfiring is so high that it's hard to imagine anybody looking at it and saying it was a good idea. How can they not be feeling like Roger Taney after Dred Scott right now? This could be the beginning of the end for restrictive abortion laws nationwide, to so decisively win a battle that costs you the war. Edit: Wow, this is getting downvoted fast. I'm leaving it up so history can be the judge. I'm feeling confident that effectively issuing a Letter of Marque to every single US citizen on their own constituents is will turn out badly. This law is only going to be abused, and severely, unless the sensible minds in the courts wake up and put it on hold.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> the Supreme Court basically rubber stamped it The Court rejected an emergency stay. It did not uphold the law. That will come after hearings next year.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoWho will SCOTUS hand the bill to for the unplanned and unwanted children who are carried to term in the meantime by women who could not get access to healthcare until hearings are held [1]? Who should these women sue for damages due to defective statute and who have been harmed by the state of Texas? [1] https://www.foxnews.com/politics/texas-6-week-abortion-ban-prevent https://www.foxnews.com/politics/texas-6-week-abortion-ban-p... (However, preliminary estimates suggest that the law could prevent roughly 132 procedures per day, or 4,009 per month.)
- watwut 5y agoYeah, causing damage in between. But that is what selecting justices was all about anyway last years.
- Natsu 5y agoIt's becoming more of a trend. There were quite a few such sites after Jan 6th, for example and I believe a subreddit or two devoted to such.
- crisdux 5y agoI think we are seeing citizens deputized to enforce laws and norms in other places in society too. It already happens on social media. It's also happening offline, folks are losing their jobs over just expressing opinions. Citizens without standing enforcing edicts on others. It truly worries me. This isn't exactly what you meant, but its something I think is related which I've been thinking about.
- woodruffw 5y ago"Deputized" has a precise meaning in this context: the state is substituting private citizens for officials in order to commit official acts. Individuals shaming other individuals for "expressing opinions" are not "deputized," since there's no official act. We can talk on and on about whether it's it's good or not, but it's nowhere near as dangerous as states end-running civil liberties by appointing private citizens to do their dirty work.
- jmclnx 5y agoSimilar to what East Germany had were IIRC 1 third of their citizens spied and report activities of everyone else.
- swiley 5y agoYeah. I’m against abortion but that kind of thing is HOA levels of unacceptable.
- huibv 5y agoProof that freedom of speech doesn't exist on the internet, short of launching a new AS. Sometimes I wonder if the US government should offer some kind of basic web hosting to citizens to guarantee this fundamental right.
- milesdyson_phd 5y agoFundamental right to web hosting?
- huibv 5y agoA web hosting that guarantees that the fundamental right to free speech can be exercised over the internet.
- Bootvis 5y agoThe speech isn't the issue here. The problem is the collecting of data on third persons. You might believe these providers looked through their ToS in search for a reason but I hope you agree with me that there is a difference between freedom of expression and data collection.
- msla 5y agoMore charitable interpretation: The Internet is the public square these days. Imagine if your town's public spaces were all owned by private businesses and you couldn't use them if those private businesses didn't like your message, skin color, gender, ethnicity, religion, or face. That's what I'm afraid of: The enclosure and destruction of the only place modern people have to be heard. I'm not proposing a solution. There won't be a very easy solution.
- yardie 5y ago> Imagine if your town's public spaces were all owned by private businesses and you couldn't use them if those private businesses didn't like your message, skin color, gender, ethnicity, religion, or face. It's called the mall and that is basically the rule. You can be asked to leave for no reason at all or be hit with a trespassing charge. A public square is actually public, owned by the public, occupied by the public.
- WaitWaitWha 5y agoI am confused by much of this. If the information collected is public, why is this a not equivalent to other politically motivated data collection? (Or, is the information collected not public?) There are sites that collect, collate, cross reference and publish individuals' OSINT repeatedly on various political topics. (voting records, financial contributions, gun ownership, financials, etc.)
- Shank 5y ago> (Or, is the information collected not public?) It's not public. The site was soliciting PII "tips" about abortions. Ostensibly someone might tweet out their address, phone number, name, and having an illegal abortion, in which case it would be public. But in this case, the vast majority of tips aren't going to be public. The difference with most OSINT stuff is that the information is public in some way or valuable to the public. Categorically, the site would actually be violating many privacy laws in many states, including things like GDPR. It's definitely a cross-border legal minefield anyways, so it makes a lot of sense why it would be against the terms of service to operate a site specifically to test these boundaries. Sure, it may be a Texas law, but where are the servers? Where are the people submitting the information? Where are the people currently located with information being submitted about? Etc.
- detaro 5y agoWhy would who got what medical treatment and who helped with that be public information?
- splintercell 5y agoJust like if you filed a report against a neighbor for domestic violence, you’re allowed to report crime on Citizen style or Neighborhood app or WhatsApp groups. Are any of these things public information?
- Spivak 5y agoSure, but this is really different than some vague mostly public demographic info. If you posted any of the the kind of information this site was collecting on a message board it would be labeled as some combination of stalking, harassment, and doxxing. This whole thing seems absolutely nuts.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Volundr 5y ago> Pro-abortion advocates tried for over a week to overwhelm the website with traffic and fake tips," Schwartz wrote in a blog post. "When they failed, keyboard warriors harassed GoDaddy to take down our site." I'm finding the sneering at "keyboard warriors" really amusing here. How is both the creation of this website, or the anonymous tips themselves anything but "keyboard warrioring"?